Ep. 219: Voices of Student Success: What Is the Purpose of College in the Age of AI?
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success discusses how colleges can navigate AI while supporting students’ intellectual, personal and professional development.
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success explores why students stop out and what colleges can do to help them return.
By Joshua Bay
In this episode of Voices of Student Success, Inside Higher Ed’s podcast series exploring what really shapes students’ experiences, Terah Crews, chief executive officer of ReUp Education, joins IHE’s student success reporter, Joshua Bay.
While many students stop out before earning a credential, they often plan to return. Yet re-enrolling can prove just as challenging as enrolling in the first place. As colleges look to re-enroll adults with some college but no credential, they are rethinking how they support students whose educational journeys aren’t linear. Terah and Joshua discuss why students stop out, what motivates them to return, the barriers colleges still place in their way and what it will take to build institutions that truly serve today’s adult learners.
Follow us on Apple Podcasts Spotify
Note: Transcripts may be created with the help of automated tools and lightly edited for clarity.
Joshua Bay: Hi there, and welcome to Voices of Student Success, Inside Higher Ed’s podcast series exploring what really shapes students’ experiences. From mental health to workforce readiness to artificial intelligence, we bring you the stories, research and perspectives helping educators, policymakers and higher ed leaders better understand what drives student success today. I’m your host, Joshua Bay, student success reporter at Inside Higher Ed. Thanks for joining us! This podcast is a companion to our student success news hub and weekly newsletter, where we share actionable news, ideas and insights for higher ed professionals working to ensure all students have what they need to be successful in college and beyond. If you haven’t already, you can subscribe and get it delivered to your inbox every Wednesday. In today’s episode, we’re exploring a question that’s become increasingly important to the future of higher education. What happens when students stop out and what brings them back? As colleges look to re-enroll adults with some college but no credential, institutions are being forced to rethink how they support students whose educational journeys aren’t linear. To explore this, I’m joined by Terah Crews, chief executive officer of ReUp Education, a national organization dedicated to helping adults navigate re-entry into higher education. Terah is widely recognized as a leader in supporting the some college no-credential population, more than 40 million Americans who have earned college credits but left before completing a credential. Her work is also deeply personal. Terah left high school at 17 before returning to education as a working adult learner. After navigating many of the same barriers she now helps others overcome, she went on to earn degrees from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Brown University and Harvard University. She joins us to discuss why students stop out, what motivates them to return, the barriers colleges still place in their way and what it will take to build institutions that truly serve today’s adult learners. Okay. Terah, how are you? How’s everything?
Terah Crews: Wonderful, Josh. How are you doing?
Joshua Bay: I’m doing good. I’m doing good. The weather’s been quite all over the place here in Washington, D.C., but I hear that where you’re at, your allergies are a little all over the place too.
Terah Crews: Oh, this is the time of year that Texas tries various ways to kill us, either allergies or heat. Texas is actively trying to push the entire population out of the state from June to, let’s say, like October.
Joshua Bay: Oh, really? I’ve only been to Texas one time. I was in Austin, Texas. And I think I was there around this time. And it was both like really hot and also the air was really dry as well. So, but you know what? The food was great. There was live music everywhere. It was quite, it was quite a great time.
Terah Crews: There’s a lot to love. We’re based right downtown and we love it. It’s a great little city if you can tolerate the heat for four months out of the year.
Joshua Bay: Really? Okay. Terah, again, thank you so much for taking the time to chat with me. I really do appreciate it. And I’m sure you know why we’re here and what we’re here to chat about. So why don’t we just hop right into it?
Terah Crews: That sounds great.
Joshua Bay: So, Terah, you know, when folks hear the term stop out, they often picture a student who just simply dropped out of college. But from your perspective, how does that label oversimplify what’s actually happening? And what do you think higher education still misunderstands about why students leave in the first place?
