Quick Takes

April 13, 2009

Arbitrator Rules Against Prof Who Didn't Want Extra Course

The University of Florida did not violate collective bargaining rules by requiring a professor to teach an additional course, an independent arbitrator has concluded. Florence Babb, an endowed professor and graduate coordinator of the university’s Center for Women’s Studies and Gender Research, challenged Florida’s decision to change her teaching load, saying her employment agreement stipulated that she would only be required to teach one course each semester. Given significant budget challenges, Florida officials increased Babb’s teaching requirements. Babb is now required to teach three courses over the spring and fall semesters, in addition to carrying out her duties as graduate coordinator for the women’s studies center. Ben Falcigno, an arbitrator who reviewed the case, based his decision on Babb’s 2004 appointment letter. The letter states that the “normal” course load for Babb would be two courses a year, but Falcigno concluded current budget constraints constitute “abnormal” conditions that allow the university to increase Babb’s teaching requirements. Babb was represented by the United Faculty of Florida, a statewide union affiliated with the National Education Association and the American Federation of Teachers. Pradeep Kumar, who represented Babb for the union, said the arbitration ruling is binding and won’t be appealed. Babb could not be reached for comment.

Students' Credit Card Debt Is Up

Students are carrying more credit card debt than at any time since Sallie Mae started a periodic study of the topic, USA Today reported. Data to be released by Sallie Mae today will show that the average undergraduate carried $3,173 in debt last year, up from $2,169 in 2004, the last time the study was conducted. Student debt increases the longer students are enrolled.

Arrests Follow Building Takeover at New School

Students pushing for the resignation of Bob Kerrey as president of the New School took over a building Friday morning, and university officials responded by sending in the New York City police to retake the building. Nineteen people -- some but not all of them New School students -- were arrested when the police retook the building, and other students were also arrested. Students and many professors at the New School say that Kerrey has provided poor leadership for the institution. A building takeover in December ended after negotiations, with students vowing additional protests if Kerrey remained in office.

A statement from the university defended the need to call in the police. "[T]he university has allowed and accommodated every peaceful protest, teach-in, and demonstration. We have enforced our rules governing such events in such a way as to permit protests, so long as they don't endanger the safety of other members of the community or destruction of property," the statement said. But it continued by saying that the protesters on Friday were not being truthful. "Their claim that this was a simple political protest is false. Their entry into this building was forced, they removed a man who was cleaning the building, took his phone, injured a security officer, and did physical damage to the building. Accordingly, in this case the university asked the New York Police Department to remove and arrest those who were trespassing on our property. We suspended, pending administrative review, all New School students who were a part of this action. The New School prides itself on civic engagement. We have been and will continue to be a refuge for open and critical political debate. Students and faculty who choose to peacefully and passionately oppose the policies of the university will have their rights to do so protected as strongly as we protect our right to safely and securely operate our university."

Supporters of the protest held additional rallies Friday night.

New School in Exile, the protest group, posted videos of the protests and arrests on its Web site. The group said that Kerrey and police officers were lying about the way events transpired, and vowed to continue efforts to oust Kerrey.

San Jose State Prods 'Super Seniors' to Graduate

San Jose State University -- forced to reject students for lack of space -- is trying to push out those seniors who have taken far more courses than they need to graduate, but who don't seem to want to pick up a diploma and leave. The San Jose Mercury News reported that the university is adding intensive counseling for such "super seniors." How long are some students sticking around. About 1,500 students have been seniors for at least three years. And some of these seniors really like it: 35 have been enrolled for at least 10 years, and 2 have been enrolled for 15 years.

Penn State Apologizes for Veteran Video

Pennsylvania State University has stopped using and apologized for a video prepared to help faculty members learn how to deal with students who could pose a safety risk. The video -- no longer available at Penn State but posted by critics to YouTube -- shows a veteran as being unwilling to accept the grades he receives and unwilling to accept responsibility for his work. He accuses his professor of giving him low grades because of her opposition to the war in Iraq and makes ominous statements. After veterans' groups said that the video stereotyped veterans, Penn State pulled it. A statement it gave to The Centre Daily Times said: “Unfortunately, in our efforts to also highlight in this video the potential services that are available to veterans, the portrayal of the student as a veteran may be viewed by some as unfairly stereotyping members of this important constituency. Penn State sincerely regrets any misperception."

Professor Stands Up to Animal Rights Extremists

Many professors attacked by animal rights extremists have taken the approach of becoming as invisible as possible. But a profile in today's Los Angeles Times looks at a professor at the University of California at Los Angeles who is taking the opposite approach -- organizing a campus protest against the violent acts being committed by animal rights extremists.

