Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Quick Takes: Art Disputes at Fisk and Randolph, Education Dept. Oversight Faulted, Publishers’ Lobbying Questioned, Ave Maria Law Accreditation at Risk, Miracle for Stonehill, Noose at Maryland, Trips and Spa Treatments, U. of Hawaii Settles Suit

  • A Tennessee judge on Monday rejected a proposed settlement of a dispute between Fisk University and the Georgia O’Keeffe Museum over the university’s desire to sell some of its noted collection of modern art, The Tennessean reported. Fisk and the museum had agreed on a deal in which the university would have sold the museum an O’Keeffe masterpiece and been able to sell other paintings to other parties. But the judge ruled that a new offer from the Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art, a new Arkansas institution, might be better for the state because this offer would allow Fisk’s full collection to stay in Nashville half of the time. More litigation is now expected. And more litigation is also expected in Virginia, where 11 alumnae, donors, and others plan to seek a court order to block Randolph College from selling any of its art. The college — until recently Randolph-Macon Woman’s College — has said that it may need to sell some of its highly regarded collection of American art to deal with financial difficulties. Critics of the possible sale are also critics of the college’s recent move to admit male students.
  • As it has in the past, the Education Department’s own inspector general is criticizing the agency’s oversight of student loan programs. In a new report, the inspector general found that certain federal financial requirements were not being met at 16 of 27 guarantee agencies reviewed, and that insufficient information was available for the rest of the guarantee agencies.
  • The Association of American Publishers is continuing is campaign against legislation that would require federally sponsored research to be made available online and free. The association’s latest effort — called the Partnership for Research Integrity in Science & Medicine, or PRISM — warns that the open access movement could endanger peer review and the health of academic research. While the arguments the publishers are making are similar to those they have been making for a few years, a number of academic groups are issuing statements to indicate that many in higher education support the open access movement and believe it will help students, researchers and libraries. A letter from the Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition summarizes those statements and arguments.
  • The American Bar Association has informed the Ave Maria School of Law, which it accredits, that the law school may not be in compliance with the requirement that it is maintaining an adequate faculty, The Wall Street Journal reported. The law school is in the process of moving from Michigan to Florida, a move questioned by many professors. The debate over the move has also led to broader questions from many professors about whether the administration will tolerate any criticism. Ave Maria officials have defended the move and their treatment of the faculty.
  • An apparent gas leak caused the off-campus house of four students at Stonehill College, in Massachusetts, to explode Monday, and the president is calling it a miracle that the students survived. The students were treated at a hospital and three have already been released.
  • The University of Maryland at College Park is investigating how and why a noose was placed outside buildings housing several black student organizations, The Washington Post reported. Police said that they are considering the incident a hate crime. C.D. Mote Jr., the president, issued a statement in which he said the institution “would not tolerate discrimination” and that “I know that I speak for the entire University of Maryland community in saying that we are dismayed at this possible hate crime.”
  • Testimony in the trial of Priscilla Slade, the ousted president of Texas Southern University, facing charges of misuse of state funds, was detailed and potentially damaging Monday. The Houston Chronicle reported that Slade’s former assistant testified about travel to Maine, Costa Rica and Rome; spa treatments for the then-president; and an annual manicure-pedicure party. Slade has defended her spending as necessary to cultivate donors and maintain a proper image for the university.
  • The University of Hawaii has settled a lawsuit filed by a professor who was essentially banished from campus and prohibited from contacting colleagues or students while officials investigated allegations that he engaged in “intimidating, hostile and bullying behavior.” According to the Star Bulletin, the university paid Michael D’Andrea $30,000 for lawyers’ fees and court costs and wrote a letter indicating that, “in the future, the University of Hawaii will be more careful in issuing restrictions regarding university employee contact and access to the university’s facilities.” D’Andrea remains suspended from his job with pay.

