News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Oct. 31, 2005
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
Referring to any group of people as “subhuman” is despicable and usually the first step toward genocide. The student’s words are clearly repellant.
It is, however, very frightening to see a university attempt to police thought, however disgusting that thought may be, in the manner that Duquesne has done here. Are we going to start assigning extra-curricular work for the sake of indoctrination now? However noble the intent, the means are clearly unjustified.
For instance, I teach at a religiously affiliated university and we hope that our students share our religious convictions. But surely (and rightfully so) there would be an uproar if, having “caught” a student expressing atheist sentiments outside of the university’s jurisdiction, I assigned that student to write an essay on, say, the divine inspiration of the Gospels.
Rather than engaging in blunt mind-control, Duquesne should focus on crafting a curriculum that gives its students the logical ability and historical perspective necessary to avoid such repellant ideology as this student as fallen into.
Cicero, at 8:47 am EST on October 31, 2005
I had to read that article twice because I couldn’t believe it the first time — not that there are students who are rabidly homophobic, but that University officials thought they could punish a student for expressing unapproved views on a NON-UNIVERSITY website.
A much more useful response, rather than the bizarre “reeducation camp” approach chosen, would have been to commission the humanities schools to put together an exhibition for the student union on the treatment of gays through the ages — ending with a computer displaying the student’s posting.
The answer to hateful speech is better speech, not suppression or reeducation camps.
JMG, at 9:05 am EST on October 31, 2005
It isn’t entirely clear whether the students’ rights are being violated. His school is not a public school. However, the school, if it chooses to kick him out, may be breaching a contract to him. Now, of course, as the above posters state, the school is behaving irresponsibly if it thinks that forcing someone to write something will cure all problems of bigotry and hatred in the world.
Larry, at 7:09 pm EST on November 1, 2005
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
The World Languages department at Howard Community College is seeking individuals to be included in a pool to hire adjunct ... see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
Oklahoma City University invites interested candidates to apply for the position of Assistant Professor of TESOL. see job
Job Description: The Ithaca College School of Music announces a full-time, tenure-eligible position in ... see job
Position Summary: Primary responsibility will be to manage the department’s marketing activities, including ... see job
The University of Kentucky is one great place to work. UK’s agenda—simple—to accelerate the movement toward academic ... see job
The Department of Biology at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill invites applications for a tenure-track ... see job
Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job
College of Health Sciences Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences BioTherapeutics Engineering Laboratory Position: Junior ... see job
Position Summary: Theoretical Biophysics at Princeton As part of a continuing effort to promote research and ... see job
Subhumans at Dusquene University
Subhumans are the intolerant, ignorant neanderthals who refuse to recognize the majesty of diversity, and canonize bigotry and hatred disguised under religious adiaphora. It seems to me that the only “subhuman” is the arrogant student who decided that he was god and could judge others—which means that he is ignorant of Matthew 7:1.
Arthur Ide, PhD, at 7:47 am EST on October 31, 2005