News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Feb. 28, 2007
The Christopher Newport University board voted Friday to add sexual orientation to the list of qualities on which the Newport News, Va., institution bars discrimination in admissions and employment decisions. The move follows a five-year campaign by students and professors, who previously saw the board table resolutions to expand the equity policy.
In November, several hundred students showed up at a meeting of the Board of Visitors and greeted arriving board members at committee meetings with a silent protest. The board then agreed to reconsider the issue this month, leading to Friday’s vote.
The student government led a lobbying campaign on behalf of the change. “This is all about protecting students and protecting faculty and staff, regardless of their sexual orientation, so that everyone on campus feels safe,” said Molly Buckley, student body president. “This is a somewhat conservative campus and some gay students say that they don’t feel safe speaking up in the classroom or walking at night.”
Buckley noted that Virginia is a conservative state on social issues and that voters there just backed a measure to strengthen the ban on gay marriage. “We needed to tell the board that this isn’t about gay marriage. It’s about protecting students and faculty,” Buckley said.
Virginia’s attorney general, Robert M. McDonnell, however, thinks the gay marriage ban is relevant. He wrote this month to the Christopher Newport board saying that it would not be legal for the university (or other public institutions in the state, which have done the same thing) to bar discrimination based on sexual orientation.
McDonnell argued that under Virginia law, divisions of the state cannot adopt their own policies on issues on which the General Assembly has taken its own position. McDonnell noted that Virginia law bars discrimination based on a variety of measures, but not sexual orientation. He also noted the gay marriage vote and the failure of 17 measures introduced in the legislature since 1997 to bar anti-gay bias. In light of this record, he said, the state has a position that agencies cannot bar discrimination based on sexual orientation.
A spokeswoman for the university said that the board took the letter under advisement, but did not feel bound by it. The spokeswoman noted that Gov. Tim Kaine issued an executive order in which he barred the agencies he supervises from discrimination based on sexual orientation (among other qualities). The spokeswoman said that the board discussion of the issue was closed to the public, so she did not have details on the board’s thinking, except that the vote was unanimous.
Dyana Mason, executive director of Equality Virginia, a gay-rights group, said that someone trying to challenge the anti-bias rules at a public university could cite the attorney general’s views, but that other public universities had similar policies in place for years, without difficulty. “We believe universities do have the authority to set policy for internal purposes,” she said.
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
I have a copy of it if you are interested.
Molly Buckley, Student Body President at CNU, at 11:20 am EST on February 28, 2007
I would have thought that any state institution could premise its non-discrimination policy on its equal protection obligations under the 14th Amendment. Since Romer v. Evans, it’s been clear that sexual orientation discrimination is cognizable under the 14th Amendment. Clear enough, in fact, that quite a few federal courts have rejected qualified immunity arguments by state officials defending against sexual orientation discrimination claims, on the ground that the obligation of a state agency not to discriminate on this basis is “well established” as a matter of federal constitutional law.
Art Leonard, professor at NY Law School, at 11:20 am EST on February 28, 2007
So, it is legal to discriminate based on sexual orientation in the State of VA.
Now, I wonder—if this state school is supported by Federal dollars, is there not a legal contradiction somewhere?
I just love my state of Virginia where some people truly believe they can do whatever they want to whomever they wish no matter what the cost, where it is still considered legal to openly discriminate. It’s amazing this crowd ever decided to re-join the good old U.S. after the Civil War. Perhaps they would have been better off as a separate country. Robert M. McDonnell can elect himself as President....or Fuhrer....
kgotthardt, at 5:31 pm EST on February 28, 2007
Unfortunately, the board’s vote on this issue will have little, if any, effect on protecting employees at CNU. Because Virginia is an “at-will” state in regards to employment and because CNU employees are required to sign contracts stating that they “serve at the will of the President,” the university, can, and does regularly, dismiss employees for any reason or for no reason whatsoever. The university regularly dismisses employees for purely political reasons and without giving any warning or explanation to the employees. It happened to me, and it has happened to others that I know of.
Former CNU employee, at 9:10 am EST on March 1, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
SPECIALIST SERIES positions are periodically available in the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior at the University ... see job
Job Summary Roosevelt University’s Department of Counseling and Human Services seeks a candidate for a ... see job
Job Description: Ithaca College’s Department of Sociology invites applications for a tenure-eligible, ... see job
Hillsborough Community College is a public, comprehensive multi-campus, state-supported community college located in the ... see job
The Math Forum, an innovative research and educational enterprise of Drexel University, is seeking a software engineer. The ... see job
Reporting to the Director of Financial Aid, the Senior Associate Director of Financial Aid is a member of the Office of ... see job
Posting Description: ACADEMIC ADVISOR — HALF-TIME: The Academic Advising Center at the University of ... see job
A career at Johnson County Community College is more than a job. We believe it’s important to invest in our employees and ... see job
Rank/Level: Assistant Tenure Track and Associate Tenure THE HENRY SAMUELI SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ... see job
Roger Williams University is one of the top ranked liberal arts universities in the Northeast and is an Equal Opportunity ... see job
text needed
Does anyone have a copy of the AG’s letter?
Larry, at 7:10 am EST on February 28, 2007