Terah Crews: Well, I think let’s start with the naming, the naming itself and versus what we say and say dropout. The reason we say stop out is, by and large, dropout implies that people just quit. They’re done. They decided college wasn’t right for them. And certainly there’s a subset of the population that that’s true. But the vast majority of learners stopped out because there was something going on in their life that kept them from continuing. It could be a health emergency in their family. It could be family obligations. It could be a personal health emergency. It could be a financial situation that was at the same time. It could be a point where they were just struggling to navigate all the pressures of college. But the most important thing to understand is most of these learners don’t quit thinking they’re never going to come back. They think they’re going to come back. They think they’re going to come back after about a semester. But once they’re out for about a semester, inertia takes in and it really gets challenging. This sort of like nuance is really important because for the vast majority of institutions, they do nothing once learners have been out for more than a year. They give up on them. They say, oh, well, they’ve been out for more than a year. They’re not going to come back. They’re right that they’re harder to come back after they’ve been out for more than a year because they look not dissimilar to any other working adult after they’ve been out more. They no longer even identify as a student. But if you approach it that way, if you approach it from the point of view of we’re only going to focus on the people who’ve been out a very, very short amount of time or maybe only a couple credits away from graduation, you’re really ignoring 90% of the population. So you have 90% of the population that the studies show us are thinking about coming back. Nobody’s engaging them. Nobody’s developing solutions for them. So, the biggest misconception is once they’ve been out for a little while, they’re out. They’re not going to come back. The other biggest misconception is that this population is not addressable and that it’s relatively small. This is about one in five or one in six working adults, depending on how you want to count it. It’s huge. The average stop-out population in a given state is bigger than the high school graduating pool that year.
Joshua Bay: Amazing. Terah, I really do appreciate you for really grounding our conversation, right, on the multitudes of reasons why folks find themselves in a situation where they stop out of college. I really do appreciate you for going into those different examples that are very real examples, right, for students across the country. And something that you mentioned, right, and it’s also something that stands out to me about ReUp’s work is how you approach students with the mindset that they never really intend to leave college permanently, or many of them, right, don’t intend to leave college permanently. I’m curious, like, what typically motivates students to come back? And what tends to be the biggest hurdle standing between them and re-enrollment?
Terah Crews: So, here’s the real challenge in serving this population. It’s highly diverse in what their motivations are, and it’s highly diverse in terms of what sort of barriers stand in their way. So, but in many ways, like you don’t, if you get wrapped up in all the complexity of the unique individuals and their unique challenges and their unique motivations, you overlook that simply engaging, simply starting the conversation with them and building highly scalable ways to continue that conversation is all that’s necessary. You don’t need to have a solution for every complexity in a person’s life on why they can’t come back, nor do you need to understand the unique situation that they’re in right now. You simply need to start a conversation with them. And then you have to have the ability to actively serve them for, in some cases, a long period of time before they’re actually able to make that step back. That said, you know, sort of saying there are no generalizations here. By and large, most learners are wanting to come back. Their motivations are oftentimes either like good example for their kids or their family, finishing what I started. But by and large, the biggest sort of example is there, the biggest motivation really comes down to opportunity. People are going back to college because they’re seeing the barriers, they’re seeing the ceilings in the economy that are keeping them from moving ahead. We spend so much time talking about how younger generations aren’t valuing higher education the way that they used to. Adults are. They are because they applied for that job and were told that they weren’t eligible because they didn’t have a bachelor’s degree or they didn’t have associate degree or they didn’t have a credential. So as you think about these populations, the motivations are diverse. The barriers are highly diverse. But people get wrapped up in trying to think about that and map all that complexity when really you need to start the conversation and then you need to be able to continue that conversation for long periods of time, if need be, because sometimes they have to reorganize their life to come back. And you have to understand that like this is a population. You don’t have to sell them on the value of higher education, say, the way you would an 18-year-old, because they see it. They feel it. They know the barriers. But this is what’s keeping them from economic security and opportunity in life.
