Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

A Car Ban Aimed at Carbon

As campuses across the country look for ways to reduce their own carbon footprint and the environmental impact of their staff and students, many have tried to add services (like offering loaner bicycles as an alternative to the use of gas guzzling vehicles) to change behavior. Few if any, however, are actually saying No.

But Bowdoin College is, by banning cars for freshmen.

Starting in the fall of 2009, first-year students, who like second-year students are required to live on campus, will no longer be allowed to keep a car on the Maine college’s grounds.

While some institutions have historically restricted freshmen from having cars to keep them involved in campus life or to minimize campus parking woes, Bowdoin’s ban, first raised by a member of the president’s Climate Commitment Advisory Committee, was specifically designed to make Bowdoin greener, says Tim Foster, dean of student affairs. “The driver for it, no pun intended, was really an environmental one,” he says.

Eighty-three first-year students had cars on the campus last year, Foster says, but most of those cars weren’t used much during the year. Instead, the freshmen primarily used their cars as a way to get home, especially on breaks and at the end of the semester.

Foster says Bowdoin has a number of transportation services either in the works or already in place on the campus. The Bowdoin Communal Bike Club provides community bikes for those wanting to ride from place to place. The college recently entered into an agreement with Zipcar and two vehicles will be available to students starting this fall. The Bowdoin Shuttle, which starts September 4, the first day of classes, will be an “on demand” service that will give rides to students from campus into town. (The campus is within walking distance to most needed things in Brunswick.)

The college also updated its ride-share board to make it easier for students to connect with others who need rides, Foster said. This included making more students aware of it, which they hope to achieve by giving it a more prominent place on the Bowdoin Web site, as well as giving the Web page a new look. Bus stops such as Greyhound are also available in Brunswick and the college offers transportation to Portland transportation services such as the airport. In addition, Amtrak is expected to extend to Brunswick come 2010.

The first students to be affected by the new policy will be entering in fall 2009. Although Zulmarie Bosques will be a sophomore at Bowdoin this fall, and therefore not affected by the ban, she wrote in an e-mail that she supports the decision. Bosques wrote she did not have a car her first year but also didn’t need one. Bosques said the campus is located close enough to needed shops and when she did need a ride, she could find one from an upperclassman.

“I did not find I needed a car last year,” Bosques wrote.

Bosques also said most of what you need is within walking distance of campus. Restaurants, shops, grocery stores are all within a reasonable distance. “The essentials are there,” she says.

Bosques didn’t think there would be any problems or backlash from the new policy. She has some friends at other schools who are not allowed to bring cars as freshmen and didn’t think it would deter anyone from attending Bowdoin. “I don’t think there will be any major drawbacks,” she says.

While reducing the number of cars on the campus will also surely have a positive impact on that eternal campus issue — parking — Foster says the fact that the car ban will alleviate congestion a bit factored little into its decision, especially since the university will add more parking with a new hockey facility it is building.

“The decision was really driven as a green decision, not a parking decision,” he says.

James Heggen

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

“Eighty-three first-year students had cars on the campus last year, Foster says, but most of them didn’t really use them much during the year. Instead, they were primarily used as a way to get home, especially on breaks and at the end of the semester.”

Really? If the students don’t really use the cars, how does banning them make the campus more green? Sounds like a great piece of marketing spin, but not much actual environmentalism.

Kyle Johnson, at 8:40 am EDT on August 14, 2008

A Possible Solution

Since the number of freshmen with cars on campus is so small, here’s a potential solution. Give them some sort of long-term parking far away from campus so they can drive home for breaks but still meet the goal of a car-free main campus.

And, yes, many students do need a car to get home. Those of us from rural areas can’t rely on public transportation to get us anywhere close to our destination. Instead, we need someone to come a good distance to pick us up and drop us off again...two trips instead of just one.

Robert, PhD Student, at 10:50 am EDT on August 14, 2008

Possible Solution — example

Carleton College does something very much along these lines. There are some problems with it, as there are with all things, but most are minor. And sometimes students do engineer ways around the driving prohibition during the term (now there’s a surprise!). But generally speaking, this can be a good, workable idea.

DDVA, at 3:00 pm EDT on August 14, 2008

The Greyhound?

First, I’m with Kyle. This sounds like enviro-wrap over a decision to ease parking problems.

I think the suggestion that students ride the Greyhound back and forth is callous.

I road buses all over China happily. They were extremely crowded. There was pocket-picking. A lot of people smelled very bad. There was raw meat, live chickens, and the occasional vomiting. But it was inexpensive, fast, and my fellow travellers were great to be around.

But I don’t ride the Greyhound. In my opinion, they are just plain dangerous. Often there’s a passenger or two whose mental illness expresses itself in hostility. They’re often full of drug users, and not the “whoah, duuuude” kind. And the bus stops are often in the worst parts of town with no food but a snack machine. And bus trips take at least twice as long as a trip by auto, leaving less vacation time for the students. And then there’s the odd driver who’s wacked-out on lack of sleep, withdrawal, use, or what-have-you.

