Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Quick Takes: New Campaign Against Piracy, 2 Scientists Win U.S. Award, Charges in Destruction of Anti-Abortion Display, Deadly Crash for Taylor U., Cuban-American Scholars Seek Exchanges, Princetonians Back ‘Bill of Rights’, Valparaiso Students Protest

  • Groups representing the recording and movie industries sent 40 universities letters this week demanding that they take additional steps to prevent students from illegally copying music and videos. While many campuses have dealt with the problem in part by providing music and videos to students through legal means, the letters to the university leaders said that students have been using new means to engage in file-sharing and copying.
  • The National Science Board on Thursday selected Charles Townes, a pioneer in quantum physics who spent much of his career at the University of California at Berkeley, and Raj Reddy, founder of the Robotics Institute at Carnegie Mellon University, as the 2006 recipients of the Vannevar Bush Award. The award recognizes individuals who, through public service activities in science and technology, have made an outstanding “contribution toward the welfare of mankind and the nation.”
  • Kentucky authorities have charged a professor and six students with misdemeanors for destroying an anti-abortion display at Northern Kentucky University, the Associated Press reported. The university has already removed Sally Jacobsen, a literature professor who is retiring at the end of the semester, from her classes. Jacobsen has apologized for her role in the incident but her lawyer told the AP she would plead not guilty because she did not believe she had committed a crime.
  • Four Taylor University students and one employee were killed Wednesday when a van carrying them back to campus was in a crash. One student and three employees were injured. Taylor inaugurates a new president today and decided that the ceremony would go on — while acknowledging the tragedy.
  • A new group of Cuban-American scholars, artists and intellectuals is calling for an end to U.S. policies that impose strict limits on exchanges between the two countries.
  • Students at Princeton University voted narrowly this week to endorse a version of David Horowitz’s Student Bill of Rights, The Daily Princetonian reported. Nearly 52 percent of the nearly 1,700 undergraduates who participated in the referendum — representing more than a third of the university’s student body — supported the nonbinding measure, which had been sponsored by the campus chapter of the College Republicans. It says, among other things, that students’ political views should not affect their grades, that instructors should avoid “political, ideological, religious or anti-religious indoctrination” in their teaching, and that in selecting speakers, the university and its groups must “observe the principles of academic freedom and promote intellectual pluralism.”
  • Hundreds of students at Valparaiso University, in Indiana, held a protest Wednesday over what they consider to be excessive police response to drinking problems at the institution, the AP reported.

Scott Jaschik

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Horowitz at Penn State and Princeton

As a Princeton alumnus, I was very interested to read about the recent referendum held there about the student bill of rights, “loosely” based on David Horowitz’s academic bill of rights. I note, with some relief, that at least the Princeton Republicans repudiated Horowitz’s tactics, and that in his reference to the absence of a Marxist viewpoint in an introductory economics course, one student cuts to the core of the inconsistency at work here. Here is what I wrote to the local newspaper after Horowitz’s recent appearance at Penn State:

David Horowitz, who visited Penn State on April 13 on his tour of college campuses to promote his new book and rid higher education of the scourge of political bias, is a meddlesome character. His main goal seems to be to have his ego stroked, as he caters to his partisan supporters with a steady stream of invective aimed at anybody on the left of him. But how sad that those supporters, like the College Republicans, can’t see through his rhetoric to realize that, on his own shallow and flimsy evidence, there is no serious problem here-certainly nothing meriting the time and attention of state legislators (especially at the elevated salaries they are now being paid!).

I was once the victim of a verbal assault by Horowitz myself, back in 1973, when he attacked me and Princeton University Press where I was then an editor for publishing The New Left and the Origins of the Cold War by Penn State history professor Robert Maddox. The widely reviewed book was a withering critique of seven prominent New Left writers including Horowitz (at that time an editor for the left-wing magazine Ramparts) for shoddy scholarship. Having no very good response to make in defense of their scholarship, Horowitz and some of the others instead engaged in an ad hominem counterattack by alleging a right-wing conspiracy led by such Establishment figures as George Kennan and Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., behind publication of the book presumably to discredit the New Left politically. How far Horowitz has come ideologically since then-and how little changed are his methods of operating against his perceived political enemies (which really didn’t include me, since my sympathies were on the left and my own father, a history professor at Wilkes College, had himself penned a revisionist New Left history of the origins of the Cold War).

