Advertisement

Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Quick Takes: Stay Denied in Research Dispute, University Without E-Mail, Anthro Journals Shift, Grad Student Detained in Russia, Complaint on Va. Tech, Texas A&M Immune From Suit, $100M for Oregon (Sports), Reality TV, Party Schools

  • Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito on Monday refused to stay an appeals court’s ruling that a researcher who left Washington University in St. Louis for Northwestern University could not move thousands of blood and tissue samples with him, the Associated Press reported. Alito’s refusal to block the lower court’s decision does not preclude all of the justices from taking up the case, as they have been asked to do. Many research universities have backed the lower court’s decision, saying its approach was essential for them to manage many long-term studies involving tissues.
  • Eastern Michigan University’s e-mail system has been down since Friday and is not expected to be functioning until tomorrow, The Ann Arbor News reported. Officials acknowledged a “huge inconvenience” for students and faculty members.
  • The University of California Press has announced that the American Anthropological Association is not renewing its journal contract (including the popular AnthroSource online service) and is instead moving the journals to Wiley. The move comes at a time that the association is reviewing the economic model for its journals — with many professors pushing for the association to embrace the open source movement.
  • Roxana Contreras, a Chilean graduate student at the University of Missouri at St. Louis, is facing up to seven years in a Russian prison after authorities detained her when she was trying to leave the country. The Associated Press reported that Contreras, a Ph.D. candidate in physics, bought a few medals and old currency from a street vendor, thinking she was picking up keepsakes, and found herself accused of leaving with contraband. University officials have been among those pushing for her release.
  • Security on Campus has asked the U.S. Education Department to determine whether Virginia Tech took too long (two hours) to notify students of the first shootings in April’s tragedy, The Virginian-Pilot reported. A full report by a state panel is expected soon on the university’s handling of the shootings, but officials have noted previously that at the time they sent out the warning, they were acting on incomplete information about the dangers students faced.
  • A state appeals court has ruled the Texas A&M University is covered by sovereign immunity, and cannot be sued for its role in the 1999 collapse of the Aggie bonfire, which killed 12 students, The Eagle reported.
  • The founder of Nike and his wife have pledged $100 million to the University of Oregon to help fund a new basketball arena and other athletics priorities, the university announced Monday. The gift from Phil and Penny Knight is the biggest in the university’s history, and it follows another recent instance, at Oklahoma State University, in which a benefactor has showered unprecedented funds on a institution’s sports program, a trend sure to aggravate faculty members.
  • A combination of reality television and game show that has captivated India with its promise of a full scholarship to a British university has produced its first winner: Avind Aradhya. The Guardian reported that he won after eight weeks of intense exams and on-air questioning (and the article features a few of the “easier” questions at the end). Aradhya will study engineering at the University of Warwick.
  • The No. 1 ranking colleges do not want is Princeton Review’s annual designation in its college guide of the top party school. This year’s winner is West Virginia University, followed by the University of Mississippi, the University of Texas at Austin, the University of Florida, and the University of Georgia. While Princeton Review’s guide is not known for the quality of its social science research (student surveys are the key tool), it does win points for creative categories — particularly in playing off of student’s studious or not-so-studious reputations, and their politics. Clemson University is named the top jock school. Eugene Lang College of New School University is named the place that educates “dodgeball targets.” Hampshire College topped Bard College for the coveted “Birkenstock-wearing, tree-hugging, clove-smoking vegetarians” award. Macalester College was deemed most accepting of gay students while Hampden-Sydney won for “alternative lifestyles not an alternative.” Another tradition about these rankings is for the top party school’s president to question the ranking. Mike Garrison, president elect at West Virginia, issued this statement: “I’ve talked to thousands of our students over the weekend and during the first day of classes, and their concerns are with their education, with their futures, and with the great year we have ahead at WVU. I’m focused on the way this university changes people’s lives, the research that we do, and the service we provide to the state of West Virginia. This is a special place, and the whole state is proud of it.”

Scott Jaschik

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

I think the clause “a trend to stir up faculty members” is a blatant attempt to stir up faculty members itself. If someone wants to give to the sports facilties, so be it; it is there money. I don’t think most faculty members would give this a second thought. Quit trying to create antagonism that doesn’t necessarily exist. Journalism (while it never really is) is supposed to at least attempt to be balanced and not incite others through little clauses like that.

A, at 11:10 am EDT on August 21, 2007

The Princeton Review’s “rankings”

Let’s just remember that all of PR’s so-called “rankings” are bologna, pure, plain, and simple. They are based on student responses to a survey of questions that no responsible researcher would ever devise, much less use for some legitimate purpose. Equally bad — the sampling involved is simply whoever (which students) happen to visit the website where the survey resides, and take the time to complete all (usually only some) of the “survey.” This is the electronic version of mall-intercept surveying, a technique that very little reliable research is based on. A student attending college X can easily give ratings for *another* college, any other college, whether they’ve ever even been on campus there or not. The list of perfectly appalling research methodologies, and ludicrous ranking categories, goes on and on. It is truly unfortunate that this kind of “research” can be foisted off on an unsuspecting college-bound public of prospective students and families seemingly as if there were some validity to it. Shame on the PR for annually and cynically selling its brand of snake oil. And shame on us for not relentlessly attempting to bring this deceitful organization to account, at least to use high quality surveying, sampling, and analytic techniques.

