Advertisement

Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

The Lasting Impact of a Departmental Secretary

When the e-mail finally arrived, the faculty in my building had been anticipating it for a couple of weeks. That didn’t lessen the sting. “Marilyn’s gone” was the subject line, and we began, officially, to mourn the secretary (her word) who had anchored the professional lives of more than two dozen faculty in language and literature for well beyond the 15 years I’ve been at the institution.

I don’t want to sentimentalize the position of the faculty secretary, to romanticize the bond between privileged, mostly tenured faculty and less privileged staff, who serve at the pleasure of the institution. Marilyn Todesco was the last one to sugarcoat the class politics of college employment. She was keenly aware of the power dynamics of the college on whose campus she had grown up as a faculty member’s daughter. Indeed, she inspired, even pushed me both to write an article on faculty-staff relations and to commission what turned out to be an extremely powerful article about the issue for the American Association of University Professors’ magazine, Academe (which I edit), in September 2006.

Although we don’t have any unions on campus, Marilyn kept an eye on the labor politics of the institution as a whole. She saw how important it was for workers to be organized, and she promoted the importance of the Staff Association, even though it didn’t have collective bargaining. When a couple of the faculty members in her building were appointed to a benefits review committee, she checked in regularly with us to keep up to date on the committee’s progress and to push us to advocate for better benefits for the staff. She held our feet to the fire; she made us understand that the faculty on campus had power that the staff did not have, and that we were obliged to think about all employees of the college when we made our decisions. She helped us to think about options for short-term disability policies for staff and made sure we pushed them through, however long it took. That we took up that or any staff cause at Marilyn’s instigation was not noblesse oblige on our part – it was worker solidarity. We recognized, under her tuition, that a small college is a community and that it’s the workers who hold it together. Faculty workers and staff workers.

Mourning is always self-indulgent, and this reflection is perhaps especially so. My relationship to Marilyn was especially important to me because class is central to how I see myself. I will miss our discussions of labor issues and their significance in our lives because I always felt that Marilyn understood me as the working-class kid I try to keep alive inside my upper-middle-class life. Others will, of course, mourn other aspects of Marilyn, and there were many facets to that generous woman. In her campus memorial service, many people spoke of her sweetness and warmth. But what I mourn most is Marilyn’s toughness as a worker. She pretended to worry about being too outspoken about the benefits package or employment conditions, but she never self-censored, whether in open meeting or private conversation. Not whining or grumbling – she brought well-developed critiques to the table. That’s because she loved working here, really believed in the place and its people. That love went hand in hand with firm, strong notions about what was fair.

Marilyn understood both labor politics and interpersonal relations, but she never grew angry or bitter – her analysis of class dynamics, gender dynamics, and power in general always moved her to positive action, whether it was on the campus’s Staff Council or in one-one-one conversations. Not that she things didn’t get to her: she bristled at occasions on which people treated her or, more often, faculty or staff members she cared about, disrespectfully. She had a fund of righteous anger, but she never let it get in the way of anyone’s work, especially her own. I learned from her to keep in mind that I have to work with the folks on my campus for my whole career (if I’m lucky), and that work goes better when we all talk to each other.

Marilyn was interested in everything, from a grant proposal to a teaching dilemma, to vacation plans. She was that rare mix of a hard worker and a great talker and listener. The work never pushed aside the conversation, but the conversation never seemed to get in the way of the work, either. And, of course, much of the conversation was the work – how should we put together materials for this tenure case, what information should we gather on student evaluations, where are we going to put that new part-timer?

It wasn’t only faculty who worked closely with Marilyn. Student workers loved her. She treated them with respect and concern, and they returned the favor. She wasn’t simply a maternal figure; she served as a boss and a mentor to them, helping them to see themselves as future professionals, keeping track of their progress. Some came home with her to babysit her granddaughter; most stayed in touch long after graduation.

Every random, lost, or depressed student who wandered into Marilyn’s office seeking a box of tissues left feeling that it was someplace safe. My colleague, the poet Sue Standing, said that Marilyn’s office was the hearth of our building. That’s why we need poets. It’s why we need elegies – to put language, to put structure to the everyday and yet extraordinarily powerful experience of the death of someone to whom you have grown close.

In notifying us of Marilyn’s death, much too young, of cancer, my department chair, Mike Drout, noted that Marilyn’s husband had told him “only her family was more important to her than her professors.” Every single one of us – teachers of English, French, German, and Spanish — believed that already. She made us believe it, and we were the better for it.

Paula M. Krebs is a professor of English at Wheaton College, in Massachusetts.