For those who are still dazzled by Horowitz’s rhetorical skills and can’t yet see him as the Don Quixote he is, tilting at windmills, consider this major inconsistency in his position. On the one hand, Horowitz professes to be a champion of academic freedom in the classroom and only interested in sanctioning teachers for “persistently intruding material which has no relation to their subject,” as a 1971 statement from the American Association of University Professors that he is fond of quoting reads. On the other hand, as he frequently did during Thursday night’s speech, Horowitz lambasts and dismisses entire fields like black studies and women’s studies even though he can have no argument that what professors in these fields teach that he finds ideologically objectionable is unrelated to their subject.

This inconsistency revealed itself most starkly in the interview with Horowitz printed in the CDT (April 10) where he said: “You can tell from my book that you don’t want your students going into any cultural anthropology course or department. Stay out of them. Economics departments are the best in the liberal arts schools, without question-except for the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. It’s a Marxist department.” There can be no clearer demonstration that what Horowitz is really seeking to do is undermine his ideological enemies, not support academic freedom. For, otherwise, how can he object to professors teaching cultural anthropology, or economists teaching their subject using a Marxist approach, if they do not proselytize overtly for the Democratic Party or, worse, some radical leftist cause? And why wouldn’t he be worried equally about the ideological imbalance implicit in the teaching of economics in a department where the methodology used is the mainstream neoclassical approach? I’m sorry, Mr. Horowitz, you can’t have it both ways!

Sandy Thatcher, at 9:45 am EDT on April 28, 2006

re: New Campaign Against Piracy

I suggest universities need to get out of the internet service provider business. They need to outsource student access to the internet (dorms, open campus wireless networks, and the like). Let the RIAA and the MPAA take on the ISP’s — we’re too easy of a target.

I also dislike the use of the term piracy for these activities. Anyone who has talked to South Vietnamese refugees is aware that there is real piracy in the world and copyright violation isn’t anywhere close to that.

CS Person, at 12:20 pm EDT on April 28, 2006

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Quick Takes: New Campaign Against Piracy, 2 Scientists Win U.S. Award, Charges in Destruction of Anti-Abortion Display, Deadly Crash for Taylor U., Cuban-American Scholars Seek Exchanges, Princetonians Back 'Bill of Rights', Valparaiso Students Protest

or search for jobs directly.

Adjunct Instructor, Mass Communication
Lone Star College System

Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job

Assistant/Associate Professor/Computer Engineering
Lebanese American University

School of Engineering & Architecture Department: Electrical & Computer Engineering Discipline(s): Computer Engineering ... see job

Adjunct Assistant Professor, Administration of Criminal Justice
Johnson County Community College

A career at Johnson County Community College is more than a job. We believe it’s important to invest in our employees and ... see job

Assistant/Associate Professor of Finance
Kentucky State University

The successful candidate teaching courses in finance at the graduate and undergraduate levels, research and scholarly ... see job

Office Systems Technology Faculty
Broward College

Broward College invites applicants for a full time tenure track teaching position in Office Systems Technology. Candidates ... see job

Assistant Director
Babson College

Assistant Director, Financial Aid — Student Financial Services

Reports to:

Senior Associate ... see job

Clinical Assistant or Associate Professor
East Carolina University

East Carolina University, a constituent institution of the University of North Carolina, is a doctoral institution with an ... see job

Admin & Financial Officer
University of Pennsylvania

The nation’s first university, Penn is a world-renowned leader in education, research, and innovation. Situated on a ... see job

Assistant Professor of Criminal Justice
Fairmont State University/Pierpont Community and Technical College

Fairmont State University and Pierpont Community & Technical College, with a 120-acre main campus in Fairmont, WV, is part of ... see job

CYTOPATHOLOGIST — Clinician-Educator
University of Pennsylvania

The Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania’s School of Medicine seeks candidates ... see job