BlogU

  • Quote of the Day

    By Dean Dad December 11, 2008 9:21 pm

    From yesterday's New York Times article about the faculty at the New School passing a vote of no confidence in their President, former U.S. Senator Bob Kerrey, who has churned through four chief academic officers in seven years:

    Like Mr. Summers, who is now President-elect Barack Obama's choice to be chief White House economic adviser, Mr. Kerrey was recruited in part for his star power and management acumen. And like Mr. Summers, he has often found university politics more difficult to navigate than electoral politics.

    I liked that. Earning a purple heart in Vietnam, getting elected governor, dating Debra Winger, doing two terms in the U.S. Senate, and reaching the point of being shortlisted as a Vice Presidential candidate? No problem! But academic administration? Now that's a challenge!

    For reasons I still don't understand, people from outside academia often fail to understand that the culture of academia is fundamentally different. Better in some ways, worse in others, but markedly different. That's not to deny that it needs to change in some fairly fundamental ways, but those changes will have to be facilitated by people who understand where it's starting.

    The guy was briefly among the dozen or so people most often mentioned as possibly running the country someday, and he can't even run a university.

    If he's looking for work, I hear that Illinois needs a governor...

Advertisement

Comments on Quote of the Day

  • Posted by Quality matters on December 12, 2008 at 9:25am EST
  • Dear Dean Dad -- I enjoy your writing, but this time I would give Mr. Kerrey the edge. You could note that the Times also quotes Kerrey, "the group meeting on Wednesday involved a fraction of the New School’s 333 full-time and 1,733 part-time faculty." That puts the vote in a different light. Academia is a closed and often overly proud society. They decided in the beginning that Mr. Kerrey didn't fit, and they tend to think that they are the only ones who deserve 'academic freedom.' They are ruthless in crowding out other viewpoints. This vote is one piece of a picture regarding Kerrey's leadership -- let's hear more.

  • Response
  • Posted by Jeffrey Mask on December 16, 2008 at 10:00am EST
  • The article did not explain why it was only a fraction of the 333 full-timers who voted. (The adjuncts can't be expected to participate out of availability and self-preservation.)

    But 4 CAOs in 7 years? That is a vote of incompetence in itself. Either Kerry can't pick them or Kerry can't keep them.

    Higher ed is different for a reason. Star power aside, institutions should stop promoting outsiders who do not get the difference. Higher ed is not business--and from the looks of the business world today, I'd think people would stop promoting it as a model for running everything else. A model for ruining everything else--sure.