Advertisement

Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

The Private Sector Role in Global Higher Education

In many countries, as in the United States, demand for higher education is growing fast, sometimes outstripping the ability of traditional colleges — which, in many countries, means government-run institutions — to fulfill the need.

The extent to which private institutions, be they for-profit or nonprofit, are the answer (or part of it) to meet the demand varies from country to country, with some openly embracing the private sector, others keeping them out, and still others intrigued but wary. Wednesday night, dozens of international higher education officials, investors, and others gathered in Washington for the start of a three-day meeting sponsored by the International Finance Corporation, a World Bank agency that aims to build the private sector in developing countries.

And to kick off the meeting, the group turned to Douglas L. Becker, chairman and chief executive officer of Laureate Education, Inc., whose company has built a 300,000-student, $2 billion a year enterprise by focusing solely on creating private institutions in foreign lands — so far, 70 campuses in 17 countries.

Perhaps not surprisingly, given Laureate’s bleeding-edge success, Becker sees a bright future for the private sector in international higher education — but not without some likely hiccups along the way, and only if the providers act more as “welcome allies” than as “unbidden guests,” to borrow phrases from the title of his talk.

After briefly describing Laureate’s operations (which have grown by 30 percent a year for more than six years now), Becker laid out an international landscape in which demand for higher education among 18- to 24-year-olds is growing by 10 percent a year, drawing ever more institutions into the market seeking to meet the burgeoning demand that countries’ government cannot.

Gone, he said, are the days when would-be providers of private higher education were satisfied creating vocational schools; and with the heightened ambition of those institutions has sometimes come more scrutiny and suspicion.

“As institutions have gotten more ambitious,” Becker said, “that has paved the way for some conflict with the public sector” in those countries. ” ‘Wait a minute, it was okay when we were going to let you open a secretarial school. But you want to open a medical school? You want to do sponsored research?’ ” he said, channeling government officials in some countries. (Laureate has both created medical schools and engaged in significant research; in Chile, for example, it is the largest private recipient of federal research funds, he said.)

Becker said that the onus will be (and should be) on would-be private providers of higher education to behave in ways that will ease the suspicions of government officials — and to perform well. Institutions, he said, need to be “relevant to the work place” — they need not be vocational, as many of Laureate’s universities are not, but they should focus on producing “workers who can contribute to the economy,” defined locally by the specific needs of each country.

And they must be accountable, he said, to prove that the education they are providing is worthwhile. He applauded efforts under way in Europe, through the Bologna accords, to create a common “qualifications framework” for institutions and their graduates, and in Chile, which has created and already revised a new system of accreditation. Government should set standards high, he said, so that not just anyone can pull into a foreign country “and say, ‘Let’s create a university, let’s put on a show.’ ”

“Left completely to its own,” Becker said, “the private sector will go into every crack and crevice it can find.... The threat to the reputation of the private sector doesn’t come from the people who are in this room. It comes from the people who, either purposely or accidentally, aren’t going to be able to meet the standards set by government.”

Some institutions will inevitably run afoul of those standards, he predicted — “we will see cases of universities having their licenses pulled” — and that will be “very painful,” but it will be “part of the process” that ultimately leads to full acceptance of the private sector.

The conference continues today.

Doug Lederman

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

How will standards be applied?

The article mentions the Bologna accord, which reportedly attempts to establish criteria for higher-ed degrees across numerous nations, so a) degrees would be more comparable and b) credits toward degrees could more rationally be transferred among institutions. In part, this is the same problem, writ large, that our higher-ed system struggles with, both intra- and inter-state: What content and level of competence can be presumed on the basis of courses taken and credits earned?

If “content” has to be somewhat of a given, in order to compare apples to apples, I wonder if the attempt to set international standards will then focus more on instructor qualifications (as we tend to do in America) or on student achievement, measured by some kind of exit examination? The method of assessing instructor qualifications has two problems: a) it rather pushes back the issue—how do we measure or assess the content/quality of the instructor’s credentialing institutions?—and b) it doesn’t address the problem recently discussed elsewhere in IHE, where an apparently qualified professor was fired because he failed 80 percent of his students. In other words, an institution may choose to sell devalued degrees even if its instructors are well qualified by content.

The other method, high-stakes testing, is notoriously fraught; professional and political advocates are unlikely to agree on tests that yield useful results. It would be cool, though, if academics had to come up with knowledge/performance criteria appropriate for two or three degree levels, and then to participate (perhaps through an elaborate computer-aided distribution mechanism) in assessing student exams on an institution-blind basis. But that would be practically impossible even inside the US. Internationally, we’d probably have World War III.

Rod Bell, Adjunct Professor at College of DuPage, at 11:35 am EDT on May 15, 2008

International quality control

An interesting issue, a good story and a very perceptive comment by Rod Bell. To that I will add, from my own experience as a college regulator, the issue of collusion to lower standards.

In some cases, government officials accept bribes to authorize the operation of substandard degree-granters in their country. These same officials falsify documentation of what such schools really are.

For this reason, any Bologna-like structure or process applicable to private colleges must include a completely independent external qualitative evaluation process that operates at a level of detail sufficient to determine whether colleges really do meet a widely accepted standard. Government assurances that such a standard is met are not sufficient.

Alan Contreras, Eugene, Oregon, at 12:30 pm EDT on May 15, 2008

What’s the difference?

“In some cases, government officials accept bribes to authorize the operation of substandard degree-granters in their country.”

You mean like in West Virginia, or in any institution connected with the NCAA?

wtd, at 2:50 pm EDT on May 15, 2008

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to The Private Sector Role in Global Higher Education

or search for jobs directly.

International Student Advisor
Western Carolina University

Western Carolina University is seeking qualified applicants for the position of International Student Advisor. This position ... see job

Coordinator — Center for Intercultural Advancement
Wagner College

Wagner College values campus diversity (domestic and international) and in keeping with this initiative, it welcomes ... see job

PROGRAM ADMINISTRATOR — Conference Bureau and Summer Programs
Tufts University

The Office of Conferences and Summer Programs seeks an individual who possesses strong project management and ... see job

International Student and Family Out Reach Specialist
Howard County Public School System

International Student Outreach Specialist in Maryland see job

Assistant Director, TRIUM Program
New York University

The TRIUM Executive MBA program is the groundbreaking global MBA forged from an alliance of three of the world’s top ... see job

Vice President for Enrollment Management, Planning and University Relations
Institute for Study Abroad, Butler University

New Vice President for Enrollment Management, Planning and University Relations position with the Institute for Study Abroad, ... see job

Director of Global Education Centers
NC State University

Join the Pack! A community with nearly 8,000 faculty and staff, and 30,000 students. NC State is one of the largest employers ... see job

Director Oiae Immigration
University of Georgia

Job Summary The person in this position leads and manages the University of Georgia’s International Student ... see job

Graduate Admissions Counselor
World Learning

World Learning, a 75 yr-old global nonprofit with operations in more than 70 countries. Through award-winning international ... see job

Director, Study Abroad Programs
Troy University

Troy University is accepting applications for Director, Study Abroad Programs. Troy University consists of four Alabama ... see job