Joshua Bay: I really do appreciate that approach that you just shared, right? Just that proactive reaching out to folks, adult learners. And I appreciate something that I said later on in your response. It makes me think about like when you look at new data, right? You’re seeing a decline in the traditional 18-year-old student, but you are seeing an uptick in adult learners who are really interested in returning to higher education. So it’s really served as a really important population for institutions nationwide to really think about when it comes to when they’re thinking about enrollment.
Terah Crews: So if I could add one more thing in, Josh, I think it’s not just a really important population for institutions. Increasingly, states are realizing it’s a really important population for their workforce pipeline. If we have fewer people graduating high school, we have a continued gap between the skills that are needing and the credentials they’re needing and the work and the jobs that are available. One of the most important things that states and institutions and partnerships can do right now to address our workforce future is to get adult learners re-skilled and re-educated towards the credentials that are actually needed and the jobs that are needed in the market. So, the beauty of this, sort of, this population, the opportunity in this population, it’s a failure at the start, but it becomes an opportunity. You have millions and tens of millions of people who are part of the way there, who are part of the way to fulfilling that workforce gap, part of the way to filling that enrollment gap. But you have to start. You have to start engaging and get the relationship going to have any impact on any meaningful scale.
Joshua Bay: Perfect. Yeah, I do appreciate you for bringing that up and about how, you know, there’s just many actors in this space that will benefit from re-enrolling adult learners. But with that in mind, you know, many institutions, and as you had mentioned, states and again, workforce pipelines, there is a benefit, right, to bringing back stop-out students, but things like the re-enrollment process can still involve things like registration holds, unpaid balances, really confusing policies or just outdated advising systems that can be a real barrier for adult learners. Where do you see colleges maybe unintentionally making it harder for students to return?
Terah Crews: You know, a lot of this boils down to something that I think is actually simpler than it may first appear. Most of these policies were designed with 18-year-olds in mind. So if you’re a college or an institution or somebody’s looking at your policies at an institution, start from a question of is this relevant to a 32-year-old? The average age of our learners is 31. Is this relevant to a 31-year-old? So that maybe that like that hold on registration due to a parking ticket or a $200 fee makes sense for an 18-year-old because it’s the forcing mechanism to get somebody who’s still developing responsible behaviors to come in and pay their bill. But for a 31-year-old, telling them you can’t come back because of a $200 bill that they forgot 10 years ago, it serves as like a signal I don’t belong. Or it serves as a signal of like, you’re not interested, you’re not invested in me. Moreover, it’s a bad financial decision for the institution. Like when oftentimes when I’m talking to CFOs, they’re like, wait a minute, we have a policy that says if they owe $200, they can’t come back and pay us $4,000 in tuition. Who came up with that? So if you, most of these policies, I would say like the simple starting place is to look at: is this policy relevant to a 31-year-old with a kid? If it’s not, you should have a different policy for a returning student or somebody over a specific age. These policies aren’t necessarily designed to be prohibitive. They just, most of our system is designed for 18-year-olds. So it wasn’t designed with thinking about the working parent or the working adult in mind.
Joshua Bay: I really do appreciate you for sharing how, again, a lot of these policies are right there, they’re shaped for that traditional 18-year-old student. But that sense of belonging, right, that you had mentioned, right, can be a real barrier for students when they see that $200 bill of like, do I really belong in this institution? If they’re holding something against me, that happened 10 years ago. So again, I do appreciate you for sharing that and kind of piggybacking off of that sentiment. You know, many students, many returning students, they’re also working full-time. Maybe they’re raising families. Maybe they’re also just balancing other responsibilities that didn’t necessarily exist when colleges were originally designed. From your perspective, what does an institution that truly serves adult learners look like? And where are colleges making the biggest changes right now?
