Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Hopkins Endorses Gender Parity

A recent study, three years in the making, finds that Johns Hopkins University continues to lag behind comparable research institutions in recruiting and hiring female faculty and executive leaders. The Hopkins committee releasing the report has recommended and the university has endorsed that the institution achieve 50 percent representation of women in senior faculty and leadership positions by 2020.

The report also calls for the university to make women’s concerns a top priority and points out the need to provide more work-life balance for faculty members.

Provost Steven Knapp said that women comprise two of the university’s five vice presidents and only two of the eight academic deans. Further, the report found that women made up 51 percent of the student body but only 36 percent of full-time faculty in 2005. Female full professors comprised only 18 percent of the faculty (2005 numbers) and 15 percent of department heads (2003). The university is dedicated to meet the report’s goals, but Knapp said that it would be easier to move women into leadership roles, which frequently turn over, than into faculty jobs. “I have to say that this is an aspiration but there is a rate limiting factor for parity when you look at [faculty] turnover,” he said.

Knapp said that one of the major problems with hiring women in the past, few qualified women to fill a position, is no longer an issue. “There is a huge pool of talented women in the pipeline and we need to focus on that,” he said. Knapp pointed out that people are living longer and continue to contribute as scholars at much later ages, which impedes the university’s ability to hire new professors. He said that the university may explore different pathways for people to contribute to scholarly life without taking up a faculty slot, which will free Hopkins to make more hiring decisions.

“We can’t have all this talent knocking at the door,” he said. The department of medicine, he noted, has had the most success at hiring women.

Myron Weisfeldt, who chairs the department of medicine, said that his department made a concerted and successful effort to hire more women long before he came to Hopkins five years ago. He also explained that his department has not had to deal with retirement issues to reach gender equity, like other departments, because medicine expanded dramatically at Hopkins when the budget for the National Institutes of Health doubled during the 90s.

“I believe the next big step is working on leadership,” Weisfeldt said. “Leadership turns over much more frequently than faculty.” The typical leadership position at Hopkins, he said, becomes vacant every 5 to 10 years and recruiting more women into those positions will probably be easy, he added.

“I think we need to take a very firm stance when we pick positions to make sure that we don’t overlook women,” he said, noting that women are often put off by male professional networks that seem to exclude women.

Linda Fried, professor of medicine and director of the center on ageing and health, said that Hopkins has a history of trying to solve this problem but has only met limited success. She chaired the committee that released the report, and said that prior attempts to retain more women by targeting disparities in salaries and promotions did not seem to work, suggesting a need to try different strategies. A change in how the university defines leadership seems essential, and the university must alter its culture if it wishes to recruit and retain more women.

“Hopkins, like a lot of universities, expects 24/7 dedication to work,” she said. “Men and women see this as an anachronism. We need to develop a broader array of excellence metrics, with more work-life balance, so that people can be valued and not seen as less dedicated to work,” she said. The report recommended that the university provide more “flexible” career paths, especially during the tenure track, while not reducing excellence. The report was vague on how it would accomplish this.

The report by Johns Hopkins follows on the heels of a statement signed last December by the presidents of nine leading research institutions pledging to provide more resources, to change institutional practices, and to “promote a culture that supports family commitment” as part of a drive to advance more women in academe.

Paul D. Thacker

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

50 percent?

I note that the percentage of women Ph.D.’s in math has hovered around 30% for (at least) the last decade, and that the percentage of women full-time faculty members in math is approximately 25%.

I cannot comment on the percentages in other fields.

math prof, at 9:20 am EST on November 21, 2006

Fifty percent is a nice round figure, but it will be difficult to meet that quota across the board at a high end institution such as Johns Hopkins without paying a quality penalty. Forty percent would be more reasonable goal given the greater male variability in the distribution of most of the relevant talents. Note that even the National Academy of Sciences report on “Bias and Barriers,” despite all their cant, couldn’t totally dismiss the male variability hypothesis.

CUNY Prof, at 12:45 pm EST on November 21, 2006

Gender Proportionality Uber Alles

The CUNY Prof is absolutely correct about the obvious decline in quality that will attend the mad pursuit of gender proportionality in administration at Hopkins.

