Hiding Adjuncts From 'U.S. News'
Related Stories
Everyone knows that adjuncts and graduate assistants do a lot of the teaching these days, right? Well, maybe not everyone.
The American Federation of Teachers on Wednesday posted a blog item asking how it is, given those well documented trends, that magazine rankings give parents the sense that most of the teaching at large universities is done by full-time faculty members. "The majority of top colleges report well over 80 percent of their faculty are full-time and a large number report that well over 90 percent of their faculty are full-time. University of Nebraska-Lincoln even reports that 100 percent of its faculty are full-time," the blog says of institutions in the U.S. News & World Report rankings, a small part of which are based on the percentage of faculty who are full time. "Amazing!"
Further, the blog goes on to note that AFT data suggest that at Nebraska, only 79 percent of the faculty members are full time. How could the university's claim (and many others universities' claims to be almost entirely full time in faculty members) be accurate? the AFT asked.
Inside Higher Ed posed the question to the University of Nebraska and to U.S. News and found that the two have very different interpretations of how to count faculty members -- and that the magazine will let stand Nebraska's decision to exclude all of its adjuncts and claim a faculty make-up it does not in fact have.
Kelly H. Bartling, a spokeswoman for the university, said Nebraska interpreted the U.S. News question on the percentage of full-time faculty to cover only those faculty who are tenured or on the tenure track, and not to include anyone else. She said that the university gave the magazine figures that were "exactly what they've been asking for," and that she believed other universities had similar interpretations, given their high percentages of full-time faculty members. (Given that most research universities don't have many part-time tenure-track or tenured slots, an interpretation like Nebraska's would produce many very high percentages, which is the case in the rankings.)
Robert Morse, who leads the college rankings operation at U.S. News, forwarded a definition sent to colleges showing how to count faculty members. A chart details various groups to include or exclude and, following that, adjuncts are clearly stated as a group that should count.
Asked if the magazine should redo its figures for Nebraska and check others with very high percentages, Morse noted in an e-mail that the share of the total score based on full-time faculty members is small, adding: "We will not change the rankings or go back to each school. The definition is very clear. If Nebraska has adjuncts and they are not reporting them, they are not following the definition -- no matter what they say."
He did note that Nebraska actually didn't report a pure 100 percent figure and that it took rounding to get there -- the university told the magazine in its forms that 11 of its 1,081 faculty members were not full time.
Of course the adjuncts are only part of the teaching work force that is missing from the magazine's rankings. Morse said that graduate student instructors -- who have extensive teaching duties at most research universities -- do not count. As the AFT blog noted: "Another look at Nebraska's data shows that they reported having 1,852 graduate assistants. That is nearly the same number of graduate assistants as all faculty at the University of Nebraska, and we know that graduate employees at research institutions such as Nebraska are carrying more and more of the instructional workload."
In an interview, Lawrence N. Gold, director of higher education at the AFT, said he was bothered by the unwillingness of U.S. News to fix the error and to make sure that the faculty figures are all correct -- and that the union would formally ask the magazine to reconsider. The concern comes at a time when the union has launched a campaign -- called "Just Ask" -- that encourages parents and prospective students to ask colleges about the percentage of courses taught by tenure-track faculty members.
"It seems to me that if U.S. News is putting forth these rankings as an accurate guide for families, if institutions don't properly portray the population of adjuncts, the rankings aren't portraying the situation," Gold said. "By saying that they don't care enough to correct it, they are not putting out accurate information."
Even if the share of the rankings formula devoted to this category is small, Gold noted that the data on faculty make-up are published in each institution's full profile. He said it should be correct, for the same reason the union is urging parents to ask about the issue.
"We think it's awfully important for parents and students to know who is doing the teaching and how those people are treated," he said. "Teachers are the most important factor in any student's success. The overuse and exploitation of contingent faculty is something they should be aware of and take into consideration."
Most Popular
- Viewed
- Past:
- 1 day
- 1 week
- 1 month
- 1 year
Similar Jobs
-
Functional Applications Analyst - Financial System
Chicago, ILThe City Colleges of Chicago (CCC) District 508, is the largest community college system in Illinois and one of the largest in the nation, with 5,800 faculty and staff serving 120,000 students at seven campuses and thirteen satellite sites city-wide.
... -
Marketing Data Analyst
Irvine, CABrandman University
Marketing Data Analyst -
SENIOR LAB TECHNICIAN, BIOLOGY
Mission Viejo, CASENIOR LAB TECHNICIAN, BIOLOGY
Saddleback College
Mission Viejo, CA
Job Opening # 3860/3972
Work Schedule: Monday through Thursday, 11:00 am to 7:30 pmApply By: February 24, 2012
-
Associate Registrar
Cypress, CAASPIRE – BELIEVE – ACHIEVE --We are Trident University International!
Do you want to work in an every changing, fast paced environment, and have a passion for helping people achieve their personal and professional goals? If so then please read on.
-
District Director - PeopleSoft Financial System
Chicago, ILThe City Colleges of Chicago (CCC) District 508, is the largest community college system in Illinois and one of the largest in the nation, with 5,800 faculty and staff serving 120,000 students at seven campuses and thirteen satellite sites city-wide.
... -
CHAIR, DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATION SCIENCES AND DISORDERS
Philadelphia, PACHAIR, DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATION SCIENCES AND DISORDERS
Featured Jobs
-
Manager, Academic Collective Bargaining Administration
09FebYpsilanti, MIThe major responsibilities of this position are to assist with administration of labor agreements and negotiations between Eastern Michigan University (EMU) and the instructional bargaining units representing employees engaged in the delivery and support of academic services; including the Americ
-
Assistant Professor, Mathematics-Tenure Track
09Febchicago heights, ILPrairie State College, an award winning community college located 30 miles south of downtown Chicago, is a richly diverse community college serving over 12,226 credit and non-credit students is seeking a DYNAMIC Professor of Mathematics with a passion for educating a diverse population of studen
... -
Assistant Professor - Nursing
09FebKankakee, ILKankakee Community College is nestled on the banks of the Kankakee River, 60 miles south of Chicago. The college serves approximately 4,200 credit students each semester and is dedicated to the mission of enhancing quality of life through learning.
... -
Chief of Urology at Pennsylvania Hospital
09FebPhiladelphia, PAChief of Urology sought for nation's oldest hospital
-
Assistant or Associate Professor in the Psychology Department
09FebPella, IACENTRAL COLLEGE is a residential liberal arts college dedicated to the education of 1600 undergraduate students. Guided by its ecumenical Christian tradition, the college community engages in vigorous, free, open inquiry in pursuit of academic excellence.
... -
Visiting Assistant Professor of Philosophy (Ancient)
08FebHamilton, NYThe Department of Philosophy at Colgate University invites applications for a one-year position at the rank of Visiting Assistant Professor, beginning fall term 2012.








