Search News


Browse Archives

News

Path to Transfer

November 13, 2009

Share This Story

FREE Daily News Alerts

Advertisement

A 15-minute drive in Massachusetts’s Pioneer Valley separates Mount Holyoke College from Holyoke Community College, but sometimes the two institutions can feel worlds apart.

A collaborative transfer program between the two institutions, however, is providing an opportunity for high-achieving and often disadvantaged local community college students to attend not only the prestigious women’s college but also a number of the area’s other selective liberal arts colleges.

The Community College Transfer Initiative at Mount Holyoke began in the fall of 2006 thanks to a $779,000 grant from the Jack Kent Cooke Foundation, which had also given funding to six other highly selective public and private institutions around the country for similar access programs. Mount Holyoke has committed itself to increasing the enrollment of “low- and moderate-income” community college transfers students by 10 students per year through the four years of the grant. The institution also has increased the number of annual community college recruitment visits from 20, mostly in the northeast, to about 40 nationwide.

In its first full year, according to a program evaluation from the Jack Kent Cooke Foundation, Mount Holyoke received 156 transfer applications from community college students and admitted 83 of them. This is up from 107 applications it received the previous year. The next full year, Mount Holyoke received 178 community college transfer applications. The college was unable to provide updated admissions statistics, but officials say the number of community college transfers has increased in the past academic year. Although such numbers might appear small compared to large public universities in many states, these figures are highly unusual for elite private institutions.

Though Mount Holyoke has increased its outreach to community colleges around the country, most of the work it is doing starts at home with nearby Holyoke Community College. Mount Holyoke gave more than $300,000 in its grant funds to help establish the community college’s Pathways Program, an effort at the two-year institution to push “strong, committed, under-represented students” to transfer to selective liberal arts colleges in the area. In this way the program hopes to enroll students not only at Mount Holyoke but also at institutions like Amherst, Smith and Hampshire College by providing them with many academic support services not offered to all students, such as academic and financial aid counseling and special seminars with Mount Holyoke faculty.

Both the community college and Mount Holyoke now have full-time transfer coordinators to help ease the process for interested students. Once students are identified for the program while at Holyoke Community College, they have many chances to interact with students and faculty at Mount Holyoke.

Fifteen students from the community college have the opportunity to take a Math Transition Seminar at Mount Holyoke – a five week, non-credit course that allows the students to get to know the four-year campus and interact with its students and faculty. The course also provides these community college students with a glimpse of what coursework, particularly mathematics related work, will be like at a four-year college. Though Mount Holyoke is a women’s college, this course – like all of the other collaborative efforts between the institutions – is offered to male students as well. The goal is to expose these students to the type of small, liberal arts experience they might also encounter at a nearby co-ed institution.

“For a lot of folks, mathematics is the last thing they’d pick to feel comfortable in a place,” said Charlene Morrow, a professor at Mount Holyoke who teaches the special course to interested community college transfers. “That’s kind of why we chose to offer it to these students. You can feel a lot of empowerment if you understand it. This is about teaching problem solving in mathematics. It’s not meant to be remedial or as a refresher, but to get them to approach mathematics differently.”

Though the course focuses on mathematics, Morrow acknowledges it is also about integrating these students to the foreign environment of Mount Holyoke’s campus.

“We start the course over at the community college for a week to get their minds on mathematics, because they’re already fearful enough about coming over here,” Morrow said. “Once they see that we’re all human and not that different from their current instructors, we bring them over to Mount Holyoke for the final four weeks. They’re in a regular classroom and we usually have a course assistant, who is a Mount Holyoke student. Most of this, however, really is getting them to envision themselves here, walking around the campus. Throughout the class, though it’s not the focus, we also talk about what fears and anxieties they may have about transferring.”

Students from the math seminar also interact with peer mediators from Mount Holyoke’s Frances Perkins Program, a scholarship for non-traditionally aged students who typically have transferred in from a community college.

Karen Crossi, a 33 year-old senior and a peer mentor, successfully transferred to Mount Holyoke from Holyoke Community College because of its Pathways Program.

“Mount Holyoke was never on my radar,” she said. “It always seemed like an impenetrable school that I’d never get into and I never thought I would want to go to. Nobody in my family had ever gone to college and, being in the valley long enough, I knew Mount Holyoke as an elitist place. But, after visiting and meeting others from my background, I understood that Mount Holyoke wasn’t just a place for women who were sculpted from birth to go to a place like this.”

She said she hopes to pass along this message to the Holyoke Community College students who she mentors on campus.

