Appeals court revives suit over student complaints about being pressured to participate in medical procedure.
A federal appeals court on Tuesday revived a lawsuit brought by students who complained when Valencia College instructors allegedly pressured them to learn on one another how to conduct vaginal probes -- a technique taught in a sonography program.
The college has since barred the practice of using students to conduct such training, but a lawsuit over the issue raised concerns over student speech rights, and a lower court's ruling in the case alarmed many advocates for student free speech rights. The lawsuit is against instructors who are alleged to have pressured the students to undergo the probes from fellow students and who are alleged to have retaliated against students who objected. The practice that was in place at Valencia when the controversy broke in 2015 is not common at other institutions.
The ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit -- as is standard in appeals of lower court rulings dismissing cases -- assumed that the allegations were correct and ruled on the legal issues, not on whether plaintiffs had provided proof for the allegations.
Of concern to advocates for student speech rights was the logic of a federal district court that dismissed the lawsuit on the grounds that the students were engaged in "school-sponsored" speech, which schools and colleges have leeway to regulate. That ruling prompted the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, the Student Press Law Center and other groups to file briefs saying that the judge's decision limited students' speech rights in ways that have never been intended.
The appeals court agreed. While the program that used students to teach one another how to conduct vaginal probes was a college-sponsored event, students who spoke out against the training were expressing their own views, not those of the college, the court ruled in its decision.
The appeals court said that, under prior Supreme Court rulings, there are strict definitions for when student speech can be deemed to be "sponsored" by a school or college: such speech must be perceived as having "the imprimatur of the school," faculty members must supervise the activity and "the activity, by design, imparts knowledge or skills to students or audiences."
In this case, those requirements are not met, the appeals court ruled. "The speech at issue -- the students’ complaints to the employees about the transvaginal ultrasounds -- is not school-sponsored expression," the decision said. "Private complaints from individual students do not 'bear the imprimatur of the school.'"
The proper standard for the case, the appeals court said, was speech that simply has taken place on the grounds of the college. And under that standard, a college could only take action against student speech that would cause a serious disruption, which the appeals court said was not the case here.
The appeals court also reversed the district judge's ruling that a vaginal probe without a person's consent was not unconstitutional under the Fourth Amendment, which bars unreasonable searches. On this issue, the court noted that many court rulings have found that physical procedures (such as collecting blood or other tissue) can constitute unreasonable searches. Further, the court noted that these probes can be painful to some women and embarrassing to others, especially if performed by fellow students.
"Inserting a probe into a woman’s vagina is plainly a search when performed by the government," the appeals court ruled.
Read more by
Topics
College Pages
Inside Higher Ed Careers
Browse Faculty Jobs
Browse Administrative Jobs
Browse Executive Administration Jobs
You may also be interested in...
Today’s News from Inside Higher Ed
Inside Higher Ed’s Quick Takes
Popular Right Now
NYU social work school admits to institutional racism in wake of student email
Study documents economic gains from liberal arts education
Opposition hardens against one college seeking to merge and another planning to close
New study finds that women who are not considered attractive receive lower grades
Complainant in 'unprecedented' Walter Lewin sexual harassment case comes forward
American academic leaves China, citing concerns about physical safety
Essay on writing academic book reviews
Essay on how to write research statements in applying for academic jobs
Sign Up / Sign In
With your existing account from...
{* loginWidget *}With a traditional account...
{* #signInForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *} {* currentPassword *} {* /signInForm *}Newsletter enrollment
Existing account found
We have found an existing account for the email address.
Please sign in to update your newsletter preferences.
{* /signInForm *}Newsletter opt-out
Edit your newsletter preferences
Account Info
Sign In
Welcome back, {* welcomeName *}!
{* loginWidget *}Sign In
Welcome Back
Account Deactivated
Your account has been deactivated.
Account Reactivation Failed
Sorry, we could not verify that email address.
Email Verification Required
You must verify your email address before signing in. Check your email for your verification email, or enter your email address in the form below to resend the email.
{* #resendVerificationForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Almost Done
Please confirm the information below before signing in.
{* #socialRegistrationForm *} {* firstName *} {* lastName *} {* displayName *} {* emailAddress *} {* optInIHE *} {* optIn3rdParty *} {* agreeToTerms *}Almost Done
Please confirm the information below before signing in. Already have an account? Sign In.
{* #registrationForm *} {* firstName *} {* lastName *} {* displayName *} {* emailAddress *} {* newPassword *} {* newPasswordConfirm *} {* optInIHE *} {* optIn3rdParty *} {* agreeToTerms *}Thank You for Registering
We have sent a confirmation email to {* emailAddressData *}. Please check your email and click on the link to verify your email address.
Create New Password
We'll send you a link to create a new password.
{* #forgotPasswordForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Create New Password
We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed.
Create New Password
This email address was registered with a social account. We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password, which can be used in addition to your linked social providers.
{| current_emailAddress |}
{| foundExistingAccountText |} {| current_emailAddress |}.
{| existing_displayName |} - {| existing_provider |} : {| existing_siteName |} {| existing_createdDate |}
{| existing_provider_emailAddress |}
Sign In to Complete Account Merge
Resend Verification Email
Sorry, we could not verify that email address. Enter your email below, and we'll send you another email.
{* #resendVerificationForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Change Password
Create New Password
We didn't recognize that password reset code. Enter your email below, and we'll send you another email.
{* #resetPasswordForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Create New Password
We've sent you an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed.
Edit Your Account
Profile Photo
Linked Accounts
Link Your Accounts
This allows you to sign in to your account using that provider in the future.
Password
Deactivate Account
Change Password
Deactivate Your Account
Are you sure you want to deactivate your account? You will no longer have access to your profile.
{* deactivateAccountForm *} {* /deactivateAccountForm *}
Expand commentsHide comments — Join the conversation!