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Lovely essay that reflects the importance of often-overlooked partners in higher education. Brava to Ms. Krebs for streaming the spotlight on a woman (and all the people) who so deserve such recognition, but too infrequently receive it.

Jennifer Baldino Bonett, Higher Education Writer, at 9:00 am EST on November 12, 2007

So class is central to how the author sees herself, and the departed secretary was NOCD, but plenty smart. Really. Wow.

Perhaps the author should re-examine her concept of self to identify why she needs to see herself as ‘privileged’ and needs to relegate the departmental secretary (who clearly knew more about life than the profs)into a lower caste.

Marilyn deserves a better elegy than this. The new secretary is likely to demand better.

Don’t write the staff poems. Treat them as equals.

Notte Goodenuf, at 11:50 am EST on November 12, 2007

What a lovely essay.

Notte — Clearly, you didn’t even read the it.

RSK, at 1:55 pm EST on November 12, 2007

Mooooooooo!

While I generally agree with Notte Goodenuf’s critique, I was also reminded, as I read Ms. Krebs’ essay, of that “secretary” ... administrative “assistant” ... ultimate power, Loraine Walker, in Jane Smiley’s “Moo.” That’s why any academic with half-a-brain knows where to go to learn something or get something done ... and it ain’t anyone with “Ph.D.” tacked onto his name.

If you haven’t read “Moo,” put it on your Christmas reading list.

Frizbane Manley, at 2:30 pm EST on November 12, 2007

Yes, I did read the essay. Every condescending word of it. Bless the secretary’s heart. She was never bitter despite ....

Read it without your elitist entitled bi-focals. The condescension is as apparent now as it was to the secretary before she died.

She knew. She was just too graceful to let you know. I have seen this phenomenon over and over again in academe. A Ph.D. doesn’t make anyone superior. It just means you know how to do narrow research in a specific field.

Notte Goodenuf, at 2:40 pm EST on November 12, 2007

Notte,

The reason you were accused of ‘not reading it’ is because the author states the class she identifies with is the working class, and she appreciated this woman’s help in keeping her connected in an environment where it would be easy to lose that touch with her roots. Not because the author identifies so strongly as upper class — because she identifies so strongly with the working class.

Lisa, at 8:25 pm EST on November 12, 2007

The author writes: “I don’t want to sentimentalize the position of the faculty secretary, to romanticize the bond between privileged, mostly tenured faculty and less privileged staff, who serve at the pleasure of the institution.”

Although the author may have been raised in a working class home (as was I), she cannot claim kin with the Studs Terkel Crew writing sentences like the one above.

I remain close to my working class values and roots. I’ve been faculty and I’ve been staff. The author needs to do some serious soul-searching. She clearly liked her secretary — who served at the ‘pleasure’ of the institution. Good God. Why isn’t this obvious to the rest of you?

Notte Goodenuf, at 9:40 am EST on November 13, 2007

I fully agree with Notte.

Would a faculty member ever be remembered positively as a professor who was always happy and got her work done? Of course not.

And whether Marilyn chose to be called a secretary or loved the faculty of her department is not the point—the way she and her actions were intrepreted is.

BB, at 4:10 pm EST on November 13, 2007

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to The Lasting Impact of a Departmental Secretary

or search for jobs directly.

Humanities (Adjunct) Instructor
Hillsborough Community College

Hillsborough Community College is a public, comprehensive multi-campus, state-supported community college located in the ... see job

Faculty — Speech, Tenure Track (9 1/2 Mths), Lancaster Campus — Fall, 2009
Harrisburg Area Community College

HACC, a leader in education in Central PA, is a comprehensive, multi-campus community college, providing quality instruction ... see job

British Literature: 17th & 18th Centuries
Bard College

Bard is a private liberal arts college with approximately 1,800 students, located 90 miles north of New York City on the ... see job

Assistant Professor or Instructor of Art History — East Asian Art
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Assistant Professor/Instructor -English Medieval/Renaissance Literature
Marymount Manhattan College

MARYMOUNT MANHATTAN COLLEGE, an urban, independent, liberal arts college with an enrollment of approximately 2,000 ... see job

Short Term and/or Temporary Faculty
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Assistant, Associate and Full Professors — Humanities and Social Sciences
Zayed University

Zayed University is seeking experienced faculty to teach humanities and social sciences beginning August 2009. see job

Assistant Professor of Spanish/Medieval
Miami University

Assistant Professor of Spanish, tenure-track, to begin August, 2009. Ph. D. in hand by August 17, 2009. The Department of ... see job

Dean of Humanities and Social Science 0000538
Los Rios Community College District

For more information and application please visit our website http://www.losrios.edu and ... see job

Communication
Keene State College

We are Creating a World of Possibilities! see job