Quick Takes

August 27, 2009

Ill. Governor Lets 2 Trustees Stay, Despite Vow to Fire Them

Gov. Pat Quinn of Illinois reversed course on Wednesday, allowing two University of Illinois trustees to stay on its board even though he had vowed to fire any board members who did not resign in the wake of an admissions scandal at the university, the Chicago Tribune reported. All but two trustees had resigned since Quinn and others called for their resignations in the scandal involving political patronage in admissions, which stemmed from reporting by the Tribune, but two board members had threatened to sue the state if they were forced from their jobs. In a speech Wednesday, Quinn said he thought the two trustees should go but said he didn't want to open the state to legal vulnerability. The newspaper reported that other trustees who had quit in response to Quinn's vow, from which he has now backed down, were now wondering if they had made the right decision.

VA Ends Gulf War Research Pact With U. of Texas Medical Center

The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs exercised the nuclear option in its continuing dispute with the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas, opting out of its five-year, $75 million contract for Gulf War syndrome research after just two years. The V.A. cited "persistent noncompliance and numerous performance deficiencies" as reasons for canceling its agreement, several weeks after it issued a highly critical audit focused on one leading researcher at the U.T. center. Despite the audit's findings, the university issued a response expressing surprise at the agency's action and saying it "strongly" disagreed with its conclusions.

Paul Quinn College Sues Southern Accreditor

As threatened, Paul Quinn College sued the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools late Tuesday, the Dallas Morning News reported. The move came after the regional accrediting association's Commission on Colleges denied the Dallas college's appeal of its decision in June not to renew Paul Quinn's accreditation. Paul Quinn's lawsuit alleges that the accreditor violated its due process rights.

Brigham Young University-Hawaii Punished by NCAA

Brigham Young University at Hawaii has been penalized by the Division II Committee on Infractions for violating four sets of National Collegiate Athletic Association rules. The committee report, released Wednesday, notes that the institution allowed eight transfer athletes to compete before they were academically eligible. Division II rules mandate that transfer athletes have completed at least six credit hours in the semester before entering a new institution. Secondly, on four separate occasions, the institution violated a NCAA rule that requires all athletes to have selected an academic concentration before their third year. Thirdly, the university allowed its head tennis coach to oversee the completion of amateurism and eligibility forms for international athletes -- a clear conflict of interest as the NCAA considers this a responsibility of the compliance officer. Finally, the university let three athletes practice, play and travel with their respective teams before they were cleared by the NCAA Eligibility Center. The committee has placed the institution on three years of probation for "failing to monitor" its athletics program.

Report Urges California to Follow Other States in Easing Student Transfer

California must adopt a more standardized statewide system of student transfer if it is to produce enough college graduates to fill its work force, says a new report, which points to structures in other states as models. The report, which was published by the Institute for Higher Education Leadership & Policy at California State University at Sacramento and reported on by the Los Angeles Times, contains a series of recommendations, based on an examination of policies in Arizona, Florida, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Texas and Washington, designed to ease the transfer of students from the state's decentralized community college system to public four-year institutions in California.

No Budweiser Ads for Badger Football Fans

The University of Wisconsin at Madison has ended sponsorship agreements with two major brewing companies after a campus panel recommended that banning beer ads from football broadcasts would help the fight against binge drinking, the Associated Press reported. The deals with MillerCoors and Anheuser-Busch InBev had brought the university $425,000 a year, and Badger sports officials had vigorously argued for sustaining the agreements (and the revenues). But Wisconsin's new chancellor, Biddy Martin, backed the recommendation of a committee seeking ways to reduce campus drinking. "It hurts the athletic department financially but they are stepping up and taking one for the team," Vince Sweeney, Madison's vice chancellor for university relations, told the A.P. "This was an approach that people felt would have a positive impact."

Student 'Exam Howlers'

Britain's Times Higher asked readers for "exam howlers" and received some great entries. There is the student who noted the way the French resistance movement in World War II used the Internet, the student who thought Martin Luther and Martin Luther King Jr. were the same individual (leading a very long and very influential life), and many others.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

Teaching lecture courses, in Tenured Radical.... The profit motive in education, in Eduwonk....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • Logic of argument
  • Posted by bevo on August 27, 2009 at 8:15am EDT
  • Let's follow Wisconsin's decision to ban breweries as advertisers....

    A group of students want to get drunk. Really drunk. So drunk, they cannot possibly remember what they did the night before.

    Thankfully for these students, they will have no idea how to accomplish this feat because, while attending a Wisconsin football game, they did not see any advertisements for beer.

    OR

    A group students take a break from their studies to attend a football game. They promise each other that they will resume their studies at the conclusion of the game. Because of Wisconsin's decision to ban beer advertising, these students will decide to honor their pre-game commitment. Without this ban, these students will surely get smashed.

    So, let's raise a cold, frosty one to salute the Wisconsin leadership's failure to stand up to the neo-temperance movement. Let's raise another cold, frosty one to salute the Wisconsin leadership's inability to see past this argument that lacks any semblance of logic. Let's raise a final cold, frosty one to salute the Wisconsin leadership's desire to protect all those microbreweries that line the UW campus from the evil, mean corporate giants.

  • VA cancells Gulf War research contract
  • Posted by PC on August 27, 2009 at 10:00am EDT
  • Reading the executive summary of the report, it seems the source of the problems was the way the VA set up its connection with UTSW. Administrative decisions made at inception by the VA caused the VA a lot of problems and they have decided that they are not required to continue the contract as they set it up and now want out. The sole issue with UTSW appears to be changing the consent so that individual patient information was not shared with the VA.

