News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Aug. 14
I wake up screaming, drenched in sweat. I can’t remember the specifics of the nightmare, but some words do come to mind: migration, downloads, upgrades. Ah, now I know. Over the summer, I have been receiving
e-mails regarding various technology changes that are in the works. For example, the instructions for transitioning to a new e-mail system are three pages long and, when I print them out, I realize they contain
multiple links that cannot be accessed when reading a hard copy. I decide to save this for another day, and I am reminded of my precarious relationship with all things technological, especially as they relate to my work.
I have learned to use Blackboard, Banner, PRESTO, Acalog, meetingmaker, FileMaker Pro, and several e-mail systems. I have not yet tried Dreamweaver, but I am tempted by its soothing name. I’m not such
a Luddite that I don’t recognize the value of much of this technology, despite its unorthodox blending of words and somewhat random use of capital and lower case letters, but I will also confess to being overwhelmed by it most of the time.
I am extremely grateful for, if somewhat mystified by, the brilliant and patient folks on campus who know how to use these various programs, and are willing to help me. They almost always conclude their conversations
by saying, “Just play with it. Have some fun.” Well, that’s not my idea of fun, and I have no idea how to “play” with technology. In fact, it seems to me to be the ultimate oxymoron. I want the sure-fire, step-by-step, written on paper directions that leave no margin for error. I do not want to make terrible mistakes that can’t be fixed. I want things to work correctly so that I am actually saving time by using a computer. And I find that keeping up with the required technology takes much of my spare time, leaving me wondering about what I’ve missed.
For example, as I am planning my classes I am simultaneously worrying about last year’s three day training session on “enhanced teaching” via the use of Blackboard, the one I opted not to attend. The truth is, I’ve tried using some aspects of Blackboard and, other than being able to send a quick e-mail to an entire group of students, I’ve found that we can accomplish the same things via face-to-face contact in my small discussion-based classes. Course evaluations completed by my students tend to support this.
Still, I am facing fall semester with my usual fear that this will be the year in which I will somehow be rendered incapable of teaching, due to my lack of technological expertise. There’s only one way to deal
with this free-floating anxiety that threatens to contaminate my last days of vacation. I’ll do what I always do when I’m overwhelmed: make a list.
Teaching With Technology To Do List
1. Remember that more technology doesn’t automatically translate to better teaching. Also, the fact that I’ve chosen not to use a “smart” classroom doesn’t mean I’m not smart. Learn how to use any technology
that is required or really helps me in my teaching, and don’t worry about the rest.
2. Make more time to listen closely to what students have to say, and respond thoughtfully.
3. Read students’ written assignments carefully and write more substantial letters in response to them.
4. Continue to make an individual conference one of the requirements for each of my courses.
5. Repeat the above, especially #1, to myself after turning off my computer and before going to sleep each night.
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
To the question of “how many Ph.D’s does it take to upload....?” Only those who think uploaded documents are somehow different in action than printed versions handed out in class.
Uploaded items still need to be downloaded...or at least read...by the recipient and understood. Emphasis on the understood. The mere existence of any data in any format means noting unless the audience interacts with it...a process often advanced through discussion. The act of reading is not the act of decoding; it requires processing/interaction moving both ways.
This Luddite still thinks education is an act of transformation, not simply the act of collecting data or a commodity to be purchased.
anon, at 1:25 pm EDT on August 14, 2008
No one is arguing that education is an act of collecting data or buying a piece of paper. Indeed, it is an interactive, hopefully transformational, process.
My point is that technology provides another avenue by which teachers can reach students. It’s a supplemental tool to help students learn. That’s presumably what education is all about. When faculty exclaim, “Well, I’m a Luddite,” and refuse to use technology as a means (not an end in itself), then they may as well be saying, “You’ll learn on my terms.”
However, one of the first principles of education is that different people learn differently. If it is too much to ask that faculty keep up with the times, maybe it is time for retirement.
IHE Reader, at 2:30 pm EDT on August 14, 2008
Well the key sentence here is: “Learn how to use any technology that is required or really helps me in my teaching, and don’t worry about the rest.”
It would be useful to know how the author determines a technology is helpful and whether she exhibits any effort to learn about new ways of learning that technology can enable — or whether she believe she is exempt from having to learn something new and uncomfortable, a quality she may be less tolerant of when demonstrated by her own students.
AK, at 3:20 pm EDT on August 14, 2008
Q: How many Ph.D.s does it take to upload a syllabus to Blackboard?
A1: Six ... one to upload the syllabus and five to make enough money to contribute to Blackboard’s lawsuits against myriad software developers.
A2: Nine ... one to upload the syllabus and eight to explain to the students why such a rudimentary software package is being used in a course for which they’re paying good money.
A3: Five ... one to upload the syllabus and four to convince a technologically-out-to-lunch Vice President for Finance that Blackboard is the greatest thing since grade inflation.
A4: Six ... one to upload the syllabus while four colleagues plus the local BLOAT (Blackboard Leader of Applications Training) looks over hir shoulder and gives advice.
A5: Three ... one to upload the syllabus, one graduate student to make all needed corrections to the Ph.D.’s composition, and another graduate student to make technical changes so students actually have access to it.
A6: Two ... One to upload the syllabus while the second extols the virtues of high tech while solving a differential calculus problem on hir TI-83.
A7: Two ... one to upload the syllabus and one smart-ass colleague to deride the Ph.D. for not using hir personal web-site, Microsoft Excel, and the Internet to do all of the course management any professor could possibly need or want ... oh yes, and with more attention to personal interaction and pedagogical excellence than will be done using Blackboard.
A8: None ... the syllabus for the course was uploaded by the Ph.D.’s 15-year-old son five years ago.
Frizbane Manley, at 1:55 pm EDT on August 15, 2008
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Johns Hopkins University in Washington, DC is seeking an Associate Program Chair to supervise and teach in the online portion ... see job
Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job
Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job
Eastern Kentucky University, located in Richmond, Madison County, Kentucky near the Heart of the Bluegrass, is a ... see job
Western New Mexico University, a public, comprehensive, regional institution serving a diverse multicultural population of ... see job
The MEASURE Evaluation Project in the Carolina Population Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is a ... see job
Join the Pack! A community with nearly 8,000 faculty and staff, and 30,000 students. NC State is one of the largest employers ... see job
Research position in clinical pharmacology and analytical chemistry located in the GLP Analytical Laboratory, Center for ... see job
The history department at Loyola College in Maryland invites applicants for a tenure-track assistant professorship in the ... see job
The Distance Education Coordinator will be responsible for (1) supporting and assisting schools and units throughout the ... see job
While the US can off-shore many IT jobs, as long as faculty continue to be “mystified” by technology and see “play[ing]” with it (i.e., practice using it) as oxymoronic, there will always be jobs for IT professionals in higher education. How many PhDs does it take to upload a syllabus to Blackboard?
IHE Reader, at 10:40 am EDT on August 14, 2008