Quick Takes

March 23, 2009

Senate, Ending Delays, Confirms 2 Top Science Officials

For weeks now, the Senate (at the bidding of a few senators) has been delaying the confirmations of John Holdren to lead the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy and Jane Lubchenco to lead the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. The delays have infuriated scientists because Holdren and Lubchenco are highly respected researchers whose nominations have been widely applauded. Indeed the "holds" placed on their nominations had nothing to do with them, but reflected a longstanding Senate practice in which lawmakers block nominations from going forward as a way of gaining attention for other issues. Sen. Robert Menendez, a New Jersey Democrat, for example, blocked the nominations because of unrelated concerns he has about U.S. policy on Cuba. On Thursday, however, the Senate finally and uneventfully confirmed both officials. Holdren and Lubchenco each issued statements Friday welcoming their confirmations and pledging to make their decisions in office based on sound science.

Sculpture's Removal From Exhibit Prompts Protest at Bowling Green

When a dean removed one piece from a 13-sculpture exhibit at Bowling Green State University's Firelands campus, the director of the gallery took down the rest of the exhibit to protest the censorship, The Toledo Blade reported. A statement released by Bowling Green to the newspaper said: "We removed a sculpture that graphically depicts a female middle school student, on her knees, performing oral sex on a standing male middle school science teacher.... As an institution of higher education, Bowling Green State University strongly supports the right of free speech and artistic expression. However, we also have a responsibility … to not expose the children and families we invite to our campus to inappropriate material.” David Sapp, an art professor and director of the gallery, said he was stunned and angered when he found out that officials had removed the sculpture, and so he shut down the entire exhibit. Depicting an act does not endorse the act, he noted. "Consider if this same scene was in a book and was required reading. If someone complained, should we rip out the passage because it’s not pleasant to read or talk about?” Sapp asked the newspaper.

Michigan State Students Survive Bus Takeover in Guatemala

Eleven students at Michigan State University have returned from a spring break trip to Guatemala during which their bus was seized and they were forced off and tied up, then robbed at gunpoint, The Detroit Free Press reported. The students were on a program in which they were performing volunteer work in Guatemala.

U. of Phoenix Joins Yellow Ribbon Program

Under the new GI Bill, which covers veterans' tuition up to the most expensive resident rate at a public college in the state, private colleges have the option of entering into a matching program with the federal government to cover the balance. How many colleges will participate in the Yellow Ribbon program, and to what extent, has been an open question as many institutions await final regulations. Significantly, the University of Phoenix, which serves more veterans than any other college, does plan to participate in the new GI Bill's Yellow Ribbon program at the maximum 50 percent match, for 30,000 students or more (which would cover current veteran enrollment), according to Patrick Sutliff, who oversees veterans affairs at the institution.

College of DuPage Adopts Policies Over Faculty Objections

The board of the College of DuPage last week adopted a series of policies that effectively give the board more explicit authority over daily management of the college -- including many matters that professors say should primarily be handled by the faculty and the administration. The dispute has been going on for months and focused on a revision of the college's policy handbook. The board did delay a vote on including David Horowitz's "Academic Bill of Rights" as college policy -- a measure that was included in earlier draft -- but board members indicated that they may come back to that issue at future meetings.

After 28 Years, Tuskegee President Plans to Retire

One of the longest serving presidents in higher education, Benjamin F. Payton of Tuskegee University, has announced plans to retire. During Payton's tenure, Tuskegee broadened its educational offerings (and changed its name from Tuskegee Institute to Tuskegee University to reflect that shift). Tuskegee has a prominent role in the history of black higher education and a tradition of long-serving presidents, starting with Booker T. Washington. Since its founding in 1881, the university has had only five presidents.

2 Colleges Call Off Classes to Prevent Flood Damage

Two institutions in Moorhead, Minnesota -- Concordia College and Minnesota State University at Moorhead -- are calling off most classes today so students and others may help prepare sandbags to deal with serious local flooding.

Cambridge Dons Keep Control of the University

The British government has backed off from a push for people outside the University of Cambridge to hold a majority of the seats on the institution's governing board, The Guardian reported. However, the university has agreed to provide more information about how it uses the government funds it receives.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

Teaching lecture courses, in Tenured Radical.... The profit motive in education, in Eduwonk....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • Really classy...
  • Posted by Annoyed staff member on March 23, 2009 at 9:00am EDT
  • The creation of that tasteless sculpture was a really classy move by that artist. I'm glad that administrator had the guts to remove it. Just the creation of it was sick and twisted.