David D-VA, Institutional Research, at 11:50 am EDT on August 21, 2007

How hard is truth-telling?

” .. Security on Campus has asked the U.S. Education Department to determine whether Virginia Tech took too long (two hours) to notify students of the first shootings ..”

Of course not. Something like this would be very difficult to prepare for radio stations:

“Those heading to VT this morning: VT police reports a building problem on the XX side of campus. You are asked to plan accordingly. Please stay tuned and call police only for emergencies.”

Buzz, at 12:50 pm EDT on August 21, 2007

Knight’s donation to Oregon

In response to “A’s” comment: If an individual wants to give their money to an athletic department, so be it. It is “their” money. However, they should not be able to take an 80% tax write off on this “donation to education.” When academic programs are being cut, hirings and salaries frozen, and class sizes increasing (all things that could be alleviated with more money), it is reasonable to believe many faculty members may be “stirred up” about this.

Oregon is one the few athletic programs that can rely on a Sugar Daddy such as Phil Knight to support the bulk of the program (Boone Pickens at Oklahoma State and John Arrillaga at Stanford are two others to name a few). What “stirs up” more faculty is the majority of athletic programs that are not self-supporting that take money from the university’s general fund and/or increased student fees to cover budget deficits — money that could be used to support academic programs.

George, UNT, at 12:50 pm EDT on August 21, 2007

Oh come on, David

Lighten up a bit. Did you attend a school that was ranked most likely to educate dodgeball targets?

SB, at 12:50 pm EDT on August 21, 2007

$100M for Oregon (Sports)

“In 1996, Knight donated $25 million to The Oregon Campaign, the UO’s $200 million capital campaign which exceeded its goal and stands at $217 million raised. Knight’s gift dedicated $15 million to the creation of endowed chairs across campus and challenged the campus to find a matching donor for each chair. The remaining $10 million is helping to finance construction of a new law school building to be named the William W. Knight Law Center after Phil Knight’s father, a 1932 UO law school graduate.”

Source: University of Oregon

Knight has also given ca. $25M to upgrade and enlarge the UO library.

Sports is sports and business is business. And billionaires usually get to sit anywhere they want to.

Old Duck, Professor, at 4:40 pm EDT on August 21, 2007

Alumni Money for Sports

Now that those institutions have money for sports, savvy Development folk can say to the next big donor, “Sorry, sports is covered. Let’s work to find another worthy area for your legacy.”

mdiehl, at 4:55 pm EDT on August 21, 2007

You can say that Princeton’s rankings are crap, but when you visit these schools you’ll see that there’s a lot of truth behind them. For instance, kids don’t stay sober on the weekends at WVU. It’s just not possible.

Amarie, at 5:15 am EDT on August 22, 2007

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Quick Takes: Stay Denied in Research Dispute, University Without E-Mail, Anthro Journals Shift, Grad Student Detained in Russia, Complaint on Va. Tech, Texas A&M Immune From Suit, $100M for Oregon (Sports), Reality TV, Party Schools

or search for jobs directly.

Assistant or Associate Professor in Economics
Gustavus Adolphus College

Gustavus Adolphus College invites nominations and applications for a tenure-track position of Assistant or Associate ... see job

Faculty: Temp Instructor- Sci & Tech
Fairmont State University/Pierpont Community and Technical College

Fairmont State University and Pierpont Community & Technical College, with a 120-acre main campus in Fairmont, WV, is part of ... see job

Assistant Coach, Men’s & Women’s Track and Field (Indoor & Outdoor)
Bridgewater State College, MA

BSC is one of the largest and most exciting centers for higher education in the commonwealth. Here in our idyllic setting, ... see job

Adjunct Faculty, Nursing
Joliet Junior College

Joliet Junior College is located in the Chicagoland area. JJC offers over 100 degree and certificate programs in the arts and ... see job

Student Services Manager III
University of South Carolina

A leader in academe, the University of South Carolina holds the Carnegie Foundation’s highest research designation and is ... see job

Program Coordinator
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Stone Center Librarian
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill seeks a motivated, innovative, collaborative, service-oriented, and ... see job

Security Officer, Part Time (28hrs/Week), Harrisburg Campus
Harrisburg Area Community College

HACC, a leader in education in Central PA, is a comprehensive, multi-campus community college, providing quality instruction ... see job

Research Professional II
University of Georgia

Job Summary The individual will be responsible for high-throughput processing of plant leaf and wood tissues ... see job

Temporary Research Specialist
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job