Ep. 220: Higher Ed After the Midterms: What’s Next?
IHE journalists discuss the future of higher ed policy, new accreditation rules and the Department of Treasury’s threats to colleges’ tax-exempt status.
IHE journalists discuss what they learned from reporting a five-part series on registered apprenticeships.
By IHE Staff
This episode features an Inside Higher Ed newsroom discussion about a five-part series on registered apprenticeships. Underwritten by Ascendium, the six-month project saw the team battling hailstorms in Missouri, visiting factories in upstate New York and embedding themselves with learners on the job in South Carolina. What emerged is a clear picture of the American apprenticeship, distinct from decades-old European models, and how higher ed institutions can play a greater role in these pathways to careers.
Editor in Chief Sara Custer is joined by Colleen Flaherty, senior editor for special content; senior report Sara Weissman; digital producer Justin Morrison; and Johanna Alonso, IHE’s reporter for admissions and enrollment.
Read the full series:
Why and how higher education is leaning into apprenticeships
How apprenticeships and apprentices themselves are changing
A photo essay showing what apprenticeships really look like
Where apprenticeships are benefiting rural learners and their communities
What’s needed to scale apprenticeships
Follow us on Apple Podcasts Spotify
Note: Transcripts may be created with the help of automated tools and lightly edited for clarity.
Sara Custer: Hello and welcome to The Key, Inside Higher Ed’s news and analysis podcast. I’m your host, Sara Custer, editor in chief at Inside Higher Ed, and today’s episode features a cast from IHE’s own newsroom. Colleen Flaherty is our senior editor for special content, Sara Weissman, our senior reporter who also covers workforce development, Justin Morrison, our digital producer, and Johanna Alonso, our admissions and enrollment reporter. They joined me to talk about our five-part series on apprenticeships. Underwritten by Ascendium, this six-month project saw the team battling hailstorms in Missouri, visiting factories in upstate New York and embedding themselves with learners on the job in South Carolina. We discuss what their reporting taught them about this burgeoning postsecondary pathway and what opportunities it holds for higher ed. Hope you enjoy the conversation. Welcome to The Key and welcome to a special Inside Higher Ed newsroom conversation. I am joined by four of Inside Higher Ed’s superstar journalists here with me to talk about a very exciting series that we did about apprenticeships and a little bit of a first one for our newsroom, which was a team effort to tackle a big trend and issue in higher education for lots of reasons that we can get in, that we will get into, but also working in a five-part series so that we can get to the topic from lots of different angles. So, joining us, we have Colleen Flaherty, who is our editor for special content. We have Johanna Alonso, who is our admissions reporter, we have Sara Weissman, who is our senior reporter and also covers workforce development, a variety of different types of institutions, adult learners, micro-credentials. And then we have Justin Morrison, who is our digital producer. Hi, everyone. Welcome to The Key.
Colleen Flaherty: Hello. How are you? Thank you for having us.
Sara Custer: I’m great. And it’s great to have so many people on the podcast today. I’m definitely not going to feel alone in this conversation. It’s not that I ever do, but we’ve got a lot to cover. And there are a lot of you, and I really want to hear from each one of you. So let’s just jump right in. Colleen, I’m going to start with you because you and I started the conversation about this series initially, and we both decided to focus on apprenticeships. But that was really one of your ideas. Do you want to just tell us a little bit about kind of the history of this project and why we decided to focus on apprenticeships?
Colleen Flaherty: Yes. So I think we’re excited generally to assemble a little bit of a dream team here to be able to pursue a deeply reported team project because we had an opportunity with Ascendium, who is our underwriter here. So we aligned on interest and took full lead editorially, but we’re grateful for the support, right? And then I think from there, we were interested in leaning into the alternative pathway conversation, which is very live right now. And then we looked to apprenticeships specifically because it sits at the highest end in a lot of ways of the work-based learning spectrum. And obviously, there’s a lot of energy and urgency around all of that right now. But we also lucked out because 2026, we started talking about this in 2025, has turned out to be a really big year for apprenticeships. So it’s an evergreen topic in the sense that, you know, apprenticeship is ancient, but it’s also a very current one with increasing federal investment and attention. And I think, you know, on recording day today, we just had a headline apart from the series about the Department of Labor putting millions toward apprenticeships. And then also just kind of, you know, other ways that has popped up this year for us. For example, we found in our annual presidents’ survey that 37% of presidents and not just at community colleges at four years as well, though to a slightly lesser degree, are interested in expanding apprenticeship pathways. So that’s, you know, a lot of interest in work-based learning and kind of this being a gold standard there. We wanted to take a deeper dive.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And we were, in addition to the importance that obviously the federal government is putting on apprenticeships, we really saw this as a way to bring higher education into that conversation. We’ve been hearing a lot about workforce readiness and institutions. I think we saw them struggling a little bit to find their way in that. And we saw this kind of binary being set up between either you can go down a workforce development path or you go down a higher education path. And apprenticeships can be that middle ground depending on the model of the apprenticeship, but it can really be an opportunity for people to earn money while they’re learning and in some cases, even work towards a degree whenever they finish their apprenticeship. So I think that was another reason why we’re really interested in focusing on this specifically.
Colleen Flaherty: Yeah, 100%. 100%. I think there’s this idea out there of the big blur between work and education right now. And it can be a way that is very, you know, preserving of the fundamentals and the true mission of higher education. And so, again, it just felt like apprenticeship was a way to explore that, especially with higher education increasingly leaning in in very intentional ways.
