- Keeping Students Enrolled
- Ending remediation is the wrong answer (essay)
- Accelerated associate degree track at CUNY pays off and earns fans
- Remediation Worries and Successes
- College-level statistics trumps remedial algebra in CUNY study
- How Community Colleges Can Reach Obama's Goals
- California community colleges' cautious experiment with accelerated remediation
- Accelerating the Associate Degree
Promising Path on Remediation
Remedial education remains a struggle for many community colleges, which are expected to help students who received inadequate high school educations get ready for college-level work. Legislators hate paying for remedial education; community colleges hate being defined by remedial education; students hate being unable to get into the college-level courses that attracted them to higher education in the first place.
A study being released today by MDRC, a research organization, suggests that "learning communities" -- in which students take several courses together as a cohort -- have the potential to significantly improve students' performance in remedial courses and ability to advance to college-level work. The learning communities also featured special counseling and other support services.
The study is particularly significant in that Kingsborough Community College, a part of the City University of New York where the work took place, helped the researchers conduct a true randomized trial -- in which students were assigned either to the learning community or a control group. Much education research takes place either after a college has made a change (so there is no control group) or with volunteer pilot projects (in which issues of self-selection may raise doubts about the outcome). The MDRC researchers believe theirs is the first study of its kind to use a true random trial.
The students in the learning communities took, as a group, a remedial English course, an academic course in health or psychology, and a one-credit orientation course. All of the students were entering Kingsborough, seeking to enroll full time. The college serves a diverse population -- 38 percent of students are black, 20 percent are Hispanic, and almost three-fourths report at least one parent was born outside the United States. The experimental group and the control group had similar demographics.
On a wide range of factors, the students in learning communities had more success than the students in the control group. The learning community group took more courses on average (4.9 vs. 4.4), passed more classes (3.8 vs. 3.2), earned more credits (11.5 vs. 10.4), and had a larger share of students passing all courses (43.1 percent vs. 33.0 percent). Moreover, the students in the learning community had statistically significant increases in the rates at which they passed the English tests necessary to qualify for college-level work and degrees at CUNY.
Susan Scrivener, a senior associate at MDRC and one of the researchers on the project, said that the results are encouraging and significant. Past research has shown that "remedial education is such a hard area to affect, so it's pretty notable that folks are moving through that."
Many previous studies have found that students who languish in remedial education year after year are unlikely to move to college-level work, so the fact that significantly more students can finish and move to college-level work is of great importance, Scrivener said.
Regina Peruggi, president of Kingsborough, said that as a result of this program, "three semesters out, these students are still taking courses and others aren't." The effort has been so successful that Peruggi said her goal is to have all freshmen in learning communities -- the college is already at over 60 percent.
Peruggi also said she would like to find ways to apply the concept beyond the first semester. Learning communities become more challenging to set up as students progress, since they may have more specialized courses that they need and putting together a cohort becomes difficult. But Peruggi said that the college is setting up some upper-level learning communities as well. She said that the results made her want to focus more attention on faculty members talking to faculty members in other departments -- since that happens in learning communities and is cited by professors as key to their success.
Rebecca Arliss, an associate professor of health who teaches in one of the learning communities, agreed. She said that weekly formal meetings, and more frequent informal discussions, took place among the professors who were teaching the same students. The professors worked together to reinforce one another, whether on behavioral issues (students not paying attention) or the curriculum (adding writing assignments to non-writing focused courses).
Arliss said she has added writing to many of her class sessions, having students do quick responses to prompts -- all designed to reinforce basic writing skills. In the more traditional model, a professor may have no idea how a student is faring in other classes. "We're trying to be mutually reinforcing," she said. "The question is always: How are we going to reach these kids?"
Search for Jobs