News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
May 29, 2007
An 18-year-old goes to Stanford University. She lives in the dorms. She looks the part, talks the part, fits in just fine. But then comes the news… (cue foreboding music) She’s an impostor!
Is this the plot line to “Orange County II,” a sequel to the movie that chronicled a Southern California high school senior’s uphill climb to get into Stanford?
Not quite.
In this real-life tale, which students say played out this year, a young woman posed as a Stanford student for nearly a year, tricked her roommates into thinking she was enrolled in classes just like them, until one spring day dorm staff outed her as being a phony.
University officials are checking out the claim and aren’t releasing the student’s name while police conduct their own investigation. But dorm residents and acquaintances have identified her as Azia Kim, a recent Orange County, Calif., high school graduate. Kim could not be reached for comment.
As Stanford vows to look into how dorm security can be improved, a second impostor has been revealed, this one a woman who claimed a space in a graduate physics building — reportedly sometimes spending the night there, using computer labs and attending classes. The woman told others she was working on a physics project that required her stay there, according to published reports.
Stanford officials say they have issued the individual a “stay-away letter,” which prohibits her from campus.
Greg Boardman, vice provost for student affairs at Stanford, said in a statement that the university will not share more information while the investigations are taking place. Results will be given to the Santa Clara County district attorney, who will decide whether to prosecute, he added.
“We consider these allegations, if confirmed, to be a serious breach of security within the residence halls,” Boardman said in the statement about the Kim investigation. “We are conducting a full investigation into what occurred and how security can be improved. Stanford is a remarkably caring and friendly community. It is unfortunate that some may be able to take advantage of that trust for their own ends.”
This much is apparent from numerous reports: Kim came to Palo Alto, Calif., in the fall along with other entering freshmen. She misrepresented herself to dozens of Stanford students, moving between two residence halls over several months. Friends say Kim talked her way into staying in rooms and lounges, generally telling students that she was locked out of other housing. And since she owned no dorm keys, Kim would enter by climbing through an open window on the first floor.
Depending on whether she was living amongst freshmen or upper classmen, Kim told students she was either studying human biology or taking classes in preparation to declare the major.
“Something that’s pretty consistent in everything we’ve heard is how thorough she was in doing research about what she was supposed to be doing as a student,” said Daniel Novinson, a reporter for The Stanford Daily. “She had an incredible number of details at her disposal.” That included buying books and commiserating with friends about midterms and finals, he said.
But last week, after a dorm staff member inquired about Kim’s living situation, Kim was asked to leave campus.
Students who spoke to the newspaper said they were shocked to hear about Kim’s situation. Amy Zhou, a Stanford student who lived with Kim, told the student newspaper that “personally, I don’t feel safe now that Stanford allowed this to happen and that they’re not doing anything to ensure the safety of their students.” She did not respond to messages for comment.
A Facebook group, “Azia Kim is my hero,” had attracted more than 304 members as of Monday afternoon. A student identifying himself as a Stanford sophomore wrote on the site that “all [Kim} did was just take advantage of a very laid-back and trusting Stanford culture... The mentality here is very warm and welcoming and nobody is on the lookout for a culprit, which is why she was able to hide for so long.”
Novinson said students there are generally upset that outsiders might get the impression that Stanford is an unsafe place to live. “There’s a concern that there’s going to be an overreaction [by administrators] in responding to this.”
While Kim’s motive is unclear, those who knew her in high school and at Stanford have speculated in reports that she felt pressure to succeed and saw attending the university — with an acceptance letter or not — as one way to fulfill that goal.