Sara Custer: And we decided to come at this from lots of different angles because, in some ways, it’s really exciting because it’s brand new, and there are some really, really interesting examples and case studies that are happening out there, but it’s still quite nascent. So, we were really trying to think about how we educate our audience in exactly what an apprenticeship is. And we go into a little bit of even the nomenclature on that of exchanging terms between apprenticeship and internship, co-op programs, kind of getting into a little bit of that. Looking at this in kind of a global context of what we know that some other countries have very established apprenticeship programs and maybe how those compare to what’s being started in the United States. Colleen, do you want to tell us a little bit about the angles that we took to this?
Colleen Flaherty: Yes, yes, happy to provide this kind of backbone or anatomy of the series here, and then have my wonderful colleagues fill in on their own work later. But so, first and foremost, as you said, we wanted to talk about what apprenticeships really are because to this day, I think there’s a lot of confusion out there. I even had some really well-intentioned people in higher ed lined up to talk to me for this first story about apprenticeship, who very quickly into the conversation started talking about internships, right? And it’s not the same thing because apprenticeships are rooted first and foremost in a full-time job. And we at Inside Higher Ed obviously believe in the entire, you know, full work-based learning spectrum. Everything helps, and we need more of all of it. But we wanted to keep things clean here in the series with a focus on registered apprenticeships, or at least that federally sanctioned framework for apprenticeships. There are some quality assurances there for the apprentice, even if it does introduce some rigidity, which I think maybe Johanna or Sara or others can talk about later into the model, especially when you’re trying to expand into new pathways. So that was the first story right there: what apprenticeships are and why higher ed is increasingly leaning into them. And then, next, for the second story of this five-part series, we wanted to talk about how apprenticeships and apprentices themselves are diversifying beyond traditional construction type trades to fields like teaching. That’s a big one, healthcare, another big one, professional services, even AI. And then, like, advanced manufacturing was another one that we looked at, which is kind of like a bridge between older and newer there on apprenticeship. You know, and that’s because stereotypes about apprenticeships definitely persist, and there are a lot of opportunities for higher ed in these new areas as well. And then, on for the third piece, we knew that we wanted to do something really visual here to make it multimedia to help people really understand what apprenticeships can look like day to day. And that’s where our wonderful jack of many trades, Justin Morrison, came in, which he’ll talk about. And then on the fourth piece, thinking about that, we knew we wanted to focus on how apprenticeships can pose particular challenges, but also reap major benefits in rural communities. That’s another conversation that’s really live right now, rural learners. You know, just because there may be critical or there often are critical workforce shortages in certain rural areas and then lower engagement with higher education and just general lower opportunity. And that’s really a strong area for apprenticeship because that’s where they thrive, where they’re solving for multiple problems at once. And then finally, we knew that we needed a policy-oriented, forward-looking piece about what apprenticeships really need to scale here in the U.S. because they’re growing, but they’re not scaling per se. They’re kind of hovering at around 700,000 registered active apprentices right now, according to the federal dashboard. And that’s even amid increasing federal investment. And I think the spoiler there, sorry, Johanna, there’s a lot more to say, but based on what’s worked elsewhere in the world is that if you build it, they will come. That is not just if you throw money at it in an ad hoc way, right? But if you build a trustworthy system or systems, I guess, because the U.S. is complicated relative to somewhere like Switzerland, right, where apprenticeships have really scaled well. Because this is just a very long-term investment for everyone involved. So trust and reliability and kind of long-term thinking is key to scale.
Sara Custer: Okay, let’s get into the different angles that we took for each story. Colleen, you did our inaugural piece, you kicked us off. Remind us again, I know you just ran through all the different angles that we took for this series, but remind us again what that first one is and how you developed your reporting on that piece.
Colleen Flaherty: Sure. Okay, so the first article, as I mentioned, really focused on defining apprenticeship, and it really comes down again to having a full-time job and critical engagement with an employer. If you’re the training partner or the sponsor, and then layering in training and mentorship and support that’s going to allow an apprentice to master a highly skilled occupation within a year to a few years, depending on the field. And ideally, the pathway is debt-free. That’s the design out there, what apprenticeship should be. And the end credential is portable nationally, again, ideally, hopefully. And as for why higher education is leaning in, which was that second piece of the first article, it just makes a ton of sense. It’s an incredible, maybe the ultimate affordability unlock for the learner. And of course, obviously, affordability is top of mind right now. And then the workforce relevance, another very live issue across higher education and then culture generally is undeniable since it is literally, again, a job, right, with training layered on. And not all apprenticeships end in degrees. As you said, most don’t at this point. But degree apprenticeships that have a degree built into the structure, the training structure, are taking off, especially in these newer fields that we’ve already talked a little bit about. And a lot of the colleges that are acting as sponsors and/or training partners here are finding ways to offer apprentices credit toward an eventual degree, even if it’s not an apprenticeship degree, should they choose to pursue one. And I think that’s really important because the optimist view here, you know, it’s about opportunity and it’s about abundance. So, like, someone like Sonya Christensen, who we talked to, a Christian, excuse me, Chancellor of California Community Colleges, who I believe you’ve also had on the pod, yeah, that more pathways into higher ed will bring a net increase of learners into higher ed. So, you might come in as an apprentice, you might, you know, continue on later as someone getting an advanced degree, right? Which kind of leads me into the second article, which I co-wrote with our wonderful senior reporter colleague here, Sara Weissman, about how apprenticeships are expanding again into new areas and how, with that diversification of fields, apprentices themselves are diversifying in terms of age and race and gender. And the upshot there is that higher ed is really well positioned. This is something that really stuck out to me, and kind of like the meta signal of that story