Quick Takes

April 10, 2009

Bills Favoring Guns on Campus Advance in 2 States

Legislation to permit those registered to carry concealed weapons to carry them on college campuses is advancing in Missouri and Texas. In Texas, the House Public Safety Committee has now approved a measure that appears to have the support of a majority in the House of Representatives, The Houston Chronicle reported. In Missouri, the House of Representatives voted Thursday to lift a ban on carrying concealed weapons on campuses, KOMU News reported. In both states, legislators favoring concealed weapons on campus say that students would be safer if they could respond to a threat. But in both states, some legislators and most campus safety experts say that guns pose unique dangers on campuses, where students are not necessarily mature and may be tempted to use firearms while drunk. In the words of Missouri Rep. Chris Kelly: "College boys love things that go boom. What we don't need is beer and college boys and firearms."

U.S. Cancels Auction for Parent Loans

What if the federal government held an auction and nobody came? That's essentially what happened this month, and the U.S. Education Department announced Thursday in a message to student loan providers that it was canceling its Congressionally mandated plan for state-by-state competitive bidding processes for the right to make federal student loans for parents. The auction, which was enacted as part of budget reconciliation legislation in 2007, was set to take place next week. But as the law was written, the auctions were to be held only in those states that received at least two requests from lenders -- and not a single state received two such requests, Daniel T. Madzelan, a senior department official, said in an e-mail message Thursday. Most states received no requests at all, he said. The auction idea had become increasingly fraught because of the economic downturn and with the Obama administration contemplating much broader changes in the federal student loan programs. Democratic leaders in Congress introduced legislation late last month that would have postponed the auction for a year -- which may not be necessary given the department's announcement Thursday.

Clark U. Calls Off Finkelstein Lecture

Clark University has called off a lecture by Norman Finkelstein, saying that it would conflict with and possibly detract from a conference about the Holocaust on campus, The Boston Globe reported. John Bassett, the university's president, said in a letter to the campus paper that he canceled Finkelstein's talk due to "unfortunate scheduling" near a conference sponsored by the university's Strassler Family Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies. Clark is known for its programs in Holocaust studies. Finkelstein, an outspoken critic of Israel, is known for writing about the Holocaust that focuses on Israeli use of the history of the Holocaust to justify its actions. Finkelstein was invited to Clark by a group called Clark University Students for Palestinian Rights. The statement from Bassett said: "It is possible that our understanding of the Middle East conflicts would be enriched by conversations with Professor Finkelstein. It is my judgment, however, that having Professor Finkelstein speak on the same evening as our planned conference would only invite controversy and not dialogue or understanding."

Maryland Will Keep Graduation Prayer

C.D. Mote Jr., president of the University of Maryland at College Park, has decided that the institution will keep a two-minute prayer at graduation ceremonies. The Baltimore Sun reported that the University Senate -- which has student, faculty and staff members -- voted this week to recommend that the university end the prayer, saying that it was not inclusive. But Mote, in a statement, said that "for many people, a prayer of gratitude and a moment of reflection are an important part of our commencement tradition."

U. of Colorado Will Fight Churchill Reinstatement

The University of Colorado will "vigorously challenge" any move to reinstate Ward Churchill to his job teaching ethnic studies at the Boulder campus, a spokesman told The Daily Camera. While the announcement was not a surprise, it was the first formal indication of how the university will respond to last week's verdict by a state jury that Churchill was fired inappropriately for his political views. The university has maintained that he was fired for repeated instances of scholarly misconduct. The judge in the case has the discretion to order Churchill reinstated or to instead order other compensation, such as a cash payment, but Churchill has said repeatedly that he wants his job back. Churchill's lawyers have suggested that he could simply return to campus and start teaching again, but the university spokesman called that a "spurious" premise and noted that the findings of misconduct were not discredited by the verdict. "The notion he can just settle back into his teaching duties is questionable," the spokesman said. A lawyer for Churchill called the university's position "offensive," adding that "a jury of their peers has convicted them of being constitutional violators."

Report Finds Few Options for 'Distressed' Private Loan Borrowers

Borrowers with private student loans who get into financial distress get relatively little help from their lenders and appear to be receiving little aid from the federal government because they are deemed "too small to help," the National Consumer Law Center said in a report issued Thursday. The center's Student Loan Borrower Assistance Program surveyed the practices of providers of private student loans, finding few options to help financially distressed borrowers out of trouble, and offers recommendations aimed at improving the lot of such borrowers.

