News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
June 16, 2005
For many low-income students, the gateway to higher education is through urban community colleges. But many of those students have received poor educations in high school, and have a good chance of getting stuck in remedial courses and never graduating.
Some community colleges are experimenting with new approaches to educating these students, but there are few examples of concrete evidence of how successful those approaches are. This week, however, a study is being released that suggests that the use of “learning communities” can have a significant impact on the success of students who need the most help.
The study — conducted at Kingsborough Community College — is significant because it is something of a rarity in education research: random selection was used for students in the program being studied and the control group. Because most research on education innovations does not feature truly random comparisons, factors such as student motivation or self-selection come into play.
The Kingsborough study was done by MDRC, a nonpartisan research group. It found that students who participated in the learning communities showed better grades, better retention, and — perhaps most important — more success at doing college-level work. Of students who failed both the reading and writing basic skills examination prior to enrolling, 33 percent of students in the program passed both tests within a year of starting. In contrast, only 14 percent of other Kingsborough students passed both tests in a similar time frame.
The concept of learning communities differs somewhat from campus to campus. At Kingsborough, where it is called Open Doors, it involves students being grouped into cohorts of 25 students. The cohorts then take a sequence of three courses together, with the courses meeting right after each other. Extra tutoring and counseling is available to the cohort, although similar programs are available to students who do not enroll in Open Doors.
The study is too recent to have long-term data. But even based on just a few years of data, the authors of the study say that the findings could be a guide for other institutions. “It certainly appears that the Open Doors program at Kingsborough is giving students a boost,” the report said. “It seems fairly clear that the Open Doors program can substantially improve student performance…. Open Doors students are both more likely to take critical developmental courses – and more likely to pass their courses – than their control group counterparts.”
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
This article sparked a thought about how students who are in the community college system here in North Carolina who want to transfer have to have at least 30 semester hours of college level work. Traditionally the courses are to supposed to be completed in one academic year maybe with summer school if they go full time. Do you think possibly with the remedial courses and holding students back with these courses is another way to generate dollars for community colleges?
Douglas Hall, Assistant Director of Admissions at North Carolina A&T State University, at 9:09 am EDT on June 17, 2005
Readers of this article my be interested in my new book College Student Retention: Formula for Student Success. Information about the book can be found at ww.cscsr.org/retention_book.htm
Alan Seidman, at 2:22 pm EDT on June 17, 2005
Mr. Siedman I read your book and can honestly say it was probably one of the best sources for my dissertation and it provided excellent suggested practices for increasing student retention. Moreover, I found your success formula with the inclusion for empowering the individual student accurate; however,I found that there is still one critical piece needed to finish the formula. This piece (in my humble opinion) is specific to retaining low-income, first-generation, minority students. Excellent book!
Back to the original question... Keeping students enrolled and learning communities (LC). I believe LC are more effective at universities, quite simply because university students are traditional in age and captured by living in dorms. In most cases community colleges do not serve the same type of student body. At the community college where I am employed (located in the Southwest with a majority Hispanic, first-generation, low-income, part-time attending, working, parents student body) this LC retention measure did not work. In fact, many of our students ended up dropping one of the LC courses to care for children or their work schedule changed and this negatively influenced results.
Since this study was done at a CC, how were you able to achieve success since you too serve the same type of student body, or do you?
Garcia, at 3:35 pm EST on December 13, 2006
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Job Description: The Senior Instructional Designer will be involved with training faculty and working closely with the ... see job
Job Summary: This position exists to provide program management and strategic planning functions ... see job
Angelo State University’s work environment is often described as an employee community. This applies to the work culture ... see job
Program Description Montana’s Child Welfare Training Partnership (MCWTP) is a collaboration between the Montana ... see job
Job Description: This faculty member teaches Speech courses including Fundamentals of Communication, Public Speaking, and ... see job
The Goodwin College of Professional Studies at Drexel University invites nominations and applications for an experienced ... see job
Join the Pack! A community with nearly 8,000 faculty and staff, and 30,000 students. NC State is one of the largest employers ... see job
Founding Chair for Department of Medical Education
University of Central Florida College of Medicine
The ... see job
The Leadership Coordinator will be responsible for five areas of activity. (1) Creating new initiatives under the auspices of ... see job
Hofstra University School of Law seeks a Coordinator of ISCT and Development Research to provide administrative services ... see job
Keeping students enrolled
A study was completed (PH.D. Thesis) at Michigan State University on Minority students in the physical sciences and mathematics and our findings are that the learning communites work well for these students at a large research univerity in retaining these students toward a science degree. Students are grouped into selected courses and supplemental instruction is given to assist, as well as intense advising and a freshmen semianar course. Studnents receive a science degree at a 50% rate.
Dorothy A. Reed, Director at Michigan State University, at 2:28 pm EDT on June 16, 2005