News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
June 27, 2006 Shoe Leather Recruiting: A Special Report
One day, Charles B. Reed, chancellor of the California State University System, was visiting predominantly Latino schools near Los Angeles, asking around, trying to better understand how to recruit Latino students.
At one meeting, an elderly man who had heard it all before stood up: “Chancellor, will you put your money where your mouth is?” he asked. “I have a way to get to Latino mothers. They have a lot of influence on their children.”
That man was Vahac Mardirosian, founder of the Parent Institute for Quality Education, a group that is based in San Diego and is expanding to other states. The institute is known by its acronym (PIQE, pronounded P-K), and runs nine-week training programs at schools where parents, particularly those who did not attend college themselves, learn how to improve their children’s classroom performance and put them on the path toward college.
In February, Reed announced he’d be putting his money where his mouth is. California State pledged $575,000 in matching funds to bring the PIQE program to schools near CSU campuses — enough money to allow for substantial expansion of its efforts. He also pushed to have recruitment materials printed in English and Spanish, including a popular poster titled “How to Get to College” that CSU officials distribute whenever they meet with prospective enrollees and their families. These gestures, says Reed, show that campus officials are willing to bridge language gaps and are prepared to communicate with Latino students. (The system now offers the posters in five languages, and Hmong is set to be the sixth.)
David Valladolid, president and CEO of PIQE, said that parental college counseling is critical for all students, and especially low-income students, and especially low-income students in California, where professional counseling can be in short supply. According to a University of California report, the average high school counselor in America serves 284 students, while the average California counselor serves 790, more than in any other state.
“One in two students in California right now is Hispanic,” says Valladolid, adding that PIQE is by no means restricted to Hispanic families, but that, in California, they are a large part of the clientele. “If we don’t get them to understand the system, they won’t go on.”
PIQE has one class a week for nine weeks. Two identical sections are held so that parents can work around their job schedules. The first three classes are general orientation. The next three discuss creating a home environment conducive to studying and academic success. For example, PIQE recommends that parents establish a time and space for studying complete with pencils and paper, and that they let their children see them reading.
The final three classes teach parents how to navigate their children’s schools. Parents are encouraged to visit their children’s teachers at least once a month to track their progress, and to commend their children when they do well, as well as to learn about extracurricular and special programs offered at school. Valladolid said that, for families where no one has gone to college, even knowing that college applications have to be turned in in the fall of the year before a student wants to attend is knowledge that cannot be taken for granted.
Some parents who complete the PIQE course — 30,000 graduated in California last year — become recruiters for the program. “The best recruiter for us,” Valladolid said, “is a parent who graduated and whose child is benefiting from it.”
Some parents in each class of PIQE students are identified as “parent leaders,” Valladolid said, and they get a list of 100 names of potential PIQE parents. For every name on the list they call, they get 50 cents, and for each person called who ends up attending, they get $2.
Valladolid said that many Latino mothers have great influence in their children’s decisions, but that many are from countries, like Mexico, where the education system is managed by the federal government, rather than state by state, “and parent participation is not encouraged,” he said.
Brent Knight, president of Morton College, in Illinois, says that Reed is wise to be focusing on outreach to this burgeoning population. When Knight became president of Morton, which serves an area outside Chicago that is increasingly Latino, he immediately felt that there were not enough Latino administrators. One of his first orders of business was recruiting staff members who would understand the need to connect with underserved students — and their parents — in the area.
“The community, in effect, owns the college,” says Knight. “We have a fiduciary responsibility to be representative.”
He has been successful at diversifying his staff to include several Spanish speakers, and has also led controversial efforts to have signs written in Spanish language placed around the campus to help Latino families feel more comfortable with the institution. All of the desk staff at help centers on campus are now bilingual as well, another signal that is meant to suggest inclusion.
The college has also created a summer Bridge Program, aimed at local high school students. Students are immersed for several weeks in the college environment and taught by professors to build their academic skills and prepare for enrollment. Administrators have also started the Bring a Buddy Program, which allows interested students to have their friends come with them to orientation sessions
“We’ve engaged the faculty and administrators at high school and have shown that we are as good a school as any in the areas,” says Mark Escamilla, executive vice president of Morton. “We’ve been able to change the opinions of critical players who were once skeptical of us.”
Sandra Saldana, dean of student success at Morton, says that once the new efforts began to unfold, word-of-mouth recruiting became much easier. She recalls one recent parent orientation where a Latino mother started telling others about the welcoming environment at Morton.
“In higher education, you have to market your services and how you can meet people’s needs at a good price,” says Saldana. “The message is, ‘We’re here to serve you, you, you.’ ”
That message has resounded. A decade ago, Latinos made up less than half of the college’s students. In 2005-6, Latino students, primarily of Mexican descent, make up about 74 percent of the institution’s enrollment, up from 60 percent the previous year.
