News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Feb. 14, 2007
Consider it another sign that the new Democratic Congress is making good on its vow to ramp up its oversight of the student loan industry.
Tuesday, Rep. George Miller (D-Calif.), chairman of the House of Representatives Education and Labor Committee, and Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, said they had requested information from the company, the White House , and the Education Department about the sale of 400,000 shares of Sallie Mae stock by the student loan behemoth’s chairman, Albert L. Lord. The stock was sold only days before President Bush released his 2008 budget, which contained proposals to cut into lender profits that sent Sallie Mae stock plummeting 9 percent.
The president called for around $18 billion in subsidy cuts and fee increases for the lending industry , and markets responded by sending SLM Corp. stock spiraling downward from $46.46 to $42.37 — the lowest closing price in two years.
“Given the timing between your stock sale and the public announcement of lender cuts, we seek additional information about these events,” the two members of Congress wrote in the letter to Lord. The letter asks for all communications about the lending industry dating to last November 1 between Sallie Mae and the Department of Education, including phone and meeting logs, e-mails, and meeting minutes.
“We look forward to responding to any questions that members may have on this matter,” said Tom Joyce, vice president for corporate communications at Sallie Mae. “The timing was completely and utterly coincidental.”
Joyce said that Lord had notified the corporate board during a regularly scheduled meeting on January 23 that he planned to sell some personal stock to fund several private business ventures.
“It’s undoubtedly in the board minutes,” he said of Lord’s announcement on the stock sale. Lord sold 400,000 shares, netting $18.3 million. Joyce said that this is a little less than 5 percent of the stock that Lord is allowed to own.
Miller and Frank’s letters to the company, the Department of Education and the White House ask for written responses within 10 days.
The letters follow the introduction in the Senate this month of the Student Loan Sunshine Act, which its sponsors, Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.) and Sen. Richard J. Durbin (D-Ill.), say is designed to force lenders and colleges to disclose information about any “special” arrangements in which institutions have agreed to offer products from certain lenders to their students, among other things.
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
And to think, there are still people who think the FFEL student loan program through banks is a better option than the Direct Student Loan program.
On the other hand, maybe I am just jealous I did not get in on the racket early enough. Giving out loans GUARANTEED by the federal government (you can’t *not* make lots of money at the expense of taxpayers, parents, and students) and special inside information about federal policies before they happen is just to good to be true.
PS, at 8:10 am EST on February 14, 2007
Please. The Bush Administration proposed much of the same lender cuts in their last budget, and the company’s stock went down for a few days after the budget came out. But because the GOP Congress couldn’t manage to do anything sensible, nothing happened.
It was terribly likely that the Bushies were going to propose the same cuts because they don’t have any new ideas any more.
Considering that there is a public law requiring the Administration to present it’s budget on that Monday, I wonder how the evil Sallie Mae could have figured that out.
It’s great politics, but if Frank and Miller don’t even have that merest understanding of how the economy works, we’re in for some deep trouble with them at the helm.
Skeptic, at 8:25 am EST on February 14, 2007
While President Bush may have proposed cutting the Perkins Loan Program in FY2006 and FY2007 and the LEAP program in the FY2003-FY2007 budgets, this article is focused on the proposed cuts to lender subsidies. There were no similar cuts proposed in last year’s budget.
The question is whether Al Lord had advance knowledge of the Bush Administration’s proposals that would be presented in the budget. The February 5 release date was known by everybody, but the content of the budget was not.
One could reasonably anticipate that the budget was, at best, going to contain a lack of bad news for education lenders. It was unlikely to contain any information that would cause education lender stock prices to rise.
Curiously, if members of Congress have advance knowledge of pending legislation, it is not illegal for them to trade on this ‘political intelligence’, as insider trading laws do not apply to them.
Mark Kantrowitz, Publisher at FinAid.org, at 9:27 am EST on February 14, 2007
” .. One could reasonably anticipate that the budget was, at best, going to contain a lack of bad news for education lenders ..”
Anticipating negative economic moves with the rise of the Pelosi gang is as easy as predicting what the Harvard/MIT feminist faculty caucus would do to L.A. Summers in a dark, lonely alley.
Another example: the 2008 U.S. presidential election. Voters reject the “higher taxes” candidates and the stock market rises. Almost as certain as death.
