Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Ethnic Tensions in Dallas

Jesus (Jess) Carreon has had a highly successful career leading community colleges in California and Oregon, but something went wrong in Dallas.

Carreon resigned as chancellor of the Dallas County Community College District Tuesday night, after reaching a settlement with the board, only three years after taking the position and becoming the first Latino (and first minority educator) to lead the system, in which enrollments are going up and becoming increasingly diverse.

The official announcement said very little except that Carreon was leaving his position immediately, and offering predictable statements of praise. A spokeswoman said that he was not commenting on his departure except to say that he was proud of what he had accomplished. Carreon led a successful campaign for a $450 million bond issue that officials said was key for facilities in the district, which serves about 63,000 students in credit programs. He also opened five new campus centers to try to increase access to courses.

But in recent months, Carreon has appeared to be in something of a power struggle over the district in which many Latino leaders saw him as a welcome change, many faculty members had the opposite view, and his board was divided. Tensions have been evident and awkward for all involved. A report in The Dallas Morning News on last month’s board meeting described a “surreal atmosphere” in which Carreon’s supporters from the local community urged trustees to back him and the trustees declined to do so and instead asked Carreon if he had invited his defenders (he said he hadn’t).

Throughout his tenure, faculty members have grumbled about Carreon’s leadership, with many saying that he did not sufficiently consult them and that he tended to question the way things have historically been done. Faculty leaders have denied that their reactions to Carreon were motivated by his ethnicity. On Wednesday, they were not talking. Fred Newbury, president of the Faculty Association, said via e-mail that based on legal advice, he could say only that he supported the “mutual agreement” between Carreon and the board.

The Dallas board consists of seven trustees: four white, one black, and two Latino. While the board’s leaders have denied that any disagreements with the chancellor were influenced by his ethnicity, the Latino trustees have been strong supporters and have suggested otherwise.

Minutes to the board’s January board meeting, which are not public on the district’s Web site, but which officials faxed for review, include a lengthy discussion by one of the Latino trustees about the way Carreon was being treated by faculty members. The trustee, Diana Flores, questioned why the Faculty Association was planning to conduct a detailed survey of employees about Carreon’s leadership. The survey, Flores said, was full of references to “fairness” and “organizational outcomes” and various issues that were vague, but that would allow naysayers to attack the chancellor. Moreover, she said that the level of scrutiny the chancellor was receiving was unprecedented in the history of the district.

She said that a “small segment” of the district’s employees was making it difficult for the chancellor to lead. “It is racist, racist, racist, racist at its core,” she said. She went on to describe a vice president who had left the district and told her that he had been told by a faculty member that “we don’t take orders from Mexicans.”

Scott Jaschik

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Regarding Cr. Carrion ´s resignation from the Dallas CCD: The Chancellor is not the first person to suffer the humiliation of red-neck academics. As a native of Texas and DFW I am ashamed of the tiny minds that run this district and the Nation.

Y ´all going nowheres, hear?!

D. Thomas, Ed.D.

Dounald Thomas, Dr. at Language Study Centers, at 6:10 am EDT on May 4, 2006

Previous post

I could comment at some length regarding the puerile perspectives expressed by Ed.D Thomas, but suffice it to say that his composition skills and reactionary rhetoric leave little doubt as to his intellegence, and by implication, the credibility of his viewpoint.

Scott, at 8:20 am EDT on May 4, 2006

Lets hear them Scott

Scott, Please do comment on the “peurile perspectives". The rest of your criticism is simply a straw man.

Dan, at 9:00 am EDT on May 4, 2006

the dangers of reverse racism

Iattended the DCCCD system and lived in the DFW area for 21 years. While there may have been racial overtones that could be debated, I think it is extremely dangerous to decry racism without a full disclosure of the facts. As a minority myself, I do not deny there is racism in higher education, however there are dangers in covering misuse and no synergy with racism. Let’s wait until all of the facts appear.

taj ahmad eldridge, mba,, managing partner, global policy consultancy, at 9:35 am EDT on May 4, 2006

Isn’t it funny

Isn’t it funny how when someone of color resigns or gets fired it always comes out that the decision was based on the person’s race? If the DCCCD board and faculty members had been comprised of all Latino or African Americans or other minorities would anyone be crying racism? I highly doubt it. I agree that you should wait until all the facts are out from both sides before the racism flag is raised.

Hmmmm, at 10:50 am EDT on May 4, 2006

The Last Refuge of a Scoundrel...

Yes, it’s easy to cry “racism” when you don’t like an outcome. And it’s racism pure and simple when people support (or, for that matter, oppose) someone purely on the basis of race. But what of the obligations of the writer of this piece? The words “Latino” and “racism” show up throughout the piece, but there isn’t one single example of anything for the reader to weigh in judging the role of race here. Why raise the issue if there’s no evidence? And if there is evidence, why not present it?

Publius, at 12:00 pm EDT on May 4, 2006

In Dallas the question is always about race....

The previous postings are clearly offered by those who are not members of the greater DFW community particularly the academic community. Those of us who work as professors of color at these institutions, now all to well the role that race plays in an area that remains highly segregated—heck the area where our premier institution (SMU) resides is its own city to keep from dealing with issues of integration. While all the issues of the chancellor’s departure may have had nothing to do with race..if you live and work in Dallas it is all about you know class and race were at least backdrops to the discussion...

