A judge dismissed noninstitutional defendants from a suit about early-decision admissions.
sshepard/iStock/Getty Images Plus
A judge has dismissed the Common Application Inc. and two other nonuniversity defendants from a lawsuit alleging a conspiracy among 32 selective private colleges and universities to use early-decision admissions to increase tuition.
But Judge Angel Kelley of the U.S. District Court of Massachusetts denied the institutions’ request to also dismiss the suit against them, allowing the case to continue.
At selective institutions, an applicant who takes the early-decision route generally has a better chance of acceptance, but they must promise to attend if offered admission. The students who filed this suit last August allege that—even though early-decision policies aren’t legally binding—the 32 institutions have agreed not to recruit or admit students who are accepted early decision to other colleges and universities, allowing institutions to charge the accepted students more.
The institutions argued in a motion to dismiss that the students made “no factual allegations about Defendants acting in parallel to stop competing for Early Decision admits.” But Kelley wrote in her ruling Friday that the students alleged “direct evidence of an agreement to restrain trade”: the Ivy League Joint Statement, through which Ivy institutions agree not to compete for students accepted early decision to other Ivies, she said. While only five of the institutions being sued are party to that pact, the plaintiffs “need not show that all necessary parties are part of the conspiracy” at this early stage of the case, Kelley wrote.
“Direct evidence that some Defendants entered into the agreement, combined with the fact that the remaining Defendants engaged in conduct closely conforming to that of those who had joined, supports the inference that all Defendants were parties,” Kelley wrote. However, she concluded that the students’ allegations that Common Application Inc., Scoir Inc. and the Consortium on Financing Higher Education were also in on the alleged conspiracy were too threadbare, and she dismissed them as defendants.
The suit was filed by two students who enrolled through early decision at Wesleyan University in 2019, one who enrolled at Vassar College through early decision in 2022 and one who enrolled via regular decision at Washington University in St. Louis in 2022. Three say they paid the full cost of attendance, while one says she received partial financial aid.
Their case seeks to become a class action on behalf of a huge number of other students: all undergraduates who enrolled full-time at one of the 32 institutions within the four years before the suit was filed up through the current day.