Inside Higher Ed’s editor in chief Sara Custer and news editor Katherine Knott discuss the latest higher ed news: the proposals to change accreditation, the latest from the Office for Civil Rights, the GOP’s plan to plug the hole in Pell grant funding and how the administration is redirecting grants that support low-income students.

 

Follow us on Apple Podcasts Spotify

 

View Transcript

Note: Transcripts may be created with the help of automated tools and lightly edited for clarity.

Transcript

Sara Custer: Hello and welcome to The Key, Inside Higher Ed’s news and analysis podcast. I’m your host, Sara Custer, editor in chief at Inside Higher Ed. And in today’s episode, I’ve brought in our news editor, Katherine Knott, for an update on the policies coming out of the Hill and the White House. We discuss the final proposal from the accreditation negotiated rulemaking last month and what comes next. Katherine gives us an update on the Office for Civil Rights staffing and reports on our coverage of how OCR is using Title IX to target trans students. We discuss the House GOP’s plans to plug the Pell funding shortfall, in part by eliminating subsidized student loans. And we look at how the administration is leveraging federal grants for research and student support to progress its political agenda. So there’s something for everyone in this federal policy update and we’ll get right to it. Thank you for listening and enjoy. Hi, Katherine. Welcome back.

Katherine Knott: Hi, Sara. Thanks for having me.

Sara Custer: I’m really happy you’re here for a newsroom update because it’s been a while since we’ve done a newsroom update. There’s so much to cover.

Katherine Knott: I think last time I was on The Key podcast, we were just starting the accreditation neg reg, right? We haven’t even seen the rules yet, and now here we are. The rules have been passed by a committee, right? And the July 1st deadline looms for so many other policies. Like, right, I don’t know. A lot’s happened in two months.

Sara Custer: A lot has happened. The time has just flown by.

Katherine Knott: They’ve reached consensus. Who knew?

Sara Custer: There’s lots to cover, lots and lots to cover. But before we start on that, since we both shared lost keys stories and we that well might be totally tapped, we discussed talking about just lost items stories that I’m sure our listeners are on the edge of their seat to hear.

Sound clip: Where are my keys?

Sara Custer: So I’m going to start quickly with mine and you can share yours. The other week, well, I thought I had lost my glasses about a year ago at an event in Salt Lake City because that was the last time I remember seeing them. And I was like, well, that’s it. They’re just sitting in that hotel room in that Marriott, whatever, gone forever. I need to go get them. But getting glasses, if you don’t have a prescription, it’s like, it’s like a whole thing, right? And if you work hours like we do, it’s difficult to go to a glasses shop during the week and you’ve got to spend a Saturday doing it. And it’s just one of those errands that just falls off the list. Finally, I was like, no, I have to do it. It got to the point that I like set myself a deadline. I was like, in March, I will get new glasses. So, that deadline went to the beginning of June. And I was like, this is it. We’re doing it. Set the deadline in March, and I’ll do it in June. So, I was like, we’re doing it. But of course, we’re going doing multiple things on this Saturday. We were headed to a Nationals game as well. And I was like, all right, let’s go. We’ll just pass by a Warby Parker on the way to this Nationals game. So, we get there, and I had about 15 minutes to check out some frames and do the whole thing. Got some frames, found ones that I like, these will do. And then I was going through the whole process of like giving my insurance and then setting up like an appointment to do the eye exam and everything. And then I realized that time was running too short, and I didn’t have time to finish this entire process with this poor salesperson. So, I was like, I’m going to miss opening pitch. Let’s just hit pause. I’ll be back. Went to the baseball game, couldn’t see a thing because I didn’t have my glasses.

Katherine Knott: I’m so glad you made it for opening pitch.

Sara Custer: Had a great time though. And then the very next day, I was cleaning out some drawer of lost souls in my home office. And lo and behold, there were my glasses, my old glasses that I thought were lost forever in St. Louis. So, I don’t know. I think it just, I just needed to go test the waters and show the universe that I was willing to replace these glasses before they would suddenly reveal themselves to me.

