Search News


Browse Archives

News

College Counselors for All

April 16, 2009

Share This Story

FREE Daily News Alerts

Advertisement

Students who need the most help planning for either college or a career after high school often do not receive it. Virginia Community College System officials, however, believe they have found a way to assist these students, who are sometimes overlooked by their guidance counselors in favor of their gifted or at-risk peers. Their method? Meet these students where they are, right in the halls of their high schools.

For four years, the system has employed “career coaches” who are based on-site at a number of the state’s public high schools. In 2005, the program had 11 coaches in 13 schools. Now there are about 110 coaches in more than 140 schools, serving about 40 percent of the state’s secondary students.

The program is Virginia’s answer to President Obama’s call for every American to have at least one year of postsecondary education, whether it is temporary skills training or the first step on the way to a college degree. The program also promises to boost the number Virginians who seek some sort of further education, and it is showing early signs of success at the community college level.

The coaches work one-on-one with students to set career goals and create an academic road map to help them get where they want to be. Free from having to resolve the scheduling conflicts and disciplinary issues that dominate the professional lives of many high school counselors, the coaches operate differently from the guidance counselors, with whom they work.

Elizabeth Creamer, the system's director of Postsecondary Perkins/Tech Prep, compared the coaches to executive headhunters who help career professionals find positions. She argued that, since they come from the postsecondary world, they have a wealth of resources that most high school guidance counselors do not, and can be a better advocate for their students.

The secondary role of these coaches shifts according to the needs of their local high schools. Sometimes, Creamer noted, they will help students and parents figure out the financial aid system, or give pointers on how to strengthen a résumé. At other times, she added that they will host career fairs and even offer college placement testing at their high school.

Even though the coaches work for the community college system, they are not simply advocates promoting their two-year institutions. Creamer said they make sure students are aware of the wide array of postsecondary options they have, from career and technical credentialing to the state's four-year institutions.

Community college enrollments, however, grew 7 percentage points more last academic year out of high schools that have coaches than from those that do not. Though not the original intent of the program, Virginia officials say it is a great side effect. The system currently only has numbers for community college enrollment growth, but will track growth in four-year college-going rates beginning next year.

Elizabeth Whiston-Dean, a career coach at Pulaski County Senior High School who works for New River Community College, said she was afraid, going into her position last year, that she would simply be seen as a promoter for her two-year institution. But she said her students, their parents and the high school’s administration have not seen it that way.

“I tell students up front that I don’t work for the high school and that I work for the community college,” said Whiston-Dean, a former high school guidance counselor herself. “I don’t work on commission. I do my job based on what’s best for the student. I’m here to reach students who didn’t think they were college material find their way. This is really a significant service from the community college with no strings attached no matter the student’s choice.”

Whiston-Dean believes that it is especially important for the program to reach out to students in rural parts of the state, such as southwestern Virginia, where access to higher education is limited. Her high school has even taken extra steps to ensure that her services are well promoted among the student body.

Although most career coaches give roving presentations about their services before classes in their high schools, Whiston-Dean noted that her institution has promoted them in other ways. She said some English instructors, for example, have assigned writing projects about possible careers that make it easier for these students to start a dialogue about their goals. She noted that most juniors and seniors actively seek her out, and she hopes that these other methods of promotion will help underclassmen do the same when they begin thinking about life after graduation.

Nicole Walker, career coach at Booker T. Washington and Bayside High Schools, who works for Tidewater Community College, said her schools have a formal referral process by which some instructors or counselors can suggest that certain students see her if it is well-known that they do not have any post-secondary plans. Sometimes, she said, it is just a matter of showing qualified students that college is an option for them.

“Just recently, I had a student come back to see me after two years,” Walker said. “She wasn’t planning on doing anything after graduation. Her parents are factory workers and weren’t college educated. They were just happy to have her graduate from high school. Even though she had a great GPA, she just didn’t think about college at all. She came to some meetings with me and now, I hear, she’s at [the College of] William and Mary. That doesn’t say anything about the guidance counselors here. They were happy to help. But I actually had the time to dig deep and help her out.”