Scott Jaschik and Elizabeth Redden

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

ABA’s Spaghetti standard

It is deeply ironic that the ABA has “reason to believe” that the school isn’t in compliance with a standard “to establish and maintain conditions adequate to attract and retain a competent faculty,” in view of the fact that the ABA lacks objective standards for faculty.

Here’s the ABA’s minimum standard for faculty: http://www.abanet.org/legaled/sta...apter%204_20061005150212.pdfStandard 401. QUALIFICATIONS A law school shall have a faculty whose qualifications and experience are appropriate to the stated mission of the law school and to maintaining a program of legal education consistent with the requirements of Standards 301 and 302. The faculty shall possesses [sic!] a high degree of competence, as demonstrated by its education, experience in teaching or practice, teaching effectiveness, and scholarly research and writing.

This “process” standard is clearly inadequate for a key input of legal education, and the ABA should be criticized for its lack of attention to it.

How they can turn around and wield this spaghetti-sword to attack Ave Maria is beyond me.

Glen S. McGhee, Dir., at Florida Higher Education Accountability Project, at 9:15 am EDT on September 11, 2007

question for Mr. McGhee

Mr. McGhee, Help me out here. How many people are salaried employees of the “Higher Education Accountability Project.” Knowing this information will help me put your views in context. I am also curious as to what “pRocess” standard you are referring to, and why it is “clearly” inadequate. Since you fail to provide any specifics, about why something is so “clear” (and you don’t even define “adequate”) I am beginning to think that 1) your “project” of which you are a “director” of is just you – since you do not even have your own website; and 2) your comments are political in nature, and are not even informed by any knowledge of legal education. While is is considered “hip” to bash the ABA’s standards, it is also considered “not hip” to attend a school that lacks the ABA’s stamp of approval.

Larry, at 11:45 am EDT on September 11, 2007

More spaghetti

Hi Larry. I’m sorry that my website wasn’t what you wanted. A lot of work over the past few years has gone into it. You may contact me through my site.

You are right, though: I am interested in higher education accreditation reform in general. The lack of “minimum standards” is appalling to me, especially in regard to faculty (the subject of the Ave Maria story). Thus,the ABA seems no different to me than the regional guilds.

Spellings recent defeat by the HE guilds and their members points to the deep reserves of strength and political clout that neutralized her rather modest attempt at reforming the ineffective and incestuous system we now have.

Glen S. McGhee, Dir., at Florida Higher Education Accountability Project, at 6:25 pm EDT on September 11, 2007

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Quick Takes: Art Disputes at Fisk and Randolph, Education Dept. Oversight Faulted, Publishers' Lobbying Questioned, Ave Maria Law Accreditation at Risk, Miracle for Stonehill, Noose at Maryland, Trips and Spa Treatments, U. of Hawaii Settles Suit

or search for jobs directly.

Assistant/Associate Professor of Accounting/Taxation
American University

American University is an independent liberal-arts university located in Washington, DC with 12,000 students. The faculty are ... see job

Assistant Professors, Latin American Sociology
Tulane University

2 Assistant Professor Positions in Latin American Sociology see job

Associate/Assistant Professor Non-Tenured
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Clinical Technician
Weill Medical College of Cornell University

Founded in 1898, and affiliated with what is now New York-Presbyterian Hospital since 1927, Weill Cornell Medical College ... see job

Associate Professor or Professor of Clinical Psychology (Tenured Position)
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Development Officer
Broward College

This highly responsible position, in support of Broward College and the Broward College Foundation, is responsible for ... see job

Counselor
Southern Oregon University

Faculty and staff make an educated choice to work at Southern Oregon University. They contribute to the education of students ... see job

Assistant, Associate, or Full Professor of Exercise Science
Georgia Gwinnett College

Georgia Gwinnett College, the 35th member of the University System of Georgia, is a premier 21st century four-year liberal ... see job

Associate Professor or Professor — Behavior Genetics (Tenured Position)
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Associate Provost for Institutional Effectiveness
College of Staten Island

The College of Staten Island (CSI) is one of 11 senior colleges of The City University of New York and the only public ... see job