Katherine Knott: Yeah. My one note on your story is we do have a glasses store in the, in our building.

Sara Custer: I know. And I walk by it every day. I’m like, I should go check those out. I walk by it every day. It’s right there. It’s like literally the only store I walk by every single day. It’s true. I could just pop down there on my lunch break. I could do that.

Katherine Knott: I go to the store, the MyEyeDr. around the corner. So that’s the only, that’s the only way I can get my glasses prescription updated. But I’m so glad that you found your glasses and you can see again next time you go to the Nationals game. You’re probably going to be like, wow, that’s what this team looks like.

Sara Custer: Yeah. Check out those frames. There they are. They’re real glasses. Real glasses.

Katherine Knott: You’ve been going without real sunglasses or real glasses for a year.

Sara Custer: Yeah. Well, it’s just, it’s a distance thing. It’s just so I can like, because I wear them a lot at events so I can read slides and stuff. So I’ve just been squinting or even taking a picture with my phone and then enlarging the image on my phone while I’m sitting in the back row of some presentation.

Katherine Knott: I’m so glad that we’re, I talk about with my family a lot of like we have solvable problems and we need to address the solvable problems. But a year, a year has gone by, but you fixed it now.

Sara Custer: But this is what we do. We’re resilient. We’re problem solvers. That’s what we do as journalists. You take photo enlarge. You can read it. You can read the screen.

Katherine Knott: Sure. Yeah. You know, I’m so glad for you, though, that all you had to do was send a signal to the universe that after a year, you were ready to give up on your glasses. Because for me, I often just immediately replace the thing and then I will find it. Because I can’t, I often don’t get that luck of like universe. I’m going to replace you unless this thing mysteriously emerges. And this has happened to me so much that I just give up. So in my story that I’m going to tell, I didn’t even wait for like to look because I just immediately assumed that I lost something. Like it must be in the black hole between my car and my apartment. And that it’s falling down there. So about not even a year ago, I just moved into my new apartment and I first, I was like, went shopping, had my wallet in my hand, and I come home and I can’t, I’m, and for some reason, I’m like looking for my wallet and I couldn’t find it. I had got a lot of like cat toys. So they were like on my comforter and my cat was playing with the cat toys that I brought her. I was like, look great. Isn’t this nice? And then I realized I couldn’t find my wallet. I like look everywhere. Cause again, I’ve been from my car to my apartment. There’s not that many places that it could have been. I scour everywhere. I’m like, it is gone. I like assume like I’m, I don’t even like my brain was just like, it’s done. Like, give up that really cute wallet that you really like. Done. Like, no, not happening. Like, great. Let it go. Move on. Let it go. These are you can easily fix by replacing your debit card, your credit card, all that stuff. So I do that. I log on to my phone. I’m like, very responsible. It clearly must be, you know, at the Target or wherever I went shopping. Like, let’s lock all the cards. Let’s order replacement. And then I go to my room. And for this story, you should know. Yeah, exactly. It could be in the wrong hands. I don’t want to spend the money I don’t have. Sure. Lock the lock everything down. So, you know, all the robbers, they’re not going to be happy with my credit card. So then I go back into my room. My cat’s playing with her toys. And you have to know, she’s a 23-pound cat. The vet says she wears her weight well. She, but she’s a large lady. So then Lois has been sprawling. She gets up.

Sara Custer: Chonky lady.

Katherine Knott: She gets up after playing with her toys. And there’s my wallet underneath her. I didn’t even think to look under the cat.

Sara Custer: Under the cat.

Katherine Knott: I’m like, how dare I?

Sara Custer: Yeah. Who’s a cat? So now the first place anytime you lose something, that’s the first place you look under the cat.

Katherine Knott: Yeah. She’d be like, Lois, is it under you? Can you move? She really gets annoyed with me now about that. She’s like, I’ve literally not moved all day. I don’t think you’re whatever that’s missing is hiding under you. So luckily, I only replaced my debit card before I went back and I was like, oh, there’s my wallet. So I didn’t have to get like a new driver’s license and everything.