for me: it’s how well higher ed is positioned to be thinking about how apprenticeship can really lead to real opportunity as defined by this widely cited family-sustaining wage standard that you hear in conversations about apprenticeship and just opportunity generally these days. Because there is a risk potentially with apprenticeships expanding that quality could suffer. And the UK has seen a little bit of this in some of their efforts. But colleges versus potential other kinds of training partners or just employers purely are again in the business of thinking about opportunity. Not to mention they’re used to managing a lot of funding and administrative complexity, which is part of this world, right? But just for example, on gender specifically, for example, we found in that second story something interesting that when we were looking at apprenticeship outcomes, women’s hourly wage after completing an apprenticeship was $22. Then that was substantially higher than for women with some college and no credential or even an associate degree. But it was well below the $32 an hour rate for men. And so why is that? And looking deeper into the data, we found that efforts to expand apprenticeship opportunities for women have been most successful in lower-paying fields, or maybe more accurately, in lower-paying positions and nontraditional fields. So the largest apprentice occupation for women is nurse assistant, which doesn’t pay that well, versus electrician for men, which does pay well and meets that family-sustaining wage standard, right? And also Black and multiracial apprenticeship completers, women face the largest gaps compared to white men. So, you know, all of the things that higher ed traditionally is, you know, concerned about and attuned to thinking about. And another reason, right, where higher ed could really help lead as apprenticeships continue to expand and scale on helping build additional steps into these pathways, especially in a tiered field like nursing for those apprentices who maybe started as a nurse assistant but want to continue on into their careers. Yeah, and then just in terms of my reporting, I did not have a lot of background reporting on apprenticeships before this. So I really needed to like understand what this was before I was supposed to tell our readers. So I talked to maybe 30 different people, at least really anyone who would talk to me from longtime apprenticeship advocates that people like Apprenticeships for America to people in higher ed even launching new programs and, you know, the kind of trials and tribulations and triumphs that come with that. And when I think of that first article and just ultimately great sources for me and for us, I think of somebody like Minah Woo, who’s vice president of workforce innovation at Howard Community College in Maryland, who said, you know, that she encountered some initial skepticism when she started a trade apprenticeship, first one in 2018. Like, would this kind of program take hold in one of the nation’s most affluent counties? And so she had planned for just five apprentices in that first HVAC cohort. And she got 24 the first time around. And today, it’s just the program has grown. And Woo says that the college is training hundreds of apprentices in the skilled trades and in newer fields, like construction management, licensed practical nursing, surgical technology, professional child care, information technology and accounting. And I think we actually wrote some cybersecurity as well. We’ve written about that, which is a really rich and interesting field, especially outside of D.C., right? And something cool about apprenticeship is that in a field like where if you’re working with federal, you know, as a contractor and you need, for example, a security clearance, you can work as an apprenticeship while you’re working toward that, right? So just all kinds of benefits that diverge and differ into different fields. But the apprenticeship is linked with retention and kind of this grow your own ethic as well. And then just going back to another great source for that first story, I think of Joe Ross as well, president of Reach University, who helped put this moment in context, which is kind of another thing we tried to do in the first story by saying that, quote, the story of this century will be that the workplace is going to become the college campus and that higher education is going to become work embedded at scale. And end quote. And who knows really if he’s right, but it’s a very interesting idea. And I think it’s plausible given how live the entire higher education/workforce environment, you know, et cetera, is right now.
Sara Custer: And I think it just speaks to what you quoted Sonya saying, and I think you also said it earlier, Colleen, is just those pathways to higher education, that even if these programs aren’t leading directly to a degree, if you’re able to give students credit for that, then maybe that is something that they can come back to after they’ve spent some time in the workforce because of the apprenticeship that they’ve taken. And it’s another way for colleges to extend that lifelong learning relationship that they have with these students. I want to get to the other people, Colleen, but I wonder if there is just, you mentioned that you didn’t have a background in apprenticeship reporting. And with the exception of Sara, probably everyone on this call didn’t either. It’s not a natural place that Inside Higher Ed has really sat in our reporting. What’s one thing that you’ve learned in your work on this series?
Colleen Flaherty: Let’s see. I mean, I think I’ve said a lot already. So, yeah, I guess one thing that I would say is that we got some feedback when this initial story came out, like a lot of traction, which we were really happy about. But some pushback: Apprenticeships are fantastic, but they’re not going to work everywhere for everyone. And that, I mean, we definitely are not trying to say that. We’re trying to say that apprenticeships are a solution, not the solution. But I do think there’s a lot of promise around apprenticeship in terms of scaling apprenticeship opportunities for would-be apprentices who want that pathway. And then I think this is really key, just teaching higher ed in general about working with employers to design meaningful work-based learning opportunities like across the spectrum, whether that’s something smaller and more contained, like project-based learning or internships, which we all know we need more of, right? And I think that there are, you know, financial, political and cultural imperatives right now forcing more again of that kind of an ecosystems approach to postsecondary opportunity broadly, working across sectors and finding new ways to braid funds, right? Especially as we enter this OBBBA era, right? I think those skills are going to come in really handy. And apprenticeship is really just the kind of tip of the spear. So it’s a fascinating lens, I guess, on everything happening in and to higher ed right now.
Sara Custer: Yeah. Sara, I would love to hear from you for, let’s just start with kind of the co-reporting you did with Colleen for our apprenticeship revolution. And you were really looking at trying to get it, showing our readers that these programs exist beyond just the construction and the trades, that there are some apprenticeships, programs that are focusing on different workforce areas. Tell us a little bit about your reporting there.