“A lot of students worry that they are unprepared, academically, for a place like this,” Crossi said. “They also worry that their socioeconomic class will be an issue for them to get in. Those two aren’t the case. It’s always more meaningful to hear that from someone who’s walked in your shoes than from someone in an office. It makes it more believable. I can tell them what classes to take at the community college to be more successful here and provide other insight that they won’t get elsewhere.”

Holyoke Community College officials refused to comment for this story despite multiple requests, but a 2007 performance measurement report of the two-year institution by the state indicates that 150 students were served by the program that year. That year, because of the program, 17 students were accepted to Mount Holyoke, 14 to Smith, 2 to Amherst and 1 to Hampshire.

Jane Brown, vice president for enrollment at Mount Holyoke, said the college’s recent initiatives have made the college more community college friendly. She noted that there are about 180 community college transfer students at the college currently, accounting for nearly 8 percent of its student population. About half of those students come from Massachusetts community colleges, and 38 of those are from Holyoke Community College.

“This is a historical effort for us,” Brown said. “We were founded as a college for women of modest means. You sometimes think of Mount Holyoke as being a typical selective New England college. But, if you’re interested in finding the best and brightest women, more of them are now coming from the community college system. … This isn’t really about enrollment. Because so many of the students coming from community college require such enormous financial aid, I wouldn’t look to this population if I just wanted to fill beds.”

Though the grant-funded program at the institution does not have a financial aid component, Brown insists that the college will find a way to fund any student who is accepted. She estimates about 90 percent of the community college transfers the college attracts are eligible for some sort of institutional aid.

Still, the true payoff for Brown and other Mount Holyoke officials is the success these transfer students attain at their institution. Brown noted community college transfers are often over-represented, relative to their percentage of the student population, in the number of those receiving Latin honors at graduation. Community college transfers also graduate in comparable percentages to those students who got their start at Mount Holyoke.

“It’s a way to bridge the divide,” Brown said of the college’s success in attracting two-year transfers. “At least for a lot of the local community college students, they could not imagine themselves at a place like Mount Holyoke, even though we’re just down the road.”

Mount Holyoke is not only admitting more community college transfers -- it also hired one to be its next president. Earlier this month, Lynn Pasquerella was named the college’s new president; she will take office next summer. She graduated from Mount Holyoke in 1980 but transferred in from Quinebaug Valley Community College, in Connecticut.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Matching Jobs

Comments on Path to Transfer

  • Path to Transfer
  • Posted by C. Hurley , Electrical Engineer at n/a on November 13, 2009 at 9:15am EST
  • While the program seems worth while, it also seems like a "jobs program" for administration of the program. The approximately $800K among other things provides for two full time coordinator positions, one at each school. And serveral what seems like "feel good" type seminar transition courses for the admitted students that already should have a good idea of what college is all about after 1 to 2 years of a college experience. All of this without a hint of money in the program for the would be students' tuition and otherwise expenses for continuing education at Mount Holyoke. All of this for an increase of 10 low-income transfer students per year at Mount Holyoke (or approximately 130 at the end of four year program period out of an approximate year class size of 500). My two questions would be: (1) shouldn't the "real" (without the program) incremental cost (over and above the regular student admission) per low-income transfer student admitted for this change in admission policy be near zero with the assumption that the overall year class size remains nearly the same?; (2) who are the real beneficiaries of this program?

  • Posted by Steve on November 13, 2009 at 12:15pm EST
  • This program is an insult to the other students who worked diligently to go to a four year college. These are students who sweated the college preparatory math courses in high school and did well the first time. Why not identify promising high school students for regular admission if you seek to encourage under-represented students?

  • Mount Holyoke & Holyoke Community College
  • Posted by Barbara Turlington on November 13, 2009 at 1:30pm EST
  • Bravo for Mount Holyoke. Clearly they are doing the right things in helping these transfer students to succeed. I hope others will follow their model.

  • MHC's Transition Plan for 2-Year College Students
  • Posted by Susan Shwartz , Assistant Director at Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. on November 13, 2009 at 1:30pm EST
  • As a 1972 alumna of Mount Holyoke, I applaud this program and agree with outgoing President Creighton that it is very much in a tradition of which Mary Lyon would have approved -- that of outreach. During the nineteenth century, Mount Holyoke alumnae created "daughter schools" throughout the U.S. and overseas. During the late 1960s and 1970s, Holyoke was a pioneer with ABC programs for students of color; instituted (if I remember correctly) the "Summermath" programs for middle-school-level students, and created the Frances Perkins students (returning students, usually mature women), who will be instrumental in mediating this program. This program is one more outreach and addresses the "dirty" issue of social class, which has been exacerbated by rising tuition and declining resources, especially during the Great Recession.