Sara Custer: Oh my God. But then, but then you had to go through the whole thing where like you didn’t have a debit card for a few days.

Katherine Knott: Yeah. And it was really annoying. I had to change. I had to change all of my things where all the things are linked to my debit card. So it was a real inconvenience. And you know what? The lesson is: had I waited 10 minutes, it would have been fine. Lois would have moved. She would have gotten up and I would have found it. But no, I was not patient enough to wait the year that you did for your glasses to emerge. I was just like, I just, you know, I had such little faith in myself that I’m like, of course I’ve lost my wallet. Why wouldn’t I?

Sara Custer: Yeah. Man, we’re just two extremes here. Two extremes of, to be fair, a wallet is different from glasses. If I thought I had lost my wallet, I would have been much, I would have acted much more quickly than a year.

Katherine Knott: Clearly.

Sara Custer: Yeah, clearly. But yeah. So we’re doing great.

Katherine Knott: Okay. We’re thriving.

Sara Custer: We are thriving.

Sound clip: Oh, man. Have you seen my keys?

Sara Custer: One thing that we haven’t lost, though, is our thumb on the pulse of higher education news.

Katherine Knott: Excellent segue.

Sara Custer: So we mentioned accreditation already, but let’s remind our listeners of what was a lot was decided in that negotiated rulemaking. We’ve got accreditors on the hook for quite a bit of stuff, much more than they were going into it. Do you want to just give us a recap of what their proposals are?

Katherine Knott: So the way I think about the Trump administration’s accreditation overhaul is they, the administration is going to require accreditors to do a lot of the things that the administration has been trying to require of colleges. So instead of them setting the rules, they’re going to have accreditors now like set standards on viewpoint diversity at colleges. They’re going to have accreditors have standards for student achievement. And there’s many other things like that in the reg. So it’s pretty sweeping in terms of like what they’re going to do. Like they’re going to require them to police institutional First Amendment compliance, research misconduct too, but that was a little bit more, it’s a little bit different. And we just see in pretty much every provision across the board, you know, the administration advancing its priorities via accreditors. They’re also going to make it easier for new accreditors to join. That’s been a real complaint of Republicans for a while is that the system that as it currently exists kind of prevents new accreditors from joining the marketplace. So, we’re going to see it’s going to be a lot easier. And I think the department’s going to also kind of like tighten its control over the accreditors themselves as it seeks to kind of have them required to do more things.

Sara Custer: So, you mentioned First Amendment, ensuring viewpoint diversity on campus is another big one that, as you said, or the federal government, Department of Education wanted institutions to do, but now they’re going to put it on accreditors to require that colleges are doing that.

Katherine Knott: Yeah, I mean, like, one of the ones that they’re going to require of accreditors is like, as an example of this, is like require accreditors to ensure colleges and universities are complying with federal laws. And that includes the prohibition, you know, kind of the DEI crackdown that we’ve seen from this administration. So, now they’re going to have accreditors kind of like police that as well. And I think what was also interesting, which is not directly related to this, but the fact that the regulations also will direct accreditors to not interfere with institutional governance decisions that kind of fall within the purview of state governments, boards of trustees and other governing bodies. So, it’s like, you know, giving them more power in some areas, taking away some power. So, definitely runs the gamut.

Sara Custer: So, we’ve got making it easier for new accreditors to get recognition. We’ve got requiring accreditors to police First Amendment policies on campus. Also making sure that they’re enforcing federal policies around viewpoint diversity and anti-DEI legislation. We’ve got greater accountability in academic research. And then they also are requiring accreditors to make sure that colleges are being much more transparent around transfer credits. What did they say about transfer credits?

Katherine Knott: That was one of the ones I was going to mention. My understanding of the proposal is that they’re basically going to say colleges need to transfer. Like credits need to transfer from two years to four years and make that a lot easier. I know colleges are worried about a little bit of the burden, but I think we’ve seen this time and time again of different administrations say that transfer is confusing and that colleges don’t accept credits that they should. And now I think we’re going to see the administration is kind of getting in and be like, no, you need to accept the credits. And the accreditors are going to make sure you do that.