Sara Weissman: Yeah, so I worked on some of the case studies for that story and was really interested in sort of the breadth of where apprenticeship has gone. I think we very traditionally think about apprenticeship as construction, plumbing, electricians, and really, you know, while it continues to be very important to those fields, I got to sit down and talk to, you know, apprentices who were studying to be behavioral health specialists, many with their own recovery stories and their own sort of winding paths to how they had arrived at that model and higher education via that model. I focused on Aon, which is an insurance company that felt like they were having, you know, they wanted a retention tool. They wanted to attract workers who, you know, hadn’t necessarily earned a college degree. And they provided sort of a pathway to an associate degree through this apprenticeship program where they had folks working with them full-time and real opportunities to continue working with them afterwards. So yeah, so I think that was the biggest thing I learned was just how broad apprenticeship is now and how it’s really expanding into these new fields.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And you brought up a really good point there, how the employers who are partnering with higher education institutions on these programs, they really see it kind of getting their perspective on this and the fact that they see this as a way to cultivate talent, to invest in the talent that they’ve already got there as a retention tool for the employees that they already have.
Sara Weissman: Yeah, absolutely. And they found it to be pretty effective. You know, it’s a real investment in the worker. And I think, you know, the worker feels invested in.
Sara Custer: Yeah. Sara, you also went to Missouri to speak to some educators on a teacher training program. Tell us about, so this is now kind of shifting into our apprenticeship for rural communities. Tell us about what that story focused on.
Sara Weissman: Yeah, so my story focused on apprenticeship as an engine of socioeconomic mobility for rural and underserved communities and also sort of the very real challenges those communities are up against in trying to stand up these programs and what higher ed can do about it, how higher ed can sort of step in and help. And yeah, as a part of that, I tried to sort of hone in on a couple case studies that would give me a glimpse into different kinds of rural communities and how apprenticeship was having a real impact there. So that took me to rural Missouri where I visited Missouri State University’s Pathways for Paraprofessionals program. They’re training special education teachers across the state, but really it’s designed for rural learners in some unique ways. And it also took me to Central New York sort of Rust Belt area to visit a manufacturing apprenticeship program, which is more of a sort of classic field for apprenticeship, but they were doing some kind of innovative things to be, you know, to be really supporting the learners that they had. So it was a great experience. I talked to apprentices, employers, sponsors, instructors, really everyone who had a piece in these programs.
Sara Custer: And I think because it is rural communities, those opportunities for them to launch careers and get trained for a long-term career are less or are different from what it would be from people in more urban areas. And I think the people you spoke to to that piece, you really highlighted the human stories of the people who were on these programs. And I think what shone through a lot was just the opportunity that it was giving them that they couldn’t find elsewhere in their community. Do you want to tell us a little bit about what it was like speaking to people who are actually on those programs?
Sara Weissman: Yeah, I mean, I think I really enjoyed having the opportunity to sit down and just, you know, ask apprentices, you know, what was your career and education trajectory that got you here? You know, why this model? What is it about this that works for you? And I think one of the themes that came up over and over and over again is, you know, a lot of them had either not considered college or had been to some college and life got in the way and their academic confidence was shot. And this model where they were kind of in this supportive environment of their full-time work and getting to kind of go to class in that structure was really helpful for them. And I think especially a lot of them were very hands-on learners that, you know, being able to see how their lessons were applying on the job the very next day really kept them motivated and kept them moving through. And so I met a lot of people who I think you know, hadn’t seen a degree as something that was in their future who were either pursuing a degree or sort of flirting with the idea because you know they had this structure around them. So I, yeah, I got to talk to a lot of people about versions of that experience.
Sara Custer: And is there one thing that stands out for you that you learned in your reporting for this project?
Sara Weissman: Yeah, I think my perspective on what is a successful rural apprenticeship really changed over the course of this project. I think when I started looking for examples of successful programs that I wanted to visit and spend time in, I was looking for, you know, programs that had churned out hundreds of apprentices. I was looking for robust programs, big size. And what rural apprenticeship experts sort of told me over and over again was that’s not necessarily what a rural community needs. You know, sometimes you need an apprenticeship program that’s going to invest in that one special education teacher in that one town of 700 that doesn’t have a single one. You need an apprenticeship program that’s going to graduate five construction workers because that’s enough to saturate the market. And then, you know, focus on getting 10 plumbers the next year. And it’s really more about programs that are really tailored to the communities that they’re in. So I think, you know, my ideas about impact and what it meant to be an impactful program really changed.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And what comes with that are specific challenges as well, right? Because a lot of work goes into these programs. But if you’re only graduating five people because that’s what the market demands and maybe that changes for the next year, it creates a whole different host of problems for these rural apprenticeship programs.
Sara Weissman: Yeah, absolutely. And I think also it creates a challenge for higher ed. I remember talking to Jon Turner at Missouri State. The program is kind of his baby. And he was saying, look, it doesn’t always make financial sense for a higher ed institution to invest in that one teacher in that one town, but the impact is so huge that it’s worth it. And the other thing I sort of heard over and over again was, you know, this brings in a pipeline of students that may have never stepped through your doors. So yes, maybe you’re investing a lot, but you’re going to maybe get a lifelong learner who otherwise wouldn’t have come here.
Sara Custer: Right. Yeah, you’re reaching somebody who wouldn’t have crossed your threshold otherwise.
Sara Weissman: Absolutely.
Sara Custer: Thanks, Sara. Justin, you also had the opportunity to go work face-to-face and speak face-to-face with people on apprenticeships for our photo essay for this series. Tell us a little bit about who you spoke to, where you went.
Justin Morrison: So, a lot of my work was at the time I was living in Charleston, South Carolina, and a lot of my work was done in conjunction with Trident Technical College. And they have a very large apprenticeship program. And through working through them and talking with them, I was able to connect with several different apprentices across different fields and different interests and build out my photo story that focusing on getting to places, talking to them, seeing the different settings, seeing the different locations and really trying to capture the breadth of workplaces and differences that these apprenticeship opportunities extended to people.