Jasmine Philip, career coach at Petersburg High School who works for John Tyler Community College, echoed a similar sentiment. Contrary to popular belief, she said, today’s students are not apathetic about college and their futures, they are just uninformed.

“What I find in these students is that they are seeking information,” Philip said. “They don’t know that they need some kind of post-secondary education. They often don’t have parents or siblings that have gone through the higher education system, so they’re just unaware. As a result, I’m bombarded by students on a daily basis.”

Virginia’s “career coaches” program will cost about $1.8 million this year, though most of this is covered by federal and state grants, including funds from the Workforce Investment Act, the Perkins Act and the Department of Education's Gaining Early Awareness and Readiness for Undergraduate Programs. Though Creamer said it was never the goal of the state to have these coaches at every public high school, she noted more will almost certainly be added in the future. In addition, she noted that the program is currently working on ways to track the success of its students as they enter either postsecondary training or education to see the extent to which their methods are working.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Matching Jobs

Comments on College Counselors for All

  • Program evaluation?
  • Posted by Libby , Student at Harris School of Public Policy on April 16, 2009 at 12:15pm EDT
  • Does anyone know of a program evaluation or social experiment that's been done on offering college counseling to high school students? I'm doing an assignment and I want to know what impact college counseling alone has on college-going rates, but I wasn't able to find any papers on this particular topic.

  • Coaching and Mentorship
  • Posted by Daniel Bennett , Administrative Director at Center for College Affordability and Productivity on April 16, 2009 at 1:15pm EDT
  • There is a growing non-profit organization called Strive for College that offers a similar service to mentor qualified high school students in low-income areas. It is comprised of an all volunteer workforce of college students who mentor high school students through the college selection, admission and financial aid processes.

    Organizations such as Strive and the outreach in Virginia appear to be promising in improving access to college. Policy makers should consider these type of programs if they hope to improve access, as the problem with is much deeper than funding. Simply increasing educational spending and federal financial aid will most likely prove ineffective in improving access if we don't get to the root of the problem - the lack of available information and assistance for first generation college-bound students.

  • Not New
  • Posted on April 16, 2009 at 4:45pm EDT
  • These 'coaches' and their intent sounds similar to TRIO programs.

  • hmm...
  • Posted by Alex Herzoh , Dean of Students at College of Eastern Utah on April 16, 2009 at 4:45pm EDT
  • The author of the article writes:

    “The program is Virginia’s answer to President Obama’s call for every American to have at least one year of postsecondary education, whether it is temporary skills training or the first step on the way to a college degree.”

    How is this an answer to President Obama’s call when the program started in 2005?
    It should have been written as: The program is an example of how to fulfill the call President Obama made…

  • Discipline problems?
  • Posted by Kristinschoolcounselor , School Counselor at New Athens on April 17, 2009 at 1:00pm EDT
  • I am a full time high school counselor in Illinois and I meet with every single student on my case load at least twice a year. We spend a week working on Career plans and career goals at least twice in their high school careers.

    While I believe that it is a travesty that I do spend my time with scheduling, it is conducted in a manner to promote future career goals and the paths to make those first steps towards an occupation.

    I do not deal with discipline and I refuse too...that is not how we are trained. I do several career activities and seminars throughout the year with all students regardless of their socioeconomic, "gifted," or "at-risk" status. This is the basis of the American School Counselor Association and National Association for College Admission Counseling ethics, we serve all of our students.

    Now, if we wanted to change the time and money I spend dealing with testing, we should reevaulate the high stakes testing that seem to be even more prevelant in this President's administration. I would be more than happy to spend more time with students in groups than on testing them multiple times in a school year. I would also enjoy spending more of this money on dual credit classes for my students.

  • Counseling and coaching
  • Posted by Isaura Alvarado , Counseling Program at University of Puerto Rico on April 18, 2009 at 12:00pm EDT
  • Are they counselors or coaches? I think the title should be Coaching for all or Coaching for everyone or Coaching high school students. See any difference?

    Isaura