News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Sept. 5
At U of All People, high-tech teaching is up for discussion, partly because a recent report from our regional accreditor report labeled us as “hopelessly mired in the past.” The evaluators suggested that we adopt smart classrooms, including PowerPoint and clickers in our lecture halls, interactive digital whiteboards and video hook-ups in the labs, and WiFi and virtual reality in our student recreation facilities. They strongly recommended that we provide laptops for all our incoming freshmen (after which, the computers could be passed on to needy faculty members).
But not so fast. We remember the days of the overhead projector and educational filmstrips, and we cherish the past because, frankly, it’s cheaper. This is just one reason that our motto for as long as we can recall has been “We remember.”
Accordingly, we’ve consulted with our public relations committee, and we think we might be able to drive an end-run around this current craze for technology by performing an about-face and kicking sand in the face of the technophiles. We call our movement “Back to the Basics,” and here are just a few salvos:
Those anatomically curved desk-wings with full electronic hook-ups are just an excuse to plug in rather than pay attention. There’s no substitute for rolling up your sleeves and taking notes the old-fashioned way. That’s why we at U of All People are bringing back desks with inkwells and real ink in them. We’ve also found a place that will supply quills at $10 per gross and foolscap and blotters at amazing values. When one of our literature professors intones, “Much critical ink has been spilt on this question,” our students will know exactly what he’s talking about.
Tired of faculty and students using copiers to effortlessly reproduce everything they see, as the evil progeny of the Xerox Corporation grows ever faster? Bring back the ditto machines!
Remember those unlovely hand-crank apparatuses that went ka-chunk, ka-chunk and spat out a page for every turn of the rotating drum? Remember that vaguely nauseating smell of ditto spirits, and the oddly purple text it produced? So do we, and we’ve found a whole slew of ditto machines in the basement supply room under Main Hall, along with cartons of stencils from the Kennedy era. Now those who want to create a handout will have to think twice before embarking on the effort: cutting shapes on wax-backed paper with a typewriter, not to mention fixing typos with a penknife and Liquid Paper. Now that’s pedagogical commitment.
Speaking of typing: Enough with those inkjet printers and their water-soluble text, as well as laser printers and their toner issues! We want to return to the days of tappety-tap-tap, still dear to the hearts of many old-time news reporters. For our Yellow Journalism School, we’ve located a stock of Olympia manual typewriters, guaranteed not to crash in the event of a power outage. We’ll restore the romance of the press, you’ll see! Just make sure to keep a carbon copy of whatever you write.
And finally, about those annoying whiteboards where the writing gets lost in the glare from the fluorescent light bulbs, and the multicolored markers dry out after five classes: We believe that a blackboard and chalk are more ecologically green than those newfangled nuisances, and we’ve recently re-slated all our classroom boards. Each faculty member has been issued a brand-new box of chalk for the upcoming semester, with instructions on choosing eraser monitors based on class performance. Clapping erasers used to be a privilege!
At U of All People, we remember.
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
I’ve got my quill poised. Where do I sign up?
At the root of the many things wrong with the unexamined imposition of technology onteaching is the assumption that
old = bad
(as in the apparently pejorative quote “hopelessly mired in the past'’), and
new = good.
What a university should be about is contemplative, timeless truth. Frantic fads, whether in abstract educational pseudo-science or computer toys, are the wrong atmosphere.
Ralph deLaubenfels, at 12:10 pm EDT on September 5, 2008
Of COURSE technology is key. Only it can present information. Only course information is the purpose of education. Accumulated data can be measured. And we’re back to technology being the measure of all things.
Too bad about that klunk of the ditto machine....and the Order of the Purple Thumb which all good TAs aspired to receive. Too bad about the central focus being on tools. Too bad about student and faculty engagement in intellectual exchange.
theron, at 12:30 pm EDT on September 5, 2008
Sounds good to me! Are you taking job applications?
Sarah Schneewind, Assoc Prof at University of California, at 2:15 pm EDT on September 5, 2008
Is the University of All People accepting job applications? I can teach, and work as a groundskeeper too.
Applicant, at 2:40 pm EDT on September 5, 2008
Delightful humor that many of us can indeed relate to. We remember.
And to draw a genuine pedagogical point: In commending the use of inkwells so students will be able to understand how “much ink can be spilled” on something, Prof. Galef gets at a phenomenon widely discussed in environmental studies under the name “the extinction of experience.”
How can we expect students to understand Keats’ “To Autumn” if they’ve never seen swallows gathering in the fall, or Frost’s “After Apple-picking” if they’ve never climbed a ladder hooked to a swaying bough?
The students and faculty of the U of All People, and their sympathizers, might enjoy this low-tech piece I wrote earlier this year about the extinction of experience, “Every college a farm, every college a manufactory":
http://collegiateway.org/news/2008-farm-and-manufactory
R.J. O’Hara, The Collegiate Way, at 4:35 pm EDT on September 5, 2008
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
Founded in 1898, and affiliated with what is now New York-Presbyterian Hospital since 1927, Weill Cornell Medical College ... see job
CampusWorks, Inc. (CWI), a rapidly growing information technology organization, is seeking successful college and university ... see job
San Bernardino Community College District EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY Position Information Posting Number 080218 Title Senior ... see job
Bennett College is a small, private, historically Black liberal arts college for women. As a United Methodist Church-related ... see job
The University of California Riverside invests in your future through employee training and career development, access to ... see job
This position is responsible for performing a variety of responsible duties related to the creation, maintenance and ... see job
Position Summary: The Linux Computer Engineer will develop programs for specialized applications (EPICS, ... see job
Position Summary: The Office of the Registrar of Princeton University has an opening for an administrative ... see job
Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job
Located just north of Houston, Texas, our five campuses serve 1,400 square miles. Our student enrollment is nearly 50,000 in ... see job
No Comments..?
Well, of course, there are no comments posted at this site. At U of All People, we have to write them out and send them postal. They then have to be posted in the U Newspaper. By then Gov. Palin will be in office...
Edward Winslow, A tired “refired” old professor, at 10:35 am EDT on September 5, 2008