Terah Crews: Yeah, look, the best place to start if you’re thinking about serving more adult learners is just make it easy for them to come back. They want to come back. They’re not planning their entire junior year. They’re way out for like what to do next year and go back. You got to make it easy. The schools who make it easy to enroll, sometimes it’s I sign up and I can enroll within two weeks, are the ones that are doing best with this population. So fewer registration holds for re-engaging students, no application fee for re-engaging students, fast admission, simplifying an analysis of your transfer credits done or your credits to see how they’re mapping to whatever degree they want to pursue now. The easier you make it for them to take that first step, the more you will get back in. It’s really that simple. And if you think about what ReUp does at a core level, we are supplementing what’s available to the institution today. Most institutions aren’t going to radically change their whole policies and develop a whole set of new policies for re-enrolling learners tomorrow. They’re still going to have their existing policies, and these learners are not going to have time to navigate this bureaucracy. We’re working with the learners to help them get them engaged, to help the process be simpler for them, to translate in many ways that complex policies on campus, and then to be there for them to advocate and support them when they get stuck along the way. But in turn, we’re working with the institutions to help them understand how these policies are impacting learners and how to change them over time and not just get better at serving the learners we’re bringing back, but get better at serving adult learners in general. Which comes back to one of the things I said earlier. Most institutions stay stagnant and aren’t doing anything here. Just get started. You don’t have to fix all your policies tomorrow. You don’t have to map everything out. Start from a place of, let’s start approaching all of our learners. Let’s engage all of our learners. Let’s work with a partner, in our case, to supplement our existing sort of support and coaching and advising on campus, not replace, supplement. And then let’s set a journey to become more adult-friendly over time, not just for adult learners or not just for the re-enrolling learners, but for adult learners in general. Because this is the new population. It’s the only growth demographic in higher education right now. International, struggling. Demographics are what they are. That’s settled. If you want to grow enrollment in higher education right now, you need to get better at serving adult learners, but don’t let perfect be the enemy of good in starting today.
Joshua Bay: I guess on that note, have you seen any institutions or any states that are doing really good work in this space or doing like really innovative things that other higher ed leaders who are listening right now could take note of?
Terah Crews: Yeah, there’s a lot of them. Our recent report, ALEI, really outlined a lot of what’s going on in all the states in the country. A few obvious ones that come to mind. Obviously, New Jersey has been doing a phenomenal job at this for about three or four years now. Nearly 14,000 people enrolled over the last three years. I believe if memory serves somewhere to the tune of about $350 million in economic impact, don’t 100% quote me on that. But the last time I looked at the numbers, but part of the reason is it’s a coordinated strategy. And you see this in places like Michigan. You’re increasingly seeing this in others, and places like North Carolina as well. If you have a coordinated strategy where it’s not just each individual institution outreaching on their own, but like you’re centralizing your outreach to as much of your some college, no credential within the state as possible, then that’s when the impact starts to get borderline exponential. That’s when you start to get real lift. And some of the reason for that is that learners are by and large going to choose institutions near home. They are, if you have all the institutions work together with a coordinated statewide strategy, that learner who maybe stopped out at the community college or stopped out at the four-year institution in one part of the state, but now lives in another part of the state and lives near another community college, lives near a community college, can re-enroll at that community college. We see that having options available not just gets people to return to their original institution, but gets people to stay in state. And this part is really important. For states like Michigan, for states like New Jersey, for states like North Carolina, who are taking a coordinated statewide strategy, they are not just keeping people in state, they’re not just getting higher numbers, they’re preventing these learners from going to online out-of-state institutions. So they’re keeping more dollars in state, more dollars at their institutions. And candidly, in almost all cases, it’s a cheaper option for the learners in state, and it’s better outcomes. So for states like Michigan, like New Jersey, like North Carolina, who are taking really strong coordinated strategies, they’re getting the biggest lift. They’re keeping more dollars and more learners in state for better outcomes and for a better value proposition for those learners as well.
Joshua Bay: Something that stood out from what you just said right now is just the idea of options, right? Giving adult learners options for their own socioeconomic mobility. And on that note, we’re seeing real growing interest across the country in things like short-term credentials and things like workforce pathways, prior learning assessment. How do those kinds of flexible pathways change the conversation for students who may not see a traditional four-year degree as their only route back into higher education?
