Alena Selezneva
Before I embarked on a journey to learn about higher ed leadership, I shared the sentiment of many faculty that administrators, while doing a job I would never want, surely didn’t deserve pay of two or three orders of magnitude more than mine. I mean, how hard could it be to travel around shaking hands of donors and waving pom-poms at football games and doing whatever they did behind massive desks in palatial offices? I kinda miss my former naïveté.
We launched The Sandbox, a weekly newsletter for and by college and university presidents, in August 2023, when the public didn’t think much about college presidents. Two months later, everyone was talking about them. And not with love in their hearts. We wanted to make visible the challenges of the job, especially for those in the demographic of that first congressional hearing: women, including women of color, who were fairly new presidents.
Last year I began to believe that if you hadn’t been a president since the Gaza protests, you had no idea what the current crop was going through. More recently I’ve been saying if you haven’t been in that hot seat since the beginning of this year, you were freaking clueless. Everyone I talk to, including those who have served for decades, say it’s never been this hard. Never.
There are many reasons for that, and if you’ve been paying attention, you can sing along with the choir. However, I worry that too many faculty members are not paying enough attention to the real threats facing higher ed. If you’re reading this, you are not the problem. But maybe you can remind your colleagues of what’s actually happening beyond your campus gates.
The bottom line is the bottom line: We are all at some level of financial risk. I can’t imagine any president who loves cutting programs and doesn’t feel sickened to have to lay off people. They are looking toward the future because demographic cliffs (and shifts) and declining enrollment are problems that aren’t going to go away if we ignore them. Just because an institution has lasted more than a century doesn’t mean it will continue to be around. When colleagues rail against change, maybe ask if they want to have a job in five years. If they don’t believe that’s a real possibility, send them to me and I’ll provide a list of recent college closures and laid-off tenured professors.
Those financial realities exist alongside political ones. We are all—well, most of us—trying to preserve the values we’ve worked hard to embed in our institutions, though we risk getting spanked if we use certain naughty words (can you say, “Diversity, equity and inclusion”?). Even in bloody red states, unless you’re at the University of Austin or the new New College, the leaders I talk to still care about making sure we don’t go back to the days when everyone was taught a curriculum of the dead, the pale and the male by pale, male, nearly dead professors.
Some presidents are at the mercy of state legislatures, and all have the boot of this administration on their necks. The Department Against of Education’s strategy has been to sow chaos into every facet of life as we know it. When I think about the horrors that have been unleashed on us in higher ed, I stop and remind myself that we’re not the ones having to deal with outbreaks of easily preventable childhood diseases or trying to protect from arrest and deportation vast numbers of citizens and legal residents who have broken no laws. But we in higher ed give them an easy target to impose ideological and authoritarian rule if we continue to fight among ourselves, which, sadly, is what is happening on too many campuses.
When I asked a former president if she’d ever had a no-confidence vote, she expressed surprise that she hadn’t. Then she told me what she’d said to her enraged faculty: You can try to get rid of me, but you’ll just end up with someone taller, slimmer and male who’s facing exactly the same problems. And, I’d add, with a board that already thinks you’re whiny and entitled and are unsympathetic to even important grievances.
I’m not saying presidents are beyond criticism. Sure, some of them are personally ambitious, greedy and craven and, well, just suck. And there are those who take advantage of the position to do morally hinky and plain stupid things. (Thanks to Ted Carter for the reminder.) But that’s true of leadership in any industry. Those from outside academe are always struck by how different the rules we play by are and how hard it is to make change, even in the face of pressing crises. Good presidents value their faculty, see them as essential partners and try to find ways to work around the Angry Eight, the few vocal self-righteous assholes individuals who oppose everything.
If you look at the presidents who started just five years ago, most are no longer in the job. Think for a moment about who is stepping up to the often thankless challenge of leading these days, who are mission-driven and against-the-odds optimists. Here’s a hint: They don’t look like your father’s college president.
It’s hard to find good data on how long the average tenure of the presidency is these days, and whatever it is, that’s not the whole story. Many boards give themselves a big pat on the back for hiring a “first.” But then they go along as if nothing has changed and have no idea how to support the first woman, the first person of color or the first queer president, sometimes in small towns where there are few others like them. And when those people face challenges, as of course they will in places unaccustomed to change, boards are all too quick to say “oops” and find someone new.
The stories I have heard from presidents about treatment by masters-of-the-universe board members have given me the shivers. Former provosts who take on the job often do so with no real knowledge of what to expect from these inscrutable relationships. When a president tells me stories about how they were treated—things they thought were maybe normal because they had no baseline but in fact are horrific, like attacking their families—I have been able to pull out that old breakup line “it’s not you, it’s them” and mean it.
Worse, it hurts me to report, is how many women presidents say the most vicious members of their opposition are women, including proud feminists on the faculty. This is the dark underside of the sisterhood. It’s easy to take shots from the cheap seats when you have the luxury of tenure and you think nothing is at stake in going after The Man.
But that’s a mistake. What’s hanging in the balance for all of us is higher ed under a concerted attack from outside.
When I first started working on The Sandbox, Inside Higher Ed had started covering no-confidence votes less often because they didn’t mean diddly squat. But, in fact, like a toddler’s temper tantrum, they disrupt the ability to get important shit done, waste time and cause exhaustion in people who are trying to be the grown-ups in the room. And, faculty friends, let’s be real. Do you really think boards, who already believe we are lazy and entitled and don’t do “real” work, are going to pay attention to our wailing? No. If they decide to oust a president, the next guy they bring in is going to come with a mandate to get tough, and I’m pretty sure he’s going to be much worse.
So maybe we spend some time rallying the troops on each of our campuses to fight against an enemy that’s far scarier than a president who needs to cut programs that have five faculty members and only three majors.
At a time when public trust in what we do is lower than that for the insurance industry, our tendency to go after those trying to save our institutions could be fatal. The current administration in D.C. has figured out that we will do a lot of their dirty work for them. As Maya Angelou reminded us, when someone shows you who they are, believe them. I miss my former naïveté, but not as much as I’m going to miss the higher education world we once took for granted.