But I doubt that the Hopkins leaders will care that much.

I wonder if they will use the same illogic when selecting players for their vaunted lacrosse team?

Make certain, say, to have a racial or ethnic percentage of players on the Blue Jays lacrosse team to match the racial or ethnic makeup of the undergraduate schools.

Who’s ready to bet that such absurd proportionality is crudely ignored?

Chuck, at 1:15 pm EST on November 21, 2006

The goal is commendable and the measures described above to achieve it are reasonable principles and procedures that should be a model for other institutions.

Colin Danby, University of Washington, Bothell, at 3:45 pm EST on November 21, 2006

Current Quality Penalties

CUNY Prof and Chuck, Your concerns about a decline in quality should we ‘madly pursue gender proportionality’ suggest that there are no ‘quality penalties’ associated with privileging a particular form of leadership that suits only white, middle-class, heterosexual men who have little involvement in caring responsibilities. This type of leadership is fast becoming anachronistic and will die out like the dinosaurs. We will then see an increase in leadership diversity, variability and quality.

Barbara Dalton, Monash University, at 4:20 am EST on November 22, 2006

Gender Essentialism Lives Down Under

When Barbara Walton piously and hilariously opined about “a particular form of leadership that suits only white, middle-class, heterosexual men who have little involvement in caring responsibilities,” she neglected to mention that nearly all such men were primarily raised by women.

Walton’s biological determinist, essentialist view of the sexes lends support to the old saw that when it’s 2006 in the U.S.A., it’s 1906 in Australia.

G’day, mate.

Chuck, at 11:45 am EST on November 22, 2006

Gender ‘parity’

Why is it that any identifiable group is perceived by that group to be under represented when they don’t hold a _number of positions_ equal to the group to which they are comparing themselves?

Should a better qualified male be rejected because the gender representation is not 50% male and 50% female? Or, to put it another way: should a lesser qualified female be accepted over a better qualified male simply because the ‘gender representation’ is not 50/50?

Don’t misread this. I am not stating that women are less qualified than men in any particular field. I am simply saying that both deserve equal treatment regardless of the gender representation levels of that field, organization, location, etc.

Let’s finally drop ALL the barriers and treat all people, male or female, as equals by providing equal opportunities for education, employment and advancement, and put aside this misguided belief that equality and parity depend on holding an equal number of seats at the table.

Chris, at 2:05 pm EST on November 27, 2006

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Hopkins Endorses Gender Parity

or search for jobs directly.

Adjunct Nursing
Community College of Allegheny County

All applicants must apply online at: www.ccacjobs.com. The College’s online application system will allow you to complete a ... see job

Director of Auxiliary Services
Western Carolina University

The Director of Auxiliary Services Reports to the Vice Chancellor for Administration and Finance and is part of the vice ... see job

Research Compliance Officer
Appalachian State University

Appalachian State University seeks a Research Compliance Officer. see job

Assistant Professor of Social Work
Arkansas State University

ASU seeks talented individuals interested in a career with an institution dedicated to educating leaders, enhancing ... see job

Athletic Trainer Supervisor/Athletic Facilities
Prince George’s Community College

Prince George’s Community College is a learning-centered, comprehensive, two-year college located in the Washington, DC ... see job

Agricultural Air Quality Modeling Postdoctoral Researcher
NC State University

Join the Pack! A community with nearly 8,000 faculty and staff, and 30,000 students. NC State is one of the largest employers ... see job

Assistant Director, Office of Tech Dev
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

This Assistant Director position is responsible for assessment of potential and licensing activities for the University’s ... see job

Instructorship or Lectureship of French
Wake Forest University

Small in size. Big in resources. Wake Forest, located in Winston-Salem, NC, provides the intimacy and personal attention ... see job

Assistant Professor of Curriculum & Instruction
Angelo State University

Angelo State University is an equal opportunity employer and seeks to build a diverse workforce community. see job

Assistant Director for Apartment Life and Children’s Services
University of Colorado

Posting Description: This position provides strategic leadership, management, planning, and administrative ... see job