Advertisement

Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

An Academic Blog for Students

Every student will soon be a blogger at the University of Pennsylvania’s College of Arts and Sciences — and the authors won’t just be filling their pages with party anecdotes.

As part of summer registration, members of the class of 2010 are receiving from the college personalized “academic blog” pages, where they are asked to fill out what amounts to an online questionnaire. The students’ first online journal entries will focus on their intellectual interests, academic concerns and educational experiences. Many bloggers will outline their strengths and weaknesses, and create a personal mission statement.

The academic blogs aren’t meant for mass consumption. Only the student, an academic adviser and authorized university officials will be able to see the content. The idea is to formulate talking points for when freshmen first meet their faculty mentors in the fall.

“We’re trying to give the adviser some context, so the relationship doesn’t start as ‘who the hell are you?’” said Dennis DeTurck, dean of the College of Arts and Sciences and a professor of mathematics.

The academic blogs are simple in design and look like a university Web page, with the Penn insignia in the upper-left-hand corner. Each semester, university staff will post new questions on the students’ academic blog. DeTurck said those prompts are intended to be jumping-off points and be relevant to a student’s academic standing. For instance, sophomores will be asked to explain their rationale for choosing a major and weigh the merits of studying abroad during their third year.

Only the summer entry is required of incomming freshmen, but many advisers are likely to request that their advisees update the content at least once a semester. The idea is for students to use the forum over all four years and see how — or if — their academic interests change.

DeTurck said incoming students have always been asked to fill out a questionnaire, and advisers have always kept tabs on the students, but that there wasn’t an organized recording method.

More than 300 freshmen took part in the academic blogging pilot program last academic year, and those students will continue to post throughout their sophomore year. DeTurck said some of his advisees posted just twice during the year, while others used the blog as a regular resource. And, of course, some delved into the personal realm.

“Looking at Facebook, you can see students are revealing all kinds of intimate info about themselves in a very public way,” DeTurck said. “A lot of them really open up in that medium; they’d type things into blogs that they’d never say sitting across from me in my office. They talk about girlfriends, relationships, how they feel.”

Because the College of Arts and Sciences sponsors the journal pages, DeTurck said the school is responsible for monitoring the quality in order to avoid liability issues. The student pages are considered academic records, and after an entry is completed, it cannot be altered by the student. Members of the college’s counseling office can look at material if it is deemed to be relating to the student’s mental health.

“That’s a serious issue for us — trying to be able to connect the dots,” DeTurck said. “We see this as a tool for detecting serious situations when they arise.” (Though he said that isn’t the main intent of the journal pages).

Janet Tighe, dean of freshmen and director of academic advising at Penn, she said didn’t notice too many inappopriate details in the student blogs last year. “They get the difference between this and Facebook,” she said.

DeTurck said he has been pleased with the content. Before each meeting with his advisees, he checks student pages to see what’s on their minds. Sometimes, it comes down to practical help: When one student mentioned he was struggling in physics class, DeTurck offered academic help.

Hayling Price, a Penn rising sophomore and undergraduate assembly representative who didn’t participate in the pilot program, said he would find keeping an acadmic journal useful. “I was lucky enough to have an adviser who had a common interest with me, so we had a good rapport,” Price said. “But that isn’t the norm — most people have less to talk about with their advisers, so this would help.”

Added Brett Perlmutter, president of the class of 2009: “For a first-year student who comes in with a different perspective, with any apprehension, it’s a great way to get initial feedback,” he said.

Tighe said the real test will come two or three years from now, when the original bloggers check back on their original posts.

Elia Powers

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Academic Blog for Students

What University had provided is a good idea.. for providing an individual blog for each and every student who enrolls in 2010 batch. By this every one can share open ideas of everybody and they can view each of their messages openly and they can have their creativity shared. __________________________________________ MaverickCalifornia Drug Treatment

Maverick, at 9:35 am EDT on August 14, 2008

Good idea, but...

I think this sounds like a great idea. But I guess I take issue with the term “blog” being applied to these spaces. It’s perhaps splitting hairs, but if you’ve got a writing space that is a) not voluntary and/or assigned writing, and b) is not open to the public, then I don’t think what you’re doing is “blogging.” I think what you’re doing is something else... though I don’t know what else you’d call it.

Steven D. Krause, Associate Professor at Eastern Michigan University, at 6:45 am EDT on June 9, 2006

As an Academic Advising Journal

this is a great idea, especially, as one student notes, if it is used to help students plan their academic careers and seek advice.