  • Blown Away
  • Posted by Artsie Prof on March 23, 2009 at 9:30am EDT
  • I also applaud the administrator who removed this object of "art" for exactly the same reasons stated by the first poster. If an artist has so little talent that they must rely on the use of a cheap shock to get attention, it's a good thing the rest of the exhibit was pulled. I wonder if the artist is familiar with the word "subtle." Perhaps the artist could relocate his exhibit to a massage parlor or lap dance studio, a more appropriate venue. Better yet, the artist should consider becoming part of the exhibit. It would certainly make more of a statement and prove, beyond doubt, that the artist has some talent.

  • BGSU Art Decision a Tough Call
  • Posted by Jim on March 23, 2009 at 9:30am EDT
  • The brouhaha over offensive artwork at Bowling Green Univesity is a familiar story to many college and university administrators. It is always a tough call, especially at a public university, when a work of art is so offensive to the community that it threatens to bring down the wrath of alumni, legislators and townspeople on the university. Deans, provosts and presidents then have to balance their support of artistic freedom against the real possibility that respecting that freedom will do harm to their institution. Artists, predictably, believe that their institution should go to the mat on their behalf. Administrators, on the other hand, have to take the larger view, and finding the correct balance point is never easy.

    In this case, it seems to me the dean made the right call. The artist in question has the right to produce whatever art he or she wants, but that doesn't mean the university has to put it on display. Part of the problem is the regrettable trend for artists to fabricate works that are devoid of esthetic merit but are merely intended to be outrageous, offensive, and provocative.

    To me, the real villain in this story is not the dean but the gallery director, who showed extremely poor judgment is allowing this work to be displayed in the first place. Gallery directors are at the interface between artists and the larger community, and have a responsibility to both constituencies. That this director took a stand against censorship on such a questionable and inappropriate work suggests that he or she lacks the appropriate judgment for the job.

  • Posted by Adjunct George on March 23, 2009 at 11:00am EDT
  • On the confirmation of the two anti-nuclear power science advisors - when we get the next series of brownouts, when your energy bills go up, remember these appointments. They are pro "green" power which is unable to solve the coming energy crisis. The reason for Yucca mountain was the bad decisions of Jimmy Carter to not reprocess and use the spent fuel from the reactors. Energy is the lifeblood of an industrial society and we have just drained the blood from the body.

  • Sculpture Title
  • Posted by BG Alum on March 23, 2009 at 11:30am EDT
  • I don't know if it makes a difference, but the title of the sculpture is something like, "The Science Teacher makes a decision he wil regret."

  • responding to BG Alum
  • Posted by Wilfred Toboggan on March 23, 2009 at 12:00pm EDT
  • The title isn't enough to save the sculpture. The insertion of a little common sense into the process could have saved the university a fair amount of grief.

  • Bowling Green sculpture
  • Posted by Harold Jewell on March 23, 2009 at 1:00pm EDT
  • What a debt we owe to Hans Christian Andersen when he spoofed this type of thing in "The Emperor's New Clothes." How foolishly righteous some people become in their hysterical defense of "art" and "free expression." I'm glad the Bowling Green dean yanked the piece. I beg of you, Dean, do not capitulate.

  • Posted by Max Jerrell on March 23, 2009 at 1:00pm EDT
  • The art director should be grateful to the dean. How long would it have taken for someone to have declared the statue to be child pornography? It may well have met the definition of same at which time the director would have really had something to be outraged about.

  • Posted by HJ on March 23, 2009 at 2:30pm EDT
  • If Mr. Sapp is truly sincere in his objections to the removal of the sculpture perhaps he should place it in a well lighted area on the front lawn at his home. That way he would probably reach out to more individuals than only those who would view this piece of (fill in with your own description) at the on-campus exhibit. I am also sure that he would be happy to explain the merits of such a piece to the parents of all the neighborhood children that would be enlightened by this work. Mr. Sapp could become known as the great educator among those in his neighborhood. He could even become a folk hero!

  • Bowling Green Art Decision
  • Posted by Marilyn , Dr. at Lorain County Community College on March 24, 2009 at 10:30am EDT
  • I am upset that this work would be displayed when there is so much child molestation in the world. I am especially angered that it objectifies a young female. Shame on the artist and the gallery director. Totally irresponsible and self-serving. I am pleased that the administrator stood up for the values of our society and the sensibilities of our youth.

  • Mr. Sapp's analogy doesn't fit
  • Posted by Dr. Gary Fitsimmons on March 25, 2009 at 9:30am EDT
  • Mr. Sapp's contention that the piece was part of a larger exhibit and therefore should be judged as such is a false analogy. "Consider if this same scene was in a book and was required reading. If someone complained, should we rip out the passage because it’s not pleasant to read or talk about?” Each art piece is separate and should be judged on it's own merits, and therefore, allowing that piece in the exhibit does imply at least tacit endorsement of the act. Brovo to the administrator for standing up to the blind defense of "freedom of expression" in favor of common decency.