Quick Takes

August 3, 2009

Illinois Panel Wants Trustees Out, Not Administrators

The state panel studying a scandal in which trustees and others sought admission for politically connected applicants is calling for the ouster of all gubernatorial appointed trustees, but is not seeking the ouster of top administrators who were involved, the Chicago Tribune reported. At the same time, the final report being prepared by the panel will include harsh evaluations of President B. Joseph White and the Urbana-Champaign Chancellor Richard Herman, which could be used by trustees in the future to take action against them. The university is not commenting until the release of the final report.

Hawaii Suspends Football Coach for 'Faggot' Comments

The University of Hawaii at Manoa has suspended Greg McMackin, head football coach, without pay for 30 days, following his use of the term "faggot" multiple times during a news conference last week. McMackin told the university he would work as a volunteer during this period so his action wouldn't hurt the football team. McMackin has also agreed to participate in activities designed to promote an inclusive campus environment, including making a public service announcement about the way words can hurt people. In the university's announcement about the situation, Virginia S. Hinshaw, chancellor at Manoa, said: “We all recognize that yesterday Coach McMackin made a serious mistake that has hurt many people and brought negative attention to our state and our university. He is clearly remorseful -- as well he should be. This has been a painful experience for all involved, but we must now consider actions that will help everyone learn from this very negative event and improve for the future." The comments came during a briefing for reporters who cover the Western Athletic Conference. The Idaho Statesman reported that McMackin used "faggot" three times in reference to a pre-game ritual used by the University of Notre Dame, asking reporters not to use the word after he used it, and then returning to apologize for using it. A recording of the comments may be found here.

Cheating Scandal Uncovered at Texas-Brownsville

Authorities last year uncovered a major cheating scandal at the University of Texas at Brownsville--Texas Southmost College in which employees, some of them students, helped other students obtain test answers for themselves or give or sell them to others, The Brownsville Herald reported. The cheating involved gaining access to the Blackboard system used by faculty members for tests and grading, among other uses. The university was vague on how it punished students, saying that university procedures were followed (which would have involved an F for students in courses in which they were found to have cheated). Twenty people -- 6 employees and 14 students -- were involved. The university considered, but decided against, pressing criminal charges. Juliet V. Garcia, president of the university, released a statement to the Herald on why she favored internal handling of the matter. "It’s the job of institutions of higher education to preserve and honor academic integrity. Yes, academic dishonesty is a challenge that all educators must be prepared to handle," she said. "The policies and procedures in place at the university provide the means for the campus to investigate and make informed decisions on courses of action appropriate for each case."

Arizona State U. Details Plans for 3-Year Institutions

Arizona State University hopes to create a set of lower-priced, undergraduate colleges around the state aimed at commuters and offering the option of three-year degrees, The Arizona Republic reported. University officials detailed their plans -- which they will present to the Arizona Board of Regents Thursday, along with proposals from other universities in the state -- for from 5 to 15 campuses that would offer degrees in a small number of high-demand fields such as education, criminology, and communications. Tuition would be set at the amount of the maximum Pell Grant, Arizona State officials told the Republic, with startup costs for the first campus, envisioned for suburban Phoenix, estimated at $4.5 million to $6 million. Arizona is considering numerous options for cutting what students pay for higher education, including letting more students go to community colleges for three years and enrolling at costlier universities only for the fourth year.

Boston U. Student Ordered to Pay $675K for Downloading

A federal jury on Friday ordered Joel Tenenbaum, a Boston University graduate student, to pay $675,000 to four music labels for downloading and sharing music online, The Boston Globe reported. Tenenbaum never denied sharing the music online and the judge ruled that his admission of doing so required a verdict in favor of the music companies, leaving the main question to be the size of damages (which could have been much greater). While record companies have threatened legal action many times over the downloading issue, many times focusing on colleges and their students, this is only the second case against an individual to have gone to trial.