Sara Custer: You followed a student on a pharmacy apprenticeship. There was another one that was working in automotive. Tell us a little bit about the different industries that these apprenticeships were working in.
Justin Morrison: Yeah, the fields I covered briefly were a mechatronics class, which I believe is the correct way to say it, which is a field completely new to me. I had no idea about it. Entering that classroom is a completely different environment of stuff I’d never seen and heard of before. So it was definitely interesting to see and see what that environment is like and the people in that space. I spent some time with an auto mechanic and he was just starting his apprenticeship and was really just kind of doing typical back of the shop stuff, but was rapidly working his way through. And that whole program was designed to teach him a lot of stuff once again on the job. I spent some time with a chef and he was doing all kinds of different things. And the day I focused in on him, he was doing a lot of pastry work and they extended out into like their other community too. And it was interesting to find that like even within restaurant work, there’s lots of stuff where it’s like, it’s not, he wasn’t just working for a restaurant. The restaurant was doing lots of things for other parts of the community, creating products that were sold at other shops and stuff like that. So it wasn’t just like in the kitchen learning one specific thing. It’s learning lots of different things and stretching out those different capabilities and learning those things. I also spent some time with a pharmacy technician. She was working with the University of South Carolina Medical Center at a pharmacy. And again, it’s just a very different kind of program. This was very much so like hands-on. She’s going through the medications, finding stuff, logging things and then working with her team there. You know, the thing that I noticed that was very interesting is most of these people were just working. There’s definitely guidance, there’s definitely hands-on motivation, but I think for the bulk of their time, they were doing their tasks. You know, I’m standing there in the background, I’m photographing them, but they’re just working. They’re doing their thing.
Sara Custer: You also went to an apprenticeship fair, if that’s the right term. Tell us a little bit about that. And I guess what kind of people were at the fair, both trying to attract students, but then the people who are interested in apprenticeships.
Justin Morrison: Yeah, apprenticeship fair, job fair, they kind of brokered it as a kind of a bit of both. And so part of it was the one thing they had there, they have a very large youth apprenticeship program. So part of the focus of this type of job fair was also trying to get high school students interested in different career trajectories that weren’t just typical college. So their focus at that specifically was a little different. And then additionally, you know, it was interesting to see a setting that is attracting a lot of different people, a lot of people at different spots of their lives that are like transitioning from certain types of work environments or wanting to transition to something new or just explore other opportunities. And the thing that I heard from the college, a lot of like, these are also really exciting opportunities for these job providers. It gives them a chance to meet people, it gives them a chance to build out their programs. It also gives them a chance to sort of stay within the local communities. A lot of the, I mean, even at Trident Tech, some of the instructors that I met, they were former apprentices themselves through those same programs. And these companies wanted them to come in and help teach these programs for them. And I found that interesting as well. That was kind of like a cycle that they brought this person up and learned. And they’re like, we need you to go teach this new group of people so that we could bring them back up to the same program.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And tell us about the graduation.
Justin Morrison: It was cute. It was their first, it was their inaugural graduation. They had an old school punch card clocking machine. And as like people went through the program, whether they were creating credentials or they were moving on to a new stage, this was just a chance for them to be celebrated by their family and their community. And, you know, it’s a lot of fun to see to see a lot of some younger students go up to this machine that they had never seen before and try to figure out how to get this punch card thing to work. But, you know, it was fun. It was a lot of fun to see just, you know, so many smiling faces, so many people happy to be through the program. And, you know, the keynote speaker ended up being one of the apprentices that I had gone and photographed. So it was fun to sort of see him close his journey out there.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And is there anything that you took away from this, something that you learned from spending time with these apprentices?
Justin Morrison: I mean, on one side, it’s just, it’s interesting to see so many people just like dedicated to like, I’m learning this thing. This is the thing I want to do. This is the thing I’m figuring out and pursue it. I also, I admire like just the physicality of things of like people figuring out how to do stuff with their own mind, their own hands, and getting out there and getting it done. And that’s sort of what I saw in a lot of the stuff of people just doing things. And as a photographer, it’s always more fun to photograph people doing things.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And what did they think about you being there? I mean, I suspect they probably didn’t think that they were going to be the subject of a photo essay, but what was their response to you being in their space and photographing their work?
Justin Morrison: I think as with any photo assignment, it’s about time and comfortability. The longer I’m sitting there, the more I blend into the background, the more people just kind of forget about me. I do think the situation was a little bit easier because a lot of these people were working and like I’m there and I’m doing stuff, but they have something they have to get done. This is their task for the day. And me being there has nothing to do with the task. They have work. So to some extent, it was just kind of blending into the background a little bit more and just kind of documenting the experience.
Sara Custer: Yeah. All right, Johanna. So you did the final story for us in this series and you were really looking at the policy environment and kind of what’s needed to scale this and make it a really impactful model for the U.S. sector. Tell us a little bit more about what your story focused on.