Terah Crews: It expands the population who you can serve, like at a simple level is that there is a certain population who will come back or who could come back with the right engagement and the right support. But if you can expand the different pathways of like to meet those learners’ needs, then you can radically expand what percentage of that 43 million are going to come back. If you can start adding in some of these other values, other options, you’re expanding how deep we can get into that 43 million population. That’s really important because currently we’re not enrolling as many who new stop out every year. So if we want to really stem the tide and start shrinking that 40 million population, we’ve got to develop new solutions, new pathways for learners to get back in. We can be getting more just by engaging more, but we can really significantly expand the eligible population by going deeper in. But let’s talk about why these people care about this. So what’s really important about these sort of alternative pathways is really it’s allowing us to reach deeper into that 40, 43 million who stopped out. So if we ever want to really stem the tide, enroll more people than we are that are stopping out new every single year, we’re going to have to think about new pathways to get in. We can be getting a lot more by having better engagement, better solutions, better policies, but these things are providing us ability to really open up the option of re-enrolling to a lot more people. But let’s talk about why people actually care about these things. With things like shorter form credentials, I think what we’re acknowledging is that for many people who are going back to college, they’re not simply going back for the credential, they’re going back for improved economic opportunity. So, for a learner to go back and pursue a degree, if they can do that by pursuing some shorter-form credential that gets them a better job, more salary, more income while they’re pursuing a degree that’ll give them a pathway to a career, that’s an added benefit. And we’re even seeing this with some of our learners. Some learners, particularly at community colleges, are coming back to learn a very specific skill, even if they don’t complete the credential. We’ve got to start expanding our understanding of people’s relationship with education. That some will come back to learn a very specific skill to get a better job. Others will come back to get a credential to get a pathway to a new career. And those things aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive. They can actually interrelate. You can engage that learner to come back for a short form credential or a few specific skill development and engage that learner again, ultimately, to help them get a degree and a pathway to a better career.
Joshua Bay: You know, beyond finances or beyond scheduling, how much of re-enrollment is also an emotional decision, right? Like, do returning students carry feelings of failure, shame or uncertainty that institutions often overlook?
Terah Crews: It’s absolutely an emotional decision. So it’s like the economic or the log, you know, the sort of right brain decision is like fundamentally intertwined with the emotional. One of the core things that we do when we’re outreaching is we pretty quickly try to get an assessment of like what that person’s barriers are. And it’s not just mindset where we’re not, it’s not just motivations we’re looking for, it’s mindset of where they are. And then we’re able to personalize engagement and personalize outreach, be it human or, you know, our messaging system to match where that person is. I think about my own sort of like personal experience. Many years ago, I was a high school stop-out and then I was actually a college stop-out as well before eventually going on to getting a couple graduate degrees because apparently I just loved being in school so much.
Joshua Bay: Right there with you.
Terah Crews: Yeah. It was just fun. I still miss it sometimes. But, you know, I think about like a really, a really sort of like like memorable experience for me. I went to the University of North Carolina as an adult student, really rare at Chapel Hill at that time. And I remember being in a class and being 23rd, 23, 24 years old, 18-year-olds in front of me. It was an entry-level class. And them talking about how somebody who showed up at a party the night before was so old, they were 22 or 23, younger than me at the time. And, you know, it’s funny to laugh at, but like, this is real for learners. Like, a sense that they’re going to belong, a sense that they’re not going to be alone, that they’re not going to be the 31-year-old in a class with a whole bunch of 18-year-olds whose brains are still developing. Like, does that place, do I belong there? Is it meant for me? It’s important. We need to engage them and encourage them: know you belong. Know you are not alone. You know what? We’re getting better at you being not alone because we’re getting better. We’re committed to getting more people like you back in. The good news is, I think this is starting to finally land in our industry. I’ve been talking about this ever since I was a consultant, God, like 10 years ago, about how you need to be serving adult learners. Virtually every institution in the country now realizes it. And the more we realize it, the more we engage, the better we’re going to get at meeting people where they are, helping them realize that these fears, these anxieties are okay. They’re normal, but they’re welcome. But also recognizing as much as there’s like maybe fear and anxiety, it’s not just negative emotions, it’s excitement as well. When I talk to adult learners, I tell them, it’s going to be a roller coaster. Higher education is a roller coaster. The lows are going to feel really low and the highs are going to feel very high. Know that going in. If you know that going in, embrace the highs, celebrate them, celebrate them with your family. And when the lows hit, find people like you. Find people who can give you a support. And if your people are around you, support and you’re working with ReUp, we got you. Pick up a phone, text your coach. We’re there to support you and encourage you along the way.