Hefty Settlement for L.A. Community College Chancellor

Last month, Marshall Drummond somewhat mysteriously left the chancellorship of the Los Angeles Community College District, announcing that he and the board had mutually agreed on the move. Drummond was in his second tenure in the job, having left in 2004 to lead the statewide community college system, but returning in 2007 to what he called the job he was really drawn to. It's still not clear why he left, but the Los Angeles Times reported on his settlement: $428,750 (over 19 months) and lifetime health insurance.

NJIT and Alumni Group Face Off in Court

The New Jersey Institute of Technology and its alumni association will be in court this month in a dispute over the use of the institution's name, the Associated Press reported. The two entities have been fighting since 2001, when the university tore down an alumni center to build a new student center. In 2008, NJIT told the association that it was being replaced with a new group, and that led the alumni to sue.

Conflict of Interest Charged and Denied at Old Dominion

Old Dominion University officials are denying any conflict of interest in hiring a state legislator -- whose amendment created the Center for Teacher Quality and Educational Leadership at the university -- to run it, The Virginian-Pilot reported. The newspaper, which reported on the situation, prompting criticism of the hire, said that university leaders said the lawmaker was hired on the basis of his qualifications, not his connections.

European Universities Consider Statement on Academic Freedom

European academic leaders are considering adopting a formal statement on academic freedom, with the idea that professors would benefit from an accepted statement of rights in the way American academics cite the statement of the American Association of University Professors, The Times Higher reported. Among the proposals: Faculty members should have the power to select vice chancellors (those who lead universities).

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

Philosophers shoveling snow, in The Duck of Minerva.... Dual authors in anthropology, in Savage Minds....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • Not fired?
  • Posted by Adam , English instructor on August 3, 2009 at 2:30pm EDT
  • "The University of Hawaii at Manoa has suspended Greg McMackin, head football coach, without pay for 30 days, following his use of the term 'faggot' multiple times during a news conference last week."

    While that is a not an insubstantial penalty, why is that coach still welcome on campus? Coaches get fired often for merely not winning games. McMackin used a pejorative that means "gay people should burn like a bundle of sticks" -- the strongest homophobic slur. Fire him.

  • Academic freedom
  • Posted by DFS on August 3, 2009 at 4:00pm EDT
  • To quote from the UK report,

    "Tenure was abolished in the UK by the Education Reform Act 1988 ....

    Despite supporting the idea of a statement of legally binding principles of academic freedom, Professor Fuller said the definition was 'too defensive" and should also include students.

    'If you put too much stress on expertise, it becomes very easy to censor academics[.]'"

    There's your nutshell. And, I emphasize 'nut.'

  • Not fired?
  • Posted by Allard , Professor of Philosophy on August 3, 2009 at 5:30pm EDT
  • Adam should do a bit of etymological digging. 'Faggot,' used as a rude epithet for gay males does not mean 'someone fit for burning like a bundle of sticks.' It most likely derives, via a number of steps, from a 16th C contemptuous term for a woman. It appeared in US slang in the early 20th C. 

    Those who use it today are probably ignorant of its meaning as a 'bundle of sticks,' let alone a 'bundle of sticks used to burn heretics.' In short, they're likely to be entirely unaware of either of its senses, and know only that it's a term of insult. 

    See http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=faggot

  • Once again political correctness as tyranny
  • Posted by Dr. Anonymous on August 4, 2009 at 5:00am EDT
  • Allard is right and Adam is wrong. "Faggot," like "queer," is a modest, quite moderate term of abuse. The homosexual lobby is happy to use the term "queer," as in Queer Studies and Queer Scholarship. There is no justifiable reason why we academics as a whole should be legislated to by a minority group and allow it to choose which terms are acceptable and which ones not. The poor coach really did nothing wrong, except being politically incorrect. He shouldn't have been censured at all. We have academic freedom and freedom of speech in this country. Let's use them!

  • Make the suspension stick
  • Posted by Dave , Emeritus at ASU on August 4, 2009 at 5:00am EDT
  • The Hawaii coach should not be allowed to work voluntarily while he is suspended. The point of the suspension is not merely the loss of income. He needs to be away from coaching for awhile.