Quick Takes

May 15, 2009

College Board Puts Off Plan for New Test for 8th Graders

The College Board is postponing plans to introduce a standardized test for eighth graders -- a test that the board said would promote rigor in high school and that critics said wasn't justified educationally but was just a money-making tool for the organization. The College Board announced plans for the new exam -- ReadiStep -- in October. Word that the test has been put off -- due to the economy -- surfaced Thursday when The Big Money, a division of Slate, published a highly critical article about the various ways that the College Board makes what the article called "gobstopping amounts of money" off of students. The article cited ReadiStep's launch as another way to make money, and the online magazine corrected that assertion after being informed by the College Board that it had decided to postpone the new test.

Early Indications on State Use of Education Stimulus Funds

Most states that have already decided how to allocate the education funds they're receiving from the federal stimulus package are directing the bulk of the money to elementary and secondary education, according to an analysis of 13 states by the New America Foundation. The group's analysis, which is based on applications that the Education Department has already approved for how states plan to use the State Fiscal Stabilization Fund, largely mirrors the (somewhat diminished) expectations of college officials that the recovery package would totally bail them out of financial trouble. New America's analysis shows that while states such as Oregon and Georgia will use significant portions of their stabilization funds on higher education, several others are planning to spend virtually every penny on K-12.

Amid Hiring Controversy, Provost at North Carolina State Quits

Larry Nielsen has resigned as provost of North Carolina State University, saying that a controversy over his hiring of the former governor's wife was making it impossible for him to do his job, The Raleigh News & Observer reported. Many have been critical not only of the hiring of Mary Easley to coordinate some special events for the university, but also her salary -- $850,000 over five years -- at a time of budget constraints. North Carolina State officials have consistently defended the hire as completely legal and legitimate, but another article in the News & Observer noted that Nielsen won his job (after serving in the position on an interim basis) after he hired Easley.

Why a Reality TV Show Is Seeking Professors

A few weeks back, several bloggers commented on reports that "Wife Swap," an ABC reality show in which the wives of two families are switched for a week, was seeking philosophers. Kieran Healy wondered which of two ways the show might go: "airy-fairy life of the mind vs huntin’ shootin’ fishin’ " or a contrast of philosophical beliefs, such as "Modal Realists vs Phenomenologists ('I thought you said all the beer was in the effing fridge'); Rawlsians vs Libertarians; or John Emerson goes to live with John Hawthorne." ABC was quiet at the time the rumors appeared, but the network now confirms that it is looking for philosophers -- and will pay $20,000 to those selected. Danielle Gervais, casting producer for the show, said in an interview said that "we thought it would be interesting to find parents who are philosophical" and who bring their philosophical outlook into their role as parents. How might that be evident? Gervais said philosopher parents might teach young children that "we don't believe in things like the tooth fairy" and would encourage children to "really question things" and to "ponder deep things." Gervais said she wasn't sure if the network would swap the wives in two philosophy couples or swap the wife of a philosophy duo with the wife of a non-philosophy duo. But the network wants to have couples where both spouses are philosophers and have similar approaches to raising their children. Several faculty couples have already applied, but interviewing is still going on and more candidates are welcome.

Did Lenders Get Education Dept. Approval for Windfall Profits?

During the Bush Administration, the Education Department signaled approval for some lender policies that then-Education Secretary Margaret Spellings halted in 2007, according to an investigation by the New America Foundation's Higher Ed Watch blog. The apparent inconsistency comes to light from Higher Ed watch comparing program review reports issued by the department, which suggest approval for policies that Spellings and others derided as providing excessive profits to nonprofit lenders.

Simon Study Abroad Bill Included in House Legislation

The Foreign Relations Authorization Act, introduced Thursday by Rep. Howard L. Berman (D-Cal.), chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, includes a bill of great importance in the study abroad field. The Senator Paul Simon Study Abroad Foundation Act aims to quadruple study abroad participation to one million, and diversify study abroad in terms of who participates and where they go. The Simon bill was introduced in the U.S. Senate in February.