Joshua Bay: Amazing. Yeah, I really do appreciate you for bringing your own story, right, as a stop-out student. I guess taking our entire conversation in mind, if we revisit this conversation, let’s say five years from now, what would you say meaningful progress looks like? Like, for instance, like, how will we know higher education has truly become a system where stopping out doesn’t mean the end of a student’s educational journey?
Terah Crews: Yeah, I think I’d like to see virtually every institution in the country have a significantly larger population of adult learners. Let’s even just set stop-outs aside for a second. Success looks like every institution in the country, particularly our regional publics and our community colleges, having a significant portion of their, call it like a significant portion of their institution being adult learner. That’s not just important for our institutions. Again, it’s the only growth trajectory. You’re either figuring out how to serve adult learners or you’re shrinking your institution. Just choose now because that’s the next five years. But moreover, if we expand this to sort of a broader societal and sort of like what the nation needs, what we know is we need more people with credentials. And I say credentials, not just bachelor’s degrees, because we need credentials. Some two-year, some, you know, shorter credentials and some four-year. We need more people with credentials. We have more people being displaced in the workforce. We’re going to have all the projections suggest we’re going to have more underemployment or mismatching of skills and workforce. Higher education in America is special because of its breadth, of who it serves, because of its pathways of being able to leap from community college to four-year to elite private. This is the moment in time we have to, I think we as an industry need to take a step back and say, the nation needs us to be able to serve adult learners. People are going to have to be re-skilled and re-educated at mass scale over the next five, particularly the next 10 years. What I would like to see is that every institution in the country, particularly our regional publics and those who are maybe primarily serving 18-year-old demographics right now, but like having have the ability, the admission standards that would allow for people who are adult working to come back. I’d like to see every one of those institutions have policies and programs that are adult-friendly. If they’re adult-friendly, they’re returning student-friendly in most cases. I’d like to see these institutions think about the relationship with the learner as not simply a one-and-done, but an ongoing lifelong relationship. That may be that learner coming back, taking a few credits, taking a few classes to get a better job, taking a break, coming back again. This is how we need to think about how we as an industry are serving. If we can get to that space, if we can get to a space where we’re thinking about lifelong engagement to help people navigate economic change and navigate workforce change, then we’ll have done something that I think higher education hasn’t done in 80 or 100 years, which is radically expand our mission beyond what it is today.
Joshua Bay: Again, Terah, thank you so much for taking the time to chat with me. This has definitely given me a lot of food for thought when it comes to, as you had mentioned, right, not just stop-out students, but adult learners, nontraditional, post-traditional students in general. And, you know, I know our audience will really appreciate some of the advice and some of the words of wisdom that you just shared right now. So again, I really do appreciate this conversation.
Terah Crews: Happy to talk. Always enjoy talking about this. Always enjoy talking about our learners. I think the thing that excites me is that 10 years ago, very few people were talking about this population. Many people are now. It’s 43 million people. Walk down the street, one in six. This is them. This is a larger population than AARP. It deserves dedicated attention in the industry, in our statehouses, and we’re just happy to be advocates for them along the way.
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success discusses how colleges can navigate AI while supporting students’ intellectual, personal and professional development.
The history behind tech transfer in the U.S. and why it could be under threat.
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success discusses the importance of embedding career readiness throughout college.
Inside Higher Ed’s Voices of Student Success discusses how the entire college experience shapes student well-being and what it takes to build a culture of care.
Log in to manage your newsletter preferences.