Enrollment jumps like that are what PIQE’s Valladolid hopes to see at Cal State, and which he knows, from historical precedent, are possible.
He recalls seeing a presentation a few years ago by David Hayes-Bautista, director of the Center for the Study of Latino Health and Culture at the University of California at Los Angeles medical school. Hayes-Bautista started flashing statistics about a particular demographic. “Ninety percent of this group’s parents have no college education,” Valladolid recalls him saying. “Fifty percent will drop out of high school, 20 percent of those left will be eligible for college, 10 percent will go, and 5 percent will graduate.”
“Everybody said, ‘that must be the Latino community in California,’ ” says Valladolid. But it was the white community of 1950, many of whom had moved from the Midwest. “How did they change it to where 35 percent of white students get a B.A.?” asks Vallodolid. “His response was: through schools, churches, government … educational programs. It’s the same challenge today, but rather than a migratory population, we have an immigrant population.”
— Rob Capriccioso and David Epstein
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
I applaud efforts to facilitate access to Latino college students. Yet I continue to see a cultural and societal challenge to Latinos once they get into school. Foundational theories of student development, retention, and adjustment, conflict with the cultural values of many Latinos. These conflicts manifest in negative campus climates and experiences. Including parents into the process is good, but more needs to be done to include parents throughout the college experience. College being so culturally disconnected for many, the role of the family becomes even more important.
Hugo Najera, Coordinator, Latino Student Services and Advoacy at University of Maryland, College Park, at 10:35 am EDT on June 27, 2006
Mr. Najera, I’m not sure I understand what you mean when you say, “foundational theories of student development, retention, and adjustment, conflict with the cultural values of many Latinos.” Could you please elaborate?
Daniel, Student at Wash U, at 1:50 pm EDT on June 27, 2006
Looking at college adjustment, Tinto claims that there must be a ritualistic severing of ties from home in order for a student to become independent. For many (not all) Latinos, maintaining ties to one’s family is esstential to navigate the college experience. Living on campus, participating in student orgs, and other funcitons are set to promote development, but may conflict with a family’s desire for their child to be close to home.
Hugo Najera, Coordinator, Latino Student Services and Advoacy at University of Maryland, College Park, at 2:50 pm EDT on June 27, 2006
What Mr. Najera is trying to say, in not so many words, is that much of our understanding of traditional college students and the theories built upon on that understanding are based on observations of mostly white students, especially white males. This is definitely changing and improving over time but the foundational psychology and the first theories were built on a very limited understanding of people other than 18-24 year old white men. I’m not sure it would be quite right to label those theories as shortsighted or discriminatory as most college students at those times fit that profile. Chickering’s Vectors of Student Develop provide a great example of this very phenomenon. The first edition of Chickering’s book “Education and Identity,” published in 1969, included “Establishing Autonomy” as one of the “vectors” of development (I think that’s how it’s phrased; the book is at home and I am not). The second edition of the book, published in 1993, changed this vector to “Moving Through Autonomy Toward Interdependence,” based largely on research in the intervening years on how women and men develop differently.
Kevin Guidry, at 8:30 pm EDT on June 27, 2006
Several older studies on racial climate (refer to the work of Sylvia Hurtado) have looked at issues of racial climate for latinos and blacks have found (not surprisingly) that students of color do not have experiences that are a positive as whites. A recent studies (see: Source of the River) have actually shown that latino students do BETTER in college when they visit home more frequently—which is not true of other racial groups. This is a great example of how “cultural” differences need to be taken into account when looking at retention.
Rochelle, at 3:00 pm EDT on June 28, 2006
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
The OSU College of Osteopathic Medicine has been consistently ranked nationally in rural medicine and primary care by US News ... see job
Drake University is a diverse learning community of more than 5,600 students, distinguished by collaborative learning among ... see job
The University of Rochester invites applications for a tenure-track faculty position in the Department of Biomedical ... see job
PROJECT SCIENTIST SERIES positions are periodically available in the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior at the ... see job
Technical Writing English Composition Western Civilization — Online Speech Psychology Photography MATERIALS NEEDED Interested ... see job
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at The University of California, Los Angeles and the NASA Jet Propulsion ... see job
Job Summary Roosevelt University seeks an accomplished academic leader to serve as the first Gerald W. ... see job
George Fox University seeks an Associate Director of Career Services to develop and oversee employment and field experience ... see job
Associate Dean for Research — College of Allied Health Sciences — University of Cincinnati see job
Perceived road blocks
Fifty percent of prospective students who do not attend college, do not because of a perceived inability to afford it (ACE study). The role of a pro-active financial aid administrator is critical in reaching many of the underrepresented or low-income populations. As a front office and back office financial aid third-party servicer, we educate and motivate those prospective students through the financial aid process so they can realize their dreams.
Sandra, Global Financial Aid Services, at 10:05 am EDT on June 27, 2006