Sara Custer: So is it, you said it was from two year to four year institutions, but is it, isn’t it also when a student wants to transfer from a four-year institution to another four-year institution?

Katherine Knott: Yes. I think the idea is that, you know, four years and other institutions are going to be required basically when a student’s accepted or within like 45 days of being of that of getting accepted to essentially get like a transfer credit evaluation. So it should be pretty transparent to students like what’s going to transfer and what’s not. But my understanding is it’s pretty much it’s all the institutions.

Sara Custer: Yeah, and the policy is really hinging on that credits will be the default is that credits are accepted. And that if they aren’t accepted, then institutions have to give a reasoning of why they’re not accepted. Versus now, where it’s like default is not that they’re accepted. This is going on a case-by-case basis. So it really is making it easier for students to transfer, which I think a lot of people were fairly happy about. And it’s certainly affordability advocates thought that this was a great way to cut down on the cost of college. But there were some concerns about academic independence, institutional independence and academic freedom with this provision.

Katherine Knott: Yes, I think that’s right. But I really like the way that you framed that because I think that is the fundamental like paradigm shift in the way that transfer is going to be treated is the default being like you have to accept the credits. And if not, you have to specify why you’re not. So I think that’s really interesting. And yeah, we’ve seen some concerns from institutions about burden and like what that’s going to mean. But yeah, like you said, a lot of advocates are also praising this. So there’s just, there’s a lot in the accreditation proposal. It has received consensus. So the committee, the advisory committee reviewing the regs signed off on this proposal. The next step is going to be releasing it for public comment. So that’s when everyone else is going to have a chance to have their say. And if the department finalizes the regs by November 1st of this year, they’ll take effect July 1 of next year.

Sara Custer: Yeah, that’s huge. That’s huge. That’s a big game changer. All right. We will be obviously covering every single step of that process. I’m excited to see what public comments come out for that. Let’s move on to the world of the Office for Civil Rights. And I think we, you gave us some updates on this the last time you were on The Key, but tell us where we stand now with those investigations and where the office is.

Katherine Knott: I mean, so I kind of like have two updates for you. One is like how the office is running and then what is it doing? So in the kind of the first bucket, you know, we’ve talked a lot in the last year about how the Trump administration was kind of gutting and reshaping the Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights. You know, you all remember nearly half of the office’s staff, you know, were laid off in March of 2025. Then, but the department did eventually rescind those layoffs. But we’ve learned in the last few months since I was last on The Key that while the staff were in limbo, kind of waiting what was going to happen with the layoffs, the office only resolved 1% of its cases. According to a report from Senator Bernie Sanders, the administration entered into just 112 resolution agreements, which is the fewest in at least 12 years. So not doing a lot, but at the same, and we have seen and heard Education Secretary Linda McMahon acknowledge that the office was not processing cases as quickly as it should have. And she pledged, you know, at a Senate hearing to hire more lawyers. And we have seen job postings from a federal contractor for OCR lawyers. So there is movement, and the department is trying to kind of re-backfill positions or not backfill, but boost staffing in general at the office. Now, as we reported last week, some of those jobs have much higher salaries than the folks who were working in the office to begin with before the layoffs. So, according to one former OCR staffer, the fact that they have to like pay a lot more is probably a sign of the times of like how to, you know, that the department’s gonna have to work harder to get lawyers to come work for it, how the federal workforce is going. So, that’s kind of the bucket of how things are going, you know, internally at the Office for Civil Rights. But we’ve also seen some key developments that shed light on how they’re inter on how the administration is interpreting enforcing Title IX. First, they’ve rescinded a bunch of resolution agreements that previous administrations reached with schools and colleges. So, pretty big deal because it doesn’t happen all that often. And several experts told me it just injects more uncertainty into the federal government’s relationship with institutions, right? Like, usually, you could depend on the fact that if you reach one, if you reach a resolution agreement with one administration, it would be upheld by the next. That bedrock assumption is being tested in new ways. And they all, and all of the rescinded agreements concern the rights of trans students, at least one is more than a decade old. And in one case, a school district was told to roll back policies that it adopted to comply with the original resolution agreement. So, it’s so in that case, the administration is going further than just saying, like, we’re not going to enforce this agreement. We’re actually going to make you like roll back your gender non-discrimination policy.