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
Remember James Hogue, the Princeton U. track star? He was the subject of a recent 60-Minutes episode and the film Con Man.
http://www.mileendfilms.com/conman.html
I tell my students not to let economics impede their getting an education. I’ve been an uninvited guest at the Sorbonne, the Universidad Complutense, and Harvard, to name a few. Any student sneaking into my class to learn, without any expectation of credits, gets a front-row seat and a buck for a hot cup of coffee. You’re welcome here.
aitatxua, at 9:30 am EDT on May 29, 2007
During the Great Depression my father and his best friend would enroll in colleges and stay there until kicked out for not paying his tuition. This scheme provided room and board during tough times. Not necesarily a role model event but an example of what hard times lead to.
stm60, at 9:55 am EDT on May 29, 2007
I have a close friend who infiltrated Cornell’s Asian Students’ club by showing up to the meetings and being able to speak Chinese. He told me he “just didn’t mention” that he wasn’t a student. He left when he realized at 25 he was better-organized and had a lot more life experience than these 18-21-year-olds and was doing a lot of work for them. As far as I know he just wanted to hang out and speak Chinese with people and discuss Asian culture, but it turned out to be more trouble than it was worth.
I suppose trying to sleep in the dorms is a bit different though.
I’m always amazed at the things people assume about a situation and the things they allow to continue based on those assumptions.
Kate Friend, at 10:40 am EDT on May 29, 2007
I understand that these “imposters” have some legal counts against them, but I’d also like to point out that there should be some investigation into their states of mind. It sounds like Ms. Kim in particular was under a great deal of pressure and felt this was the only way out. I hope that in addition to making sure that she doesn’t continue posing as a student, Stanford (or someone) also steers her towards some counseling.
Concerned Administrator, at 12:50 pm EDT on May 29, 2007
This is a fascinating story. I hope the young woman is not punished as if she was a criminal. She did not hurt anyone, according to the news. And, in fact, she may have even helped some of the students, who exercised a bit of kindness to a stranger when they let her use their dorm rooms. I hope Stanford shows that its welcoming atmosphere is not just for those who can pay. Why don’t they check this young woman’s school record and see if she can return to school in the Fall, this time officially? If she showed such smarts to pose as a student, maybe she did not register because she didn’t have money? Let’s see how Stanford shows its true spirit of loe for teaching and aiding the young generation. Or not.
Marla, at 2:05 pm EDT on May 29, 2007
The administrator above expressed the condescending in loco parentis attitude assumed by pre-1960’s colleges. The sheer absurdity that an 18 year old could be drafted to fight and die and Vietnam, and yet was treated like a child while at university, often more strictly than by their parents, was transparent to many people at the time. In loco parentis became very unfashionable in higher ed for a couple decades, but with the rise of corporate-modelled university administration, such well intentioned pleas about Ms. Kim’s sanity and maintaining security in residence halls seems more motivated by concern for legal liability than anything. Only a degree from Stanford would have the social capital that gives elite degrees their value, the knowledge Ms. Kim was absorbing will be completely unmarketable without it.
Austin, at 9:25 pm EDT on June 9, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Posting Description: This position provides strategic leadership, management, planning, and administrative ... see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
Position Number: FY 09-45 Reports to: Director of Student Success Center Scope: Student Development Specialist II: to perform ... see job
Reporting to the Director of Financial Aid, the Senior Associate Director of Financial Aid is a member of the Office of ... see job
Occidental College is looking for a dynamic individual to provide essential leadership in the Office of Residence Life and ... see job
Everest College, a respected member of the Corinthian Colleges’ network of schools, is dedicated to helping students ... see job
The University of North Carolina’s Kenan-Flagler Business School is seeking to hire an Associate Director focused on the ... see job
Assistant Director for Student Services would be the principal staff member in charge of international student services and ... see job
Everest College, a respected member of the Corinthian Colleges’ network of schools, is dedicated to helping students ... see job
Utah State University is a Carnegie Doctoral/Research University/Extensive school of more than 20,000 students, nestled in a ... see job
Whew! Good thing Ms. Kim never employed the phrase “little Eichmanns.” If she had, of course, Stanford wouldn’t be able to kick her out for something as mundane as fraud and misrepresentation.
Dave S., Assoc. Prof at Land Grant U., at 9:10 am EDT on May 29, 2007