Quick Takes

April 9, 2009

AAUP Council Backs Churchill's Reinstatement

The National Council of the American Association of University Professors has issued a statement calling for the reinstatement of Ward Churchill by the University of Colorado. The statement, in its entirety, is this: "We believe the disputes over Ward Churchill's publications should have been allowed to work themselves out in traditional scholarly venues, not referred to disciplinary hearings. We believe Churchill should be reinstated to his faculty position at the University of Colorado." A Colorado jury last week found that the University of Colorado did not fire Churchill as an ethnic studies professor on the Boulder campus for legitimate reasons, but for his political views. A judge will later determine whether Churchill can return to his tenured job. Typically, AAUP's academic freedom committee issues findings about cases involving claims of wrongful termination, but Nelson noted that the National Council from time to time speaks out on its own, as it did in this case. Churchill was fired after the university found that he had engaged in numerous instances of scholarly misconduct.

N.J. Higher Ed Aide Nominated for U.S. Labor Post

President Obama on Wednesday nominated New Jersey's top higher education official (who is also a former top aide to U.S. Sen. Edward M. Kennedy) to head the Labor Department agency that oversees federal job training programs. Jane Oates, executive director of the New Jersey Commission on Higher Education and a senior adviser to Gov. Jon S. Corzine, is the president's choice to be assistant labor secretary leading the Employment and Training Administration, which administers the Workforce Investment Act and other federal job training programs. If confirmed by the Senate, Oates would oversee the agency's work, among other things, on spending additional billions in federal stimulus money for job training, much of which could flow to community colleges, and working with Congress to renew the Workforce Investment Act. In other recent Obama administration personnel moves, the president has nominated John Q. Easton, executive director of the University of Chicago's Consortium on Chicago School Research, to direct the U.S. Education Department's Institute of Education Sciences, which oversees the federal government's work on education research. At the center, Easton worked closely with Education Secretary Arne Duncan on research aimed at improving the Chicago Public Schools. And the Portland Press Herald reported that Duncan has appointed Glenn Cummings, dean of institutional advancement at Southern Maine Community College and a former speaker of the Maine House of Representatives, for a key role in the Education Department's Office of Vocational and Adult Education.

Brown U. Profs Vote to Replace Columbus Day With 'Fall Weekend'

Brown University professors, at the request of student groups, have voted to rename the institution's Columbus Day holiday as "Fall Weekend," The Providence Journal reported. Student groups had called for the change in light of "the nature of Christopher Columbus's conquests and treatment of Native Americans." The vote is not going over well with Providence's Italian American population. Raymond Dettore Jr., national historian for the Sons of Italy, told the Journal: "I don't think this is right. Columbus was the one that opened up this part of the world to Western civilization. Whether it was him or anybody else, it was going to happen eventually. Columbus showed the world was not flat." He added, "Why don't they change the name of Brown? Was it not founded by slave traders? Brown has gone just a little too far with some of these things over the past few years."

SMU Admits Drug Death Wasn't 'Isolated Incident'

After maintaining for two years that the drug overdose death of a student was an "isolated incident," Southern Methodist University officials have acknowledged that there was a broader drug problem at the time in the Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity, where the student died in his room, The Dallas Morning News reported. "SMU has concluded that the use of illegal drugs by members of the fraternity was not isolated to the student who died," said a university statement to the Morning News. "Statements made by several SAE members indicate there was drug use by additional fraternity members in the SAE house or as part of fraternity activities." The university is barring the fraternity from holding parties until November, and said it didn't impose a harsher penalty because a majority of members today were not members at the time of the death of the student, Jake Stiles. The university's characterization of the death of Stiles as an isolated incident infuriated his family members, who cited extensive evidence otherwise, and was the subject of a lengthy article in January in The Texas Monthly.

Massad May Have Won Tenure Battle

Joseph Massad may have won an epic tenure battle at Columbia University. No official announcements have been made by Columbia or Massad, but The Angry Arab News Service -- a blog sympathetic to him -- quotes him as confirming campus reports that he has been assured of tenure. Many scholars of Middle Eastern studies believe Massad deserves tenure and that his promotion has been held up unreasonably because of opposition by pro-Israel groups. Those groups, in turn, say that Massad is hostile not only to Israel but to students whose views on Israel differ from his own.

Johns Hopkins Bars Gifts to Medical Professors From Drug Companies

Johns Hopkins Medicine has become the latest medical school to bar gifts from pharmaceutical companies. New policies announced Wednesday prohibit the acceptance of gifts or entertainment -- including food -- regardless of value, from pharmaceutical and medical device companies. Consulting arrangements that carry compensation but no real duties also are barred. Beginning in 2010, Hopkins will no longer accept free pharmaceutical samples, although in some limited cases, it will use "de-identified samples " (those without the brand name or manufacturer's name) for patient education. While consulting work for drug companies will not be barred, reporting requirements to prevent conflicts of interest will be strengthened. "Industry plays a crucial role in advancing medical research and treatments, and the intent is not to discourage principled partnerships," says Julie Gottlieb, assistant dean and director of the Johns Hopkins Medicine Office of Policy Coordination, in a statement. "The major reason for developing this policy is to limit the impact of industry marketing influence on faculty and physicians' decision making and by so doing protect patients."

Scranton Bishop Presses Colleges for Proof

The bishop for the Diocese of Scranton has deemed the response of four Catholic colleges to his inquiry into contraceptives on campus “insufficient.” The presidents of King’s College, Misericordia University, Marywood University and the University of Scranton said in a joint letter Monday that they do not provide condoms or oral contraceptives on campus, but the bishop said further documentation is needed – citing two specific reasons for concern, including the inclusion of condoms on Marywood’s packing list for international students. Officials at the four colleges either declined or did not respond to requests for further comment Wednesday.