"People always say: 'Don't respond. If you respond, that will give [the attackers] credibility,'" said J. David Jentsch, a neuroscientist whose car was set on fire. "But being silent wasn't making us feel safer. And it's a moot point if they are coming to burn your car anyway, whether you give them credibility or not."

Arizona State Will Honor Obama, But Not With Degree

Arizona State University may not think President Obama deserves an honorary degree, but it will name a scholarship program for him. At Arizona State, commencement speakers aren't automatically offered an honorary degree, and the university announced that it was thrilled to have him give the address, but would hold off on an honorary doctorate, given that he is just starting his tenure in office. As bloggers and others found that Arizona State had awarded honorary degrees in the past to Erma Bombeck, Hugh Downs and others who arguably have not influenced American society as has President Obama, many have questioned the decision not to award the president a degree. On Saturday, Arizona State announced that it was sorry for any implied insult, and was naming a major scholarship program for the president. Knox College, meanwhile, is reminding people that it thought Obama was worthy of an honorary back in 2005, when he was just starting out in the Senate.

Crossing a Line to Protect a College's Image

Ohio Wesleyan University is apologizing for an incident in which an admissions officer -- who has not been named -- trashed issues of the student newspaper that might not have projected the image that would appeal to prospective students' families, The Columbus DIspatch reported. The university has apologized to the newspaper and pledged that it would take steps to prevent any tossing of papers based on their content. The admissions officer was apparently upset about an article about the "50 Day Club" in which seniors mark the 50 days prior to graduation with a daily trip to a bar.

LSU Ousts Controversial Hurricane Researcher

Louisiana State University has fired Ivor van Heerden as a research professor and deputy director at the university's Hurricane Center. The New Orleans Times-Picayune reported that van Heerden -- who does not have tenure -- was not given a reason for his dismissal, and that the university isn't talking, citing confidentiality requirements. Van Heerden played a prominent role in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, criticizing the Army Corps of Engineers, among others.

Time on Facebook Costs Students High Grades, Study Finds

Among the papers that will be presented at this week's annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association is one by an Ohio State researcher, Aryn Karpinski, that documents a decline in college grades for students who spend a lot of time on Facebook, as opposed to those who don't, The Times (London) reported. The gap is the equivalent of a letter grade, the research found. We would tell you more, but we need to share our feelings about this news on the walls of 829 close friends.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

How to teach writing to non-humanities majors, in Acephalous.... The adjunct career, in Literature Should Mean Something in Your Life....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • ASU Blew It!
  • Posted by Diogenes on April 13, 2009 at 8:00am EDT
  • ASU should stop the purely political posturing against President Obama and give a sitting President the honorary degree. Erma Bombeck "yes" and first Black American President "No?" That's absurd, smacks of racism and partisan politics, and is uncalled for! Give the degree, ASU, and stop fumbling around! You made a grave error of judgment and fudging and coming up with lame alternatives and half-apologies will not work. Do the right thing. Do not insult our president.. John McCain and his supporters on your Board of Trustees will eventually forgive you if you do the right thing. The rest of the country will never forget this if you do not!

  • Conflict of interest
  • Posted by Cesar on April 13, 2009 at 8:00am EDT
  • Nellie Mae (now Sallie Mae) is not a good source for this type of information, because they historically use it to advocate for higher loan limits on federally-guaranteed students loans -- which they say are "good debt" as opposed to credit card balances which they say are "bad debt." Increasing the student loan limits, so the argument goes, will reduce the need to "finance" a college education with credit cards. There is no evidence that students are using credit cards to finance the college education. The same individuals would still be using credit cards even if they didn't go to college; credit cards may be more readily available on campus. In addition, there doesn't seem to be a relation between increasing student loan borrowing limits and relieving credit card debt levels, even using the company's own info.

  • Obama doesn't need another degree
  • Posted by AR Viera , UT Libraries at UT Knoxville on April 13, 2009 at 9:30am EDT
  • On the ASU honorary degree story: President Obama doesn't need another degree. That said, I live in a town and work at a university that has a tendency to name streets and buildings for people, primarily sports figures, prematurely. There is no harm in taking a wait-and-see approach to Obama's record. It seems Mr. Obama was the first to caution against hype. I remember listening to "Wait Wait Don't Tell Me" (the NPR quiz show) when Mr. Obama was in the US Senate. When the hosts heaped praise on him, Mr. Obama's good- humored response was approximately: "Let's wait until legislation I sponsor is signed into law."