Johanna Alonso: Yeah, so we sort of envisioned it as, I think from the beginning, as sort of like what folks’ wish lists would be for policy changes. And that is what we ended up titling the article was “The Apprenticeship Wish List.” And yeah, so my plan was to essentially talk with folks in the space, researchers and advocates, about the question that I, or the way I phrased it for everyone was in like a dreamland where you can have whatever you want, what would you choose to have policy-wise to reach that 1 million apprentice goal? And yeah, I got very, very different answers. They were all in a somewhat similar space. Everyone said money would be great, but they all had different images of where they would spend that money first if they really did have sort of like these unlimited funds. And then there was also a lot of interest in some other areas, such as how to evaluate quality, how to evaluate students’ progress. For example, how to entice employers to participate. There was a lot of talk about how employer buy-in is maybe one of the biggest barriers to starting new apprenticeship programs. So lots of different people speculating on how they would get that employer buy-in. And also a lot of people said, I don’t know exactly what my dream would be. My dream would maybe be to figure out a problem, figure out that employer incentive issue. You know, I think it was, oh goodness, let me real quick remember who I’m thinking of. Thank you. It was Taylor Maag from Jobs for the Future. I believe Maag is how it’s pronounced, M-A-A-G. She sort of said, like, one of her dreams would be to solve this employer issue. Her phrasing was, find the tried and true solution on employer engagement. So yes, some of these dreams were actually solving a problem, figuring out the best method for something rather than I want to institute my method, which I thought was a good way to think about it. And on a similar note, a lot of several people talked about data and sort of the fact that right now the federal government does not track a ton about apprenticeships. They don’t track job outcomes on a wide scale. And so it can be hard to tell what exactly is working and what exactly we should invest in. And so there was a lot of interest in expanding that. It is very, very wide-ranging. I got a lot of different responses. And I was very happy about that because it, although, you know, maybe to some extent it’s a little disappointing that there isn’t one perfect solution that everyone would go for if given the opportunity, it was interesting to hear that there are a lot of different avenues we could go down to make these incremental improvements. So I found that really interesting.
Sara Custer: Yeah, and it’s worth mentioning that the 1 million apprenticeship number came from the president’s executive order on apprenticeships early in his second term, early 2025 at some point. I can’t remember exactly when he signed that executive order. So yeah, I think it was really important that we get into that to see exactly what the mechanisms are to try to make that a reality. I wasn’t surprised to see that a lot of people said money, but it was also about infrastructure as well, right? Can you tell us a little bit about that?
Johanna Alonso: Yes, absolutely. Lots of people were talking about infrastructure and using the term in a pretty broad way, I think, to sort of describe all sorts of structures and systems that would improve the broader apprenticeship system in this country. So that includes things like those incentives for employers. It also includes those wraparound supports that I think Colleen talked about earlier and that also including mentors and instructors. Instructors was an issue that came up. I actually went back and spoke with two people that Colleen and Sara had previously spoken with for previous articles. So that was Jonathan Woodward from Mississippi Gulf Coast Community College and Jon Turner from Missouri State University. And I believe it was Jonathan Woodward who was talking about how it’s hard to find good instructors or not good instructors, hard to find instructors, qualified instructors, because they’re people from the companies, from the employers, and you’re sort of taking them away from that work to train the apprentices. And that was something that he talked about being maybe the biggest barrier or the biggest challenge for his specific institution. And he talked about a vision that he had, which had to do with legislation that he actually did propose draft and propose in the Mississippi legislature that would have provided a tax credit to companies who, you know, allowed their employees to serve as apprenticeship instructors. And the tax credit would be worth the employee’s salary. It sounded very well thought out, but unfortunately didn’t take off this year in the legislature. But yeah, I think all of these different factors of just setting up good systems that address real on-the-ground problems, like instructors, getting qualified instructors to participate, getting wraparound supports for students, which includes all sorts of things, transportation to the institution. But the infrastructure question and the money question are very, very, very intertwined because a lot of these things I think that institutions have a good idea of how they would want to go about it. They don’t have the funding for it. Again, this is something that Jonathan Woodward and Jon Turner both talked about: just sort of having concepts of what would really help their students, but it costing more than you might think to actually make those things happen. Let me, yeah, it was Jon Turner who was talking about how so many of their apprentices are mothers coming back to the workforce after their kids are in school. And a lot of them just don’t have a ton of experience with different technologies and, you know, the technologies where they turn their coursework in. And he was basically talking about how they ended up sort of needing more just individuals to be able to help those apprentices when they ran into technological roadblocks than they really anticipated being an issue at all. So again, the institutions have a very good concept of the unique challenges the students face and the unique wraparound supports they might need. It costs money to employ people and just, you know, put those ideas into practice. So infrastructure, big issue, but definitely very much hand in hand with the money question.
Sara Custer: Yeah. Is there anything that stands out for you as something that you learned in your reporting, Johanna?
Johanna Alonso: I learned so much. I’m one of the people you referenced earlier who apprenticeships is not, was not really something I knew about very much at all before we started this series. And then, of course, I had the pleasure of reading Colleen’s, Sara’s and Justin’s fabulous reporting before I had to jump into mine. No, everything that I’ve already said is already something that I learned, but something else that was really interesting to me was sort of the relationship between apprenticeships and other parts of the workforce ecosystem. This is something several people talked about: you know, the Trump administration is very excited about apprenticeships, but there are other places they are maybe cutting from or considering cutting from the larger workforce ecosystem. And folks were basically telling me that even if those things seem siloed or seem different, and it seems like you can make cuts to one and still advocate for apprenticeships, they were very much of the opinion that any cuts to the workforce ecosystem are going to have a negative impact on growing apprenticeships. And even things outside of the workforce ecosystem, sort of like foundational math skills or reading and writing skills, programs that are designed to help adults with those skills are major for apprenticeships because you do need those skills to go into the majority of apprenticeship programs. And so, yeah, basically, just learning about the extremely interconnected workforce ecosystem of our country was really, really interesting. And of course, writing about higher ed, we all know how much different areas of the higher ed ecosystem touch each other and interact with each other and have consequences for each other. So, it certainly made a lot of sense once people started talking about this. But I found it really, really interesting.