This journal does attempt to capture some of the energy and motivation associated with facebook, myspace, livejournal, and blogs. But if the university establishes this forum; if it monitors the forum’s content; and if it freezes what the student writes so that s/he can’t go back and change it, it’s not a blog.

kathleen yancey

kathleen yancey, Florida State University, at 8:50 am EDT on June 9, 2006

Portfolio

It sounds more like an academic portfolio. I agree with Steven and Kathleen that it’s not quite a blog if it’s not public and not editable.

Definitely an interesting idea. Maybe it would be more interesting if the students were allowed to make parts of it public and could find other students who share their interests or concerns. One of the greatest benefits of “real” blogging is the feedback you get from others who’ve had similar experiences and can offer advice.

Laura, Bryn Mawr College, at 10:40 am EDT on June 9, 2006

Why call it a blog at all?

I concur with the above comments that while there is definite merit in an academic journal of a student’s experiences and changing thoughts throughout their degree(s), calling something that is not changable, not sharable, not RSSed and policed by faculty is by no means a blog. I suspect the good online credibility that might result from the term blog will backfire since bloggers have a strong tendancy to argue whether the term blog is appropriate or not. Better to call is an Academic Journal or something similar and give the project a chance to take its own form rather than badly mimicking another ...

Tama Leaver, University of Western Australia, at 10:50 pm EDT on June 12, 2006

These may be an excellent idea for faculty and studnets, but are certainly not blogs — the word shouldn’t be applied to them. Blogs are (at least to some extent) able to be personalised, are regularly updated and are open to editing and comments, as other commenters have pointed out. That is the point of blogs — they are a tool for sharing and developing ideas, not recording them and freezing them in time.

Mary-Helen Ward, University of Sydney, Australia, at 11:00 pm EDT on June 13, 2006

‘Uneditable’ – that is a bit harsh. It would force bloggers to get their entries right first time. I suppose they think that it forces the students to represent their thoughts much more carefully. But who is ever able to give clarity and verisimilitude in such a way? So a student makes a mistake, and then must post a comment or a follow up entry to correct the mistake. OK, that forces them to reflect upon the mistake and the reasons for making the mistake. That’s a pretty extreme form of reflective thinking. Is anyone that disciplined? Is anyone comfortable with behaving in that way? Would we want all of our mistakes to be recorded permanently? Would anyone then ever take risks with what they write? Would anyone ever write anything worthwhile?

My conjecture is that they will find that this approach makes their students very uncomfortable about the technology. They certainly will not get good quality, engaged and involved blogging.

Robert O’Toole, Arts FAculty E-learning Advisor at University of Warwick, at 7:20 am EDT on June 14, 2006

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to An Academic Blog for Students

or search for jobs directly.

Non Teaching Academic Staff
University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee

UW-Milwaukee Letters and Science. For complete job description and to apply, please go to see job

Publications and Strategic Communications Production Manager
Vanderbilt University

Publications and Strategic Communications Production Manager Office of Undergraduate Admissions, Vanderbilt University ... see job

Systems Analyst – Technology Solutions Services
Portland Community College

The Analyst monitors, maintains, and upgrades applicable technology, which includes quality assurance, problem solving, ... see job

Adjunct Faculty, Culinary Arts
Joliet Junior College

Joliet Junior College is located in the Chicagoland area. JJC offers over 100 degree and certificate programs in the arts and ... see job

The Patricia and J. Douglas Perry Chair in Psychology
Old Dominion University

Candidates for the Perry Chair are expected to be full professors and to have an outstanding research program, evidenced by ... see job

Assistant/Associate Professor or Professor
East Carolina University

East Carolina University, a constituent institution of the University of North Carolina, is a doctoral institution with an ... see job

Biology Instructor
Technical College of the Lowcountry

TCL is located in Beaufort between the historic cities of Savannah, GA and Charleston, SC and adjacent to the resort area of ... see job

Adjunct Faculty, Adult Education
Elgin Community College

We’re committed to our vision of becoming the best comprehensive community college in the United States. see job

Construction Engineering and Structural Engineering Assistant Professor
California State University—Fullerton

Construction Engineering and Structural Engineering Assistant Professor positions in Civil & Environmental Engineering Dept., ... see job

Associate Professor/Professor
Medical University of South Carolina

In the historic, coastal city of Charleston, the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) offers a wide range of ... see job