Advertisement

Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Latest Twist in Distance Ed

Violeta Ettle wasn’t sure what to expect when American University offered its first fully online course four summers ago.

The associate provost for administration was confident there would be interest, but from whom? That’s the question facing many college administrators as they develop distance education strategies. The typical targets: students (not necessarily from that institution) from all over the world, and those (enrolled at the college) who are living on campus but want the online option so they can take courses whenever they want.

Turns out, the American program is somewhat of a hybrid. While the university marketed that first course, about terrorism and the legal system, to all sorts of groups in an effort to gauge outside interest, all but two of the 27 students who took the class were its own. Many of the students were away from Washington for the summer, living abroad or at home.

That’s been the case each year since, as almost all of American’s online students are enrolled at the university from fall through spring, and up to 70 percent are away from campus during summer months.

“The most important information we’ve gathered is that our distance learning courses are most attractive to our own students,” Ettle said. “Students know they can use credits toward a degree, whereas some students [outside] might be unsure how they could use the credits.”

As distance education continues to evolve, American’s model will likely become more common, according to Diana Oblinger, vice president for Educause, the nonprofit group that deals with technology issues in higher education.

“It makes absolute sense,” Oblinger said. “Both institutions and students are concerned about the time-to-degree. If you can take a course while you are away and when it’s convenient, that helps you progress toward graduation. From an institution’s perspective, why allow your student to take someone else’s course?”

This summer, American is offering 25 online courses, none of which are longer than seven weeks. The condensed schedule works well for students who are either amidst or have just finished study abroad programs or summer jobs and want to extend their stays away from campus while earning credits, Ettle said. It’s also popular with students who take on internships during the year and want to go to school in the summer without having a full course load.

American provides incentives for those who are part of the distance learning program. Starting several summers ago, the university began giving professors whose online course proposals were accepted a $2,500 course development grant. Summer teaching at American isn’t a substitute for teaching an academic year course, and the additional compensation is only monetary incentive to teach in the summer online. Students receive a discounted rate on summer distance courses, and the price hasn’t changed in four years. A three-credit course costs $2,200, which is about 30 percent cheaper than a graduate course and about 25 percent cheaper than an undergraduate course, Ettle said.

There are other obvious cost savings: Students don’t have to pay for campus housing, and the university frees up space for other uses. The overhead cost of running a distance education course is also significantly less than it is for a normal classroom-based course, Ettle said.

“We’re utilizing our facilities more efficiently,” she said. “We want repeat customers — it’s good for them and it’s good for us.”

Still, American limits students to two distance courses per summer to prevent those who are working or studying elsewhere from overloading their schedules. The university places no limits, though, on the number of summers a student can take an online course.

Oblinger said it’s becoming more common for a university to either require or strongly suggest that its students take an online course as a way to prepare them for how learning often takes place in the workplace.

Logistics are generally easier when a university’s own students take its distance education courses, according to Oblinger. They are familiar with the academic enterprise, she said, and administrators know students are of a certain quality.

Some of the most popular summer distance courses at American are offered through the Schools of Public Affairs, Communication and International Service. Ettle said she would like to see an increase in the number of required courses, as opposed to electives, offered through the program.

American is considering expanding its distance program beyond the summer. Whether the existing summer program expands is largely a function of how many faculty agree to take time away from research and travel, Ettle said.

Then there’s the question of effectiveness. American’s summer distance courses are capped at 25 students, but only a few are at maximum enrollment. The attrition rate in summer courses is 10 to 15 percent — well above the norm during the academic year. Ettle said it’s common for students to drop a course after realizing they’ve underestimated the workload. (Oblinger added that one of the reasons why more colleges aren’t targeting study abroad students is that many of them already have full slates.)

Students and faculty who take part in the summer courses continue to fill out satisfaction surveys, and Ettle said thus far she is “comfortable” but “not ecstatic” with the results. For instance, faculty report that student performance during the summer is generally comparable to performance during the academic year.

“The jury is still out on whether students are learning just as much or more in distance courses compared to face-to-face,” Ettle said. “We’re not saying that distance learning is going to be the silver bullet, but it’s an option.

Elia Powers

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

I disagree strongly with Violetta Ettle. Not only is the jury no longer out, but the verdict was decided long ago — online learning can be every bit as viable a delivery format as face to face. Differences in quality and outcome between courses is much more the result of differences between instructors, rather than any inherent strengths or weaknesses in the delivery format.

Robin Nash, at 10:50 am EDT on August 9, 2007

Kind of “old” news

I’ve taught a state and local government online since the Spring 2000 semester. The course is legislatively mandated for all college students in Texas. About three or four years ago, I decided that it might be interesting to teach the course during the summer. I like it and the course fills up quickly. I don’t have to be in town to teach the course; I’ve taught it from Colorado and this year from Florida.

I had an unusual experience this summer. Three of my students were international students taking the course from international locations. A South Korean student was taking the course from South Korea. A Japanese student took the course from Japan. A Danish student took the course from home in Denmark. When you add the student working for a military contractor in Guam, I taught a state and local government course with a world-wide audience.

The most significant challenge for those students and me was identifying a local government meeting to attend and observe. All students in my state and local government course are required to attend local government meetings. Of course, there are local governments in South Korea, Japan, and Denmark. I was most challenged in helping the student identify a local government to observe in Guam.

Dave Rausch, Associate Professor/Political Science at West Texas A&M University, at 12:35 pm EDT on August 9, 2007

I totally agree with the comment posted about the quality of online courses. There is no question that they can be as good as or even better than face-to-face courses.

