News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Sept. 12, 2007
How should administrators handle student-sponsored events that feature alcohol? Or, for that matter, half-naked partygoers dressed in caution tape?
It isn’t just an academic issue for justifiably cautious student life coordinators and campus safety officials, who have not only substance-related injuries to worry about, but the potential for sexual abuse as well. A number of campus parties known for risqué themes have ended in multiple hospitalizations in recent years, causing a swift response from administrators. Brown University’s notorious “Sex Power God,” for one, has historically been a metaphorical (at least) orgy of partially clad or costumed students sponsored by the Queer Alliance student group. It was temporarily placed on probation when the event ended with 24 hospitalizations in 2005.
“The university concentrates its education and outreach efforts on behavior that threatens student health and safety — alcohol and substance abuse, vandalism, threatening behavior, physical violence — and intervenes when student health and safety are at risk,” Margaret Klawunn, Brown’s associate vice president of campus life and dean for student life, said in a prepared statement.
Students tend not to appreciate official incursions into their social lives; there was grumbling at Columbia University this week about an alleged crackdown on dorm parties.
But crackdowns pose some vexing issues for campus administrators, too: the knowledge that overstepping their bounds could send more students into closed dorm rooms or unlisted parties off campus.
Just last week, Brandeis University informed a student group that its “Wear Anything But Clothes” fund raising dance — in which students were to pay $1 to $4 for admission based on how creatively they covered themselves without actually donning clothes — could not take place as planned this weekend. The administration claims that concerns over drinking or sexuality were not the reason for the decision, although an earlier event held by the same group, Liquid Latex, allowed the least-clad students to pay the lowest entrance fees and ended with three cases of alcohol intoxication.
A chief concern for administrators is how to attract students to on-campus events while keeping the themes relevant and worthwhile. Since students can always go to parties not under the supervision of the university, “we work hard to have students be attracted to on-campus events, and to have those events have sound social, educational and recreational value to them,” said Rick Sawyer, the vice president for student affairs and dean of student life at Brandeis, in an e-mail.
“We also have tried to have balance in our practice which lets students know that we care about their health, that we care about their ability to find an appropriate and safe social life and that our practice recognizes that the vast majority of our students are mature and responsible and don’t need to be ‘parented’ by us,” he said.
Sometimes that means offering alcohol at university-sponsored events. There are three locations on campus licensed to serve students of drinking age, Sawyer said, although the canceled event didn’t fall into that category. He added: “Our students like to have a good time. For the most part they do not feel that getting high or drunk is a requirement. They like the feeling of trust that we share by allowing alcohol to be a regulated part of the program, whether they are of legal age or not.”
Dianne Ma, a co-coordinator of Liquid Latex, which raises funds for an annual performance of students slathered in the group’s jellylike namesake, said that drinking is “still obviously very prevalent, and I don’t think the administration can do anything about it.”
She added that creative, edgy events like the “Wear Anything But Clothes” dance attract students who might otherwise be drinking off campus. “Probably more people are gravitating towards off-campus parties and especially the frat parties ... just because we haven’t had any dances,” the junior said.
Brown may always retain some association with spirited free-for-alls, and some colleges may be more hard-drinking than others. But the underlying concerns over safety and responsibility, balanced with student freedom, apply everywhere.
“We are not unhappy with the culture of parties that are held on campus, with or without alcohol,” Sawyer said. “In regards to parties off campus where alcohol is present, my wish for a change in culture is universal to all campuses — students hosting unapproved parties should better understand the responsibility that the hosting implies and the price to be paid should someone get hurt as a result of attending their party.”
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
Gosh, does Brown have any lacrosse players they can blame things on?
Insufficiently Sensitive, at 9:50 pm EDT on September 12, 2007
Yes Eric. Many people here realize the ridiculousness of the drinking age being 21 when almost all other legal aspects of adulthood are granted at 18. This is nothing but politics however – plain and simple. I will attribute it to a large extent to the group MADD (Mothers Against Drunk Driving) and that, I believe, a high ranking politician in Massachusetts was unfortunate enough to have a teenager killed in an alcohol-related car accident. Since it is impossible to be FOR drunk driving it became simple for the politician to DO SOMETHING (or appear to do something) and go on a crusade against drunk teenage driving. And who couldn’t also be sympathetic to the Mad Mothers and their dead children? The solution? Raise the drinking age. This snowballed nationally after other politicians saw that they could be perceived as DOING SOMETHING and there would be almost no organized opposition. Drinking teens and citizens concerned with sensible application of legal rights are not big voting blocks. Done deal.
Daverco, Why 18 in the US and Not 21, at 12:40 pm EDT on September 13, 2007
My then-19 daughter spent the summer in Austria a couple of years ago, along with a number of other American students. It seems that most were not able or willing to manage their new drinking ‘freedom’ responsibly. They were ‘ugly’ Americans, in just about any way you can imagine, grossly intoxicated for large amounts of time. By all accounts, my daughter behaved, but that’s not the point. Many would use the observation of how kids behave when they are allowed to drink to justify laws and regulations forbidding it. My perception is the opposite: the irresponsible drinking pattern is the result of the late and sudden ‘freedom’, and might be expected at any age when the rules abrubtly changed. I think it makes better sense to introduce alcohol at a much younger age, but in controlled, responsible settings — family functions, restaurants, etc. Make the social aspect the important part, not the rebellious aspect, or worse — the intoxication aspect. By the time they’re 18, maybe more young adults will drink like adults. But if they don’t, it’s their problem — they are adults at 18 in all other areas of law.
Glenmore, at 5:30 pm EDT on September 13, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Job Description: Ithaca College’s School of Business invites applications for a full-time Assistant Dean for ... see job
Situated on rolling hillsides in southern Pennsylvania, Cheyney University, established in 1837, the oldest institution of ... see job
Eastern Kentucky University, located in Richmond, Madison County, Kentucky near the Heart of the Bluegrass, is a ... see job
Western New Mexico University, a public, comprehensive, regional institution serving a diverse multicultural population of ... see job
DEAN OF INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT SERVICES DUTIES: Under the administrative direction and leadership of the Vice President of ... see job
Posting Description: The Office of Community Standards and Wellness has an opening for a full-time ... see job
The Division of Student Life and Services at Oberlin College seeks applications for the position of ... see job
Western Carolina University is seeking qualified applicants for the position of Assistant Director of Service Learning. This ... see job
Participate in and supervise student life activities in a Residence Hall. Responsible for coordinating the work of Resident ... see job
Faculty and staff make an educated choice to work at Southern Oregon University. They contribute to the education of students ... see job
For a sensible drinking age...
Does nobody else find it perverse that American college students can be recruited into the army but not enjoy a beer on campus? Campus bars run by the student union are pretty common outside of the US. Here in New Zealand, things are even more relaxed. Open liquor in a public place is legal; drinking in a car is legal so long as the driver is sober. The police here even provide escort for our students’ annual “Undie 500″ boozy road trip from Christchurch down to Dunedin. Some video via TVNZ: http://tvnz.co.nz/view/page/423466/817207.
Eric Crampton, University of Canterbury, at 9:50 pm EDT on September 12, 2007