Quick Takes: Chemerinsky Gets Irvine Deanship, Student Tasered at Florida, Hamilton Center Is Alive and Independent, Hunger Strike at Minnesota, Harvard's Green Pledge, Bats Displace Students, Higher Ed and Cancer
Erwin Chemerinsky, who was offered the job as the first law school dean at the University of California at Irvine and then saw the offer rescinded, has the offer back. Chemerinsky and Michael V. Drake, Irvine's chancellor, issued a joint announcement Monday -- after days of intense criticism of Drake for taking back the earlier offer. The second offer came after Drake flew to North Carolina (Chemerinsky teaches law at Duke) for a lengthy meeting over the weekend. Chererinsky said last week that the offer had been revoked because his liberal writing about legal issues apparently worried Drake and some conservative supporters of Irvine. Professors at Irvine and elsewhere were outraged that the job offer had been rescinded for political reasons, and some pushed for Drake's ouster. In their joint statement, Chemerinsky and Drake said: "Our new law school will be founded on the bedrock principle of academic freedom. The chancellor reiterated his lifelong, unqualified commitment to academic freedom, which extends to every faculty member, including deans and other senior administrators." During a telephone press conference Monday, Chemerinsky said that he would never have agreed to any position that made him feel "muzzled" and that he would continue to write op-eds (the apparent source of conservative opposition to his appointment) although he also was mindful of the role he would have as dean. In several comments during the press conference, Drake suggested that the main problem in the last week was publicity. He talked about how the revoked job led to "more noise" than he expected, and said that the "public nature" of the discussions has been difficult.
A student who would not stop asking questions of Sen. John Kerry at the University of Florida was tasered by university police Monday, The Gainesville Sun reported. While accounts and video of the incident suggest that the student was refusing to give up the microphone, many in the audience said that the police went too far and that a taser was not needed. Police charged the student with disupting a public event and said that they would investigate the incident. The Independent Florida Alligator, the student newspaper, called the use of the taser "inexcusable and out of line." The use of a taser by campus policy set off a controversy last year at the University of California at Los Angeles.
The Alexander Hamilton Institute for the Study of Western Civilization is alive and well -- just not connected to Hamilton College as organizers originally hoped. The institute was the brainchild of three Hamilton professors, who wanted to offer seminars, fellowships and other programs about Western thought and U.S. political history at the college. While the college initially approved the concept, the plans fell apart in a debate over control of the institute -- with college officials insisting that governance needed to be comparable to that of other institutes and organizers pushing for more autonomy. The organizers also said that they believed there was hostility from some liberal professors to their idea. The reconstituted institute has received some of the philanthropic support that was pledged to the center at the college. The main difference is that the new center, while located in the same locality as Hamilton College (Clinton, N.Y.), will offer programs for students from a range of colleges and local residents.
Eleven students at the University of Minnesota on Monday announced the start of a hunger strike to back clerical, technical and health care workers who have been on strike in a dispute over wages.
Harvard University and the environmental agency in Massachusetts annnounced an agreement Monday under which the university committed to ambitious goals for limiting greenhouse gas emissions at a new science complex it is planning, The Boston Globe reported. However, the newspaper also reported that some environmental groups are criticizing the state for exempting Harvard from an environmental impact review.
More than 200 students at Texas Southern University have been forced to leave their dormitories because of an infestation of bats. KHOU News, which has video of some students trying to fend off bats with brooms, reported that health officials fear some students may have been exposed to rabies and may need shots as a result.
Another advantage for those who go to college: Research just published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute finds that those with a higher education are less likely than others to die from cancer.
Comments on
Quick Takes: Chemerinsky Gets Irvine Deanship, Student Tasered at Florida, Hamilton Center Is Alive and Independent, Hunger Strike at Minnesota, Harvard's Green Pledge, Bats Displace Students, Higher Ed and Cancer
Reprimand in Private, if at all
Posted
by William Sumner Scott, J.D.
on September 18, 2007 at 5:55am EDT
Dr. Drake made a mistake - he has corrected it.
Time to take the public eye off Dr. Drake and get on with building a law school judged by real criteria,
Service to the general public should be at the top of the list rather than only the 20% who can pay.
William Sumner Scott, J.D.
wss@jefound.org
Three Cheers
Posted
by Publius
on September 18, 2007 at 7:30am EDT
Three cheers for the Alexander Hamilton Institute and its founders.
Oh what a tangled web we weave
Posted
by Habeeb Al-Aidroos
on September 18, 2007 at 9:15am EDT
Let's see now. Dr Drake hires Dr Chemerinsky one week, fires him the next and re-hires him this week. The withdrawal of the decanal offer was ostensibly NOT for political reasons but a "management" decision. The re-hire, it appears, was because the public heat became unbearable. Adaptive flexibility in decision-making is one of many skills imparted by the undergraduate curriculum in most business schools. But how is one to distinguish it from a flip-flop? I'm afraid it is back to square one for Dr Drake. If he were to apply for Advanced Standing and I the Chair of Admissions, I might consider sophomore status.
Fortunately this sordid affair is now coming to a close. It was a vicious assault on the First Amendment and on academic freedom. For someone like me who lived, studied and worked in the US in the middle of the last century, it was nothing if not reminiscent of the Mc Carthy era. But Dr Chemerinsky demurs. He claims the comparison is unwarranted because he did not lose his job. He had tenure.
Could those loud cheers I hear emanating from the Windy City be the now-unemployed Norm Finkelstein?
Habeeb Al-Aidroos Harvard '64
"Higher Ed and Cancer"
Posted
by George Gollin
, Professor of Physics
at University of Illinois
on September 18, 2007 at 10:10am EDT
From the press release at http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/djm174v1 :
"These differences [in cancer mortality] likely reflect relationships between education and other factors that are more directly associated with risks of developing and dying from cancer, such as tobacco use, cancer screening, and access to healthcare."
So it is not surprising.
It's a good thing
Posted
by Larry
on September 18, 2007 at 12:15pm EDT
Mr. Al-Aidroos, I look at it another way: the political process worked. Everyone of all political stripes agreed that despite his politics he would be an asset to any new school.
Maybe Dr. Drake was being overly cautious, but in the end he was happily surprised to see the Americans are much more intellectual and much less partisan than sometimes appears.
At last, something to celebrate
Posted
by Diana Relke
, Professor
at U. of Saskatchewan
on September 18, 2007 at 2:50pm EDT
Now that Chemerinsky has had a nick-of-time rescue from the growing ashheap of progressive academics, do we dare hope that El-Haj will be tenured and Kovel's anti-Zionist book be released in the US? An offer for Finkelstein from some honorable institution would also be nice.
Something to celebrate?
Posted
by Jon L. Albee
, Graduate Student
at Rice University
on September 18, 2007 at 3:35pm EDT
No yet. What about Andrew Meyer at the University of Florida?
Dr. Drake may be off the hook, but American academia is tested (literally) every day. Is there any excuse for not letting Mr. Meyer complete his questioning of Sen. John Kerry?
No matter where you turn, speech codes and oppressive conformity find their way to universities. On of the great ironies of our culture.
And people (students, faculty, alumni) are getting pissed off.