I would also like to note that Kentucky State University has been using summer online courses for several years as a way that students who have to go home to jobs can still take courses from their own school. The school benefits, and so do the students. But at KSU, the online course prices did not need to be discounted, and that tiny school of 2,200 students has grown to offering over 80 online class sections this summer, many of which reach the maximum enrollment of 25 or more. American University is certainly not unique in offering summer online courses, and it seems to be still far behind many other schools—-for example, KSU—-in providing these offerings. So, why does American, with its meager 25 courses, get credit for this?

Diane Garrison, at 1:45 pm EDT on August 9, 2007

When you take away the differences there is no difference

As Dr. Fred Saba of San Diego State University says of just about every study and comparision of distance learning, “When you take away the differences and normalize the variables, there is no difference between distance and face-to-face instruction.” (I hope I’ve quoted you correctly Dr. Saba!)

In general, good instruction is good instruction and bad instruction is bad instruction, whether delivered in person or delivered from a distance.

Having taken (and taught) severeal online classes I have had good and not so good learning experiences in both venues.

In general, at least at the graduate level, I notice more self-directed and self-motivated students in the online program. This makes a big difference in the quality of the interactions between instructor and student and between students. And motivated students makes interacting makes a big difference improving learning outcomes.

Jerry Marino, at 3:30 pm EDT on August 9, 2007

Latest twist???

Is this a story from 2000 that has been reposted? The jury is no longer out, as pointed out above. The jury is back, the verdict is in, the jurors have gone home, and the graduate students are publishing their EdD dissertations on Distance Education.

It is comical that the people at American University (AU) are surprised that most of their online students are their own. Lessee.... $2,200 for a three-credit course. That’s more than $700 per credit hour. Um, that’s kind of expensive. Why would I pay that, when I could a) enroll with AU, take as many online courses at my local state university as possible in elective subjects, transfer the credit to AU, finish faster, save a bundle on tuition, and walk away with an AU degree?

The dynamic is in exactly the opposite direction as that expected by AU’s administrators.

Also, someone at AU should take a look at:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List...ountries_by_GDP_%28PPP%29_per_capita

In most high-income countries, the universities are quite good and most are subsidized. So, no joy there. Likewise, the cost of one three-credit course at AU is about the same as a full year’s income in many places. So, no joy there.

The real latest twist in distance education is true competition.

One can hire an instructor to teach an online course for between $1,500-3,000 per course. For a class of twenty, that works out to be $75-150 per student. Throw in $5 per student for the eCollege fee (unless the school is running Moodle). That is your marginal cost. Triple that, and you arrive at something on the order of $250 — $500 per student, per three-credit online course.

When AU and other universities start charging tuition that approximates marginal cost, instead of the bloated monopoly rates that they currently charge, that will be a new twist.

Charles Evans, Executive Director at Free Curricula Center, at 11:10 am EDT on August 21, 2007

Very interesting comments, especially the last cost analysis by Charles Evans. At $1500-$3000 per course, if one assumes teaching it occupies 30 hours of instructor time, the instructor is being paid $50-$100 per hour. Not counting effort to develop and update a course, I suspect that interactions for delivery of the course would consume substantially more than 30 hours of instructor time for a quality 3 credit unit course. If his estimates are true faculty or instructors must willing to work for that. Certainly the interaction could always be outsourced to less expensive instructors (grad student teaching assistants) which is widely done for conventional courses.

The economics, expectations and needs of the student “customers” are critical. Discussion almost always centers around these issues and the expectations of administrators that such courses will be less expensive and more profitable. What is often missing is consideration of the economics and expectations from the perspective of the faculty and instructors who do the teaching. Can others provide specifics of how faculty compensation is determined for teaching on line or distance ed courses?

James Christmann, Professor, Biology Chair at Sonoma State University, at 7:40 pm EDT on August 29, 2007

Our online learning service is for the K12 market. We had thought the summer would be a slow time since our primary markets were homeschoolers and afterschool. It turns out that there is a third crowd: the summer studies. There are ALOT of kids who need or want to prep for the next year or to review the previous year and who are pleased to do it online. For us, in the summers, its primarily a math crowd

john edelson, Founder at Time4Learning, at 4:15 pm EDT on September 16, 2007

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Latest Twist in Distance Ed

or search for jobs directly.

Assistant Director of the Law Enforcement Training -316803
Miami Dade College

Job Description: The Assistant Director is second in command of the largest Law Enforcement Training Center in South Florida, ... see job

Manager of Laboratory Services (UCP-VII)
University of Connecticut

The Department of Chemistry seeks to fill the full-time, permanent position of Manager of Laboratory Services (UCP 7). see job

University Based Programs Manager
University of Pennsylvania

Creates and supervise operational plans: scheduling and staffing. Manage and utilize resources, staff, and budgets. Set ... see job

Dean of Curriculum and Academic Quality
Johnson County Community College

A career at Johnson County Community College is more than a job. We believe it’s important to invest in our employees and ... see job

Instructional Technology and Media Specialist
Princeton University

Position Summary: Princeton University’s Office of Information of Information Technology seeks an ... see job

District Director, College Training and Development (CT&D) — 244604
Miami Dade College

Job Description: The District Director of College Training and Development (CT&D) is responsible for providing the overall ... see job

Director, School of Law Technology and Media Services
Oklahoma City University

Oklahoma City University invites interested candidates to apply for the position of Director, School of Law Technology and ... see job

Director of Instructional Technology and Faculty Development
Kankakee Community College

Kankakee Community College is located in a growing tri-city metropolitan area surrounded by several rural communities. see job

Associate Director: Academic Programs (112134)
Northeastern University

Northeastern University, founded in 1898 and located in Boston, is a private research university that is a leader in ... see job

Course Developer — Education
Laureate Education, Inc.

Laureate Education, Inc., is focused exclusively on providing a superior university experience for adult professionals ... see job