Sara Custer: So that’s a shift in our because we’ve seen the administration try twice now with Penn. And I, was it, was it San Jose State where they retroactively applied their Title IX policies from 2020 that were not in force whenever they allowed trans athletes to compete?

Katherine Knott: I would say they were in force. So it was the administration’s Title IX rules. What’s changing is the interpretation of the rules. Because like that, that’s what I’ve found is so interesting with these situations like Penn and San Jose State is the Title IX rules that were in place are the current Title IX rules that currently exist. It was a different administration interpreting them because the rules took effect spring, summer of 2020. And then, you know, the Biden administration took over in January of 2021. And then, and then the Biden administration’s Title IX rules really never took effect nationwide. So it is, it is more, I think it’s more of a matter of like what’s shifting is the interpretation of what do these rules require. And like I had one expert tell me that I talked to for the Title IX story on like the rescinded agreements that, you know, in 2020, the administration’s interpretation, you know, and during the first administration, it was essentially like Title IX does not require the inclusion of trans students was the way that this expert interpreted the administration’s view. And then now in Trump II, we’re seeing that we’re seeing more evidence that the administration’s view is that Title IX requires the exclusion of trans students. And especially like women-only spaces. And we’ve seen that a lot with athletics, but it is like that’s kind of that is a big shift in what is expected of colleges and how do you treat trans students and what are the rights of trans students on college campus campuses. Of course, it’s the administration’s policy that gender, there are only two genders in this country and it’s what you’re born with and it cannot be changed. And that is informing a lot of how they interpret Title IX. I will say the other big development that we’ve seen in kind of this realm is the administration open investigation into Smith College and its admissions policies to admit trans women. So that’s a very big investigation that will have that will likely have implications for the other women’s colleges that admit trans women. So we’re gonna be watching that very closely.

Sara Custer: Okay, let’s move on to what’s happening in the world of FAFSA, because we know that there is a massive Pell shortfall that could increase to nearly 17 billion by September 2027 if lawmakers don’t act now. But we have seen some plans for ways to plug this gap. What have we seen?

Katherine Knott: Well, the Trump administration’s plan is to put $10 billion into the Pell program and keep the maximum Pell flat at, I believe, $7,395, $7,395. The House Republicans’ plan, which was released last week, is to boost the maximum Pell by $50. And they are going to end subsidized loans for undergraduates to pay for the difference. We are not entirely sure exactly how the math all works because we need to get more information about the House Republicans’ budget, but that’s essentially the big cut that they’re proposing. They are also proposing cutting other, like, student aid programs, such as work study, to kind of pay for the difference.

Sara Custer: And what’s been people’s response to this proposal?

Katherine Knott: So, what we’ve heard from advocates is they’re grateful that the Congress is addressing the shortfall in some way, and the $50 boost is appreciated. It’s a far cry from the $200 that advocates have been asking for, but they really don’t like the decision to cut other student aid programs and subsidized loans. I mean, subsidized loans basically don’t accrue interest while students are in college. So, that’s because the government’s subsidizing the interest. So, that ending is going to increase students’ debt. And I mean, that’s what we heard pretty much from everyone of like, this is not a good solution to solve the shortfall because it’s only going to have other implications for students. So it’s like helping affordability in one area, taking away in the other.

Sara Custer: Right. So as we are, as you say, Katherine, we still haven’t figured out the math behind this plan that House Republicans are proposing. But really what advocates are saying they need for a sustainable model for the Pell going forward is more mandatory funding so that that way it’s not vulnerable to every single year, different appropriations, political wind shifting, politicians having to cut here, rob Peter to pay Paul essentially to plug more money into the Pell funding. If there was more mandatory funding, which part of the Pell program does have mandatory funding, if there was more put into that, then there would be much more consistency for this student aid program. And we’re not sure yet if that bill, if this bill is going to do that. We might know by the time this podcast publishes.