C. Bigsby, at 10:45 am EST on February 14, 2007
What really needs to be investigated are the financial interests that staff members of the Department of Education have in lenders like Sallie Mae.
Specifically, what financial interest does Terri Shaw, or her family members hold in Sallie Mae? What about those that she brought with her into the Department of Education from Sallie Mae?
It is highly implausible that she would leave an extremely high paying position as VP with Sallie Mae “out of the goodness of her heart” to take over the reigns of Federal Student Aid — a government position that almost certainly pays dramatically less. Wonder where she’ll end up when she leaves FSA (in shambles). Probably with a cushy, do-nothing-but-get-paid-ALOT position with a lender. Either that or retired.
[Thanks, Terri. Thanks for all the pain you’ve caused us, the borrowers, particularly those of us who fell into the trap of default, and have had our livelihoods ruined by by FSA (for which default payments are a huge moneymaker) despite our good faith and desire to make good on our loans. Hope it was worth it.]
Furthermore, where were the antitrust investigations over the last decade, as Sallie Mae was (and still is) running roughshod through the nonprofit student loan industry, subsuming entire organizations, or their loan portfolios, to the detriment of the public?
These are the questions that need to be thoroughly explored- These knee jerk, 1-news-cycle inquiries are meaningless.
Alan Collinge, Founder at Studentloanjustice.org, at 11:46 am EST on February 14, 2007
Well, imagine that...insider trading by the CEO of a major corporation. The biggest problem with unfettered capitalism has always been greed. American society needs to re-evaluate how we fund such important endeavors as education, and health care. Sure, we need the efficiencies provided by capitalism, but we do not need the terrible inequities that often accompany this structure..like the Al Lord stock deal. As I’ve written before, Mr. Lord made over $41 Million in his last year at Sallie Mae. This came directly from the pockets of students and from the taxpaying public.
If the feds can prove that Mr. Lord had prior knowledge of these regulatory changes, then he should be forced to give up whatever he made on these stock options. Of course, that’ll never happen, which is why “for profit” companies should not be permitted to run student loan companies, colleges, or hospitals.
feudi pandola, at 9:05 am EST on February 15, 2007
I took out a loan with Sallie Mae in 1993, my original loan amount was for $13,000, through deferments and consolidations, my present loan amount is for $16,500 and I have paid something every month since 1993.I don’t seem to be making much of a profit? Tell me what is wrong with this picture?
Jennifer T. Grace , BA,RN, M.Ed, School Nurse, at 7:15 pm EDT on March 26, 2007
I started medical school eager to make a difference and save lives, help people and society, give back.......instaead, I ended up with double plus my student loans due to deferment during residency, financial hardship during a job change and divorce, and all for what? So I can panic and struggle to make ends meet while “helping” others feel better?? I feel worse daily watching the interest compound on my loans and seeing them increase, paying and not denting them, knowing I will have them ALL my LIFE and I will never know freedom of choice to structure my career to suit what I love and help those in need.
They don’t tell you that part.....I end up $250,000 in debt to Sallie Mae (starting at less than $150,000 — you do what you have to when all you have is yourself to count on), I work and easy 60 hour week, with emotionaly draining patients, in the constraint of the insurance and malpractice threats and grip, and for what? To go through divorce, neglect my own family and life and struggle to make ends meet.....
Thanks Sallie Mae for helping a public servent become more dissilutioned and disheartened every day.
Lynn
Lynn, MD, at 9:15 pm EDT on April 9, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Financial Administration Systems Solution
Duties And Responsibilities: Reporting to the ... see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
School of Dentistry seeks for a full-time tenure or tenure track faculty in biomaterial sciences. see job
Position Summary: Princeton University Investment Company (PRINCO) is responsible for the management of ... see job
Exciting Campus Director Opportunities with Growing Proprietary College. see job
Posting Description: The Department of Anesthesiology is looking for several CRNA positions due to growth. ... see job
Lead the development, testing, integration and implementation efforts for the document imaging/business process management ... see job
Leadership Major Gift Officer see job
Position Summary: Provide general office support with a variety of clerical duties and related tasks, ... see job
The Academic Coordinator position for the Hofstra University Physician Assistant Studies Program is a full-time ... see job
No Reservations Required.
Camp Cupcake is newly decorated and there are several vacancies available.
John F. DeFelice, Associate Professor of History at University of Maine at Presque Isle, at 7:41 am EST on February 14, 2007