Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

From Idaho to California

On July 1, in Idaho, Harv Lyter stepped in as proprietary schools coordinator, filling for the first time a new state position dedicated to overseeing the for-profit college sector. The next day — having prepared for the job for several months — he sent letters to Breyer State University and Canyon College, indicating that they were not registered in accordance with Idaho law.

“The bottom line is they know if they went through the registration process, they would be turned down,” Lyter said. “Neither of those schools is properly accredited by an accrediting agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education or the Council for Higher Education Accreditation and/or the State Board of Education in Idaho.”

Meanwhile, in California, July 1 marked one year since the bureau charged with regulating proprietary colleges was shuttered, since the law regulating that 400,000-student sector had expired. Since then in Sacramento, debate on a permanent fix has deadlocked. Even a temporary bill allowing colleges to enter into voluntary agreements to comply with lapsed regulations expired, on July 1 of this year.

While Idaho was cracking down, California’s system had cracked.

Since July 18, Breyer State University has been incorporated in California, with a Los Angeles address. Canyon College of Idaho filed as a California corporation August 5; its new address is 4017 Garfield Ave, Carmichael, Calif. Both institutions had told Lyter that they’d be opening up shop in California, he said — although his primary concern is ensuring they don’t continue to operate without state approval in Idaho, too.

The colleges, he said, are “looking for more fertile ground.” (Breyer State, which has a history in Idaho, seems to have established itself in its third state this year. Alabama officials declined to renew its license this spring; its latest corporation filing in Idaho is dated June 26.)

The gap in regulation in California “gives these guys a window of opportunity,” Lyter said. “And the unfortunate part is that it will probably be more difficult to get them out once they’re in than it would have been to have kept them out in the first place.”

Phil Braun, director of administrative services at Canyon, said the college’s lawyer would have to speak on the issue of its relocation (when pressed about whether they’re located in California, however — the college’s own Web site has a California address — Braun said, “that is our mainstay, yes").

Braun characterized Canyon as an independent college that operates without federal money. A message left at the main number for Breyer State was not returned Monday afternoon.

UPDATE: Senate Bill 823, a hotly controversial measure that would replace the expired regulatory apparatus, failed Monday under reconsideration in California’s Legislature. While the bill has enjoyed support from consumer advocates, it is disliked by many in the for-profit college sector, and opposed by the state’s Department of Consumer Affairs, which housed the now-defunct bureau charged with regulating proprietary colleges.

When the original Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education Reform Act of 1989 expired last year, some feared that California, which in the 1980s had the dishonor of being called “the diploma mill capital of the world,” could once again become a haven for colleges of questionable quality.

Russ Heimerich, a spokesman for the Department of Consumer Affairs, said Monday that the department is no longer tracking colleges that are coming into the state.

Unless a college contacted them, “We wouldn’t even know about a new school coming in.”

Elizabeth Redden

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

For-profit state licensing

State licensing of for-profits is necessary for those postsecondary schools seeking access to Title IV funds, but its requirements vary from state to state.

But just what are those state requirements needed for licensing? Surprizingly, they can be MORE stringent than those minimum standards now maintained by public schools and colleges.

Idaho might be doing the right thing, but how can we tell without knowing what those requirements are? Transparency is just as important, if not more so, as accountability when consumer higher ed issues are involved.

According to the Californian Association of Private Postsecondary Schools (CAPPS) website, SB 832 is on the legislative agenda. Of course, passage of SB 832 may mean that those schools leaving Idaho could be returning some time soon. http://www.cappsonline.org/

Glen S. McGhee, Dir., at Florida Higher Education Accountability Project, at 9:15 am EDT on August 19, 2008

who needs California when they have CSCCS and AIDE?

Fortunately, Breyer State’s and Canyon’s “accreditations” travel with them like spare tires. So even though the state of California can’t tell the difference between a university and a mailbox, the schools are able to reassure us that the difference is unimportant.

Both BS and CC were credentialed (along with the degree-granting, but otherwise non-existent “Medical College of London") by a fantasy entity called the “Central States Consortium of Colleges and Schools.” CSCCS was run by Breyer State’s (former) president, who is still a Breyer State professor, a Canyon professor, and an ex-St. Regis professor.

I note that there’s been a recent adjustment, with the BS and CC accreditations oozing from an unrecognized thing called the “Association for Innovation in Distance Education.” But the idea’s still the same.

George Gollin, Professor of Physics at University of Illinois, at 9:26 am EDT on August 19, 2008

misleading name

I’ve become a lot more uncomfortable with for-profit universities in the last few years, partly because of what I have seen of the University of Phoenix—and how some legitimate non-profit universities have started down the same path by competition from U. of Phoenix.

What is especially amazing is that the name “Breyer State University” implies that it is a public institution. If you don’t know which American state “Breyer” is, there are lots of public universities that don’t have the state name in them. My alma mater was Sonoma State University, part of the California State University system. I can see how someone might assume that “Breyer State University” was also part of the CSU system.

Even if Breyer State wasn’t a questionable for-profit institution, the inclusion of “State University” in the name of a non-governmental school seems like fraud.

Clayton E. Cramer, at 10:20 am EDT on August 19, 2008

It’s simply amazing that such fraud can be foisted on the American public while government agencies responsible for oversight dance with the dollars provided by the for-profit sector.