Private Equity-Backed Firm Buys Florida For-Profit College

A for-profit education company owned by a leading private equity firm has bought Florida Technical College, which operates three career-oriented campuses, according to Stifel Nicolaus Investment Banking, which announced the sale. EduK, which operates several colleges in Puerto Rico and is financed by Leeds Equity Partners, completed its purchase of Florida Technical College from Forefront Education, Stifel Nicolaus said. Florida Tech operates 17 programs on three campuses. Terms of the sale were not disclosed.

Nasty Editorial, Nastier Response

The student editors of Hillsdale College's Collegian knew they'd blown it; the publication's Web site offered an apology for a staff editorial last week that ridiculed the losing ways of the Michigan college's baseball team and the "badass ... swagger" of its members. But as low as the student journalists admit to have aimed, their targets appear to have ratcheted it down a few steps. The paper's editor found the carcasses of several dead animals (including a goat and "one and a half deer," as the Associated Press put it) on the steps of the off-campus house where he lives, with a copy of the editorial tucked underneath. College officials said they had resolved the situation, declining to say whether baseball players were involved and making clear that no animals had been hurt in the incident.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

How to teach writing to non-humanities majors, in Acephalous.... The adjunct career, in Literature Should Mean Something in Your Life....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • Auto de fe Time!
  • Posted by Diogenes on April 9, 2009 at 7:30am EDT
  • Ah the evils of Satan's contraceptives and birth control! Let the inquisition and torture begin! Bring on Abstinence-Only Grand Inquisitor Palin! Light the fires! Prepare for the auto de fe! An answer is not enough, the Master says. Interrogations now follow....Repent, and you'll be relaxed before the fire!

    And I though we had it bad with the Abomination of Desolation...I mean the Bush Library, on our Holy Ground! Guess I should fell lucky!

  • Churchill case a reason to employ adjuncts
  • Posted by Jack Olson on April 9, 2009 at 9:45am EDT
  • Would the University of Colorado have found it easier to dismiss Ward Churchill had he been an adjunct? Undoubtedly. Instead of convening a panel to consider charges against him of academic misconduct, and even then being sued and losing a token judgement for wrongful termination, the university could simply have declined to renew his contract.

    Hence, his case illustrates a good reason for universities to rely on adjuncts as much as possible and tenured faculty as little as possible. When one of the former embarasses the university by slandering victims of mass murder, you can easily dispense with him. Yet, when one of the former does it, you have come to grips with the Tar Baby. A judge or jury may force you to continue to employ him even after an academic panel has substantiated his academic misconduct. Since the AAUP appears indifferent to the academic misconduct Churchill committed, I assume they are equally oblivious that he represents a good reason why university administrators would want to abolish tenure.

  • Posted by Adjunct George on April 9, 2009 at 10:30am EDT
  • The position taken by the AAUP on Plagerist Churchill is priceless. Someone guilty of plagerism and fired should be reinstated because he is tenured. A great example for those us us who believe tenure is a problem rather than a solution to use. Keep up the good work in destroying the academic community brand.

  • AAUP Lays an Egg
  • Posted by Fossil , Prof. of Mathematics (emeritus) at Gargantuan State U. on April 9, 2009 at 10:30am EDT
  • As a 40-year member of AAUP, I am deeply ashamed of that organization's stance in favor of the odious Ward Churchill. If there was ever a fraudulent "scholar" who deserved to be kicked out on his ass, posthaste, it's Churchill (quite independently of his "Eichmann" crack, where he had every right to make a damn fool of himself). AAUP puts me in mind of New York's Patrolman's Benevolent Association. The latter group has never encountered a case where a cop is guilty of abusing his authority or brutalizing the public, no matter how strong the evidence. AAUP has never met a (left-leaning) professor who doesn't deserve a life-long meal ticket, no matter how wretched or tendentious his or her research, no matter how much he or she has misused an instructor's authority in order to proselytize. You can bet they're delighted by the promotion of the rather dubious Joseph Massad!

    On the other hand, one has to assume that a prof (or grad student) with conservative views would get the cold shoulder, no matter how egregiously that person's academic rights were violated.

    This would seem to be of a piece with Brown U.'s quasi-comical attempt to write Columbus out of history. Sanctimonious petulance is the order of the day.

  • What Fossil Said
  • Posted by Rod Bell , Adjunct Professor at College of DuPage on April 9, 2009 at 11:45am EDT
  • Quality expression. Great judgment.

  • AAUP
  • Posted by Puzzled on April 9, 2009 at 12:15pm EDT
  • Mr. Fossil is right on the mark. Would AAUP be for the reinstatement of a professor who has violated the most important standards of the profession if he were an acknowledged Christian? An acknowledged and outspoken conservative? A law professor who argues that waterboarding is not torture?

  • Correction
  • Posted by Jack Olson on April 9, 2009 at 5:00pm EDT
  • When I used "former" the second time in my comment on Churchill, I meant "latter", referring to tenured professors.

  • Prof. Fossil's comments
  • Posted by Humanities Based Prof , Faculty at An Urban College on April 13, 2009 at 10:30am EDT
  • Finally...I can not thank Prof Fossil for his well written and well supported comments! At my own institution, I find that I am fearful to express my own opinions and thoughts on any topic when they tend to run against the ultra liberal left and frankly find it a troubling situtation to be at an institution who proclaims "Academic freedom" but forgets to publish the understood second part of the sentence, "well, of course only as long as it is liberal."