BlogU

  • ABC’s and PhD’s: The Secret Lives of Soccer Moms

    By Susan Bassow September 16, 2008 9:50 pm

    My kids have been playing soccer since they were 4 years old, and just this week, I found out that the mother of one of my youngest daughter’s teammates is an author of a novel. As we watched our 7-year-old daughters warm up before a game, I asked her what her novel was about. Being in the military. Turns out that she graduated from West Point, and had had a full military career before becoming an author and a full-time soccer mom of 5 soccer-star children, ranging in age from 18 to 7. Wow, I had no idea that she had gone to West Point. And I think that she has no idea that I have a PhD in science.

    Funny how many of my kids’ teammates’ (and classmates’) parents do not know of my academic background. I do not brag. In some circumstances I cannot hide my science PhD background, like when I run the school’s Science Fair, or give a “lecture” to my child’s 4th grade class about global warming. But for the most part, my children’s friends’ parents think of me simply as another “stay-at-home” mom. Does this sometimes bother me? Yes. But I do not make my life’s decisions based on what others may think of me. Rather I follow my own inner compass – creatively finding ways to satisfy my hunger for intellectual stimulation and my desire to contribute academically, while simultaneously taking primary care of my children (i.e., driving them to soccer practices 5 days a week!)

    There is a television show on TLC called “The Secret Life of a Soccer Mom” – usually not about true “soccer moms” per se. The premise is secretly to offer a full-time, stay-at-home mom (usually a somewhat dissatisfied one) who previously had a career, with an opportunity to spend a week in the job of their dreams. Meanwhile their families think that the women have been spending a week being pampered. Then after the week of working hard, the women fess up to their families and then are miraculously offered a wonderful full-time job opportunity in their chosen careers. I have only watched a few episodes, but it seems like roughly half of the women choose to forgo the offer and continue to stay at home with their families (often with a renewed appreciation for what they have), and the other half choose to accept the offer and return to work, beginning their foray into the juggling act of balancing career and family. If I were on that show, and someone were to offer me a full-time, tenure-track position at a university near my home, would I take it? Or would I continue to hodge-podge my academic life and drive my kids to soccer practice daily? Not sure. Now, if it were TENURED…

Advertisement

Comments on ABC’s and PhD’s: The Secret Lives of Soccer Moms

  • Kudos
  • Posted by Sarah Bennett on September 17, 2008 at 12:50pm EDT
  • I was so happy to read your blog! I am currently an adjunct at two colleges in my area and have been struggling with finding a full time position with a Master's degree in zoology. The thought has crossed my mind that this part time stuff would be great when we have kids but I wasn't sure how I would feel about myself. It's nice to see that you have chosen your family and are happy with that choice!

  • Posted by Terri Hicks on September 17, 2008 at 2:45pm EDT
  • You are describing an upper-middle class life choice which few families can afford. Why did you choose to pursue an education that someone else might have benefitted from and actually put to use? It doesn't take a West Point education or a PhD to be a good mother. What is the father's role in your families? Are they condemned to extended work hours in order to makeup for the loss of your paychecks? Fathers are just as important as mothers in a child's development. How much time do your children get to spend with the first and most influential man in their lives?

  • I take issue with what you say...
  • Posted by Susan on September 17, 2008 at 3:50pm EDT
  • Terri,
    How dare you say that I have not "benefitted from" or "put to use" my PhD. I have published, and contributed academically, and now am being more charitable with my time and energy. Yes, it is a luxury that some families cannot afford, but know that we as a family have made choices to be able to afford living on a single main income. My life is nonetheless "using" my PhD. A doctorate of philosophy is different from professional degrees (i.e., JD or MD), where the destination is a specific job, though not all graduates from these degrees take jobs squarely in their profession. In fact, most PhD's do not go on to take a full-time tenure-track position at a University. See previous discussions on this blog and elsewhere with some statistics on this issue. There are simply far too many PhD's granted each year for all PhD's to find tenure-track positions at Universities.

    Further, both fathers are very involved with all of their children. Thank you for your concern about this issue.

    Please think before you insult other's decisions in life. A PhD is the ultimate degree in education -- not a job prerequisite.

  • Whoa, Terri!
  • Posted by Dr. K on September 17, 2008 at 4:10pm EDT
  • Your comment sounds awfully judgemental. Susan Bassow earned that Ph.D. and kept no one from getting theirs if they wanted it. Who's to say that she knew she would have children when she pursued her Ph.D.? Who's to say she knoew how they would make her feel?

    I am pregnant with my first child. I make more than my husband, and so staying home with the child is not really an option for me, and if it were an option, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't take it. For many African American women like me, the stay-at-home concept still feels rather new and suspect. (Our mothers and grandmothers did the juggling act, so not doing so feels like slacking.) But I wouldn't condemn a person for switching careers or paths within a career. What Dr. Bassow has done seems to be just that.

  • Posted by Steve on September 18, 2008 at 10:35pm EDT
  • Frankly, the post and thread points up just how much of a commodity the PhD. is nowadays. Almost everyone with a PhD. is now underemployed in one sense or another. The PhD. is simply a period of low paid labor, not unlike spending one's twenties in a series of low paying jobs before either gaining a professional degree or going into a more lucrative line of work.