Catholic College Bars Talk by Advocate of Gay Marriage
- Providence College reverses ban on speaker who favors same-sex marriage, but questions remain
- Some professors fear Catholic colleges are ignoring call by the pope to focus less on abortion and homosexuality
- Tensions over gay rights at two religious colleges
- Quick Takes: Sallie Mae Halts Consolidations, Threats Prompt Saint Xavier and Oakland to Shut, Aquinas Uninvites Gay Rights Philosopher, Yale Won't Start Abu Dhabi Campus, Baldwin-Wallace Goes Test-Optional, Public Barred From Diana Musical
- British theologian uninvited from University of San Diego
Providence College administrators have called off a lecture organized by several academic departments by a philosophy professor at Wayne State University who is an advocate of same-sex marriage rights, The New York Times reported. Hugh F. Lena, the provost and senior vice president at Providence, sent out an e-mail announcing that the lecture by John Corvino could not take place. In his e-mail, Lena cited a document created by American Roman Catholic bishops in 2004, "Catholics in Political Life," which questioned the appropriateness of honoring political leaders who take positions that disagree with church teachings. Lena also said that the college requires that "both sides of a controversial issue are to be presented fairly and equally."
On his blog, Corvino questioned the provost's statement. Corvino noted that he was not being given some award but was invited by academic departments to give an academic talk. Further, he noted that the organizers had invited a theology professor at the college to speak immediately after him, explaining the church's views on marriage, and that the professor had accepted the offer. So, Corvino wrote, his appearance complied with the various rules in place. "The provost seems to want to have it both ways: the appearance of a commitment to vigorous academic dialogue, combined with an isolationist approach to disfavored views; in other words, a Catholic identity defined primarily by what it excludes rather than what it includes," Corvino wrote. "Pope Francis, the Catholic Church’s new leader, has been justly celebrated for his welcoming tone toward gays and lesbians. Notwithstanding my abrupt dis-invitation, I remain hopeful that Providence College may soon better reflect that tone."