Ward Churchill, the controversial University of Colorado professor found guilty by a faculty panel of multiple forms of academic misconduct, has released a detailed defense. In a six-page reply, he questioned the process under which he was investigated, the standards the committee applied, and its conclusions. He characterized the process as "the latest step in CU's ongoing attempt to fire me for political speech and, more fundamentally, for scholarship which challenges the orthodox 'canon' of historical truth."
Gustavus Adolphus College, in Minnesota, has announced that it will no longer require applicants to submit ACT or SAT scores. College officials said that they had studied the experience of other liberal arts colleges that have dropped the requirement, and found that other measures -- particularly high school grades and coursework -- were better ways to predict college success.
Faculty members at the University of Maine at Presque Isle have voted no confidence in President Karl E. Burgher, citing his failure to communicate well with students or professors and allegations that he wanted to ignore an incident where athletes on a road trip hired a stripper to perform for them in a hotel, The Bangor Daily News reported. Student leaders joined faculty members in calling for the president's ouster. Burgher told the newspaper that he did not want to discuss details, but that he was working with faculty members to "resolve" issues in ways that would satisfy everyone.
A major donor to Stanford University athletics has just made a gift of $100 million, The San Francisco Chronicle reported. The gift has not been announced formally and is not entirely for athletics, the newspaper said. It identified the donor as John Arrillaga, a developer.
Thousands of students in Indiana are finding their state grants for the next academic year significantly smaller than they expected, The Indianapolis Star reported. Officials blamed a number of factors, including a larger-than-expected applicant pool and a tight state budget.
Ryan Cross, a former basketball coach at Barton County Community College, in Kansas, pleaded guilty to wire fraud in falsifying the records of athletes, The Hutchinson News reported. Barton County Community Collegte has been facing one of the largest scandals in two-year college athletics, with multiple indictments of former officials.
Comments on
Quick Takes: Ward Churchill's Defense, Gustavus Adolphus Drops ACT/SAT, Presque Isle Professors Vote No Confidence, Stanford's Semi-Secret $100M, Indiana Students' Grants Shrink, Wire Fraud by Coach
Cjurchill Kangaroo Court at CU
Posted
by BA
on May 25, 2006 at 12:20pm EDT
Living in Colorado, I have been following this controversy from the start. Governor Owens of Colorado made clear his intentions early on to get Churchill fired and to punish anyone within the state of Colorado who publicly supports Churchill. Among other things, the University of Colorado administration is bowing to threats from Owens to punish UC if it does not fire Churchill. Owens threatened to withhold state and federal funding from UC if it does not comply with his wishes to get rid of Churchill. Moreover, Owens has had conversations with David Horowitz about imposing the so-called "academic bill of rights," a right-wing attempt to impose speech control on faculty to its liking.
Now Churchill has been found guilty of so-called "research misconduct" by a committee that does not follow respectable and professionally accepted standards of research procedures nor has it followed even the rules of the University of Colorado under which it operated.
Churchill was found guilty by a committee that amounts to a prosecution team (of CU lawyers and their cohorts), without sufficient opportunity to defend himself and without a jury. Moreover, following a previous pattern, the committee made clear that CU intends to initiate yet another investigation (for an actual total so far of 3) into Churchill’s academic performance based on still more purported allegations.
This entire debacle is Kafkaesque. And it is certainly a disgrace to the University of Colorado.
specifics please
Posted
by Larry
on May 25, 2006 at 6:10pm EDT
BA, Can you point to a single part of the report which you think is legally or factually incorrect. Was Churchill not given an opportunity to defend himself, cross examine witnesses, or was he not informed of the nature of the charges against him? If you have not read the report, then you are not helping. Further, as a constitutional and statutory jury trial is not required when sanctioning or dismissing a professor or any public employee.
Politicians make all sorts of crazy claims, but most of them are for public consumption only.
quicker link to full text of Churchill's six-page message
Posted
by n4
on May 25, 2006 at 6:10pm EDT
Unfortunately, it's not so easy to find a simple posting of Ward Churchill's six-page 5/25/06 message, so I have posted a copy of it at this url:
http://la.indymedia.org/news/2006/05/160029.php
(the link in your article, for example, does not lead to Churchill's message itself but to commentary about Churchill's message and to yet another link to a downloadable microsoft word document of Churchill's message. This is an unnecessarily roundabout way of getting the information.)
Churchill's powerful response
Posted
by md
, Churchill responds with specifics
on May 26, 2006 at 4:15pm EDT
Churchill's reponse to the report contains answers to all of Larry's questions. Perhaps he might offer some specifics as to what parts of it he finds insufficient