Katherine Knott: But yes, essentially that. And mandatory funding is similar to like how Social Security and these other programs are funded, where like the government commits to pay what the bill is, where the annual appropriations process only deals with discretionary funding. So like this process is not really going to engage mandatory money.

Sara Custer: Right. But we also got some good news in the world of FAFSA, which was about real-time decisions, students getting real-time decisions on their FAFSA applications.

Katherine Knott: Yes. So, you’re going to fill out your FAFSA and know immediately how much money you are eligible for. And I think crucially, what came up in the reporting for our story on it is if there’s an issue, students are going to find out like right away. So, if you’re like at a FAFSA fair or something, you submit it and you’re like, oh, I filled out something wrong, you’re going to be able to like address it right away with the person who can help you versus like getting an email, having to log back in. So, it’s a big win and it’s a big improvement for the FAFSA for sure.

Sara Custer: Sure, that’s a huge game changer for students and their planning for the costs of college and troubleshooting. And gosh, aren’t we a far cry from the troubles and headaches that came from the FAFSA fiasco two years ago?

Katherine Knott: Never forget. Was it only two years ago?

Sara Custer: Oh no, it’s been such a long time. End of 2023, beginning of 2024.

Katherine Knott: Yeah, it was spring 2024. I guess that was two years ago. Time flies when you’re having fun.

Sara Custer: Well, it’s good to see that the Department of Education was able to make such quick improvements so quickly on that application, considering how important it is to students’ lives and funding their college.

Katherine Knott: Definitely.

Sara Custer: Okay, so as we are looking forward, let’s talk a little bit about what we’re watching in the world of grant funding.

Katherine Knott: Ah, the best topic ever.

Sara Custer: Yeah, we got a pretty bombshell report from the Office of the Management of Budget.

Katherine Knott: Yeah, Office of Management and Budget. So it’s, yeah, I mean, there’s a lot that’s going to change and that is changing with how the Trump administration funds federal grants for research and pretty much anything. And we’ve spent a lot of time in the last month writing about grants. So it’s been a pretty wonky few weeks here at Inside Higher Ed. I mean, what else is new? But the first one that everyone should be watching for and aware of is this new regulations, proposed rules from the Office of Management and Budget that basically sets the terms for federal grants and the rules that are and the stipulations that go along with them. And the basics of it is everything the administration tried to do with federal grants last year, that some of that got hung up in courts, some of it didn’t. This is going to strengthen their case and strengthen their control over grants. So this, you know, senior political appointees are going to be the ones that decide whether to award or cancel funding. There’s going to be new directives that grantees will have to follow. It’s again, another very wide-ranging proposal that touches on a lot of the department’s priorities. There’s a list of things that OMB told us that it would prevent, you know, so similar to things that we heard grants getting canceled for last spring, you know, supporting DEI, researching gender-affirming care, climate change, you know, all those kinds of things are going to be prevented as a part of this proposal.

Sara Custer: So this document is really wonky. It’s called the Uniform Guidance. It governs grant making for the whole of the federal government, and it’s currently open for public comment. Some of the criticisms of this have been: well, the biggest one is that politically appointed people are now going to be making decisions about grant funding across the whole federal government. That includes NIH, that includes NSF, that includes Department of Defense, that includes NASA, everything. So it’s real arguably legitimate concerns about political overreach in federal funding of academic research. Also, a flattening of how we think about what is good academic research, if there’s just this all-uniform mandate on how we give away grant funding. There was one bright spot, though, and that was around indirect rate costs, because there were some concerns that OMB was going to address the indirect rate costs, which have been in the conversation, even though the 15%, the government’s effort to cap it at 15% was stopped by a federal judge. They did not address that this time, so that was maybe one small win for the research universities that the indirect rate costs were not capped by this.