I suggest the administration leave their cars at home and take local transit—if they want to reduce parking and carbon. And maybe ride the Greyhound a few times, just to get a taste.

Can’t forget to mention the #1 reason to avoid riding the hound: cannibalistic beheadings.

JP Craig, at 8:45 am EDT on August 15, 2008

Bus and Train Travel

As Jim Hightower says, decades ago we should have made public transit more convenient by criss-crossing the nation with rail and additional bus ways. We still could.

David Korten thinks we could make efforts to locate workers nearer their jobs. There are many ideas. Likewise such initiatives as no cars on campus (and car-free downtown areas!) will involve costs and trade-offs.

Cars take up space and they go fast, which spreads everything out, creating more asphalt, more parking garages and more need for cars. Not only do we need smaller, more fuel efficient cars, we need to cut down on their use, period. The planet is running out of cheap oil, and we’re polluting ourselves to death.

Alphonse, at 12:30 pm EDT on August 15, 2008

Learning to teach might be a start

A university should not be allowed to make claims of reducing any carbon footprint by moving the difficulty onto those who are not university employees. There are valid ways: Build a village on campus for housing of employees —including the officers—within walking distance of the campus. Reduce heating temperatures and raise AC settings. Don’t use disposable plastic materials in cafeterias and coffee shops. Don’t water the campus in daylight hours. Buy bus passes for staff and faculty. Encourage use of smaller vehicles, bicycles & motorcycles with differential parking rates.

Finally, do not waste a good learning opportunity! Study the energy reduction problem by enlisting the aid of these freshman students in a special topics seminar. Maybe, freshmen might consider transferring to a school that will involve them in a real-world problem as a learning experience instead of teaching them that problems are best solved by inflicting mindless decisions on vulnerable citizens. Maybe a study might recommend that the carbon problem would be better saved if administrators didn’t run junkets to meetings and that the college president should take her/his vacation on a Greyhound bus.

Prof Ed, at 9:25 pm EDT on August 15, 2008

The Greyhound service mentioned in the article is available, but so is Concord Coach, a far better alternative and a far cry from the downer experience that riding a Greyhound can be. CC comes right up to campus and provides great service to Manchester Airport (NH) and Boston Airport.

And in response to the suggestion of having a distanced off-campus lot where first-years can park their cars, but not drive them around all the time — that’s what Bowdoin has had until they just sold the lot back to the town. Although I’m sure this played a role in the decision, I do believe some of the other more promoted motives.

Overall, I think it’s a good move for Bowdoin. I like the idea of having everyone in the first-year class be a little more campus-bound to help foster the community spirit right away. It will also give them good exposure to the Bowdoin-run transportation which is actually quite an impressive service.

John, at 4:15 pm EDT on August 16, 2008

Stupid!

As a first year, I found that my car came quite in handy. No, I didn’t drive it every day, but it was a huge convenience to have it available when I needed it. Now I hear that Bowdoin plans to compeltely ban cars for first year students, in the name of environmentalism. Does our administration honestly think that taking 100 cars off the road, and consequently inconveniencing its students, is going to solve the climate crisis? This is pathetic. I’m glad I came to Bowdoin in 2006, at least drivers weren’t thought of as environmental criminals then.

Jake, Bowdoin, at 7:45 pm EDT on August 16, 2008

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to A Car Ban Aimed at Carbon

or search for jobs directly.

Building Services I
Columbus State Community College

Columbus State Community College invests in employee development by providing numerous resources, partnerships, training and ... see job

Utilities & Building Infrastructure Mechanic (U&BIM)
Yale University

General Purpose
Responsible for the safe and efficient operation and maintenance of the site physical plant ... see job

Senior Producer, National Programming
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The Sr. Broadcast Producer for National Programming will report to the Program Director for North Carolina Public Radio WUNC, ... see job

Facilities Management Assistant, Wildwood Conference Center, Harrisburg Campus
Harrisburg Area Community College

HACC, a leader in education in Central PA, is a comprehensive, multi-campus community college, providing quality instruction ... see job

Director Facility Management/Qatar
Weill Medical College of Cornell University

Founded in 1898, and affiliated with what is now New York-Presbyterian Hospital since 1927, Weill Cornell Medical College ... see job

Food Service Worker (Butler-Wilson Dining Facility)
Princeton University

Position Summary: THIS IS AN ACADEMIC YEAR POSITION *RE-POSTED* The Food Service Worker is responsible for ... see job

Cook, Butler/Wilson
Princeton University

Position Summary: This cooks position is located in our Butler Wilson Dining hall. The successful candidate ... see job

Project Manager
Bennington College

The Project Manager plans, budgets, and oversees all projects, renovations, and construction of any campus facilities. see job

Construction Project Coordinator (Req. #0601086)
Georgia Southern University

Physical Plant. Oversee all areas of the project management function within the Engineering Department. Minimum Requirements: ... see job

Director of Facilities (Utilities and Engineering)
Yale University

General Purpose
Reporting to the Executive Director of Facilities Operations Infrastructure, and with broad ... see job