    This is not apparent from the headlines, which make it sound like UT was the cause of the cancellation.

  • Yeah, this will work
  • Posted by Sarah on August 27, 2009 at 10:30am EDT
  • Has this Biddy person ever been to Wisconsin? Been to a game? Where governors who have tried to raise alcohol taxes were run out of office? Where an abundance of Wisconsin fans aren't even students and alumni and watch the games on tv in BARS?

    What about tailgates? Are they going to ban beer there too?

    This panel needs to study how other universities have helped educate their students on responsible drinking. I'm pretty sure commercials for beer aren't even in the top ten strategies for that anywhere else.

  • Bravo Biddy
  • Posted by Bill on August 27, 2009 at 10:30am EDT
  • This just in: College students like to drink! Regardless of the radio broadcast ads.

    What a strong stand against college drinking. I'm sure this is the same pannel that has come up with many other mostly failed plans to curb drinking at UW. I'm sure the beer ads on the radio braodcast were the main reason kids thought they should crack a cold one. Or maybe it's the bars around the stadium and State St that have people stuffed in them getting their drink on at 8am for the 11am kickoff. It's not like you can go to the student union and have a beer....oh wait, you can, that's right. Students most certainly won't be able to see or hear any ads the next day for NFL broadcasts or watching the stupid reality shows on MTV or whatever station college kids watch these days.

    I don't hear ads for pot on Badger game broadcasts, but I think some students are still smoking dope. I wonder where they got the idea to go after some hippie lettuce if it wasn't on the football, basketball, or hockey broadcast? I don't hear ads for Natti Light, Busch Light, or Milwaukee's Best, but the students are drinking that slop. How did they ever find these brands if they weren't on the broadcast?

    What's next; no more ads for hotdogs and bratwursts to fight student obesity. Will UW please save us from ourselves! Bud Light has the best ads on the radio, but I don't drink the pale yellow water they call beer. In the end, it still comes down to peer pressure and personal choice, not a radio ad.

    I'm guessing the season ticket holders will be paying for this loss of revenue, not the pannel that made this decision.

  • What are we here for?
  • Posted by doqu on August 27, 2009 at 11:15am EDT
  • While previous posts have made the case that college students will drink no matter what, and yes there are other methods to help educate students to about the dangers of binge drinking, they're missing the point. Is revenue and sports popularity more important than setting examples, showing courage to make unpopular decisions, and standing up for what you believe in knowing there will be consequences??? This may be a symbolic gesture, but a very powerful one.
    Congratulations.

  • beer ads
  • Posted by formerccpres on August 27, 2009 at 11:15am EDT
  • It's a problem with the admissions standards. If the university would just admit students who don't care much about drinking alcohol, the problem would likely be solved. Well, we use that solution to improve grade averages, graduation rates, and placement success; why not use it to solve the drinking problem. Reminds me of Lester Maddox, governor of Georgia, who was dealing with terrible riots in the state prisons. His comment was that the problem was with the quality of people who were the inmates.

  • Good move
  • Posted by Frank , director at CBRE on August 27, 2009 at 11:30am EDT
  • If the Athletic Department wants more revenue thay shoud stop scheduling games with Cal Poly, Wofford, Citadel and the like and play somebody known for top football teams. Now the fans wised up and they can't get rid of the tickets for these exhibition games.

    It's time drinking became a minor at Wisconsin instead of a major. This is another step in supporting that overdue change. If you want to talk the talk you have to be willing to put the money where your mouth is. BTW Biddy got her PhD from Wisconsin so she is no newcomer to the area. She just happens to have come from working at another school that puts academics first, Cornell University. Hopefully some of that will rub off on the Wisconsin students.

  • Posted on August 27, 2009 at 12:00pm EDT
  • Most Wisconsin students prefer home grown brews, and you'll find little Coors or Bud in tailgate coolers. This action has all the fingerprints of the usual government lunatic idea that comes from the bureaucrats propensity to make a show of "doing something" -- a show usually more unfit for public consumption than even what Edward Abbey used to call "recycled Rocky Mountain sewer water."

    The state of Wisconsin has a couple of decades of history of placing partisan political shills who can't get jobs elsewhere into management positions in higher education. That educational system has been in a downward spiral ever since the Badger State accepted the parties taking control over their colleges. This Biddy and Vince action scene has all the originality of a bad Hollywood movie script.

  • Small Beer
  • Posted by richard on August 27, 2009 at 2:00pm EDT
  • So, let me get this straight: judging from the majority of responses to the brief piece on the sudden death of beer ads during UW football games, taking the high road would involve continuing to support athletes who 1) aren't old enough to drink, and 2) aren't supposed to drink anyway, in support of the purity of bodily fluids we demand from such vital national heros, by using them to advertise beer. Anything else is a sign that the chancellor is a (presumably leftist) social engineer who hasn't spent enough time in the many brewpubs that line the Madison campus and is just getting political brownie points to use with somebody or another in the future.

    Did I get that right?

    Do me a favor and don't post any complaints about how poorly your students think, all right?

  • To Hell with Drunks and Drunks-to-Be
  • Posted by DFS on August 27, 2009 at 3:30pm EDT
  • And back to you, PC. Of course, you're right. But, what did you expect IHE to say?

    And now back to the drunks. Whoo-Hoo!