Katherine Knott: Yeah, and they also weren’t proposing a new model. Like, I think we’ve seen there’s an effort from a lot of the higher ed associations at D.C. to kind of propose something different to change the way that those indirect research costs are paid for by grants. And OMB was basically like, we’re not going to make any changes, and please don’t tell us about any changes you want to see. They’re like, this is not what we are doing here today.

Sara Custer: One of my other favorite podcasts.

Katherine Knott: Also, interesting that they said that awardees could not use grant funding to pay for article publishing charges with publishers. And again, like, this is one of the things that we’ve been hearing about a lot over the last year. And this document kind of codifies that. Like, we’ve heard that NIH was going to limit how much grantees can use to pay for those publishing fees. We’ve heard about the concerns about politicization and the senior and the political appointees. And once this proposal kind of gets finalized, it just gives the administration’s power, like it makes it more concrete. Forgive me, I misspoke. It’s not article publishing charges, it’s actually article processing charges. The APCs, forgive me for misspeaking on that.

Sara Custer: Forgiven. Okay, so OMB, pretty big deal. I feel like I’ve said that like three different times. Game changer, big deal.

Katherine Knott: Well, it is federal policy. Everything’s a big deal and a game changer.

Sara Custer: If we’re sticking in the broad understanding of grant funding, let’s now move on to the world of student aid grant funding and student support grant funding. What are we seeing there?

Katherine Knott: So I think the biggest development that was expected, but we did finally see the education department officially reallocated money away from minority-serving institution grant programs to a broader grant, like pool of money called the Strengthening Institutions Program. So we, again, we’ve expected it. The administration considers all of these MSI grant programs to be illegal. And the Congress kind of gave the department a way to give them, put this money in a larger pot. So we know it did finally happen. And that grant program, I believe, is now like open for applications. And then the other big thing that we have seen and then we had a story about last week is the way that the administration is kind of using its priorities and using these grant competitions to advance those priorities. So for instance, in two recent grant competitions for the TRIO, so for two of the TRIO programs, states got a preference, like a preference. So they’d get a little bit more money if you’re a state applying, and you get a little bit more points in the application if you were a state, and you could be eligible for more funding. So in the Talent Search TRIO program, everyone else would be capped at a million, but a state could get 10 million a year over five years. So we reached out, our reporter Ryan Quinn reached out to, I think, every state to ask if they’ve applied. He heard back from some and they some shared their application. TRIO advocates are worried that this will take away resources from existing TRIO programs. States see an opportunity to better serve their communities. So we’re going to be watching to see how, where does the money actually go with the TRIO funding and kind of what those programs look like. Also, the department, as a part of, you know, advancing its priorities in the Talent Search, you know, they are going to also give a preference to programs that like focus on apprenticeship, kind of other ways to college, which again, advocates see as like an undermining of TRIO, which is supposed to be about preparing students for like a more traditional college experience. So lots, lots to see as the department’s kind of priorities, which are legal now because they’ve codified them. So the priorities like workforce development, AI, returning education to the states and some other ones. I think the other ones like patriotic education for our purposes. So those are the priorities that they are using to determine who gets money this time around.

Sara Custer: Yeah. So, all of this is legal, right? Whereas last year, whenever we saw the administration canceling MSI funding or TRIO funding, that was not legal, why? Because that was congressionally approved funding, and you can’t just stop awarding that. But what we’re seeing now is the tactic is to just shift the priorities of that or shift the direction of where that funding is going. Still giving that funding, but in a different way for different purposes and to different recipients.

Katherine Knott: Yeah. I don’t know if everyone says what they’re doing with MSIs is like totally legal, but they certainly were given the ability to like move discretionary money for the MSI programs to the broader grant program. The question is: what happens with the mandatory money, which apparently we’re talking a lot about funding and mandatory funding on this podcast today?

Sara Custer: Man, it’s very discretionary.

Katherine Knott: Man, love that. It’s the hottest topic around. So I think we’re still going to wait to see what happens with the mandatory money for those grant programs.

