News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Oct. 26, 2007
Student journalists and college media advisers gathered in Washington Thursday for the first full day of the National College Media Convention, staking out sessions on all aspects of college media production and management and career opportunities. As just a sampling of the offerings, editors at Virginia Tech’s Collegiate Times talked about covering the April 16 shootings; craft-oriented sessions focused on news design, visual storytelling and sports writing; and seasoned college media pros discussed strategies for boosting advertising revenue, recruiting and retaining newspaper staff, and navigating conflicts between student journalists and college administrators.
On the latter subject, a session titled “Up Against the Wall: Working With Administrators” — which might as well have been called “How to Survive on a Christian College Campus and Still Write News,” as one panelist, Terry Mattingly, joked — offered perspectives on how an effective student press can function within private religious colleges with closed administrative cultures. When confronted once, for instance, by an irate Christian college administrator scandalized by the word “slut” appearing in the student paper (appearing in that case, ironically, in a quote defending the institution’s dress code), Mattingly recalled asking, “Look, would you prefer that we never use the word slut in editorials and replace it with the biblical word — whore?”
In his opening remarks, Mattingly, a religion columnist for the Scripps Howard News service and director of the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities’ Washington Journalism Center, described six possible models for student newspapers, ranging from a university public relations model (with an adviser charged by the administration to actively screen all content), to an educational model (with an adviser that helps guide content but with student editors making nearly all of the decisions), to complete independence. “Whatever the rules are, know what they are,” Mattingly advised the students in the audience, stressing the need to know how the rules apply when it comes down to the “moment it’s a really bad story — which at Christian colleges means sex, drugs or donors.”
“You have less freedom if you don’t know where the lines are,” added David Dixon, an associate professor and newspaper adviser at Malone College, an Evangelical Quaker institution in Ohio. At Malone, the newspaper’s written 25-30-page policy manual outlines a chain of command — which provides a buffer against college officials from outside that chain who might wish to control content — and a publications board is in place to mediate any problems (they haven’t had to use it yet for that purpose, Dixon said, but it’s there).
Panelists also briefly discussed the lack of press freedoms for student journalists at private colleges (while the focus of the session was on religious institutions, panelists pointed out that some of the same issues are applicable to small, secular private colleges, too).
Yet, as Richard Kless, the adviser at Providence College, a Roman Catholic institution in Rhode Island, said, “I realize that students don’t have any legal First Amendment rights, but they expect them. And they certainly have freedom of expression and freedom of rebellion.”
“Your administrators do own the press. But you know what, they don’t own all of them,” said Mattingly, who recalled telling officials at a Christian college that was tightening its controls on the student newspaper several years ago that they were “begging for a blog” — an off-campus, gossipy, unaccountable blog that covers campus happenings absent journalistic standards.
“You know what? Now they do” have a blog, Mattingly said. “And they’re mad at me, because I predicted it.”
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
Nice synopsis on a universal topic by the reporter, Ms. Redden. While I’m sure there are several hundred session at this conference, she picked one that precisely addresses the concerns of all student publications, be it college or high school, or major, private, religious or HBCU institutions: working with fickled, misinformed, overly sensitive, and heavy-handed adults in power whom have seemingly forgotten how wantonly foolish it is to suppress efforts of serious student thought, expression and news.
RWRagland, DC Director at JEA, at 3:15 pm EDT on October 27, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
East Carolina University, a constituent institution of the University of North Carolina, is a doctoral institution with an ... see job
Located on the Appalachian Plateau, an area of rolling hills, California University of Pennsylvania is a short drive from ... see job
Fairmont State University and Pierpont Community & Technical College, with a 120-acre main campus in Fairmont, WV, is part of ... see job
PROJECT SCIENTIST SERIES positions are periodically available in the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior at the ... see job
Angelo State University is an equal opportunity employer and seeks to build a diverse workforce community. see job
Assistant/Associate, Tenure Track, Acting/Directing Professor. Western Carolina University’s Department of Stage and Screen ... see job
Everest College, a respected member of the Corinthian Colleges’ network of schools, is dedicated to helping students ... see job
Reading Lab assistants work with course instructors and students in an electronic lab. Students work individually to improve ... see job
The Drexel University Earle Mack School of Law and the School of Public Health seek outstanding candidates for a joint senior ... see job
Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job
Good Practice
The Christain schools let the journalist know early to tow the line that they will meet from the owners.
quizzical, at 9:20 am EDT on October 26, 2007