Quick Takes

December 1, 2009

La Salle Settles Brain Injury Lawsuit for $7.5 Million

La Salle University has agreed to pay $7.5 million to cover the lifetime costs of caring for a former football player who suffered brain trauma in a 2005 game, the Associated Press reported. The family of Preston Plevretes had sued the Philadelphia-area university, alleging that it allowed him to play even though he had endured a concussion in a practice weeks earlier; the university had argued that the brain injury resulted entirely from the second blow. The settlement, which did not include any admission of wrongdoing by La Salle, came on the day a trial was to begin in the case. Brain injuries from football have been the focus of increasing attention this fall, in the wake of a National Football League-sponsored study that suggests a greater risk at all playing levels than previously acknowledged. La Salle officials said in a statement Monday that "[f]rom the time of Preston’s injury, the university community, led by those who know Preston and his family, have been hoping and praying for his recovery. That hasn’t changed."

Quantity vs. Quality (of Papers) and Econ Profs

A new study examines an unusual situation within economics: Writing more papers can be linked with higher salaries for professors but also with lower reputations. Writing about the work, Daniel Hamermesh of the University of Texas at Austin, and co-author of the study, says: "The question is why writing more (essentially ignored) papers has opposite effects on reputation and salary? Are university administrators ignorant, rewarding something visible that in fact reduces the scholar’s quality, as measured by his/her colleagues? We tested lots of explanations for the anomaly, but none described it well." The paper was published by the National Bureau for Economic Research and the other author is Gerard Pfann of Maastricht University.

Pittsburgh Students Protest Tax Plan

About 150 students who said that they had more than 10,000 student signatures on petitions jammed a City Council meeting in Pittsburgh Monday, opposing a plan by Mayor Luke Ravenstahl to add a 1 percent tax on tuition, The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported. The mayor says that the funds are needed for city services, while students and colleges say it is an inappropriate way to raise money. Many of the students said that they were bothered by the tax plan's implication that students hurt the city. Rotimi M. Abimbola, student president at Carnegie Mellon University, said: "We really, really need to dispel this myth that students are a burden to the city." Many colleges nationwide are watching the debate in Pittsburgh with concern that the tax idea, if enacted, will spread.

Rutgers Settles Suit by 4 Minority Groundskeepers

Rutgers University, while denying wrongdoing, has settled a lawsuit by four groundskeepers -- three of them black and one a Latino -- who charged that they were denied promotions because of racial discrimination, The Star-Ledger reported. Each plaintiff will receive $71,875, and their lawyers will receive a total of $300,000 in legal fees. Both sides had agreed not to publicize the settlement, but the newspaper obtained it under an open records request.

State Senator, 5 Others Sue Southern Maine for Age Bias

Six former student affairs officials are suing the University of Southern Maine, charging that they lost employment there because of age bias, The Portland Press Herald reported. The university recently reorganized many student services functions, and many jobs were shifted, with those in old jobs allowed to re-apply for the new positions. Those suing, all over 50, say that their age was a factor in their not being hired. The university denies any discrimination. An unusual factor in the suit: One of the plaintiffs is a state senator. who formerly was director of career services and professional life development.

The Influence and Values of Harvard's Admissions Dean

A Boston Globe article today on William Fitzsimmons, Harvard University's admissions dean, credits him with encouraging the university to be much more ambitious about recruiting and enrolling students who didn't grow up with much money or the expectation of going to a place like Harvard. The article notes that Fitzsimmons is the son of a local gas station owner and that, as he set his sights on Harvard as a youth, "the nuns at his Catholic high school refused to write him recommendations, proclaiming the college full of atheists, communists, and rich snobs."

Lack of Autonomy Seen for European Universities

Many European universities lack the autonomy they need to excel, according to a new report by the European Universities Association. The report notes that most governments voice support for autonomy (and cut back on the share of budgets they provide), but said that, in many cases, too much government oversight remains. Financial management is a key area where government controls remain, the report says. "The main issues mentioned were related to the low levels of public funding, short funding contracts which made planning difficult, line-item budgets and a lack of independent financial capacity, such as lack of ownership of university buildings or limitations on universities’ employment policies," the study says. In addition, it says that "reporting procedures were also perceived to be heavy and cumbersome, and, in a number of cases, irrelevant." The report also bemoans "a lack of ability to determine the level of tuition fees or to decide on their introduction."