  • Conflict of Interest
  • Posted by R.F. on April 13, 2009 at 10:00am EDT
  • Cesar, two observations.

    First, from your statements you have never worked in a Bursar's Office or you would know that many students (and parents) use credit cards to charge tuition, fees, books, and room and board.

    Some use their card as a bridge until a student loan disbursement comes in to the school, some use it to get the airline miles or cash back from the card issuer. Other use their credit card to pay for their expenses up front and then wait for an employer reimbursement.

    Which brings me to my second observation; not everybody who uses a card to pay for school is getting a student loan.

    SLMA may have an interest, but their data can be easily checked by others.

    Best advice is to watch "borrowing" closely...from all sources.

  • *sigh* correlation does not imply causality
  • Posted by social science prof , psychology at University of Kentucky on April 13, 2009 at 10:00am EDT
  • I wish a publication like "Inside Higher Education" wouldn't commit the correlational fallacy. Just because students who spend a lot of time on Facebook get lower grades doesn't mean that Facebook is costing them higher grades. There could be any number of other factors responsible for the relation, e.g., lower academic engagement and intrinsic motivation, for starters. It is entirely possible that if these students weren't on Facebook, they'd find plenty of other non-academic ways of spending their time.

    When I teach undergraduates, I know that few of them are going on to have careers as scientists. My primary goal is for them to become better educated consumers of the science news they read in the media. (That's assuming they even read science news, but I digress.) This would be an easier task if journalists themselves were more careful about the conclusions they draw in their articles.

  • Obama and "hype'?
  • Posted by georgia , Writing program coordinator at UT on April 13, 2009 at 10:00am EDT
  • I am confused by AR Viera's notion of "hype" as it relates to the ASU/Obama issue. While I agree that Mr. Obama doesn't "need" another degree, I'm not quite certain that Hugh Downs and Erma Bombeck "needed" their honorary ASU degrees. Does AR Viera suggest that ASU is waiting to see whether Mr. Obama's achievements live up to the standards set by Downs and Bombeck? I'm additionally confused about the notion of naming streets and buildings and such "prematurely"--has the University of Tennessee named anything for someone who's later been found to have been a criminal or other figure of disrepute?

  • Just silly...
  • Posted by Diogenes on April 13, 2009 at 11:45am EDT
  • No one "needs" an honorary degree. They are given to recognize accomplishment. Winning and election as the first Black American president after a hundred years of racism, Jim Crow Laws, KKK lynchings and the racist fear mongering of the 2008 elections is sufficient. And I cannot think of a real, legitimate reason to deny this honor to President Obama. However, I can imagine a lot of partisan reason to deny our President this honor. Did they run out of certificates? Are they having a hard time erasing the name "Sarah Palin" from the last one? This is pure, transparent, right wing partisan posturing or worse. ASU will lose in the end for their mishandling of this event. Pesident Obama is the bigger man and probably not cancel his appearance, though he has every right ot after this bigoted snub.

  • Local Ties
  • Posted by AZ Native , HR Director at Arizona Wetern College on April 13, 2009 at 12:00pm EDT
  • ASU bungled the Obama issue, but Bombeck and Downs should not be treated dismissively by posters. They both lived in the Phoenix metro area, were generous with their time and talents, and enriched the lives of Arizonans as a result.

  • Obama degree at Arizona State
  • Posted by Alberta academic , Music at University of Alberta on April 13, 2009 at 1:15pm EDT
  • The question raised by the ASU Obama situation probably should be, "Should serving politicians even be considered for honorary degree status while they are in positions of influence that have the potential of directly or indirectly affecting an institution's welfare?"  As I recall, here at University of Alberta, no serving political figure can be considered for an honorary degree until 6 months following completion of their term of office in a city, province or country's government, since all three bodies are involved in the funding of public institutions.  

  • Posted by Not so proud PA Native on April 14, 2009 at 12:30am EDT
  • Penn State and veterans...

    "...the portrayal of the student as a veteran may be viewed by some as unfairly stereotyping members of this important constituency..." Once again, veterans are viewed as unstable, and that would be the best description...

    I contend anyone who views the video will have no choice but to stereotype, since the illustration only highlights one veteran. What about the Penn State veterans who have some of the highest GPAs on campus, or those that volunteer? Where is their BALANCED video???

    How about those who assist their peers in study groups and in working through traumatic events, who routinely help others get help? Do they not deserve to be held up as examples rather than liabilities?

    Wow! I am very ashamed of Lionland for this cowardly portrayal!