Hawkeye CC Ends Jobs of All Part-Time Faculty

Hawkeye Community College has announced plans to eliminate the jobs of all 33 part-time faculty members as well as the positions of 10 full-time faculty members, The Waterloo-Cedar Falls Courier reported. College officials said that the decision was based on expectations of limited state funds for the next year.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

Philosophers shoveling snow, in The Duck of Minerva.... Dual authors in anthropology, in Savage Minds....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • PLUS Auction: An expensive joke meets its demise
  • Posted by J. Dean on April 10, 2009 at 8:30am EDT
  • As predicted by many, the PLUS auction was a bust. A party was given but nobody came. The whole thing struck many of us as a joke when first proposed, but the wasted time and government money on this auction is no joke. Maybe the people that wrote the legislation and those that supported it in Congress can reimburse the Treasury for staff time wasted at the Department of Education, printing costs at the Federal Register and for the pain and suffering at many colleges where aid administrators wasted time trying to figure out what was going on.

    Its good that the PLUS auction is dead.

  • Major Feature Worthy Article - Major Report
  • Posted by T Smith on April 10, 2009 at 8:45am EDT
  • The above Report Finds Few Options for 'Distressed' Private Loan Borrowers is worthy of a major article. Please, push this into the main arena. I'm one of the borrowers of private student loans who is "too small to help." I'm drowning here, and the lenders are throwing me a bowling ball. Check studentloanjustice.org to read about others like me.

  • Clark University's Ban on Finkelstein
  • Posted by John K. Wilson at collegefreedom.org on April 10, 2009 at 9:00am EDT
  • I hope that InsideHigherEd will follow up on the banning of Norman Finkelstein from Clark University. I wasn't aware that a university president was empowered to ban speakers based on alleged scheduling conflicts, which happen all the time in academia. But here's the odd part. According to President Bassett, "having Professor Finkelstein speak on the same evening as our planned conference would only invite controversy and not dialogue or understanding." But according to the Boston Globe and Finkelstein's website, he was scheduled to speak on April 21. According to the Clark University site, the holocaust conference is being held April 23-26, and there are zero events on campus that conflict with Finkelstein's April 21 speech. Clark University needs to make a fuller explanation of what happened.

  • Posted by Master of None on April 10, 2009 at 10:00am EDT
  • Mr. Wilson, po-tay-to, po-tah-to, perhaps? 21 April may not fall "near" 23 April to you. To President Bassett, it does. Similarly, the president's understated assertion here may be that a Finkelstein talk on the 21st would cast a shadow over the conference 2 days later. Of course, it might equally provide important context for it. A compromise with a similar outcome: invite him a week later.

  • Posted by Frustrated college male on April 10, 2009 at 10:45am EDT
  • "In the words of Missouri Rep. Chris Kelly: "College boys love things that go boom. What we don't need is beer and college boys and firearms.""

    What a sexist stereotype and a darn shame that Mr. Kelly would play into it when contemplating the rule of law! Evidently, boys are the only ones that we have to worry about in our society who might have the drunken idea to shoot someone or cause an accident. Certainly, a girl would never think of levelling a gun at someone, right?

    Let's face it. No matter what you may think about guns on campus, using the legislative pulput to blame boys alone for the danger of guns is ignorant and denigrating to young men, adding to the feeling that they can do no right. It's no wonder that male role models right now are Seth Rogen, Will Farrell, and Larry the Cable Guy. If society tells you that all you can be expected to do is become a screw-up in life, I guess men may as well show just show successful of a screw-up they can be.

    Thank you, Mr. Kelly, for coming down on the young men of America and using the law to call them alcoholic, irresponsible, and incompetent.

  • Sidearms in the Classroom
  • Posted by L Musgrove on April 10, 2009 at 11:15am EDT
  • It may be that the unstated motive is the legislative destruction of public universities in Texas and Missouri. The private universities must be licking their chops. Who would want to send their freshman daughters into dorms at state schools in TX and MO? Why would a new PhD apply to these state's schools knowing sidearms are in the classrooms?