Too many public officials are profiting from such quackery and providing the shield of protection that obfuscates what a college is or ought to be.

The ease of acquiring fake degrees or half-baked copies thru frivilous colleges is going to hurt the original higher education enterprise.

The public has inadequate protection by its officials. This is a hallmark of a third world country!

Bob P, at 1:20 pm EDT on August 19, 2008

Why?

Why does the government think it is responsible for regulating education. Who cares if a diploma mill pops up. If the person has a phony degree than he/she will not get hired. My firm would never higher someone who is not qualified. The free market will deal with this problem. The only thing the government can do is build regulations that will provide accreditation to diploma mills. Diploma mills can exist with or without accreditation...so whats worse accredited or non-accredited diploma mills?

Gabriel, at 2:00 pm EDT on August 19, 2008

Nuclear engineer with fake degree

Gabriel wrote: “If the person has a phony degree than he/she will not get hired. My firm would never higher someone who is not qualified. The free market will deal with this problem...”

The list of possible St. Regis “University” customers includes a fellow who bought a B.S. in Nuclear Engineering, and landed a job at a nuclear power plant in Minnesota. According to a news report he now works in the control room of another nuclear power plant, but this time in Wisconsin.

George Gollin, Professor of Physics at University of Illinois, at 2:30 pm EDT on August 19, 2008

Speaking of Education

Shouldn’t we be concerned that the word “higher” has been used TWICE by two different people in this comment section when the obvious word should be HIRE?!!!

Let’s all check the origin of our degrees...

jr, at 4:25 pm EDT on August 19, 2008

Still why?

George, If someone obtain a phony degree and was subsequently hired than most likely there was something wrong with the people conducting the interview...especially if you are hiring for a Nuclear Engineer. How hard would it be to find out that the interviewee is incompetent to fulfill the requirements of a Nuclear Engineer??? Cheers!

Gabriel, at 5:15 pm EDT on August 19, 2008

metafraud opportunities

“Both BS and CC were credentialed (along with the degree-granting, but otherwise non-existent “Medical College of London") by a fantasy entity called the “Central States Consortium of Colleges and Schools.” CSCCS was run by Breyer State’s (former) president, who is still a Breyer State professor, a Canyon professor, and an ex-St. Regis professor.”

Oooh! I’m about to lose my job in a massive layoff. Maybe instead of starting a diploma mill (which at least some states, like my own of Idaho, regulate), I’ll start an accreditation organization instead! I’ll bet no one regulates those yet!

Clayton E. Cramer, at 7:30 am EDT on August 20, 2008

idaho and fake degrees

I don’t know how many of you read the recent story on fake degrees and diploma mills, and I can’t recall if IHE covered that story, but there are two thing in this story we can pretty much bank on.

First, Idaho is not at all likely to pass a law more stringent than the feds. I’ve lived there, earned a degree there, and live just a few miles across the border, and get a lot of Idaho news. They just don’t do that sort of thing. If anything, they’ll be more lax when it comes to oversight and regulation when they can. It’s just the way the state is. This is probably why the institutions in the story set up shop in the state in the first place. I’m glad to see Idaho cracking down.

In answer, partly anyway, to Gabriel’s question, most fake degrees, well, many of them anyway, are not used to get jobs, but to move up the salary schedule on a job already held. I’m assuming these people with fake degrees provide their “official” transcript, which is why those who ran the diploma mill that was busted here recently were convicted of fraud. I doubt my institution had to check the veracity of my transcripts and degree when I was hired, because it was from an accredited. The diploma mill case in my area was discovered in just this way, a federal law officer used a phony degree to get a significant pay raise, someone checked, and low and behold, a diploma mill was uncovered and thousands of fraudulent degrees, from GED to PhD were discovered to have been sold. Here’s a list of folks: http://tinyurl.com/62a72r

bradley bleck, instructor at Spokane Falls CC, at 7:30 am EDT on August 20, 2008

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to From Idaho to California

or search for jobs directly.

Associate Dean — College of Arts & Sciences — Strategic Planning & Academic Affairs
Western Illinois University

Recognized as one of the nation’s “Best Value” institutions and one of the “Best in the Midwest Colleges” by the ... see job

Director of Student Recruitment
Memorial University of Newfoundland

BUILD OUR NEXT GENERATION OF STUDENTS! see job

Manager — Rudd Center for Food Policy & Obesity
Yale University

General Purpose
Manage strategic planning, development and execution of all communications initiatives and focused ... see job

Career Services Advisor
Walden University

Walden University is focused exclusively on providing a superior university experience for adult professionals through the ... see job

Transfer Advisor
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Librarian
American University of Afghanistan

The American University of Afghanistan (AUAF) offers a unique opportunity to teach and work with a dedicated international ... see job

Administrative/Professional Positions
George Washington University

The Department of Microbiology, Immunology & Tropical Medicine (MITM) at The George Washington University in Washington, DC, ... see job

Vice Chancellor of Administrative Services
San Jose/Evergreen Community College District

Position Information Opportunity Type: CLASSIFIED MANAGEMENT EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY Working Title: Vice Chancellor of ... see job

Asst Vice President
University of Georgia

Job Summary The responsibilities of this senior level management position include: Day-to-day operation of ... see job

Assistant Director 002616
University of Maryland University College

The Assistant Director, Faculty Services will provide leadership and direct the day-to-day operation of the Faculty Services ... see job