At CUNY, Religious Studies, or Religion?

City University's trustees approve new degree at Medgar Evers, over faculty objections that program would favor one religion over others.
June 27, 2007

The City University of New York Board of Trustees approved the creation of a religious studies major at Medgar Evers College on Monday, over the objections of CUNY faculty leaders who said the new program would blur the separation of church and state by focusing not on the study of religion but on the practice of certain religions.

Medgar Evers, a predominantly black college in Brooklyn, is now set to enroll its first class of students in the interdisciplinary program, which culminates in a B.A. in religious studies, this fall. The program aims to help students "explore how religion functions in and shapes the modern world and how it empowers, enlightens, limits, complicates, inspires and conflicts modern society," the program proposal says. "Degree candidates will study and analyze the most important standard texts and investigate contemporary and historical religious practices from a global perspective, with emphasis on religions of the African Diaspora."

The religious studies program has considerable support on the Medgar Evers campus and was approved by the college's faculty in May 2006. Charlotte Phoenix, the college's interim provost, said that the institution's history of activism means that "if in fact there was faculty opposition [to the program] on this campus, everyone would have heard about it."

At Monday's meeting, Frederick P. Schaffer, senior vice chancellor for legal affairs and general counsel at the CUNY system, said he “saw nothing” to back up the concerns of some members of the University Faculty Senate who feared that the program might violate the Constitutional separation of church and state. The concerns, he asserted, were based not on the proposal but on the religious backgrounds of the program's faculty and of the college's president. Edison O. Jackson, the president of Medgar Evers, is an ordained minister who serves on the ministerial staff of an African Methodist Episcopal church in Bedford-Stuyvesant.

Faculty leaders, however, cited a range of perceived problems with the degree program as conceived by Medgar Evers. At a June 4 meeting of the trustees’ Committee on Academic Policy, Programs and Research, Lenore Beaky, vice chair of the systemwide University Faculty Senate and the senate’s representative on the board committee, read a statement from the senate’s executive committee that called the Medgar Evers proposal “seriously deficient in several important respects.”

One concern, Beaky said, was that “the proposal appears to promote the practice of religion to teach religion rather than to teach about religion.” The program, she added, “would be unconstitutional [because] as a public university we cannot violate the separation of church and state by favoring either religion or any particular variety of religion.”

The program, Beaky said, was “geared to … community experiences more suited to the practice of African-American protestant religions,” rather than the academic study of religion. She pointed to the religious affiliations of the college faculty who would teach in the program, as well the Christian affiliations of all of the scholars and others from whom Medgar Evers sought endorsements in its proposal.

Of the nine faculty members whose C.V.s are included with the proposal and who are to teach in the religious studies program, five focus their work on Christianity or African-American churches. Three others are scholars of philosophy and the fourth studies Islam in the black community.

The committee also criticized the affiliations of experts who wrote letters in support of the program that Medgar Evers officials cited in their proposal. Of the seven letters, four came from academics, all of whom focus on Christianity. Emilie M. Townes, a professor of African-American religion and theology at Yale University's School of Divinity and president-elect of the American Academy of Religion, wrote that Medgar Evers was "an ideal place" for a religious studies major. Another letter came from Christine E. Gudorf, a professor at Florida International University and president of the Society of Christian Ethics, of which Darryl Trimiew, the chair of Medgar Evers's department of philosophy and religion, is vice president. The third letter was from Marie A. Failinger, a law professor at Hamline University in St. Paul, Minn., which is affiliated with the United Methodist Church.

The fourth letter was from Barbara Austin-Lucas, a professor of religious education at Alliance Theological Seminary in Nyack, N.Y., run by the Christian and Missionary Alliance, and president of Women Organizing, Mobilizing and Building, a faith-based aid group. Her son, Hakim Jabez Lucas, is a lecturer in philosophy and religion at Medgar Evers.

The other three letters came from community leaders, including the executive director of the local YMCA and Lonnie F. Oates, a minister of the Christian Church, who wrote that his church is "in great need for better educated church members and a preparatory program for our ministers." He added: "A degree in religious studies would be a sound foundation for their preparation for Seminary.... Religious studies graduates would provide us with needed potential staff members and would of course be welcome in our churches for lay minister positions in education, evangelism and community development."

Beaky also complained that students would also be required to do internships "requiring them to work closely with professionals, practitioners, and/or graduate professors in their field of choice in order to obtain hands-on experiences in the professional practices related to religious studies," at least some at community and faith-based organizations. The proposal, Beaky added, confirmed that the program is “geared more toward the personal development of students -- development as agents of change -- rather than of their critical understanding of religions,” as would be expected of a liberal arts major in religion.

Manfred Philipp, chair of the University Faculty Senate and a chemistry professor at Lehman College in the Bronx, also criticized the program’s “sectarian” focus. At a public hearing on June 17, Philipp asked why there were no specific course offerings on Roman Catholicism, Orthodox Christianity and other Christian branches, while there were several courses on the religions of African-Americans and Caribbeans.

Phoenix, the college's provost, responded by calling the groups Philipp listed as "sects" and suggesting that students could take independent study classes to learn about those groups. In an interview, she also proposed that students could do internships with those groups or research about them to fulfill the major's requirements, adding that "the courses in the proposal are just the ones we'll have at the beginning, but as the major grows, we'll add more classes and more specific classes."

Philipp also contends that the program offers several courses on “a specific brand of Christianity" -- the Protestantism found in black churches -- including a required upper-level course called "African Traditional Religions." Students concentrating in philosophy and religion would also be required to take "Black Philosophical Thought" and students in the religion and social justice concentration would be required to take "Caribbean Religions and Social Justice Movements" and "The Role of the Church in the Black Community." Other than a class on Buddhism and Hinduism required of the philosophy concentrators, all of the other required classes are surveys, such as "Peace Education," "Religious Ethics" and "Philosophy of Religion."

But Phoenix defended the religious studies major as “a way to explore how religion functions in and shapes the modern world.” It was not intended to be “an exhaustive look at every religion in the world -- there’s no way we could cover them all,” she said, but rather a course of study focused on the "social science perspective" on modern religion.

“Our program is in no way trying to prepare students for seminary or sectarian studies, because that’s not what most of our students want,” Phoenix added, explaining that a survey of students interested in the religious studies major found that students were more likely to want to go to law school or to pursue non-profit or social service jobs than to go on to study divinity or become clergy members.

Jeremy Leaming, a spokesman for Americans United for Separation of Church and State, said "the fact that some faculty say it may not be a very well-rounded program at the moment doesn't amount to a violation of the separation of church and state." Unless there is evidence that the program's faculty are "trying to proselytize or inculcate Christianity or another religion," he said, there are no grounds for objection to the religious studies program.

"Public universities," Leaming added, "must ensure that religious study courses are just that, academic courses on religion, and not classes that should be taught at a bible seminary or a bible college." He declined to comment further without more information on the program at Medgar Evers.


Be the first to know.
Get our free daily newsletter.


Back to Top