Cambridge Students Rewrite Grace

Students at Newnham College, part of the University of Cambridge, have rewritten a Latin Grace said before the weekly formal meals where they dine together, and more than a few eyebrows have been raised as a result, The Times of London reported. According to the Times, the prayer has been said as: “Benedic nobis Domine Deus et his donis quae de liberalitate tua sumpturi sumus per Jesum Christum Dominum nostrum. Amen.” (Translation: “Bless us Lord God and bless these gifts which by your generosity we are about to eat, through Jesus Christ our Lord, Amen.") The new version, prepared to be more inclusive of students from many faiths, is as follows: “Pro cibo inter esurientes, pro comitate inter desolatos, pro pace inter bellantes, gratias agimus." (The translation: “For food in a hungry world, for companionship in a world of loneliness, for peace in an age of violence, we give thanks.") Mary Beard, a Cambridge classics professor who blogs for the Times, has published a critique of the new language. Beard writes that "the undergraduates' rewrite was a classic case of disguising a load of well meaning platitudes in some posh dead language, which was actually an insult to that dead language."

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

Philosophers shoveling snow, in The Duck of Minerva.... Dual authors in anthropology, in Savage Minds....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • It is a money-making scheme
  • Posted by CC Prof on May 15, 2009 at 8:30am EDT
  • The short piece on another "educational" test concluded with the following:

    "The article cited ReadiStep's launch as another way to make money, and the online magazine corrected that assertion after being informed by the College Board that it had decided to postpone the new test."

    The article from the online magazine, "The Big Money," did not deny its assertion that this test was another way to make money. It corrected its assertion about the launch of the test. The launch of the test and the motive for launching the test are two different things.

    In my opinion, the article in question was correct about the motive. These tests are money-making schemes and they exist throughout our educational system. Money flows from the masses to the multitude of officers at corporations, non-profits, colleges, etc. and they pay themselves quite well. We never had trickle-down economics. We have trickle-up economics.

  • Corruption and Higher Education
  • Posted by CC Prof on May 15, 2009 at 8:45am EDT
  • With tight budgets everywhere there couldn't be a better time to expose the corruption in higher education. The corruption at NC State is just one example of the goings on all over the country. The real corruption in higher ed is that cushy administrative positions have increased dramatically over the last three decades. This increase in high-paying positions has led to a decrease in full-time faculty and an increase in part-time faculty.

    This is not a problem of funding in general because, even with the decreases in state aid, colleges have managed to increase tuition. The real problem is in the distribution of the funds. There is a growing inequality between the administrators and the faculty in terms of pay just as there is a growing inequality in society between the corporate officers and the front-line workers.

    With tight budgets everywhere, it is an excellent time to pressure administrations to get rid of these cushy positions that only exist to funnel large sums of funny to friends, politicians, family members, etc. There are many legitimate administrative positions, and they are necessary for the operation of colleges. However, there are too many administrative positions that are unnecessary. These positions need to be eliminated and part-time faculty positions converted to full-time.

  • Latin! Wow!
  • Posted by Libertarian on May 15, 2009 at 9:30am EDT
  • That students anywhere (except perhaps the Vatican) know enough Latin to use it creatively is awesome. Looking at our colleges, they'd be more likely to pray in Pig Latin than the language of Cicero!

  • Wife Swap
  • Posted by Searching Professor on May 15, 2009 at 10:15am EDT
  • Wow, I can think of some hot philosopher babes I want to swap my wife for! And get paid $20K in the process, woo hoo!!! Where do I sign up?

  • Dead language
  • Posted by Phil on May 15, 2009 at 11:00am EDT
  • 'Beard writes that "the undergraduates' rewrite was a classic case of disguising a load of well meaning platitudes in some posh dead language, which was actually an insult to that dead language."'

    As opposed to disguising religious dogma in a posh dead language? Beard must know that the medieval church insisted on using Latin to keep the hoi polloi in ignorance and awe. Seems like a classic case of academic condescension.