    The two comments preceding mine seem to mean well, but in accordance with an outsider's perspective. First, the seminar for the two-year transfer students (we've always had February Freshmen) is not a "feelgood" seminar, but an orientation to what may be a very different culture. In the story, one woman commented that a place like Mount Holyoke seemed inaccessible to her. There's an adaptation. It would be dishonest to assume that there isn't -- just as there is for students from different cultures, different religions and of diverse sexual orientations. It diminishes the seriousness of the enterprise by referring to this as "feelgood."

    The comments about paying for administrators seemed gratuitous. As for financial aid, once these students are accepted, they are Mount Holyoke students and will no doubt be funded out of the same pool of financial aid that supplies the rest of our undergraduates. If Commenter #1 is reducing this to "base respects of thrift," consider that the College will be funding them for a shorter time than the usual four years. It is also not inconceivable that the College could receive additional grants and/or alumnae might be prevailed upon to endow this program.

    To the gentleman who thinks that Mount Holyoke should, instead, recruit students who have worked hard in high school to attend traditional four-year institutions, I can only say that he is definitely missing the point. This program provides further diversity to the student body, in the way that the Frances Perkins scholars do. In addition, it affords opportunity to students who, for one reason or another, were not able to attend a four-year school straight out of high school. For some, it may have been financial reasons, or family reasons; for others, this represents a way of capitalizing on a sudden, later-blooming spurt of intellectual growth. The College is able to accommodate them as well as its traditional demographics (already quite diverse): if it can do so while addressing the issue of sharing privilege, I believe it is Holyoke's duty to do so, and I am very proud that it sees its duty clear.

  • Posted by Zack on November 13, 2009 at 2:00pm EST
  • C. Hurley, it is true that this program funds jobs to administer it. This is typical of many, if not most, foundation-funded programs, since they often impose administrative burdens beyond what staff already in place can reasonably handle. You mention that funds are not being used to cover student tuition expenses and the like. Although I do not know whether this is truly the case (the article doesn't provide enough detail to tell), most of the institutions to which the community college students transfer meet the full financial need of their students. A low-income transfer student might conceivably receive $30,000 or more in institutional grant funds each year. If they enroll for three years, that's well over $100,000 committed by the four-year college, which is a decidedly good deal, and certainly well in excess of 'near zero' expense. I can understand your distaste for the seminar offerings to students who have already attended college courses; however, this presumes that the student experience at a community college and at a residential, four-year liberal arts college is the same. I assure you that it is not. Finally, I am a little confused by your comment about who 'really' benefits from this program. I imagine that the students who were able to transfer to the four-year instutions probably think they benefited, too, don't you?
    Steve, I must disagree with your premise that promising high school students are injured by this program. Institutions like Mount Holyoke have some of the most diverse student bodies of all private US colleges, primarily because they strive to admit excellent students from traditionally underrepresented groups. I can promise you that most students who did very well in high school were admitted to college if they applied, whether at Mount Holyoke or elsewhere. I don't think the few dozen students participating in the program changed this outcome. Further, you seem to assume that students enrolled in community colleges didn't do well the first time around, and didn't work hard to go to college. As the article states, the math seminar is not a remedial course. It is instead geared to transitioning this group of students from a community college environment to a four-year liberal arts college environment. Enrolling at a community college is a choice like any other, that students make per their own unique needs. It doesn't automatically mean that they are unqualified academically.
    So many chips. So many shoulders.

  • Talented community college transfers
  • Posted by Harriette Seiler , Former adjunct at University of Louisville on November 13, 2009 at 10:30pm EST
  • I am a former adjunct instructor who taught 15 yrs at the Univ of Louisville. One of the brightest and most conscientious students I ever taught was a transfer from a local community college. I am sure she slugged it out and succeeded in the tough high school courses mentioned in a comment above, but her family/life/economic situation kept her from continuing her education at that time. After a few years out of school, she returned to earn her Associate's degree at the community college. At about age 30, she entered the university and excelled through to her bachelor's, then on to Medical School. Because an admissions team took a chance on that "transfer" student, there is a wonderful physician out there somewhere today.

    Perhaps money was the barrier. The US Dept of Education has found that "high academic achievers from low-income families are five times less likely to attend college than their more economically advantaged peers" (intro to GEAR-UP program, n.d.).

    So I applaud Mount Holyoke for facilitating the transfer of students with potential for success.

  • Posted by Wick Sloane on November 15, 2009 at 9:15am EST
  • Mount Holyoke often visits the community college where I work. What I particularly like is that Mount Holyoke travels with admissions officers from Smith and Wellesley, which also seek women whose lives didn't lead to college earlier in life. All small schools have their own character and none are a fit for everyone. Traveling with several highly selective women's schools works very well because the community college students get a view of three places. The message to the students is, "We believe in supporting your education. If one of us is not a fit, here are two others."