Sara Custer: Right. And one thing I will say about TRIO is that some people actually think that giving TRIO funding to states isn’t a totally bad option. This has historically gone to individual colleges, individual programs, and states had no oversight of what federal funding was flowing into those programs. And especially now that we’re seeing prioritization for workforce readiness programs and AI programs and apprenticeships, it makes sense that states can see where funding is going for that talent development side. So I can see how that would make sense, but I can also totally see how TRIO advocates are very concerned about the impacts this is going to have on underfunded and underprivileged students trying to get access to college.

Katherine Knott: Well, you’re also talking about like too, like the programs that have been on campuses for decades. They have staff, they have support, they have institutional know-how and know-how to get students to and through college. And there’s a chance there’s all, I mean, the great in fairness to this, the whole thing, the grants do give prior experience credit. And that’s a lot more points than the state points in the kind of the rubric. So there’s credit in the grant competition for people that currently run programs. And again, we’re just going to kind of see how that all shakes out.

Sara Custer: Okay, final one thing we’re watching. We have, as you mentioned, a looming July 1 deadline. What could that possibly be?

Katherine Knott: Oh my goodness, it’s here, everyone. We’ve been talking about reconciliation in the One Big Beautiful Bill and the major changes it’s going to make to higher education and the policy changes take effect July 1. So to recap, that means graduate student loans will be capped starting July 1. There’s a bunch of lawsuits, so maybe they won’t. Who knows? And the professional, so that’s the end of Grad PLUS. Grad PLUS is dead starting July 1. There’ll be the professional loan caps and the graduate loan caps. Workforce Pell starts July 1, though it’s going to be a little while before I think all the money starts flowing. There’s a lot of logistics that have to happen. Changes to student loan repayment plans take effect in July. And the department has not yet finalized, but comment periods, the comment period has closed on a new accountability metric that will cut off low-earning programs from federal student loans. So that could be finalized any day now. It’s supposed to take effect on July 1, but it’s not yet final.

Sara Custer: And you dug through the public comments for that specific policy. What did you find?

Katherine Knott: I saw find a lot of what we expected to hear. I mean, the vast majority of the comments were from representatives of cosmetology programs who are worried about how the new earnings test is going to affect the industry. I mean, I think 90% of cosmetology programs fail the earnings test. We also heard a lot from religious programs and like faith-based institutions who are worried that religious studies and rabbinical programs could also suffer and have to close as a result of the earnings test. So, a lot of deep concern from the higher education sector about the impact of the earnings test. You know, we’ve heard time and time again from institutions that it’s not fair because they can’t control earnings. So, I’m going to be interested to see how this changes the discussion between colleges and employers about what students should make, because there is now a benchmark. You have your graduates have to make more than a high school, than the average high school graduate in your state. So there’s just, yeah, lots of concern. But I also picked up as someone who covered previous comments on similar regulations in the past, there seemed to be a little bit more like resignation of like, this is happening. Here’s how can we make this work rather than like fighting the underlying principle. And part of that is because it’s in law. Like Congress passes as a law, so there’s not much to fight over it in the way that like past battles over gainful, I think, have been fought over like the department’s overreaching and things like that. Like Congress has said every program needs to pass an earnings test to get federal student law, student loans. So that will be interesting. I mean, obviously, we’ve the department is already flagging low-earning programs on the FAFSA, and they’ve collected a bunch of data as a part of previous gainful employment. So who knows when we’re actually going to see some of the data that they’ve been collecting on earnings, but it should be within the year, I think. We’ll sooner.

Sara Custer: That was a whirlwind news update. Gosh, I say this every time, but we clearly need to get you on more frequently so that we can go a little bit deeper into some of these stories. And I promise that we will. Thank you so much, Cal.

Katherine Knott: A whole Key episode on grant funding.

Sara Custer: Listen, you say it in jest, but that stuff is really, really important. We know the millions of dollars that are that are flowing to minority-serving institutions, and we know that that funding is the tide that raises all boats for students at those institutions. So, it’s incredibly important. Katherine, thank you so much. I hope you don’t lose anything under your cat anytime soon.

Katherine Knott: Me too, me too. You never know.

Sara Custer: All right, talk to you later.

Katherine Knott: Thanks. Bye, Sara.

Share This Article