Documenting the Decline of (Print) Law Reviews
Related Stories
You don't have to look far for evidence of the decline of the print medium, as daily newspapers contract by the day, amid other signs.
But not surprisingly, perhaps, publishers are not exactly advertising their woes, and as a result, Ross E. Davies, editor in chief of The Green Bag law journal and a professor of law at George Mason University, had some difficulty when he sought to catalog the print readership of the country's leading law reviews.
In a paper prepared for The Green Bag's annual almanac and available now on the Social Science Research Network, Davies found that many law reviews were inconsistent, to be kind, in keeping up with a U.S. Postal Service requirement to publish their circulation numbers. Seven of the 15 leading journals he examined had not published their statistics for 2007-8, and several of them seemed to flout the rule consistently.
While Davies speculates about whether ignorance or something else explains the failure, he suggests that it may be better explained by what is revealed by the data he was able to collect, which show that all of the law reviews have seen significant drops -- most in the range of half to two-thirds -- in their print circulations. Harvard's law review fell to 2,610 paid subscriptions in 2007-8, down from a peak of 8,760 in 1979-80, and the University of Virginia's had dipped to 530 from 2,396 in 1980-81, as seen in the table below.
Total Paid Circulation for Law Reviews in Top 15 of 'U.S. News' Rankings
| Law Review | 1979-80 | 1987-88 | 1997-98 | 2007-8 |
| Yale | Did not report | 3,700 | 3,300 | Did not report |
| Harvard | 8,760 | 7,325 | 4,367 | 2,610 |
| Stanford | Did not report | Did not report | Did not report | 1,008 |
| Columbia | 3,795 | 2,947 | 2,273 | Did not report |
| New York U. | 2,100 | Did not report | 1,362 | Did not report |
| Boalt Hall (U. of Calif.) | 2,549 | 1,990 | Did not report | 884 |
| Chicago | 2,068 | Did not report | 1,922 | Did not report |
| Penn | 2,176 | 1,762 | 1,334 | 923 |
| Michigan | 2,950 | 2,535 | 1,925 | 783 |
| Northwestern | 1,771 | 1,264 | Did not report | Did not report |
| Virginia | Did not report | 2,029 | 1,536 | 530 |
| Cornell | 3,350 | Did not report | 2,803 | Did not report |
| Duke | 1,326 | 1,335 | Did not report | 957 |
| Georgetown | 3,197 | Did not report | 1,487 | Did not report |
| Vanderbilt | 1,995 | 1,550 | 1,265 | 850 |
Does the underreporting of the numbers reflect an "unwillingness ... to confront the possibility that a drop in circulation might be connected to a drop in influence or status[?]" Davies wonders.
He is quick to note, though, that with the increased availability of the law reviews through electronic means, including services such as Westlaw and Lexis and HeinOnline, it is distinctly possible that the "net consumption of law reviews is actually on the rise, along with their influence or status."
But without good and accurate data from the publishers, Davies says, "Who knows?"
Most Popular
- Viewed
- Past:
- 1 day
- 1 week
- 1 month
- 1 year
Similar Jobs
-
Assistant Dean, Law School
New Haven, CTRequisition Number: 14336BR
Department: Law Sch
University Job Title: Assistant Dean
Posting Position Title: Assistant Dean
Bargaining Unit: None
Job Category: Managerial & Professional
-
Law School Instructor
New York, NYThe City University of New York (CUNY) is the nation's leading urban public university serving more than 480,000 students in a wide range of educational programs at 24 colleges and institutions in New York City.
Job ID: 5352
Regular/Temporary: Regular -
Law
Tuscaloosa, ALPosition Title: Lecturer
Position Summary:
-
Director Domestic Violence Clinic - FY12
Tuscaloosa, ALPosition Title: Assistant/Associate/Full Professor
Position Summary:
The University of Alabama School of Law is seeking a qualified individual to direct the Domestic Violence Clinic. Clinical faculty rank will depend on experience.
-
Law
Tuscaloosa, ALPosition Title: Assistant/Associate/Full Professor
Position Summary:
-
Philosophy of Law
Tuscaloosa, ALPosition Title: Assistant Professor
Position Summary:
Featured Jobs
-
Chief Diversity Officer
10FebKennesaw, GAKennesaw State University seeks applications and nominations for a noted scholar and national leader to fill the cabinet-level position of Chief Diversity Officer.
-
Science Data Librarian
10FebMiddlebury, VTMiddlebury College, located in Middlebury, Vermont, is a nationally recognized liberal arts institution where the pursuit of knowledge knows no bounds.
-
Assistant/Associate/Full Professor-Doctoral Studies-Dreeben School of Education
10FebSan Antonio, TXThe University of the Incarnate Word (UIW) is one of America's two largest Hispanic-serving Catholic institutions.
... -
President of the College
10FebNewberry, SCNewberry College in South Carolina invites applications, nominations, and inquiries as the private institution begins its national search for its 22nd President.
-
Alexander Crombie Humphreys Chair in Economics of Engineering
10FebHoboken, NJThe School of Systems and Enterprises (SSE) at Stevens Institute of Technology is seeking candidates for the Alexander Crombie Humphreys Chair in Economics of Engineering.
-
Manager, Academic Collective Bargaining Administration
09FebYpsilanti, MIThe major responsibilities of this position are to assist with administration of labor agreements and negotiations between Eastern Michigan University (EMU) and the instructional bargaining units representing employees engaged in the delivery and support of academic services; including the Americ