Asst. Prof. In Dallas, at 12:00 pm EDT on May 4, 2006

Publius’ “fair and balanced” commentary is wrong on one point: the author of the article DID specify criticisms of the chancellor (leadership style, lack of consultation) as well as Carreon’s accomplishments, all of which had nothing to do with ethnicity.

The critics did make a telling point, however — that Carreon “tended to question the way things have historically been done.” I would submit that this is a mark of effective leadership, which the trustees and faculty apparently aren’t ready for.

I would also suggest that this string of commentary, which includes slurs against Texans and Latinos alike, simply misses the point. Competent leadership is hard to find, and often is even harder to tolerate.

The nation and Dallas CC District can debate race, immigration and ethnicity until the cows come home, but until we recognize, respect and nurture competency, we will continue to get the (mostly mediocre) leaders we deserve.

John R., at 1:25 pm EDT on May 4, 2006

Undoubtedly, there will always be those who cringe at the use of the word “racism.” This has been the case since the days when local authorities proudly wore police caps by day and hoods by night (not that long ago). But for many of us who have lived our lives in the so-called enlightened entrails of the academy, we certainly have many stories to tell.

The tradition in higher education when one reaches a certain level of responsibility is to bow and walk away quietly and go forward to the next challenge.

In these scoundrel times, it is unlikely that the facts of the case will ever be shared with the public. Plausible deniability, I think is the borrowed phrase and policy in practice that institutions use to shield their secrets.

Leonard Ramirez, at 7:40 pm EDT on May 4, 2006

Although race could have played a part, until evidence is presented it seems odd to assume race was a factor. Larry Summers was run out of Harvard despite groveling. Sometimes the faculty just doesn’t want to change and they can be a powerful group.

Brian, at 9:15 pm EDT on May 4, 2006

Ethnic Tensions in Dallas

Unfortunately, the cry of faculty about not being consulted enough is very familiar to those of us in higher ed. They typically demand far more input than their range of expertise in the area warrents.

I don’t know the facts of this incident in Dallas but there may well be racial undercurrents in the faculty stance. Despite the fact that many have tenure, they are still adept at stirring the pot without ever having the courage to stand up and say what they really mean. They hide behind anonymous surveys with vaguely worded questions that are subject to interpretation.

HigherEdpro, at 9:10 am EDT on May 5, 2006

Carreon

Based on article, “Carreon led a successful campaign for a $450 million bond issue that officials said was key for facilities in the district, which serves about 63,000 students in credit programs. He also opened five new campus centers to try to increase access to courses,” it sounds like Carreon’s successes were a threat to the faculty. People hate change, it’s in their nature to despise it. All kinds of jealousy and envy pop up when someone is doing something that is effective and good and outshines those who have just sat on their tush doing nothing. Those of us who are called minority know of the silent institutional racism that opposes our advancement. Sure the institution will allow you to act as a leader as long as you do what they say and don’t overstep your boundaries. They are too insecure for that. Go Carreon because with every seemingly defeat, promotion awaits you. Change for the betterment of mankind is what is important. I pray for you and salute you in your accomplishments. Elizabeth

Elizabeth Richardson, Assistant Director, MLK Academy at WMU, at 12:15 pm EDT on May 5, 2006

White Faculty

Having read the article from Los Angeles and myself an adjunct college professor over ten years, I can tell you one fact.

All colleges are driven by majority White faculty who hide under shared governance mythology and union rights that functions more like a segregated country club.

These White faculty associations and I have taught at ten different colleges and am the author of three books, hide behind professionalism yet are not held accountable for their racial conduct of White majority hires and then using Blacks to fight Mexicans. These White faculties are not held accountable to anybody and through their hiring perpetuate White self perservation even if they covert their incompetency.

Julian Segura Camacho, Adjunct Faculty at CSU, at 8:40 pm EDT on June 15, 2006

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Ethnic Tensions in Dallas

or search for jobs directly.

Postdoctoral Scholar Series, Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior
University of California, Irvine

POSTDOCTORAL SCHOLAR SERIES positions are periodically available in the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior at the ... see job

Research Associate-Blanket
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Specialists, Department of Chemistry
University of California, Irvine

The Department of Chemistry anticipates openings for all levels of the Specialist series. Requirements — Applications are ... see job

Adjunct Assistant Professor — English as a Second Language/English for Academic Purposes (ESL/EAP)
Johnson County Community College

A career at Johnson County Community College is more than a job. We believe it’s important to invest in our employees and ... see job

FOREIGN LANGUAGE — Arabic — Associate Faculty Pool
West Valley/Mission Community College District

WEST VALLEY-MISSION COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT ACADEMIC PART-TIME EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY FOREIGN LANGUAGE — Arabic — ... see job

Programmer Analyst
Yale University

General Purpose
Under the general direction of the Director of Informatics and ITS Manager, work with Informatics ... see job

Associate / Full Professor
NC State University

Join the Pack! A community with nearly 8,000 faculty and staff, and 30,000 students. NC State is one of the largest employers ... see job

Undergraduate Adjunct: General Education
DeVry College of New York

General Education Adjunct Faculty for Undergraduate Students MANHATTAN LOCATION see job

Materials Science and Engineering Faculty Position
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Faculty, Chemistry/Biochemistry, Full-Time, Tenure Track, Fall 2009
Salem State College, MA

Salem State College is an equal opportunity / affirmative action employer. Persons of color, women and persons with ... see job