  • guns in the classroom
  • Posted by guns aren't the problem at Ohio State University on April 10, 2009 at 12:30pm EDT
  • Dear frustrated college male:

    Let's add Chris Brown to your list, in the interest of being balanced, since you only listed "dumb white guys".

    To L. Musgrove, hell yes I'd send daughters of mine knowing there might be a student packing. She'll have a better chance at survival with a person who knows how to handle a weapon, against someone holds a gun sideways like the idiots in the movies, on television, and on your local news. Better yet, how about teaching your daughters how to shoot, so they won't be victims?

  • Hoplophobia and conspiracy theory
  • Posted by JJR , Catalog Librarian / Library at Texas Woman's University on April 10, 2009 at 1:15pm EDT
  • The same tired "drunken students with gunz" canard being raised by the Hoplophobes, now wedded with conspiracy theory in the comments section. I work for a state university in Texas that is majority female and non-traditional aged. Most of our students are commuters. Some of them work and have to take night classes and perhaps be in the library until closing. Our library staff (mostly female) stays until Midnight. If this measure passes, it means our students who are 21 and would be able to carry a compact pistol in their purse, which is somewhat more effective at stopping a deadly threat or violent attack than a can of mace or pepper spray. I am a librarian, I obey the law as it now stands, but I am also a CHL holder in Texas and outside of my work hours I carry everywhere permitted by law. There are scores of your fellow citizens legally "packing heat" in restaurants, movie theaters, even the grocery store, all around you, every day. And thank goodness, because there are also career criminals carrying guns the law *already* prohibit them from having and for whom prohibitionist policies are a joke, as it only affects the law abiding like me. So I can effectively defend myself at home and around town, but must disarm going to and from work, and while on campus during the day. A video presented by our own campus police department on "what to do in an active shooter situation" told us that most incidents will be over long before police arrive. Guess what--that means self-defense and survival is your own responsibility, and yet currently the great state of Texas wants to keep me from having the best tool I can have to ensure my survival (and the survival of students and co-workers) because of political correctness and the squeamishness of some university administrators and faculty. Hypocritically, our university PD supports the ban, but I suspect this is more CYA than their honest opinions as police professionals. It is up to the Texas legislature to fully restore Texan's 2nd Amendment rights, to not only Keep but also *Bear* arms, i.e. to carry them on our persons. It is already a crime for a CHL to consume alcohol while carrying, or to enter an establishment where 51% or more of the revenue is derived from alcohol sales while carrying, and it should remain so.

  • Posted by Adjunct George on April 10, 2009 at 1:15pm EDT
  • Good on you, University of Co. As a taxpayer, I support your decision to get rid of one of the plagarists in your midst.

  • C.D. & Guns on Campus
  • Posted by Wossamotta U. on April 10, 2009 at 2:45pm EDT
  • Nice job, President Mote. As a nonreligious individual, I am pleased that free speech was upheld. I might suggest making it clear that all religions are meant to be equally included in this portion of the ceremony, but it is certainly important to respect the faith aspects of various folks' identities. Politically, this was also an adept decision, following the porn wars of last week.

    As for the guns on campus, one need only look at the history of colleges in this country to know it's a very bad idea. Certainly, we have less of the dueling culture these days, but in colonial and post-colonial higher education, students were frequently shot and stabbed over disputes--often under the influence. And, if I may add, those events necessarily took place at all-male schools. We've already got plenty of fists to deal with. Let's not return to the dark ages on this one. Jeez, I can just picture some kid with a now-legal AK, half in the bag, going to find the guy he thinks likes his girlfriend on a Saturday night. Which legislator wants a piece of that one?

  • The Precious "Ward" and Wossamotta U.
  • Posted by DFS on April 10, 2009 at 4:00pm EDT
  • It's no wonder that, despite the actual number of comments on IHE during its entire "reporting" and discussions about Ward Churchill, that it's just going to be imbedded somewhere so that the busy or lazy will not have an immediately available 'Click.'
    Secondly, Wossamotta U. -- Wossamotta You?
    Exactly how many straw men can you pigeonhole into your argument?
    "...[O]ne need only look at the history of colleges in this country to know it's a very bad idea." We are not now colonial nor post-colonial. In fact, I submit that whenever there was a reduced potential loss of life or limb, a gun put an end to the exigent idiocy by the gunman.
    We are smarter than this straw argument now.