That Time of Year: Coaching Carousel Cranks Into Gear

The season for many college football teams ended last weekend, which meant the start of the season that follows: firing time for many coaches. Monday brought the dismissals of head coaches at the Universities of Notre Dame and Virginia, following closely on the heels of dismissals or resignations of their peers at Marshall University, the University of Akron, and the University of Louisville, among others. While the changes are mostly about X's and O's, and the coaches' relative lack of success in winning football games, they are also about $$'s. Notre Dame will pay Weis as much as $18 million to buy out the rest of his 10-year contract (though other news reports have described that figure as exaggerated), while Virginia will spend $4.5 million to rid itself of Al Groh.

Grawemeyer Award for 'Improving World Order'

Trita Parsi has won the 2010 University of Louisville Grawemeyer Award for Ideas Improving World Order for Treacherous Alliance: The Secret Dealings of Israel, Iran, and the United States, published in 2007 by Yale University Press. Parsi is co-founder and president of the National Iranian American Council. Grawemeyer awards, worth $200,000 each, are awarded each year in in the fields of music, political science, psychology, education and religion.

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Around the Web

Philosophers shoveling snow, in The Duck of Minerva.... Dual authors in anthropology, in Savage Minds....

FREE Daily News Alerts

Comments on Quick Takes

  • The Pittsburgh Folly
  • Posted by Diogenes on December 1, 2009 at 8:15am EST
  • 10,000 students are a true and horrible burden to town like Pittsburgh. So horrible that if this tax scam goes through, they should do all their shopping on campus or outside of Pittsburgh. Talk about exploiting students as a cash cow! Time for a student boycott of the city of greed! If I owned a business in Pittsburgh, I'd let the short-sighted city government know right now that this measure has consequences that outweigh the benefits.

  • Only in America
  • Posted by Rutgers Grad on December 1, 2009 at 8:45am EST
  • The lawyers get more money than their clients in the Rutgers case. What a country.

    And Notre Dame (who blew the opportunity to have Urban Meyer as head coach) gets to pay multiple millions to rid themselves of their head coach.

    Only in America.

  • Ageism
  • Posted by G. Tod Slone on December 1, 2009 at 9:45am EST
  • Bravo to those U of Southern Maine ex-employees! Clearly, age bias is rampant and unchecked in academe today. Those chanting the diversity mantra are likely the same persons effecting bias regarding age and whiteness of skin. Academe should be ashamed!

    G. Tod Slone, PhD and Founding Editor (since 1998)
    The American Dissident, a Journal of Literature, Democracy & Dissidence
    A 501 c3 Nonprofit Providing a Forum for Vigorous Debate, Cornerstone of Democracy
    todslone@yahoo.com
    www.theamericandissident.org
    1837 Main St.
    Concord, MA 01742

  • Nice Ad
  • Posted by eubie on December 1, 2009 at 10:15am EST
  • G. Tod - let's hope your journal displays more rigor than your hysterical comment evidences. Nice job getting your advertisement in the comments section though.

  • Posted by guilty bystander , PhD on December 1, 2009 at 2:30pm EST
  • At first, I thought, $71K for a groundskeeper was a lot of money. Probably enough to pay off the mortgage &c. But I am puzzled why the attorneys got four times as much. I don't understand the logic, but see I made a mistake going for a PhD--I only teach college and would really aspire just for the $71K myself. If I'd chosen law school, maybe I could have paid off the mortgage and have a boat, and a condo, and also the happy feelings of Helping The Victims too.

  • another fired football coach!
  • Posted by UNLV Prof at UNLV on December 1, 2009 at 4:45pm EST
  • UNLV recenntly fired football coach Mike Sanford after four straight losing seasons.

  • guilty bystander
  • Posted by DFS on December 1, 2009 at 4:45pm EST
  • Don't fret. Every system of governance has its leeches. You know -- those 'educated' enough to obfuscate anything.
    Oh, by and large, they are also our Congress. I so look forward to their governance of our health care.
    Good luck!