News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Sept. 29, 2005
The University of Oregon has ended a policy that some students charged discouraged white students from enrolling in certain sections of some courses.
Under the policy, an office that provides academic support to minority students could certify for enrollment up to 10 students in 18-student sections of selected English and mathematics courses, generally introductory courses. These sections are smaller than other sections, allowing for more personal interaction.
The Oregon Daily Emerald wrote about the policy last year, describing the experience of a white student who wanted to enroll in one of the sections, and who felt discriminated against because of her race. The remaining slots in the courses were open to other students, including white students, but this student reported being given the run-around when trying to enroll. “I shouldn’t have to wait just because I’m white,” the student was quoted as saying.
The article in The Daily Emerald prompted College Republicans to protest the policy and led one conservative student, Melissa Hanks, to complain to the U.S. Department of Education, although she had never tried to enroll in one of the courses. “I got a bee in my bonnet about this,” said Hanks, who graduated from Oregon in the spring and is now studying anthropology at Oregon State University. “It’s just not right to exclude people because of their skin color.”
A spokesman for the University of Oregon said that the university decided to change the policy after receiving a complaint from a student, and that the decision did not involve the Education Department. Oregon released a statement that stressed that the reserved slots were not open to just any minority students, but only to those who had been certified for the courses by the Office of Multicultural Academic Support, which serves only minority students.
Under the new policy for the courses, pre-certification will still be required, but a number of other offices at Oregon will be able to certify students. Most of those offices are also for minority students, but one of them is a general program to provide academic support to undergraduates of all races. Adding that office, the statement said, “ensures that those receiving priority registration will be racially diverse.”
Hanks said that she was pleased that a wider range of students would be eligible for the priority registration.
But Colin Smith, a field organizer for the Oregon Students of Color Coalition, criticized the university for changing its policy on the courses. “Recruitment and retention rates are going down, and no one is supporting students of color,” he said. “This is just another part of the culture of backlash against underprivileged groups.”
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
It’s sad to see that even at my alma mater, affirmative action for rich white kids is alive and well- and expanding.
dan, ucla, at 1:41 pm EDT on September 29, 2005
Andrew, I agree with you. Of course, with many professors the group of students with that gets the preference is the ones with social skills that can whine the most.
Larry, at 1:42 pm EDT on September 29, 2005
“To achieve equal employment opportunity based on individual merit, without regard to race, color or national origin.”
The sentance above was one of the mission statements proposed at the founding of the NAACP.
Ray, at 5:29 pm EDT on September 29, 2005
Apparently, qualifications such as merit and ability are meaningless to those who can’t compete. So we have to bend the rules to eliminate the intelligent. In other words cheating has to be allowed. Don’t they see that no one person can have everything he wants?
Shlomo, Shlomo, at 5:58 pm EDT on September 29, 2005
I’m glad that European American students are standing up and protesting against, and helping to end, racist policies such as this one. Apparently that poster Dan has racial animosity against European Americans since he assumes that all European Americans are privileged and non-European Americans are “disadvantaged". Dan, shed your hate, open your eyes (and your mind) and look at the real world for what it really is.
Eric, at 8:28 pm EDT on September 29, 2005
The end of race preferences (so-called affirmative action) and other forms of government paternalism cannot come soon enough.
At universities, the majority of black students live a self-imposed exile outside the mainstream of campus life often because of their paranoia about race and their insistence on seeing every university transaction – student elections, grade distribution, graduation rates — through the prism of race.
Guilt-ridden white liberals and other paternalists self-flagellate over the need for this absurdity. They cannot imagine treating black students exactly like we would any other group of people. Instead, they want to embed race more deeply into the fabric of American life.
To get beyond race, we must remove it from the public landscape, stop treating black students as a separate group and start regarding them as full members of American society. Period. Now.
Places like University of Oregon have already done their fair share to foster a marginalized, embittered group whose bitterness is fed by the patronizing benevolence of white liberals who give them misguided comfort.
Congratulations to UofO for waking up at long last.
Chuck, at 1:06 pm EDT on October 1, 2005
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Whitehead Institute (MIT Affiliate) an experienced payroll administrator to join a fast paced accouting and finance office. see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
Responsible for coordinating and directing all functions related to the day to day customer service and external ... see job
BUSINESS & INFORMATION SYSTEMS INSTRUCTOR Accounting, General Business, Business Law & Statistics Part-time Temporary Pool ... see job
Eastern Kentucky University, located in Richmond, Madison County, Kentucky near the Heart of the Bluegrass, is a ... see job
Founded in 1898, and affiliated with what is now New York-Presbyterian Hospital since 1927, Weill Cornell Medical College ... see job
Hillsborough Community College is a public, comprehensive multi-campus, state-supported community college located in the ... see job
The Senior Vice President of Finance and Operations is the chief finance operations officer of the college, reporting ... see job
Job Summary The Associate Vice President for Environmental Safety reports to the Senior Vice President for ... see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
When any group gets ten of eighteen spots reserved in a class (we’ll round that off as 56%) based on a non-academic criterion, there is a problem. Basic courses fill quickly enough as it is, but when the majority of seats are off limits to a segment of the student population, something is just plain off.
My best experience with systems that spread availability out for core courses came in my community college days. Every third student who attempted to enroll for English 101 (transfer composition) was turned away. Now, that was a colorblind system.
Andrew Purvis, at 6:28 am EDT on September 29, 2005