Sara Custer: Yeah, it is that ecosystem. And I think, Colleen, you’re the one that said it, postsecondary opportunities. And so, yes, it totally makes sense that there is an ecosystem there, and this isn’t just a siloed program or pathway into getting higher education credits or a career. Okay, so I think we’ve established that apprenticeships was not a natural home for Inside Higher Ed before we started this project. But I’m curious to know how anyone’s perspective has maybe changed about apprenticeships, kind of what you thought about it going in and how that’s shifted after the work that you’ve done. Anyone?
Colleen Flaherty: I can jump in.
Sara Custer: Colleen.
Colleen Flaherty: I learned that I actually probably am an apprenticeship completer myself, and I had no idea. My first job out of college was to be a teacher in New York City. And in the program, I earned a master’s degree in education at the same time. And it just never occurred to me that that was a degree apprenticeship until I learned about all the different kinds of apprenticeships that there are, including youth apprenticeships, as Justin mentioned, some of which can be registered apprenticeships, and then degree apprenticeships as well. And this was confirmed to me by Joe Ross at Reach University that, yes, you probably did do that. And so it just, it was kind of interesting. Again, just, you know, these things are out there and they work. And I hesitate to mention that a little bit because obviously I didn’t stay in the field. I’m now here at Inside Higher Ed as a journalist, right? I’m not a teacher in New York City anymore. But I mean, I like to think that, you know, it certainly was a meaningful learning opportunity for me. I think I filled a workforce, you know, community-based need at the time for a while I was doing it. It taught me a lot. It’s always something I could potentially return to. And I’m sort of still on the periphery, you know, of that world reporting on education. And so, yeah, that would be my very specific takeaway.
Sara Custer: Yeah, interesting. And, you know, yes, you’re a journalist, but you’re still a journalist within the world of education. So I’m sure your experience on that program certainly informs how you think about higher education and the knowledge that you’ve got for the sector. Any other perspectives that shifted in this project?
Sara Weissman: I think that even as someone who covers workforce education, I feel like I fall, you know, party to the trap of thinking of traditional higher education and workforce development as very separate sometimes. And I think that this project really reframed apprenticeship for me as sort of part of the adult learner space. You know, the average apprentice is in their 30s, I believe. And I, you know, met a lot of apprentices who were kind of using this model as a career switch, who were using it as something that would work with having to have a full-time job, having a family, being rooted in a place and not necessarily being, especially in rural communities, not being able to necessarily drive to a campus. They wanted their education to kind of be where they are rooted and where they are. And so I think it was just a little bit of a mind shift. And also thinking about how the design of apprenticeship programs and especially the instruction portion sort of has to be aligned with that student. It has to be sort of designed for an adult learner, designed for someone who’s place bound. So yeah, I think that was a perspective shift for me.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And that really addresses a lot of the issues that we talk about all the time with higher education is providing students the support that they need, meeting them where they are, thinking about the adult learner and their needs, addressing the affordability issue, allowing students to take care of all of their other responsibilities outside of what they’re learning and really facilitating that learning by pairing it with a job where they’re able to still earn a wage while they’re getting higher education credit. So it really, whenever it works well, I think it hits a lot of those issues and really addresses a lot of those that a lot of institutions are still grappling with.
Sara Weissman: Yeah, absolutely. And there’s probably a lot for maybe traditional higher ed to learn from some of the creativity that apprenticeship programs are showing and how they serve those learners.
Sara Custer: Yeah. Justin, you were going to say something.
Justin Morrison: One of the things that I found very interesting was just how much of it is hands-on learning and learning through doing. As a learner myself, that’s how I learned things, even when I was in college and beginning the process of trying it. And seeing so many people just actually doing the work and learning through doing the work is just very interesting. And I think a very different approach to how people learn things sometimes that could have been conducive to me in a lot of different environments had I just been given an opportunity to try out stuff and experiment with things.
Colleen Flaherty: Right. Right. Justin, I was just going to say, I’m so glad earlier in the conversation, I had been wanting to say that. I’m so glad you circled back to that because through what you were saying and what Sara was saying, and a lot of what I’ve sort of been thinking about maybe more implicitly throughout this series and other things that we do is that, you know, what we’ve talked a lot about workforce, we’ve talked a lot about this ecosystems, you know, imperative that higher education, you know, is facing right now. I feel like what gets lost a lot in this work-based learning conversation is like the pedagogy of it, right? And I’m not talking about like learning styles and, you know, whether or not they’ve been disproven, right? I mean, there is so, like, specific learning styles, there is so much research out there that show it showing that people learn by doing, you know, that students are more engaged when they feel like their work, their, you know, course content is directly relevant to their lives, right? So I think that there is, you know, whether it ends up being an apprenticeship or not, kind of going back to this tip of the spear, what can be learned broadly kind of point that I was trying to make before, that there really is like a pedagogical conversation to be had here around apprenticeship and like, you know, how students learn best and how they want to learn, as evidenced by, you know, a lot of data, including our own student voice surveys, right? You know, immediately relevant seeming content is consistently pings very high on how students say that their academic success could be improved.
Johanna Alonso: If I could also just share something that I learned or I thought was especially interesting. I really enjoyed reading, especially in my colleagues’ articles, just about folks at institutions who just decided to start these programs. I mean, so much, we hear so much in our reporting about things starting just because a professor or a staff member thought they would be valuable. And that is one of the beautiful things about higher ed: that there is so much flexibility for folks to just use their knowledge and what they see as a need. And we are so lucky that we have a higher ed landscape where sometimes those people can go to their administrators and say, I have kind of a crazy idea, can I do it? And that’s true of so many things in higher ed. And we talk about this all the time. And it’s awesome that it’s extended to, or that it extends to apprenticeships. That’s, you know, constantly working at Inside Higher Ed. We hear about things like this where a professor has started an initiative or a project, and it’s just like incredibly cool that they had the opportunity to do that. So, of course, I shouldn’t be shocked at all that it extended to apprenticeships. But especially talking with Jon Turner with that Pathways for Paraeducators program, that’s where it sort of sunk in for me, just that folks can see that sort of need and step in and try something cool. So, I think that is one thing that sort of speaks to why higher ed is such a great home for apprenticeship programs, and also it is just something that is such a strike to me as very neat and makes me happy. So, yeah.
