Quick Takes: U.S. Audit Slams Fifth Third Over Student Loans, Northeastern Ill. Withdraws Proposal on Protests, Effort to Save AP Italian Fails, Baltimore Hebrew May Merge Into Towson U., For-Profit Purchases
The Bush administration's Education Department has taken a lot of heat for its perceived failings in regulating the student loan industry, which critics say have resulted in conflicts of interest and excessive profiteering by lenders. Are department leaders trying to go out on a different note, or has its inspector general been fully unleashed? An audit released Wednesday by the Office of Inspector General concludes that Fifth Third Bank violated federal prohibitions against illegal inducements in agreements the lender had (jointly with the now-defunct Student Loan Xpress) with several firms that helped it market consolidation loans to borrowers. The audit found that Fifth Third paid the three companies (MSA Solution, Inc., Pacific Loan Processing, Inc.,and Law School Financial) increasing commissions when they signed on more borrowers, violating federal rules against inducements, and urged the department to examine arrangements that Fifth Third had with other such middlemen to see if they violated the same rules. The inspector general urges the department's Federal Student Aid Office to limit Fifth Third's participation in the federal loan programs and to consider fines or other financial penalties. A spokesman for Fifth Third declined to comment on the audit, but the report itself contains comments in which bank officials protest that the department's interpretation conflicts with years of previous guidance and rulings.
Northeastern Illinois University has withdrawn a proposed policy on protests and signs that angered many students and civil libertarians. The proposal would have required, among other things, that protesters to submit copies of fliers and signs to administrators two weeks before bringing them on the campus. Sharon Hahs, the president, sent a memo this week to faculty leaders telling them that the plan was being withdrawn, but the note did not provide detail on why. That prompted the College Freedom blog, which has been critical of the proposal, to say that "it's not clear that the administration has learned to respect freedom on campus, and that existing and future policies will be interpreted to protect academic freedom."
An effort to save the Advanced Placement Italian program has failed, but it could be revived in the future, the Los Angeles Times reported. The College Board announced last year that the program had failed to attract enough students to be sustainable. But following protests from Italian teachers and Italian-American leaders, the board said it would reconsider if private funds could be raised to support the program. The Italian Language Foundation was created for that purpose, but failed to attract enough money. College Board officials told the Times that if funds are raised in the future, the program could still be revived.
Baltimore Hebrew University may merge into Towson University, The Baltimore Sun reported. Baltimore Hebrew is a small institution focused on training teachers for Jewish schools and programs. It is officially non-denominational. Towson officials said that a merger could enhance Jewish studies offerings.
It's been a busy week for for-profit acquisitions in higher education. Rockbridge Growth Equity announced the purchase of Northcentral University, an online institution with 7,500 students in undergraduate and graduate degree programs. Kaplan Inc. meanwhile announced the purchase of companies that provide English language training in Vietnam and in Britain.
Comments on
Quick Takes: U.S. Audit Slams Fifth Third Over Student Loans, Northeastern Ill. Withdraws Proposal on Protests, Effort to Save AP Italian Fails, Baltimore Hebrew May Merge Into Towson U., For-Profit Purchases
Posted
by kgotthardt
on January 8, 2009 at 7:55am EST
--Third declined to comment on the audit, but the report itself contains comments in which bank officials protest that the department’s interpretation conflicts with years of previous guidance and rulings.--
That wouldn't surprise me. Still, this change of ED's heart could help students who have struggled with bawdy loans and collection practices that would make any rational, ethical person furious.
Hey IG, have you re-reviewed MY case yet and discovered the lies?
Forgiveness
Posted
by Dr. Steve
on January 8, 2009 at 8:30am EST
Maybe now the incoming Obama administration will look favorably upon student loan forgiveness, especially targeting loans that are over-the-top, egregious, otherwise predatory, or being paid by students going into teaching or other public service fields.
It would make sense for a liberal president to invest in the social fabric (channeling a tiny fraction of the current, reportedly one trillion dollar "bail-out" money) after all the Wall Street depredations and the moneyed elites ripping off the public coffers, throwing us into an historically severe recession with no socially redeeming benefit at all.
Loan Forgiveness
Posted
by Gadfly
on January 8, 2009 at 10:20am EST
Forgiving more student loans sounds desirable and attractive. However, there is an issue of fairness: not all students borrowed out of necessity and not all students with need borrowed.
Better to reduce the need to borrow for those currently in school through more funding for Pell grants - to increase the average award and to extend eligibility to those with incomes through something closer to the family median.
If more funds are available, eliminate interest for the in-school period on all subsidized Stafford and Ford loans
delusions
Posted
by ex-loan huckster
on January 8, 2009 at 12:30pm EST
K Gotthard -- you and your ilk (i.e., the angry left) are so enraged you cannot comprehend simple concepts. So 5th Third pay referral fees to acquire FFELP loans? So what? If those students didn't borrow from Fifth Third, then they would have borrowed from Citibank, or Nelnet, or Sallie Mae, or Chase. And it wouldn't matter who since the loans are all the same. At Direct Loan schools they would get no choice and forced into a loan without borrower incentives.
FFELP lenders became the whipping boy for a societal problem in which undisciplined parents don't save anywhere near enough for college; lazy and incompetent guidance counselors send thousands of students to the wrong colleges; and colleges irresponsibly jack up tuition thanks to endless enrollment growth and (heretofore) easy credit. Blame belongs all the way around the circle, not just on the financing agents.
Student loans
Posted
by Faculty Person
on January 8, 2009 at 1:40pm EST
I'd like to see a combination of Dr. Steve's and Gadfly's approaches.
Short term student loan forgiveness (with appropriate qualifications but if we can bail out Wall Street fat cats who messed up why not students as well)?
Longer term reform the student loan program, increase other aid and continue to look at college costs.
Return standard consumer protections to student loans
Posted
by Alan Collinge
, Founder
at Studentloanjustice.org
on January 8, 2009 at 4:30pm EST
No one seems to be willing to acknowledge that nearly every basic, standard consumer protection has been stripped away from student loans over the years.
Congress, and the new administration need to give these protections back to the people- protections that whould have never been taken away in the first place- so that student loans are treated the same a s every other type of loan in our country, federally guaranteed, and not.