Future Docs Are Confused, Too
Related Stories
Struggling to understand the national debate over health care? You're not alone -- your future doctor may well be baffled, too.
A study published in the September issue of Academic Medicine found that nearly half of all medical students believe they have been inadequately educated about the "practice of medicine" -- especially related to medical economics.
“Our patients expect us to understand the system,” said Matthew M. Davis, one of the researchers and an associate professor of pediatrics and internal medicine in the Child Health Evaluation and Research Unit at the University of Michigan's medical school. “If we don’t, that can result in poor patient care. And if we don’t expect doctors to understand the health care system, who is going to?”
The study, by Davis and two colleagues at Michigan, examined tens of thousands of survey responses from medical students about the extent and perceived quality of their training in an array of curricular areas, including clinical care and decision making and the practice of medicine -- with the latter including health care systems, managed care, and practice management, among other areas.
The vast majority of respondents (more than 80 percent across the board during the period, which ran from 2003 to 2007) reported receiving "appropriate" levels of training in the clinical aspects of their education, including such things as diagnosis and management of disease, ethical decision making, pharmacology, and care of patients.
But fewer than 50 percent of medical students said they believed they had received appropriate training in areas related to the profession they are prepping to enter. (Because it is based on a survey, all of the data relate to future doctors' impressions of the education they received, not their actual aptitudes.)
The picture looked a little different when the researchers compared the national sample of students with responses from two individual medical schools, one of which had a "higher intensity" curriculum when it comes to the medical profession, and another that provided less instruction on that set of skills and knowledge.
Students in the former program were significantly likelier than those in the latter to report satisfaction with their level of training on the practice of medicine. And they were three times likelier to report appropriate training in medical economics and health care systems.
"The high-intensity curriculum in health care systems -- which differed from the lower-intensity curriculum both in structure and in class time devoted to the subject -- seems to have translated into a greater sense of appropriate instruction on the subject among graduating students," the authors wrote.
And it did not appear that the additional attention paid to that subject matter distracted students from the more clinical aspects of their medical training: They reported comparable levels of satisfaction with their perceived instruction in clinical areas as their peers did.
"This means that a higher intensity curriculum in health care systems could hold the potential to overcome medical students' perceptions of inadequate training in the practice of medicine and health care systems," without impairing the hugely important clinical aspects of their training, the authors say.
Most Popular
- Viewed
- Past:
- 1 day
- 1 week
- 1 month
- 1 year
Similar Jobs
-
NURSING INSTRUCTOR
Oroville, CA
Butte-Glenn Community College
NURSING INSTRUCTOR
Final Filing Date Monday, March 19, 2012
Classification:Instructor - Full-Time (177) Days
Temporary Member of Academic Staff - Tenure Track possibility Contingent upon availability of continued funding -
Surgical Technology Department Chair
Altamonte Springs, FLCity College, established in 1984, is a non-profit organization that provides higher education including a Bachelor of Science Degree in Business Administration; Associate of Science Degrees in Nursing, Emergency Medical Service, Business, Allied Health, Legal, Broadcasting, and Private Investiga
... -
Part-Time Skills Instructor, Physical Therapy Assistant (#5404)
Conroe, TXRecognized as a "Great College to Work For" for the past three years, the Lone Star College System (LSCS) is one of the fastest growing community college systems in Texas.
... -
Assistant/Associate Professor and Program Coordinator, Addictions Studies/Behavioral Health
University Park, Global -
Assistant/Associate Professor, Addictions Studies/Behavioral Health
University Park, Global -
Post-Doctoral Fellow
Columbia, SCA leader in academe, the University of South Carolina holds the Carnegie Foundation's highest research designation and is known for its pioneering First-Year Student Experience. Campus settings include the coast, mountains and capital city.
Featured Jobs
-
Assistant/Associate/Full Professor-Doctoral Studies-Dreeben School of Education
10FebSan Antonio, TXThe University of the Incarnate Word (UIW) is one of America's two largest Hispanic-serving Catholic institutions.
... -
President of the College
10FebNewberry, SCNewberry College in South Carolina invites applications, nominations, and inquiries as the private institution begins its national search for its 22nd President.
-
Alexander Crombie Humphreys Chair in Economics of Engineering
10FebHoboken, NJThe School of Systems and Enterprises (SSE) at Stevens Institute of Technology is seeking candidates for the Alexander Crombie Humphreys Chair in Economics of Engineering.
-
Chief Diversity Officer
10FebKennesaw, GAKennesaw State University seeks applications and nominations for a noted scholar and national leader to fill the cabinet-level position of Chief Diversity Officer.
-
Science Data Librarian
10FebMiddlebury, VTMiddlebury College, located in Middlebury, Vermont, is a nationally recognized liberal arts institution where the pursuit of knowledge knows no bounds.
-
Manager, Academic Collective Bargaining Administration
09FebYpsilanti, MIThe major responsibilities of this position are to assist with administration of labor agreements and negotiations between Eastern Michigan University (EMU) and the instructional bargaining units representing employees engaged in the delivery and support of academic services; including the Americ