Sara Custer: Yeah, and we also saw that with the woman at Howard Community College. She started the HVAC program and thought it would serve five. It started with 24. And then, all of, I think you said in your story, Colleen, that her colleagues were maybe a little bit skeptical of it, maybe because it was an affluent community, but now she’s got people knocking down her door to be part of it.
Colleen Flaherty: Right. And I think, kind of going back to what you said and what Johanna said, this is something that can start with, you know, individual change makers and really maybe going against the tide a little bit, but really lead to change broadly at their own institutions. I mean, like I said, her programs have scaled now to beyond the traditional trades, to hundreds of students, and beyond the institution to change higher education, what it is, who it serves and where it’s going, which is, again, one of those really live questions right now. Sure. And that kind of gets into, it all kind of tumbles into like the trust question as well, and this being a bipartisan issue and like community engagement and that return on investment. It all always comes back around to this, I feel, in a lot of our conversations. But always the T word, although I didn’t mention VUCA today, Sara. I meant it.
Sara Custer: You’re just going to have to read this story.
Colleen Flaherty: It’s implicit. It’s implicit. It’s the underlying context for all of this.
Sara Custer: Okay, final question for everyone. We’ve kind of touched on it just now, but anything that you think people in higher ed should know about apprenticeships? Sara Weissman, do you want to start?
Sara Weissman: Yeah, I mean, this might seem simple, but just that they can do it, they can get involved. I think, you know, we, I forget as a part of which story, we looked at an Apprenticeships for America study that found that, you know, about 500 community and technical colleges had registered apprenticeships, only about 200 had active apprentices. And that’s a small fraction of higher ed. I feel like this is picking up steam, but still, you know, so many aren’t necessarily looking at apprenticeship as something to get involved in. And like Colleen said, you know, it’s a solution. It’s not the solution. It’s not going to work for every institution. But I think, especially at a time when we’re really questioning, or there is a lot of questioning of sort of the value of higher education, ROI, especially very sort of connected to is this going to get me a good job. Having higher ed on the job makes a lot of sense and is a pretty compelling value proposition. So that would be my one plug is that it’s worth exploring for more higher ed institutions. And there’s now potentially money on the table. Not potentially, I mean, Colleen mentioned the story we’ve got out today of the Department of Labor pouring millions of dollars into apprenticeship programs at different institutions. There’s money on the table there. So there’s an opportunity to get some initial lease investment in these programs to get them off the ground.
Sara Custer: Yeah. And you mentioned, I mean, at a sort of politically polarizing time for higher ed, you know, this is a bipartisan issue. Everyone seems to like apprenticeship. So there’s something to be said for investing in that.
Sara Weissman: Sure.
Sara Custer: Any other lessons for higher education around apprenticeships that you would like to share? Johanna, you look like you’re about to say something.
Johanna Alonso: My thinking face. I think that just going off of what I just said a moment ago about, you know, these individual people having these big ideas and bringing them forward. I think that it is interesting to maybe ask yourself. I mean, again, Jon Turner, he’s a professor of special education, Jon Turner at Missouri State is. And this is something where he saw a need in his field and thought, you know, realized through, you know, just thinking about solutions that apprenticeships were a strong way forward. So, I mean, you know, it obviously is very dependent on the field and the community, but it is just something for individuals in all sorts of fields to have in their toolbox if they are thinking about solutions to workforce problems in their communities. Like, nothing says that you can’t use apprenticeships as a tool for addressing your workforce needs, no matter, as we learned from Howard Community College, no matter where you are and no matter what your position in the institution is. If this is a problem that you as a professor or staff member at an institution are thinking about for your field and your community, I just think it’s something to have in your toolbox and to remember that you don’t need some sort of special credential or skill to put forth this solution, to put forth apprenticeships as a solution for your community, if that makes sense.
Sara Custer: Yeah. Well, that’s a great note to end on. Thank you all for your work on this series, and thank you all for coming on The Key today to tell us a little bit about your reporting. I will, of course, link to every piece in the notes for this episode and on the article page. And you can find all of them on insidehighered.com. Thank you all. It’s good to see you. Oh, and I want to say one last thing. We had a fifth reporter on the job with us. We had baby Weissman. He did an excellent job. And just hats off to him. Hard hats off to him.
Sara Weissman: Critical to my reporting process.
Sara Custer: Yes. He was with you in the rainstorms in rural Missouri.
Sara Weissman: Yeah, the hailstorm. That’s true. Yes. The both of us survived a hailstorm. It was, you know, his first reporting trip. So very exciting.
Sara Custer: Yes, the first of many. What a stud. What an ace. And we just wish you very, very well as you pursue motherhood and your leave coming up. And it’s just been a pleasure working with all of you guys on this.
Sara Weissman: Yes.
Sara Custer: All right. Thanks, everyone. Talk to you soon.
IHE journalists discuss the future of higher ed policy, new accreditation rules and the Department of Treasury’s threats to colleges’ tax-exempt status.
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success discusses how colleges can navigate AI while supporting students’ intellectual, personal and professional development.
The history behind tech transfer in the U.S. and why it could be under threat.
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success discusses the importance of embedding career readiness throughout college.
Log in to manage your newsletter preferences.