News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
April 19, 2007
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
Wow — a student arrested at U. of Co. for speaking his mind. And I thought that we were supposed to be teaching them how to be independent thinkers. Silly me! Where’s Horowitz when you need him?
Hoosier Prof, at 8:46 am EDT on April 19, 2007
Just because the college rankings are a hit overseas doesn’t make them accurate or more descriptive of any college. It only means that more people are receiving incomplete pictures of colleges.
Regina Mooney, at 10:15 am EDT on April 19, 2007
What the Federal government should be looking at are the FERPA and HIPPA regulations which prevent professionals from sharing information that possibly could save the lives of innocent folks. Everyone is so afraid of running afoul of these regulations that they tend to share no information — even in situations that they could do so.
Jim, VP for Student Development, at 10:15 am EDT on April 19, 2007
The popularity of rankings definitely doesn’t make them accurate- but take a look at this report. It actually addresses how inaccurate the rankings are and puts forth a set of guidelines, developed by a national committee over the course of six years, that is intended to be the beginning of making rankings transparent, accountable, andconsistent with university goals and quality indicators. It seems like the first time someone is recognizing how flawed the rankings systems are and proposing some sort of solution.
Eva, at 11:05 am EDT on April 19, 2007
People also need to learn that just because you can doesn’t mean you should.
kh, at 11:20 am EDT on April 19, 2007
The experience of this student at the U of Colorado is a good learning experience. This is a case study in why one should not yell “FIRE!” in a crowded theatre.
Allegedly, he chose to say to his classroom that he understands the VA Tech killer, because sometimes the flouescent lights and stress make him feel like killing people.
How could this student not understand that this type of a statement would cause some panic?
Geoff, at 1:26 pm EDT on April 19, 2007
Geoff, To me, your argument doesn’t make sense. The (falsely yelling) “Fire in a crowded theater” exception to the general rule of free expression stems from the fact that the audience for the cry would be unable to reflect upon whether or not there really was a fire, and there would be a “clear and present danger” of injury. (This is sort of akin to a farmer suing you for spooking his livestock by scaring them.)
On the other hand, when someone explains their views about current events in a lighted classroom, the audience won’t instinctively and immediately injure themselves. Instead, this student expressed his thoughts on a matter of public concern, and students could reflect upon it, and were neither obligated nor caused to act. Therefore, the actions of the school are likely unconstitutional, and certainly shameful. Likely charges will eventually be dismissed, but this student will be branded for life based on the mere fact that he calmly expressed his views on a matter of public concern. If the facts are as they are presented here, the is one of the most egregious acts of censorship I have seen in a long time.
Unless you are arguing that it everyone knows that expressing a political viewpoint inspires an immediate violent reaction on the part of people, your argument is problematic. Instead, you are just arguing for censorship.
Whether a remark is made is good judgment is a matter for the speaker to decide.
Larry, at 4:02 pm EDT on April 19, 2007
Kh and Geoff: Apparently, we all agree that this was poor judgement. So what? The question is whether or not this is an arrestable offence. As Larry points out, the courts have already defined the difference for us, expressly so that you, me, or the local cops DON’T get to decide. In the meantime, what ever happened to just pulling the kid aside and telling him to use better judgement? Talk about passing the buck! Don’t like what a student says? Call the cops!!
Hoosier Prof, at 5:56 pm EDT on April 19, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
The nation’s first university, Penn is a world-renowned leader in education, research, and innovation. Situated on a ... see job
Applications are being sought for the Specialist Series from B.S., M.S., Ph.D. or M.D. candidates with strong laboratory ... see job
Hesser College Salem, NH Kaplan Higher Education Corporation Director of Admissions Exciting Growth Potential Are you ... see job
Angelo State University’s work environment is often described as an employee community. This applies to the work culture ... see job
(Departments to be determined) The UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center, in collaboration with departments in the ... see job
The WFU Physics Department invites applications for a tenure-track position at the Assistant or early Associate Professor ... see job
Farmer School of Business: Director of Professional Development to coordinate and supervise career services and related ... see job
Division of Public Administration, Mark O. Hatfield School of Government The Division of Public Administration in the Mark O. ... see job
A career at Johnson County Community College is more than a job. We believe it’s important to invest in our employees and ... see job
The University of California Riverside invests in your future through employee training and career development, access to ... see job
Mental Health Check-ups
The government focus should be on how to stimulate public awareness of mental health check-ups. They should be more common than routine physicals. Only then will prevention be possible.
William Sumner Scott, J.D.
Judicial Equality Foundation, Inc.
wss@jefound.org
William Sumner Scott, J.D., at 8:45 am EDT on April 19, 2007